California's Film Industry Has a Gap | What's Driving the Work Elsewhere

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
136 Video Views·Mar 18, 2026
California's post production workforce, the people who edit, score, and mix every film and show you've ever seen, has been losing work to other states and countries for years. How does an industry this embedded in a state end up competing for its own survival? In this episode, we speak with a panel of post production professionals about the economic forces driving work elsewhere. And about the bill in Sacramento they believe could change that.
Featuring:
Marielle Abaunza, President, California Post Alliance
Ben Urquhart, VP Post Production & Integration, Universal Pictures
Brian Ralston, Film Music Composer & Producer
Dennis Dreith, Media Composer
Amélia Rolland, Singer-Songwriter, Composer and Vocalist
AI Generated·May contain errors
Despite the recent efforts of tax credits for Hollywood,
there's still a component of Hollywood that's struggling significantly.
It's the post-production.
Today we sit down with a number of people involved in this industry
that are trying to save it from moving to other states.
I just finished a feature film for a major streamer,
and that orchestra was recorded in Macedonia.
And everything was done remotely.
The overall cost of the production was cheaper to do it there.
When we lose the studio work,
we lose a whole cultural lifeblood of our city.
So there's more at stake than just the entertainment jobs.
There's really a fight for our cultural lives here as well.
I'm Siamak. Welcome to California Insider.
It's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you.
Thank you very much for having us.
We want to talk to you about your industry.
You know, we have been covering Hollywood,
and there's a lot of pressure on your industry.
Jobs, it's a difficult time to be in this industry,
especially in L.A. and in California.
But you guys are part of this industry.
A special part is a different part than filming.
It's post-production.
First of all, what is post-production?
We want to know how it's doing.
There's a mantra that goes around that you make a movie three times.
You write it, then you shoot it, and then you enter post-production.
And that's where the movie gets formed.
It's a long process that really starts at the beginning,
right with the script,
because we're required to come in and break it down.
What is the sound? What visual effects are required?
How are we going to color it when we get to the end?
And our editors start the day we start shooting.
They're receiving dailies, and they're at work right away.
So this is a process that is about taking that footage in
and assembling it into its final form,
including localizing it for the whole world
and doing edits and fixes for the global audience.
And does it take a long time to do this process?
When I am budgeting a film,
my template is that post-production takes 26 weeks.
So it's half a year.
It can vary depending on the scale and scope of the project, of course,
and in different mediums, whether that be TV or commercial, right?
But it is a required process.
It's the third leg of the stool.
And how many people are involved in this?
The best example that I can give you,
which is also an illustration of the lack of education and awareness
around post-production, is when you go to a movie theater
and the movie ends and the picture is over and the lights come out,
people are walking away, and they don't stay through the credits.
And if you actually stay through the credits
and you see all those names, and there's hundreds,
hundreds of names per film,
that gives you an idea, a good illustration,
of how many people are employed in post-production
because it's everything that happens after a movie's completed production.
It's the picture editor that puts the movie together.
It is the colorist that works on the color of the film
and gives it its tones.
It is the composers and the musicians that do the scoring.
It is the sound artists that do the sound editorial,
which is all the sound effects.
It is the mixer that gives you the atmosphere.
And then, of course, it's also the people who put the DCPs together
so that you can go and see the theater.
It's the people that write the font on the screen
when you're seeing the credits.
So there are so many people that are employed in our industry
because all of our jobs happen in dark rooms.
It's not as visible as production.
There's a lack of awareness,
and therefore there's a misunderstanding
and a misrepresentation of how large our community actually is.
As someone reporting on California's economy and policies every week,
unfortunately, I see the middle class shrinking in California.
Some of it has to do with our policies,
and there is another side to this that we are facing major inflation
here and across the country.
Unfortunately, the dollar has lost 10% of its value
just this year to date.
That's why more and more people are turning to real assets
to protect their financial future,
like physical gold and silver from American hard-fought gold.
Unlike paper assets, these tangible investments
can't be controlled or devalued by inflation or bad policies.
You can have them delivered straight to your home
or securely stored in a tax-advantaged gold IRA,
giving you a safe, reliable way to safeguard your wealth,
no matter what happens in California or the rest of the country.
American hard-fought gold has an A-plus rating
with the Better Business Bureau and thousands of five-star reviews.
And right now, when you call, you can get up to $15,000
in free silver with your first purchase.
Call 866-595-2304.
That's 866-595-2304.
Or text KALI to 65532.
Make sure to text KALI to 65532.
Beat the system and protect your wealth with something real today.
In many cases, there's even hundreds of people
who aren't even on those calls.
We have oftentimes 100, 110 musicians employed on a single session,
and over several days, that could be 300 or 400 different musicians
employed over a course of a picture.
We don't see them.
So what we are, we're the people, you don't see us on camera,
we're not seen at all, but we're heard and we're felt
and the end product of what we do is seen on every picture.
So we're seen and heard on every picture, but we aren't.
I would add, to personalize it, I've been out of work for two years
as a result of these sort of economic earthquakes in our business.
Post-production is so collaborative,
so it took me a minute to think all the way through,
but as I applied to jobs, it's like,
have you ever managed multiple people?
Of course, I'm like, well, I've had a few direct reports,
and I'm like, oh no, every film has 30 to 50 filmmakers on it,
and they're a wild bunch.
So yes, I have managed a lot.
It's a fascinating realization to say we spend a mountain of time
with a lot of people to get these movies done,
and it is all kind of in the dark.
In terms of what's going on in your space,
we are hearing it's gotten really tough for people to find jobs,
to actually find gigs, and can you tell us what's happening?
The biggest problem, which is the reason that we're here today,
and which is the reason we formed the California Post Alliance,
is that the current global market is often being driven by tax incentives.
So territories like the UK, Canada,
are two examples of countries that recognize the value
of the entertainment industry
and how much economic growth it brings to their nations,
and they have become very aggressive,
and they provide rebates in the form of tax incentives
to filmmakers and content creators.
And California, because historically production and post-production
has always happened here,
we were never aggressive because we have the talent,
we have the infrastructure.
But now we've given territories the opportunity to build their pool of talent
and their infrastructure, and we're falling behind.
And so tax incentives, I would say, is probably not the only,
but one of the primary factors for productions going elsewhere.
You mentioned productions going elsewhere.
How have you guys been impacted?
Can you tell us your stories?
I think for the music part, it's very easy.
We used to have six major court scoring stages working full-time.
That would be oftentimes 600 people employed on a single day at the peak times,
and that peak time would last several months out of the year,
the majority of the year.
And of those, now we have three scoring stages
that are sitting idle most of the time.
So where we were seeing literally 500, 600 musicians working on a single day,
we're lucky if there's a single orchestra working
during a whole week of the year right now.
So work has tremendously evaporated from here.
So that's not only the musicians who aren't working,
that's the scoring mixers and the people who set up the microphones
and the people who manage the studios.
And every other aspect of that, that affects the music copyists
and the orchestrators and the musicians themselves.
It affects, you know, the music repair shops.
I mean, you can go on and on.
And every type of thing, you know, the restaurants in the area.
When we would work at one of the major studios,
lunchtime, 100 people would descend on the local restaurants and have lunch.
Those restaurants are idle during lunch.
You can walk in those places in Culver City now
and have lunch wherever you want without a reservation,
which, you know, a few years ago, we couldn't have done that.
So those are the kind of impacts of this.
It's much greater than just the musicians sitting in a chair
or the film editor or the post-production sound people.
And we're very similar.
Those working in post-production have a very similar discipline,
and it affects all of us in much the same way.
I just last week finished working on a feature film for a major streamer,
and, you know, the decision of ours of where to score that orchestra was not ours.
It's the production company deciding.
And that orchestra was recorded in Macedonia,
and everything was done remotely.
We were physically here, but the musicians and the cascading effect
of all the people hired that Dennis is talking about
was actually in Macedonia because of cost,
because of, you know, rebates pulling them,
because of a lot of other issues.
It's not any one particular thing.
But the overall cost of the production was cheaper to do it there.
And we didn't have to fly there to make that happen either
because we could monitor it remotely.
There's things that we can do for sound that's much better than Zoom,
and we can hear that sound transmitted in perfect quality remotely.
And it just requires us to be up at a weird hour
because during their day is probably our middle of the night.
And every production can't necessarily go there.
I think every, in our case, orchestra is chosen, you know,
if it's not a terribly difficult score in terms of technicality,
if the quality of that score is good for this group or this group,
then they choose where they want to go.
Some of it might go to London, but one score might be more sound design-like.
And we decide, well, you know, this other group over here in Macedonia
can do that perfectly fine at a lower cost, at a much lower cost.
So what's happening to your colleagues, your peers, and you guys in this space?
I think that Amelia, as a rising talent,
is also the reason that we're working so hard to save this industry
because we're not just trying to take care of the people that are hurting now,
that are out of work, you know, like Ben shared,
that are finding themselves not being able to work enough hours
to maintain their health care within the union.
We're also trying to protect the legacy, the next generation.
Absolutely.
I think, you know, the challenge here is we're seeing kind of two phenomenons,
is you do have a lot of young people like myself
who are moving from other countries and other states
to be able to come to California because we still believe,
when we come here, that this is the place to be
for both production and post-production.
You don't really hear about scoring and being a film composer
so much elsewhere in the world.
All the people I have been absolutely adoring their work
have come to California at some point or are still in California.
And no matter where they're from, they could be, you know, from the UK,
from Europe, from all over the world.
But this was the place to be when I was growing up.
I mean, you know, you guys worked on the movies that scored my life really clearly.
And so, you know, a lot of us are just moving from like states and countries
to be able to come here either to work directly,
thinking that this is kind of the beacon of work.
And, you know, a lot of people actually don't even go to school.
They just come to L.A. and they give it a try
because this is such an important part of the culture of California, right?
But at the same time, once we're done either working here for a few years
or you're done with your degree, I went to USC.
This is a huge school for, you know, music, but not just for music.
I mean, the School of Cinematic Arts is just one of the biggest schools in the world for this.
We kind of see ourselves asking ourselves the questions, what do we do now?
Because, yes, we want to stay.
We want to support this industry.
But at the same time, we're young.
We have to pay bills like everybody.
And, you know, obviously on the call sheets and on all the projects,
we're not the first choices, obviously, because our, you know, careers are so fresh.
Executives and other people, they're not going to bet on us right away, rightfully so.
But we have to still make a decision for our future.
And right now, you know, the question even for myself is,
I love this community that's been the most incredible part of my life.
But I still have at the end of the day to pay my rent and ask myself,
can I even, you know, pay groceries at the end of the month?
And what's been really sad to see is we're all friends at USC.
There's this little like kind of family that's happening.
And when we were all out of what we were doing,
we saw a lot of our friends going back to their origin, you know,
state of origin or like just other countries, not because they wanted to,
but because they had to, because the work was gone.
And if we're talking about post-production, as you mentioned,
now you can record all over the world,
which means you don't even have to be in California anymore.
You know, for our young composers,
like you can record music anywhere in the world because they kind of jumped
on that train seeing that, well,
we can basically offer the same thing for a lower cost.
And it's very attractive to young people because we're not being offered the
same amount of money to record our music. Right.
And then at the same time, if we're talking more about sound,
some of the people, you know, I work with for on sound on my projects,
they all moved to Canada because there's just no structure for young people to
be able to be in sound here in California. But again, it's not a choice.
They have to do it.
But one of the things that is important is,
and this is something that our economist, Adam Fowler,
said as it is much easier to rehab or save an industry that already exists
than to start a new one elsewhere.
And California still has the largest real estate infrastructure in post-production.
And that's what we're fighting for right now.
We're at that critical moment of being able to remind the world of who we are.
Why is the Hollywood sign here? Right.
We have the sign. Hollywood originated in California.
And we have facilities that have been around for hundreds of years.
The Fox scoring stage, the scoring stage at Sony,
where John Williams goes and scores all the beautiful films that have come out of California.
We need to remind the world that this is why we are who we are.
And everybody's watching.
Everybody knows that if California gets it right, then it's back on.
And right now we're not. Right now we're falling behind.
But we're not so behind that we're at a place of no return.
But we could be if, for example, right now we're lobbying,
we're advocating for a post-only tax incentive bill,
which is the reason that the California Post Alliance came to be.
We are incredibly grateful to Assemblymember Nick Schultz, who is authoring the bill.
The bill is AB 2319.
We're also incredibly grateful to our unions that are supporting us and they're standing behind us.
And we're incredibly grateful to the post-production community that is willing to come out
and tell their stories and be vulnerable and say, hey, we're not taking this for granted.
We are not going to lose it.
We are not going to allow the degradation of art that has been around for so long
and skills just because there's a lack of awareness.
Of how important and how large the economic impact of this industry is across the state.
You know, you have Skywalker Sound up in Northern California.
You have ILM. You have so many post-production homes here in Los Angeles and Burbank.
There's some in San Diego.
So we have to just show how big it is.
And because we're unseen doesn't mean that we are that we don't exist.
We are literally one third of the process as Ben alluded to earlier.
One thing that is different, Ben talked about there's three phases of making a film.
One thing that's different about production than post-production is production,
you hire different people per film.
There's different directors, different actors, different crew assembled for a short period of time.
Whether that's a 10-day shoot or a 30-day shoot or a two-month shoot, whatever that is.
And then they all kind of go away and we go into post-production.
Post-production, these are career, salaried usually, employees working at facilities,
living here full-time, have families.
They don't come into town just for the shoot.
The people in California have careers on salary that are being hired at all these studios,
at all these facilities, and this is where they're based.
So it's a different workforce in effect.
It's a long-term workforce where people have worked at these companies for decades.
And that's impacting their work differently.
Films can shoot all over the world, but then when you come back to post,
you're coming back to a company like an ILM or a Skywalker that has existed
and employs hundreds and hundreds of people.
How are people getting by in your space right now?
Clearly from the music side, we're losing a large part of our community.
People are having to maybe go work in symphony orchestras in other towns.
They're taking jobs in theater work.
If they can find work elsewhere, a lot of them have just left the workforce,
have left the music business, in our case, altogether.
Another thing I want to talk about that Amelia talked about that was really important
is that we don't have sort of an apprentice program like a lot of other industries do,
except we do.
When I was a young musician, there was so much work that both as a musician
and an orchestrator, I would sit in an orchestra as a young musician
next to the most seasoned performers in the business,
and I would learn from them.
So everything I learned in college was one thing.
My real education started on the job when I sat next to seasoned professionals.
When we had enough work, we were able to bring in all these young players
to supplement who had incredible talents,
and they really were able to grow to become the next generation.
The other aspect of what we're really losing, besides all the economic loss,
is an artistic loss.
For example, when we look at here what happens,
who plays in our jazz clubs here in Los Angeles,
who plays the chamber music concerts.
These are all the musicians who work on a daily basis in the studios.
When we lose the studio work, we lose a whole cultural lifeblood of our city.
So there's more at stake than just the entertainment jobs.
There's really a fight for our cultural lives here as well.
There was a tax credit that was given to the industry for $750 million
to revamp this industry, and is that not helping you guys?
It's helping us to a certain degree.
This tax incentive that we are introducing for this year
would cover projects that have shot elsewhere.
So in order to qualify for the existing production tax incentive,
a film or a television show has to shoot in California.
And there is a post-production qualifies under that.
So if something is shot in California,
then the post-production would qualify for the tax credit?
Exactly. And really, if we present this opportunity,
that might actually even incentivize productions to stay here
if they didn't qualify for the current tax incentive.
Because not every production is going to receive
or have the tax incentive awarded.
But if then there's a post-production option,
whether it's that they're going to shoot elsewhere
for creative or budgetary reasons,
if there is a savings in post-production,
that may even incentivize even further productions to stay in California
if we have this option.
And the other thing that's important to point out
is that we're not asking for something that doesn't already exist.
New York, Louisiana, New Mexico, I believe,
are states that already have a post-production tax incentive.
So really, there is no sense.
It doesn't make sense that California,
again, having the largest footprint and pool of talent,
does not offer something that other territories already do offer,
within the United States even.
My message box is sadly kind of full of heartache.
Hey, how are you doing? I'm miserable.
Thank God I'm in the VA.
I was able to get a second mortgage on the house.
But we're thinking of leaving.
Thinking of leaving California.
Over and over again.
Even my own wife said, like, why are we here if you can't get a job?
Well, A, I believe in this business, and I believe in all the people.
I was smiling when Dennis was recounting
his youthful adventures in scoring,
because that was my experience, too.
I showed up as a young person,
and people just taught me how to do things.
They were like, you should come here.
One of my dear friends taught me on my very first day
as a post-production assistant this little phrase,
let's think this through.
And I think of him all the time, and that was 20 years ago.
And that meant so much to me as a young person.
We've been talking about it here,
but film work in California is a legacy cluster.
The expertise, infrastructure, and talent pool is all here.
So when a place like Georgia sets up a post-production tax credit,
they can get started, but a lot of those dollars end up coming back here
because they need the experts to come and fix what they started.
So they're going to end up hiring some of our people here.
That's right, that's right.
And so what we're trying to,
we don't want to seed those dollars out to there.
The film industry is actually more potent
in terms of generating revenue for California
than the aerospace industry.
If we spend a dollar on film,
it generates another $0.93 in revenue for California.
Every post-production job equals 1.5 induced jobs.
Our salaries that go to pay our mortgage,
that go to the coffee shop, that go to the dog groomer,
a film job is worth 1.5 other jobs in California.
There's not enough awareness around that,
and I think we've taken for granted
that we were the core of the industry,
but it's buildable elsewhere,
and these other jurisdictions are,
as they have risen, the numbers are really clear.
We have gone down,
and this attrition of people and work is really,
it's agonizing,
because when I was a young person,
the mid-90s,
I got suspended from school for a little while,
but I had a professor who loved me,
and he basically was like,
call my friend John, and he will put you to work.
And I made a very small amount of money
cleaning up floors after the film,
after we finished shooting every day,
and it meant the absolute world to me.
And I've always felt, hence,
that I could go out and get a job.
There's a PA job for me somewhere,
and the sad truth of it is,
that's not real anymore.
I haven't been able to turn a dollar
on post-production in two years,
and I really thought I'd be like,
well, I can go be a PA.
No, and that's a big change.
Post-production, one of the things
that always fascinated me about post-production
is that there's a line.
There's definitely a moment in time.
Most people that ended up in post-production
came either for music,
or they found themselves in post-production
kind of by accident.
Maybe they wanted to be directors,
and then this was kind of like
the next best thing, right?
But then there's a definite moment in time
where someone actually woke up,
a child heard a sound effect,
and said, I want to go and study that.
And so the evolution of post-production
is quite fascinating.
But what I love about it
is that it continues to be accessible, right?
These are jobs that you really don't need
a four-year degree or an Ivy League education
to make a really good living out of,
to be successful, to be able to buy homes,
to be able to provide for families
and send your children to school.
So there are long, green, sustainable jobs
that we are relinquishing to other territories
because we're not being competitive enough
as a state.
And so it really is an investment,
one of the metrics that Assemblymember Nick Schultz
shared that our economists helped put together,
or actually this is public information.
In the fourth quarter of 2024,
the state of New York awarded 18 projects
the post-production tax incentive rebate.
That was about a $10-11 million investment
that the state made.
Those $11 million generated
around $50-$60 million of revenue for the state.
That was $60 million that was spent
in the state of New York
because the state of New York decided to invest
$11 million into their post-production community.
So that is the amount of money that we stand to lose
in revenue for the state
that we need to let legislators know,
hey, this is an investment.
This is not a handout.
This is an investment
not just in the economic facet of the state,
but also the cultural, right?
We don't want to lose that soft power, let's say,
that California has in terms of influence,
in terms of visibility.
How much is the incentive that you guys are looking for?
That is still being put together.
So I'll let Assemblymember Nick Schultz,
who's authoring the bill, present that.
But right now, where we are is,
so we formed the California Post Alliance, right?
The main mission was to advocate,
to educate, and to build community.
And the advocacy efforts are well on their way
with the introduction of this bill,
the Post Only Tax Incentive Bill.
And right now, it's going through legislative council.
And we're working with all of the stakeholders,
unions, vendors, artists,
to create the language of the bill.
And once that process is done,
we will be able to, or Assemblymember Nick Schultz's office
will be able to share all of the details.
So those are still being hashed out.
A lot of people might be wondering
why you guys haven't left the state to find other jobs.
You've been out of work for two years.
I'm sure with your skills,
you'd be easily finding other roles in other states.
Why are you guys here and advocating for California?
Well, one, you can't beat the weather.
I feel like the weather is awesome.
Why is that not like the number one point
of why are we saving the industry, right?
Can you imagine like Angelina Jolie sweating
in the heat of Texas?
We're here, her hair will be flawless.
Well, so truly, I'll use Karen Baker Landers.
She's our vice president for the California Post Alliance.
And she always says, California's a vibe.
It is a vibe.
There really is no other place in the world
that is as colorful in the best of ways as California.
There's people from all walks of life.
It's a state that embraces creativity.
And it's a place where you can make a living
out of being creative.
And so I still have complete and total faith in our community.
I love California.
Karen, as I quoted her,
she's the only woman in sound that has two Oscars.
No other state, no other country has that.
So this is a place where creativity is nurtured
and you can capitalize on that.
And so we don't, that's why I'm here.
I also think that, you know,
some of us are still lucky enough to be working.
I am, and I don't want to be the last of my kind
that works in this industry.
And I hate to think that I'm one of the last people
that gets to have a career in film music.
I mean, I've had a wonderful life because of it.
I mean, it's provided cultural opportunities for me,
financial opportunities.
And to think that, you know,
that there may be nobody after me that gets to experience that
is a horrifying thought.
And I think that's a big part of why we formed this group
is we don't want to be the last of our breed.
That's right.
And I think we, I want to say too, you know,
there was a conventional wisdom that used to say
that post-production would follow production.
If we produced a picture someplace,
it would post in that same place.
But now there are opportunities elsewhere.
In many ways, we talk about this,
we're sort of in a trade war right now with other places.
And I think there's a global trade war.
And there's many places that are,
that have seen the value of what we do
and they want to attract those jobs.
As Brian said,
these are jobs that aren't just a one-off job
that lasts for three or four weeks.
These are careers that last, spend a lifetime.
And other cities want to create those opportunities,
other locations.
London wants to do that.
They offer a standalone post-production credit
and they do it really for no other reason
except they want the jobs that we've created,
they would like to create that there.
And I think this is why it's important.
And I just want to say too,
that the post-production tax credit,
any tax credit in the entertainment industry
is not a charitable event at all.
This is money that actually, you know,
makes money for the states.
And it's made money for every state
that's offered an incentive,
has actually made money on it.
So it's not like the state is giving money away.
It's an investment.
And it's an investment to keep those
kind of long-term jobs here,
to create longevity for these jobs, you know,
for generations long after I'm no longer here
to have people doing exactly what I'm doing right now.
For me, the why was because I was born in California.
I was born here.
This is my home.
And I refuse to believe that we cannot come together
and do things that will make us vibrant again.
And I also recognize and fully believe,
you know, the United States doesn't make a lot anymore.
I mean, I'm talking about, like,
things are often designed or conceived here
and then made elsewhere and then shipped back in.
But entertainment is one of the things
that the United States, particularly California,
makes and exports to the world.
And if there's an intellectual property or a thing
that certainly the United States,
but more so even California,
certainly provides the entire world of,
it's our entertainment.
And I think that concept of that intellectual property
that we export is so valuable to our industry,
so valuable to our country,
and we are so good at it
that there is no reason why we cannot come together,
no matter where you're at in this country,
even politically,
and we cannot recognize that
and come together to save what we have built.
Because we've already built this.
It's here.
And we just need to do the things to be competitive
and to make it vibrant again.
So you guys did make a good case for your tax credit.
Well, we'll see what happens with California lawmakers.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much.
Thank you for having us.
Yeah, this is terrific.
Thank you for giving us the platform
to educate on post-production,
which is one of the missions of our organization.
What do you think about the post-production in California?
Do you think we should offer them tax credits?
You can always email us at
siamakarkaliforniainsider.com or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Karami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.
