ARTH 4007 Robert Campin Part 1

Art of the Renaissance Period
59 followers
18 Video Views·Mar 18, 2026
Art Historian Dr. Vida Hull
ETSU Online Programs - http://www.etsu.edu/online
Northern Renaissance
Robert Campin, the master of Flamaul.
We're not sure of his birth date.
Somewhere in the neighborhood of 1375 to 79.
Robert Campin died on April 26th, 1444.
The historical story of Robert Campin begins with these two panels
and one is painted on the front and the back.
They've now been severed
so you can look at them as three different images.
But these panels that we call the Flamaul panels,
today they're in Frankfurt in the Städel,
the Kunstinstitut, the Städelische Kunstinstitut.
And as you can see, you have Saint Veronica,
the Virgin Mary and the Christ Child and the Trinity.
And we want to look at each of these.
Now, these panels were once believed to come from
a monastery at Flamaul, which is near Liege.
And they had this artwork with a very distinctive style,
but they didn't know the name of the artist who painted it.
And this is something that happens a lot in art
and particularly in early Netherlandish art.
You start to group the artists by style
and sometimes we never find out their name.
We just give them a conventional name.
In this case, he was called the Master of Flamaul.
You see here the Virgin and Child,
Mary offering her breast to the nursing Christ Child.
And you can see the style.
It's a style where the figures seem to be weighty.
They have a kind of tangible material existence
that's called plasticity, three-dimensionality, volumetric.
The features are somewhat fleshy.
You have kind of earthy figures.
And it's been suggested that his style is additive,
that he has many, many particular items
that go together to make these images.
And here we're looking at the picture of Saint Veronica.
Now, it's a little unusual to see Veronica as an old woman.
Usually, Veronica is shown as a young woman.
Veronica is a figure of legend, actually.
Her name means Vera, icon, true image.
And the story was that when Christ was being led
to his death on the cross,
a woman wiped his face with her veil
or her napkin with a cloth.
And the visage of Christ, the face of Christ,
became imprinted on that cloth.
And this was known as Veronica's veil
because it was a true image.
So that's where her name comes from, Vera, icon.
Or sometimes it's the pseudonym.
So here we see her holding up that image of Christ.
And in this case, it's very unusual.
He's showing, the artist is showing you the image of Christ
on a kind of translucent veil,
very, you can see right through it to the cloth beneath.
So she's displaying it for her veneration.
On the back of the Veronica once was a grisaille trinity.
And I think I've said this before, but I'll say it again.
We talk about this term grisaille, which means gray.
And we think that very often the exteriors of altar pieces
were painted in more subdued colors.
So they would be closed during the week and open for mass.
And then during Lent, they would be closed
and then opened on Easter Sunday
with all the beautiful colors inside.
You can see that this has the illusion
of being an unpainted stone statue
standing in a niche, looks very solid.
And you have cast shadows,
which give it the feeling of reality.
This becomes a tradition that artists will show
on the outside of a painting,
the holy figures as though they were stone statues.
Now, in this case, the iconography is the throne of grace
where God the Father offers his Son
for the salvation of mankind.
And when you look at the detail,
you can see all of the details of the beard, of the crown.
And you can also see the little dove of the Holy Spirit
sort of perched on Christ's shoulder.
So this does make it the trinity with God the Father
as the bearded man, crowned,
God the Son, Christ, who has died for the sins of mankind.
And the dove, the dove of the Holy Spirit.
So we have an artist that's called the Master of Flamaul,
who now is generally identified as Robert Campin.
So how was the Master of Flamaul identified
as Robert Campin?
In 1909, an art historian named Georges Huland de Luz
found authenticated paintings
by an artist named Jacques Dara.
These paintings had the arms of Jan de Klerk
and there were documents and auras describing payments
to Jacques Dara for polychroming statues
and for painting four subjects
as wings to an altarpiece of 1434.
Now, they had those paintings
and the paintings were similar
but not identical to the Flamaul style.
The Flamaul style also seemed to be similar
but not identical to some paintings by Roger van der Weyden.
So it sort of puts them in that circle
and we have some documents about Dara and Roger van der Weyden.
Jacques Dara was a pupil,
an apprentice to an artist named Robert Campin of Tournai.
Dara was in his household from about 1418,
probably coming there as a very young child
and he became a master in 1432.
So here we have something similar.
Now, there were also documents
showing that Roger van der Weyden
was an apprentice to Campin
and he became a master in 1432.
So because of those similarities,
said, okay, it's not exactly like Dara,
it's not Roger van der Weyden,
it's somebody who has a connection with both of them,
who better than their master?
And it was decided that the master of Flamaul
was probably Robert Campin.
And that identification has held up,
well, all the way through the 20th century
and into the 21st.
Now, as I said, we have some documents on Robert Campin.
These aren't all the documents,
but it's giving you an idea of some of the things
that we know about Robert Campin.
He was active in Tournai.
He doesn't seem to have been born in Tournai
because he purchased his citizenship.
In 1410, by 1422, he was married
to a woman, Isabel,
who was seven years older than he was.
He served in various offices.
For example, in 1423, he was the sub-dean
of the Goldsmiths and Painters Guild.
In 1425 and 1427, he was the steward of the city
and he held other city offices.
And then he got involved in a rebellion
and a push for a democratic government.
The rebellion was put down
and Campin was fined in 1429.
He was also sentenced to make a pilgrimage
to Saint-Gilles in Provence.
This is Saint-Gilles-du-Garde.
As punishment for his participation in the rebellion
and the subsequent democratic government
that was set up.
In 1432, Robert Campin was sentenced
to a one year's exile
for living an immoral life with Laura Paulette.
The name Paulette means chicken
and I admit, art historians sort of think of her
as Campin's little chickie.
At any rate, it's been suggested
that the sentence was really connected
with his political activities
and that this was used as a kind of excuse.
Whatever the case is,
it looked like he was going to have
to close down his workshop and go on exile.
However, he didn't have to.
There was an intervention by Madame de Hanoi
who could be either Margaret of Burgundy
or Jacoba of Bavaria.
They both use that title
and because of this aristocratic intervention,
the sentence was reduced to a fine.
However, they didn't know that was going to happen.
So, we see in 1432,
several of Campin's apprentices
including Roger von der Weyden
and Jacques Derat become masters.
In other words, they've been apprentices for many years.
They've been working in the Campin workshop
but now when it looks like the Campin workshop
is going to be closed down,
they can't just continue to paint.
They have to be masters in their own right
and it kind of shows
that they were really advanced artists
and possibly well thought of
because Derat almost immediately
becomes the guild provost.
In other words, he has an office in the guild.
So, we believe that the reason
they chose to become masters at that time
was because they thought
that the workshop would close down
when he was going on exile.
The only paintings attributed to Campin
that are dated
are two panels in the Museo del Prado in Madrid
and they're known as the Whorl Altar Wings
and they're dated 1438
which is fairly late in Campin's career.
And here they are,
see, both showing a domestic interior
with the donor kneeling with John the Baptist
and then on the other wing
we see Saint Barbara reading.
There's John the Baptist with Heinrich Whorl
the donor and Saint Barbara.
Now, there's an inscription at the bottom
and that identifies the donor
and it gives the date
and this would be the translation
in the year 1438
I painted this effigy of Master Heinrich von Whorl,
Doctor of Cologne.
Now, we know something about him.
Heinrich von Whorl is the Provençal
of the Franciscan Order in Cologne
from 1432 onward.
He's a professor of theology
at the University of Cologne
and was a very well-known preacher.
And here you have a very naturalistic,
undoubtedly recognizable portrait.
You'll notice that he's kneeling,
he's praying to whatever was the holy image
in the middle of the altarpiece.
Now, one of the interesting things
is that we can see parallels
between the work of Roger van der Weyden
and the figures shown in the Whorl wings.
And so here is a painting,
a detail from a painting,
it's actually been cut up
and one of the fragments that survive
is St. Mary Magdalene by Roger van der Weyden,
now in the National Gallery in London.
And you can see that St. Barbara,
although she's seated on a bench,
but she's very much in a similar pose.
So one suggestion was
that perhaps Roger van der Weyden was so great
that he even influenced his master.
Here's another example.
Roger van der Weyden's Christ appearing to his mother
from the Miraflores altarpiece,
which now is in the Gemäldegalerie in Berlin.
The pose of Christ, particularly the raised hands,
where he's showing his wounds to Mary,
this is after his resurrection,
and he appears to his mother
and he's displaying that he's come back from the dead
and that he truly was wounded,
he's showing those wounds.
Well, the raised hand makes sense.
But then we look at St. John the Baptist
who also has his hand raised in a similar manner,
presumably sort of protection over the donor,
but John the Baptist doesn't have
the holes of nails in his hands,
it's not showing his wounds,
so it has been transferred perhaps
from another event
and doesn't make quite as much sense.
So that's another example where they say,
well, maybe Campin took it from Roger van der Weyden.
However, we think that the date
of the Miraflores altarpiece
was around 1440 or 1444
and that painting was in Spain.
So how would Campin have seen it?
So that raises another question,
oh, two other questions.
Could both of these images
refer back to an earlier painting
with a similar pose, a similar gesture,
which could be by Campin
or it could be by Roger van der Weyden?
But then there's the other question,
could the mural altarpiece
be by a follower of Campin,
not by Campin himself?
We'll leave that for now.
No, we won't leave it for now.
We'll ask these questions.
Are the mural panels really by Campin
or, as has been suggested,
are they a pastiche by another artist?
And a pastiche is when you take elements
from different works of art
and you put them together
in creating a new work of art.
And according to this theory,
it is not by Campin himself
but a follower of Campin
who's using motifs from Roger van der Weyden
using motifs from Robert Campin.
If that's the truth,
then we have no dated paintings by Campin.
Could the mural altarpiece
come from the Campin workshop
or could it be by an artist
trained by Campin?
There's a lot of unanswered
and maybe unanswerable questions.
So let's just look at this
as part of the Campin group
and I should explain that phrase,
the Campin group.
There is a series of books
that's put out by
the Royal Institute of Artistic Patrimony,
the Institut Royal du Patrimoine Artistique
in Brussels.
And what they do is
they will have a book
where they will talk about
the Campin group
or the Roger van der Weyden group
or the Jan van Eyck group.
So if there are pictures
that seem to be related to that artist,
they'll put them in the group
even if they think
they might be followers,
even if some people think
they could be workshop pieces
or another artist
who's modeling himself
on the more renowned artist.
So there are a lot of
attribution questions
with the body of works,
the au voir,
that's attributed to Campin.
So let's look at
some of the details here.
We see this convex mirror
in which is reflected
both the room
and the saint who's standing there.
So the saint is taking on
a very tangible presence.
He actually can be reflected
in the mirror.
And we also see this little statue
of the Virgin and Child
which is hanging on the wall
and, you know,
how meticulously it's shown.
I'm going to look at
some of the details
from the Saint Barbara wing.
Barbara is seated on this settle.
This is a bench
with a footrest and cushions.
It was a very substantial
piece of furniture
and it marks
the owner of the room
as being relatively well-to-do.
We might say, you know,
middle class or upper middle class,
but someone that can afford
nice furniture.
In the room,
there are a number of objects,
one of which is this metal,
possibly copper pitcher.
Another statue, in this case,
the Throne of Grace,
the Trinity where God
offers Christ on the cross.
And a little view
through the window
where you see a man
riding on a road
which circles around
the other figures,
the landscape details.
Well, we're now going
to go back to
one of the works
that's believed to be
very early in Campin's career.
And pretty much everyone
gives this painting
to Robert Campin.
It's known as the
Cerlin Lamentation Triptych.
Now, I'm not going to ask
that you remember Cerlin.
I'll just call it the Lamentation
or the Lamentation Triptych.
It is today
in the Courtauld Institute
in London,
attached to the
University of London.
And we think that it dates
from fairly early
in Campin's career,
from about 1415 to 20,
one of the possibly
earliest paintings we have
that's associated with Campin.
As you can see,
it's got three different panels,
a donor panel,
the entombment in the center,
and then a resurrection.
Let's look at the donor first.
We don't know the donor's name.
We see him kneeling in prayer.
He has a little dog beside him.
Does it show his fidelity
to his faith?
Or is it just really his little dog?
Could be either.
Could be both.
We see a winding road
that leads up to the
hill of Golgotha
and the empty cross
where Christ has been
taken down from the cross
to be laid in the tomb,
which we see, of course,
in the center.
The thieves are still
hanging on their cross.
The landscape seems to rise
very steeply.
And it has been suggested
that winding road
may refer not just
as the way to Golgotha,
but could also be a metaphor
for the pilgrimage of life.
The background,
and you'll see this
all three panels,
is what we call tooled gold.
It's covered with gold leaf
over, well,
you'd have your
sealed wooden panel
and then you would apply
red bowl or gilders clay to it.
And you can build up
with gesso
or something to build up
patterns in this.
And you can use tools
to stamp designs.
And then you would take
gold leaf and apply it
to this adhesive red bowl
or gilders clay
over the whole surface.
And then, of course,
it would be burnished.
So it suggests a kind of
heavenly, timeless background.
Now you can see the scroll
or banderol next to the
donor and he's praying.
And presumably his words
would be written on it,
but there's nothing left.
So maybe the words have,
you know, flaked off
over the centuries.
He probably was
praying for salvation,
perhaps saying something like,
have mercy on me,
oh Lord.
He's facing
the panel with the entombment.
And there we see
Joseph of Arimathea
and Nicodemus
laying Christ in
the sarcophagus.
At this point where
he's being held above
this tomb,
this sarcophagus,
and he's displayed
for our veneration.
We see Mary
leaning over to embrace
and give her son
a last kiss.
We see John
reaching out and supporting her.
And in the foreground,
we see two holy women
who are facing inward.
We just see their backs.
That does two things.
It makes us feel
that there's a real spatial,
that there's really space there
for the figures to
be in a foreground
before everyone else,
and they're able to
turn in space.
But also because
they're looking in
from the same direction
that the viewer is,
they lead our eye
to the veneration
of the body of Christ.
You can also see
that there are angels
with the instruments
of the passion.
The flying angels
with these draperies
that flutter, it seems,
are holding
the crown of thorns
and the nails.
There are angels
standing
on either side
of the panel.
One is holding the lance
that pierced Christ's side,
and the other
is holding the spear
with the sponge
soaked in vinegar
that was offered to Christ
when he said,
I thirst.
That angel is weeping.
He's rubbing his eyes.
Now, later we'll hear
that Erwin Panofsky
says that
Roger van der Weyden
is the first person
to paint tears
in the history of art,
or at least that we know of.
And I thought of this painting,
and so I went to London
and I went to look at it,
and yes,
there are no visible tears.
So he's weeping
and he's wiping his eyes
and the eyes are red,
but you're not actually
seeing the tears.
Now, if there ever were any,
you know, the glaze
that had them in,
the top layer
would have been
abraded over the years,
but all I can say
is there are no visible tears.
Does this have a deeper
iconographic meaning
that relates it to
its placement on an altar?
Presumably it was
on an altar.
And Barbara Lane
has written pretty extensively
about this.
She compares this painting
to the rite of reserving
the host on Good Friday.
Now, the host,
the word comes from
the Latin word for victim.
So it refers to
the sacrificial victim,
in this case,
the consecrated bread,
which is transformed
into the body of Christ.
And on Good Friday,
there is a mass
and the host,
the consecrated bread
that is supposed to be
the body of Christ,
is saved or reserved.
It's placed in a receptacle,
which is known as the
sepulchrum,
the sepulcher.
And on Saturday,
they do not consecrate
the bread.
This is when Christ
is in the tomb
until the host
is resurrected
on Easter Sunday.
And so here,
the body of Christ
is stretched out
right above
the table of the altar,
if this was an altarpiece,
which it presumably was.
And Barbara Lane
sees that analogy
between the host
and the body of Christ
depicted
and the event
of the entombment,
which is reenacted
in the reserve host.
Now, the style
of quite interesting,
because there are some things
that we would say
are old.
They're the traditional way
things were done.
But we always think
of Robert Campion,
Jan van Eyck,
Roger van der Weyden
as being the founders
of this new naturalism.
So we're seeing
sort of both things
going on in this painting,
and that's one reason
it's dated so early.
You have things like
the tooled gold background,
and this is very,
very traditional.
But you also have
this almost sculptural
feeling of the figures,
the plasticity
or the plastique
of the new naturalism
showing you solid figures.
And you'll notice
that there's a lot
of very sharp angular
outlines and folds,
which adds to the feeling
of suffering.
There's a detail
of that weeping angel
I told you of,
and yes,
you don't see any tears,
but you know
that he's rubbing his eyes.
And you might also
take a look at this
tooled gold background
in every single
panel of this painting.
It's very elaborate
and it shows you
vine scrolls
and of course,
every time in Christian art
we see
vines,
grapes,
that reminds us of wine
and reminds us of
the blood of Christ.
Because during the Eucharist
or the communion service
or the Mass,
the sacrament of
the bread and wine,
the bread is believed
to be transformed
into the body of Christ,
the wine into the blood
of Christ.
And there we see
the details again.
And here's the final
panel,
the right panel
as we're looking at it.
The resurrection.
What comes after
the entombment?
Christ is three days
in the tomb
and on Easter Sunday
celebrates
the resurrection of Christ.
Here,
he's stepping forth
from an open tomb,
from an open sarcophagus.
You'll remember
that the master
of Trebon
showed a closed
and sealed sarcophagus.
So, you know,
there's different ways
to show it.
And the
soldiers who are
the sleeping soldiers
who are supposed
to be guarding the tomb
to make sure
that the apostles,
the disciples,
the followers of Christ
don't come and steal the body,
some of them are waking up.
And we see them here
in, you know,
the one soldier
who's wakened up.
He seems to be very shocked.
Well, he might very well be
if someone's stepping
out of a tomb alive
and he's agitated.
There's a feeling of chaos
with all these angular shapes
and you can see
how the soldier's costumes
are very exotic.
It's hard to say,
you know,
far away,
long ago
in this
far eastern
exotic location.
And so now you see
how all three of these panels
work together.
Another painting
that is unfailingly
attributed to Robert Campin
is the nativity in Dijon.
This is in
the capital of Burgundy
and we see,
once again,
weighty figures
exist in volumes.
We see many,
many particular details.
We see a vast landscape
and we see in that landscape
and in some of these details
observation of the visible world,
something that's creating
what we sometimes call
the new naturalism.
The figures are
somewhat earthy,
somewhat fleshy.
Look at some of them.
Now, there are a number
of literary sources
for the nativity.
One, obviously,
is the Bible,
the story of
the birth of Christ
in Saint Luke.
And there are prophecies
of the coming of Christ
in Isaiah,
at least the Christians
believe them to be prophecies
of the coming of Christ.
There is also
what is known
as the Proto-Evangelium,
an apocryphal gospel
that tells the story
of the midwives,
which we'll talk about.
And another literary source
for the things
that are going on
in this picture
are the revelations
of Saint Bridget of Sweden.
Now, Saint Bridget
lived in the late 14th century
and in 1372, I believe,
she went to the Holy Land
and she visited
the various sacred sites.
And at many of them,
she would have a vision.
When she was at the grotto
of the nativity,
Mary appeared to her
and showed her
what it was like
at the birth of Christ.
This vision was then told
in her book of revelations
or visions of Saint Bridget.
And it made a great impact on art.
What she says happened is
Mary is dressed all in white
and she's ready to give birth
to the child.
And suddenly she says,
I know not by what member
the child is born.
One moment it's in Mary's womb,
the next moment it is lying
naked and shining on the ground.
In other words,
the child does not pass
through the birth passage.
It's a miraculous birth.
The child comes
from the sealed womb.
As later, it's sometimes said
he comes from the sealed tomb.
It is a miraculous birth.
And she also compares
the light of Joseph's candle
to the radiance of the Christ child.
The light of the candle,
the natural light is nothing
compared to the light of the child.
So there you see the detail
of the child lying on the ground,
naked and shining.
And you see the gold rays of light
coming from the child.
We call this type of image
a Bridgetine Nativity,
when the child is lying
naked and shining on the ground.
And you will see this used
over and over in Renaissance art.
Now, I promised to tell you
about the midwives.
The midwives are from
this apocryphal gospel,
a proto evangelium
before the gospels.
And Mary's about to give birth.
So Joseph goes to find
midwives in Bethlehem.
And when he returns,
she's already given birth.
There's two midwives.
And Mary explains that
this was a miraculous birth,
that the child was,
that she was a virgin.
And one midwife believes in it.
She has faith.
But the other one does not.
Well, you know,
I got to check this one out.
And it says she reaches out her hand
and her hand is withered.
And then Mary tells her
to touch the child
or her hand will be healed.
And because of this miracle,
she then believes.
So the midwife who is kneeling
is the believing midwife.
The one who is standing
with her hand outstretched,
she's the one whose hand withered
before she would believe.
Let's take a look at
some of the landscaped elements.
In the far background,
you have a rising sun.
It symbolizes the dawn of a new era,
the era under grace.
It's also quite interesting
because it is in gold.
So we have all of these,
you know, naturalistic elements.
And yet you have,
you might say,
that old fashioned method
of showing sunlight
as gold and golden rays.
And yet that makes it richer.
And it was undoubtedly
what the patron would have wanted.
And then we see this detailed,
panoramic landscape
with the winding road
that draws your eye back.
You know, you get some idea
of the journey of the shepherds,
the journey of Joseph and Mary
to Bethlehem.
It's a little detail
of the flying angels
singing Gloria in excelsis Dea.
And here are the shepherds
who have come to adore Christ.
See them as though perhaps
they're three different ages.
And, you know,
the oldest bearded person
has taken his hat off.
The others are leaning
over his shoulder,
you know, looking
at this newborn babe
who is the savior of the world.
You'll notice that one of them
is carrying a bagpipe.
Now, that's not a Scottish bagpipe.
Bagpipes come in different forms,
but you'll very frequently
see the bagpipe
used as a kind of peasant instrument.
And we'll see in other works of art
that it may actually
have some other meanings as well.
And there are just
some of the details.
