CYBERSECURITY: WORKING WITH & PROTECTING EACH OTHER

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
1 Video View·Mar 19, 2026
28th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Philippines🇵🇭- February 3-4, 2025
-Mr. Mark Bryan Manantan
Director of Cybersecurity and Critical Technologies, Pacific Forum
AI Generated·May contain errors
This will be live streamed. Thank you so much. Are you able to see my slides?
We see you. Yeah. Can you see my slides? There's a slide. Please proceed.
Invitation and the opportunity to present this very timely and critical forum or dialogue. I
am Mark Mandanda, Director of Cybersecurity and Critical Technologies. I'm also currently a
visiting fellow at the National Institute for Defense Studies here at the Ministry of Defense
in Tokyo. And I'm dialing from Shinjuku today for this very wonderful gathering of experts
looking at different strategic and political and security concerns animating the Philippines.
And Pacific Forum, we are a Honolulu-based think tank and we look at emerging security issues
from nuclear nonproliferation, maritime security and also technology policies such as cybersecurity.
What I'm going to do in the next 10 minutes is to share with you a project that we've just concluded
last year. It's called the Cyber ASEAN Capacity Building Project supported
by the Australian government. And hopefully my presentation in the next 10 minutes
would prompt some reflections and also some insights from the participants that
we can further expound on in the question and answer open discussion as part of this particular
session. So I think to begin, let me just play this video to also make this session a little
bit interactive. And it introduces the project that I'm going to discuss in the next couple of
minutes. Let me just go back to my slides. So the presentation that I'll be giving today
first discusses the Cyber ASEAN Project. The video just showed you a snapshot
of the project aims and goals and its accomplishment. And I'll probably end with
some of the lessons and key findings from this initiative that hopefully could prompt some
reflections and insights to those who are in the room participating in this important forum.
So Cyber ASEAN is the first and homegrown cybersecurity assessment framework that we
have concluded in 2024. This was supported by the Australian government. And the idea here is
to support the implementation of the ASEAN Cybersecurity Cooperation Strategy. And so
building on the dimensions of the ASEAN Cybersecurity Cooperation Strategy,
we conducted several consultations across the region, particularly on four key pilot countries
in Southeast Asia, namely Philippines, of course, Vietnam, and Indonesia, and Jakarta. And the idea
really of Cyber ASEAN is to imagine and rethink the conduct of cyber capacity building in the
region given, as the last two experts have noted, the increasing vulnerability and risks that the
cyber domain poses to ASEAN itself, but also because of the interconnected and borderless
nature of cyberspace. And this particular slide over here presents to you all the existing
and current cybersecurity assessment framework. And our team at Cyber ASEAN,
all the existing tools, and we've come to a conclusion that most of the tools that are
being implemented or developed in the past often create or often possess or have indicators where
these are indicators that are applied to target countries without the knowledge or at least the
insights of the target users. So what Cyber ASEAN did is to flip the script and really
reimagine and reframe the conduct of cyber capacity building by emphasizing the local context and
ownership. Instead of coming and conducting consultations in Manila, in Hanoi, in KL,
and also in Jakarta, we decided to position the target stakeholders in the driver's seat
at the very onset to get their insights and views and perspective in constructing the Cyber
ASEAN framework to really make it a homegrown cyber assessment framework that is tailored
to the unique needs and challenges as well as seizing opportunities among the target partner
countries. And as you can see in this bunch of consultations, we've gathered the cybersecurity
experts, and I think Secretary Uy was also present during the Manila consultation,
and we've also been lucky and fortunate to receive the support of the GFCE community
throughout these engagements that we had over the last two years. And on top of that, we also did
virtual experts meeting with key experts from the United States, from Australia, from Japan,
from the European Union, and Korea to really have an understanding of what are the international
best practices that we could integrate to the creation of the Cyber ASEAN framework.
And so what are the lessons and findings from Cyber ASEAN that I think are relevant to today's
discussion in this particular forum? I think it was already echoed in the previous remarks that
cyber attacks are borderless, but what we've noticed in Southeast Asia is that a lot of the
Southeast Asian countries have varying threat perceptions when it comes to cybersecurity.
And this is very much reflected in how Southeast Asian policymakers and experts would often reflect
on or would often distinguish the South China Sea issue and also the cyber threats and risks
that are associated with the South China Sea issue. And so in order to really persuade and
understand the context, the geopolitical context, both offline and online in Southeast Asia,
particularly among the target partner countries that we've targeted or we've engaged for this
particular project, we constructed a cyber threat tracker, which you can find in our website,
to really show to the policymakers that the cyber attacks that are happening in Indonesia
are also happening in Vietnam or also happening in the Philippines. And so it underscores that
despite the varying threat perceptions that each country has in terms of a particular threat actor,
the reality is most often than not, these threat actors are operating not just in the
computer networks and enterprises in the Philippines, but are also actively engaged
in other cyber campaigns in Indonesia, Vietnam, and Thailand. And this is really an important
tool for us, the cyber threat tracker, to set up the geopolitical as well as the threat context
for all the policymakers that we've engaged for the project. Another aspect of the project that
makes it persuasive and iterative, as the Secretary Uy already mentioned, is the lack of adoption,
at least enforcement, of cybersecurity standards. And during our consultation across the region,
it was brought up that we need to create a business case for cybersecurity. Most often
than not, governments would come up with cybersecurity roadmaps, strategies, and policies,
but these are not backed by adequate resources and investments. And so when we were conducting
the consultations across the four countries, it was very, very important to create a business case.
And so a big part of the CyberASEAN project is emphasizing the economic benefits of adopting
cybersecurity standards. And here, we created an economic regression model to demonstrate
the ad value of cybersecurity policy and strategies to the different sectors across
Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam, and Malaysia. And as you can see on the chart on this right
side of my slide, that indeed, there is a positive outcome when the four ASEAN member
state countries adopted cybersecurity standards in the form of the NIST framework or through the
ISO 27001. So this is the one in Malaysia and also in Vietnam. And you can find the report
cyberasean.platform.org that really fleshes out which specific sectors gained from the adoption
of cybersecurity standards. And I think this is the last slide, and I'm happy to go through all
the other insights and feedback from the consultation, but I'd just like to emphasize
these three things that I think are very unique to Southeast Asia. The first is the concept of
backdoor diplomacy. Throughout the consultation, I think there was an apparent question about public
attribution. As you've already seen in my previous slide, there are a lot of advanced persistent
threat actors, or if I simplify it for the people in the room, hackers infiltrating critical
national infrastructure. And for sure, you've also heard about this in the news. But Southeast Asia
has a very different and distinct approach compared to the United States and other western
countries in terms of public attribution or calling out a particular threat actor.
It was discussed in our consultation that backdoor diplomacy or quiet attribution
is the preferred style over megaphone diplomacy or public attribution, given the obvious
complex political security and economic interdependence. Of course, evaluating this
approach is very hideous and complicated, but a lot of the policymakers who've engaged in the
region do actually agree that this is more palatable to the current context in the region
where restraint is perceived as a form of active cyber defense compared to really calling out a
particular actor, given the obvious asymmetry among the resident cyber powers in the region,
namely China, but also you have other political actors such as Russia and also North Korea.
Another aspect is on information sharing and threat management. While we emphasize a lot on the
interplay or the presence of advanced persistent threat actors that emanates from the cyber powers
that I've mentioned, there is still a lot of trust deficit among the ASEAN member countries
themselves. And this really cuts into the heart of the region to come up with a very solid,
and I think long-term, commitment in terms of information sharing and threat management
response. And here, I think the remedy, or at least the one that serves as a connecting tissue,
are the role of the computer and emergency response team, or the incident response team,
or often the people-to-people relationships that these communities have built with one another.
I've heard the Asia-Pacific CERT community was identified previously really play an important
role, especially in crisis management or addressing high-level cyber incidents.
And lastly, I think one of the key interesting findings from the consultation that we did
throughout the past two years is really the importance of public-private partnership,
where again, the role of incentives is very important for governments to really ensure
a successful implementation of national cybersecurity strategy or policy, considering
that 90% of the critical national infrastructure operated by the private sector. And so rather than
really seeing national cybersecurity strategy as more of a prescriptive or adopting a prescriptive
approach on these policy documents or initiatives, I think it's very, very critical to emphasize
a cross-sectoral collaboration among the public and private sector, including the role of academia
and civil society. And I'll just touch on the final component of the project, which is inclusion.
And we've heard about the workforce development. And I think in the context of the Philippines,
it's quite unique among the Southeast Asian countries we've covered in this project,
because there is a greater attempt to bridge the gender divide in terms of workforce development
in the cybersecurity sector. So you can find out more about CyberASEAN and other public
relations and communications campaigns that we've did about the project through podcasting.
And you can definitely download the report at cyberasean.pacquorum.org. Once again, thank you
so much for your attention, and I look forward to a wonderful discussion in the Q&A.
Thank you, sir. Well received. We have about five minutes for questions. Are there questions
from the floor?
