Misrepresentation _ Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 18, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back everybody to the Law of Contracts. In this lesson we are continuing talking about
the processes of bringing contracts to an end and we're going to begin with the first major
method by which this takes place. This is obviously through the idea of misrepresentation.
So this lesson is essentially going to talk about misrepresentation, taking something of
an introduction to the subject. We'll examine some of the basic terminology in this area,
as well as the ways in which misrepresentation ties into these basic conversations. We'll explain
what actionable misrepresentation is, what it looks like, we'll look at the delineation between
void and voidable when it comes to contracts and we will just take a look at some of the basic
case law in the area as well. So as a basic preliminary we need to make a delineation
between what is known as a void contract versus a voidable contract. What is the difference between
these two concepts? But when looking at vitiating factors, as well as other instances where there
may be an opportunity for a contract to come to an end, that is not obviously through the
specific performance of a contract, we will often use the language of void and voidable.
What these two things mean is if a contract is void, it will be treated as though it had
never existed in the first place. In fact, when a contract is actually considered to be void,
the law will just assume that it never existed in the first place, owing to the fact that it
could have never had any legal effect. That's what void means, it means that it essentially has no
basis for existing in law. A contract will be voidable where an aggrieved party is able at
their own discretion to render the contract void owing to some kind of foul play on the part of
the other side of the contract. So a contract is voidable essentially if there is an aggrieved
party, let's say there is some breach of contractual terms for example, and the person on the other
side who has been aggrieved by this breach of contract can say we choose to either void the
contract and therefore it ceases to exist, it no longer existed, or we can carry on with maybe the
imposition of damages or some kind of remedy for the breach. That is what voidability means,
it means it has essentially the potential of being void so long as the aggrieved party at their
discretion decides to do so, but it doesn't necessarily have to be void. So that's the
distinction. A contract is void, if a contract is void then it is a far stronger claim you're
making that it is voidable, but it could still represent a void contract if the aggrieved party
decides to do so in that way. Continuing on with the various different preliminaries and the key
terminology that is attached therein, let's make a distinction here between misrepresentation and
actionable misrepresentation. When we talk about something being actionable misrepresentation,
what we are doing here is referring to statements which are made prior to the formal conclusion of
a contract, which are made by one of the parties which are false or misleading and may induce the
other party to contract on the basis of that false or misleading statement. Like I said, the
resulting information is then inducive to the other party to then enter the contract.
So if I say, if I tell a lie or I mislead some factual circumstance and the telling of that
lie or the misleading of that factual circumstance induces another person to enter into a contractual
arrangement on the basis of that misrepresentation, then we have what is known as actionable
misrepresentation. There are a number of requirements to satisfy the concept of actionable
misrepresentation and these include the fact that the statement must be a statement of material fact,
it must be something that is either false or misleading, it must also induce the other person
to contract as well. So these are the things that are required if you're thinking about,
or if you have a problem question that is on the subject of actionable misrepresentation.
You must first determine that the statement in question that is being essentially discussed,
that is being analysed as potentially being misrepresentation, firstly that must be a
statement of material fact. The statement then must also be either false or it must be misleading
and then the false or misleading statement of material fact must also induce the other party
to the contract. What do we mean by all of these things? What is a material fact? What is a
statement by material fact? Well it is something that is quite difficult to ascertain sometimes,
there are some instances in which it is very easy to ascertain. You could for example have
a contract for the sale of a car let's say, a sale of a vehicle and you say that the car is
working absolutely fine, when in fact you know that it is probably not. Then that may be a
statement of material fact about the about the quality of the product and because of that statement
of material fact about the quality of the product that is false or misleading, that may induce an
individual to enter into a contract to purchase the vehicle. That could be considered actionable
misrepresentation. There are a number of statements which could be considered to be fair rather than
being false statements of material fact and this is really where we get to the first case that we
can look at in this area of the law. The case of Bissett versus Wilkinson or Bissett versus
Wilkinson from 1927 and this gives us an illustration of the idea of a material fact,
a statement of material fact and the extent to which it may be false as the result and therefore
contribute to actionable misrepresentation. The case itself was a case which concerned the
question of whether a statement of opinion could constitute a statement of material fact
for the purposes of actionable misrepresentation. Specifically the claimant in this case was the
owner of a piece of land, the defendant in this case was an individual who wanted to purchase the
from the claimant for some sheep farming. The difficulty was in the representation of the
capacity of sheep that could be kept on the land itself. The claimant suggested that around 2,000
sheep may be the capacity. When this turned out to be false the defendant refused to pay
the future instalment on the basis that this was misrepresentation.
So the defendant, they are the defendants in this case because they refused to pay and then
the claimant sued for breach of contract for their refusal to pay. But the defendant's argument is
this is false, this is a false statement and it was misrepresentation. So what you see here is
could the claim that it had a capacity of around 2,000 sheep, could that represent
a statement of material fact? Is that then a false statement of material fact? Well that's
something that you would understand on the basis of the facts of the case, whether or not 2,000
sheep could actually be on that particular piece of land. And then finally did that induce the
defendant to actually contract with the claimant? That is what the defendant argued was the case.
Well it was held by the Privy Council that in fact there was no misrepresentation on the basis that
because the land had never been used for sheep farming the actual capacity of that land, the
amount of sheep that could actually ever be put on that farm, could not be available information
to the claimant. The claimant was stating an opinion rather than a statement of material fact,
a false statement of material fact. They believed that it could be around 2,000 as the capacity,
but they could never actually know that for certain because that piece of land had never
been used for sheep farming. So they just looked at how big the land was and made the assumption
that they could farm 2,000 sheep on it. When this then turned out to be false this was not
misrepresentation according to the Privy Council. They offered an opinionated statement and this
statement was not made on the basis of fact and so as a result of which it could not be understood
on the basis of fact and so the parties involved could not then sue on the basis of misrepresentation
or at least could not refuse to pay on the basis of misrepresentation.
