Breaking Down The Battle Between Mercedes & Ferrari | Jolyon Palmer’s F1 TV Analysis

Trackside Racing
5 followers
#F1 #ChineseGP
Jolyon Palmer takes a close look at how the battle between Mercedes and Ferrari unfolded in China.
AI Generated·May contain errors
So the Mercedes early on managed to re-pass the Ferraris and it looks like they're in a league
of their own until the safety car comes out and this seems to really hurt George Russell
as he has no tyre warm-up on the restart and he actually gets re-passed by Hamilton and then by
Charles Leclerc as well. So we're into another quirk of the new rules and this is the balance
between harvesting energy in the battery, getting it topped up for the restart and warming your
and speaking to a lot of the drivers they're saying actually the tyres are almost secondary now
because if you start a lap, a restart, a race start with nothing in the battery because you've
spent so much energy warming and getting the tyres into the right window, the tyres and the brakes,
if you've got no battery you are dead meat anyway and that's what happened to quite a few
at the start of the Australian Grand Prix. There is a recharge limit to how much you can get so
you think at low speed you keep braking, you keep part throttle, you can just keep recharging but
it's nine megajoules of recharge allowed and once you've spent a load of that by trying to warm the
brakes by being more aggressive on the throttle you then don't have more of an allowance to get
the battery topped up. So that was the issue in Melbourne and you can see here under the safety
car a bit of data Antonelli versus Russell and they have really different approaches to how
they're going to keep some temperature in their hard tyres at this stage. You've got Antonelli
who basically doesn't really use the brakes very much, he goes to half throttle and that means he's
not using energy from the battery so he's doing a load of weaving as a result. You can see the
steering trace here, Antonelli in the blue, loads of weaving, snaking the car down the straights a
lot more than George Russell and that's his way of putting energy through the tyres, it goes a lot
more to the fronts and it's a little bit more risky on the rears but that's Antonelli doing
his work. Russell meanwhile has a lot more accelerating and braking events which is more
old school and traditionally would be the better way to warm up your tyres, you heat the brakes,
the brakes heat the tyres and you put energy through them anyway longitudinally rather than
laterally. So you can see George much more aggressive on the throttle here going full throttle
whereas Kimi's just sort of holding it around 50%. Long story short, it looked like Antonelli's
version was better, he managed to fire up the tyres a little bit better than Russell. Russell
then had to be a little bit careful as well later on in the lap that he didn't cook the
battery, use too much and end up as a sitting duck to the Ferraris and that meant ironically
he had no tyres when it started so the hard tyres hadn't fired up and Antonelli as well
had a little bit of a buffer with Colopinto and Ocon between himself and his teammate and Lewis
Hamilton so that allowed Antonelli a bit more of a reprieve and George Russell fell down to fourth
and he stays there for the moment but Russell is deep and Lewis Hamilton's up a place. George
Russell's quest to win this Grand Prix just got harder. Okay, the big Ferrari duel then and this
is where we're going to see eventually George Russell come through but let's diagnose what's
going on here between these Ferraris because they have been putting on quite a show for us
through the first couple of weekends. I love the way that both Lewis and Charles have been driving,
super aggressive but ultimately on the limit of clean and fair, respectable between the two,
so hats off to them. It starts on lap 24, Lewis looking after his tyres at this stage,
you can see how close you've got Charles and you've got George Russell behind.
When you're within a second you get a little bit more energy deployment, it's called overtake
in 2026 and it allows you basically to have more deployment for longer down the back straight so
this is where it kicks in for Charles with a bit of a slipstream as well. He has to do it on the
brakes, dives to the inside and takes the place off of Lewis, that second place at this stage.
The problem is when you now use your battery down the back straight, you use that overtake,
you become vulnerable so this is what we've seen sort of yo-yo racing where someone makes the move
but then they've used the battery and now if someone else, if the driver has been overtaken,
has been able to harvest that a little bit more they can just come straight back.
So in this particular occasion you've got Charles now trying to harvest desperately on this run to
the final turn because then we've got another run up to turn one which is longer and it's a chance
for Hamilton and possibly Russell to repass. So look at Leclerc, the rear light starts blinking
and he's basically harvesting up towards the final turn. So you had Russell getting on the radio
saying what's Charles doing, he's backing up Lewis and me. Yes, because he's desperately trying to
harvest the battery and allow himself something to defend into this final turn. So when we get
through here we can see straight away this is now the straight and he looks immediately into his
mirrors and thinks has Lewis got anything more to offer to come back because he's obviously used his
battery into that big hairpin and on this occasion he's managed to just harvest enough
to keep Lewis at bay but of course Lewis now has the overtake enabled for the next run of laps and
that gives us our next moment on lap 26 and this is a big one then, this big brawl between
the two Ferraris, love to see it in the hairpin. Charles doesn't defend particularly hard this time, Lewis
comes through and that's back up into second position but the overtake then goes to Charles
and you can see here the overtake marker board at the final turn, OT. So that's where if you're
behind there it's like DRS in years gone by but you get it for the whole lap, a little bit more
energy that you can harvest and thus deploy. So we get Charles coming back in towards turn one and he
sweeps around the outside and this is just fantastic racing between the two Ferraris but at
the cost of loads of battery through the lap. So you've got them fighting it out, really keen to
assert a little bit of authority in the team early on, they obviously realise they've got a good
chance this year. You've got Lewis now coming down the inside again at turn six and all the while
they're fighting, they're using battery and you've got George Russell sitting behind just watching
this with the popcorn out thinking okay I'm going to wait my chance and it'll come to him. So we've
got harvesting through seven but all the while now Hamilton's thinking maybe I'll do a little bit
more and then Leclerc's thinking maybe I'll do a little bit more and they're sort of teasing each
other to use their batteries against each other through this middle sector where it's the best
place to harvest, it's difficult to overtake and you're off throttle for longer. All in all it
means that Russell now attacks in towards turn 11, we come through turns 12 and 13 and the Ferraris
have been going at it so hard with each other that they've now got nothing left to defend from
Russell. So they've been just working against each other too much that after 11 laps of Russell
sitting there finally because the Ferraris have been racing so competitively with each other,
George manages to just breeze past Lewis Hamilton and he's not far away from clearing Charles Leclerc
as well at that moment. What it looks like from Russell here is should be Lewis on the on the
attack but of course Charles has the overtake because he was behind at the start of the last
lap so there's a benefit for him and it's just simply the easiest pass that George will have
for a podium position and it's not long either before he manages to clear Charles. If you're
Lewis here you're thinking please I need a little bit more juice I want to go and take second place
unfortunately he doesn't have that overtake which means Charles has a chance to top up the battery
more down this back straight and boof there goes George, nothing that Lewis can do because he's
basically used all of his ammo in the middle sector. Absolutely mad it was such a tough battle
it was just so so hard out there just to it was great great fun like dicing with the the cars I
wish that you know we had a good start and then I just kept losing the lead you know it's really
hard to hold the the Mercedes off it was impossible actually they were just so quick on the straight
so we've really got to step up so we can I think the car is good enough we just need more power on
the straights. Now to illustrate this the driving differences make such a big difference to the
deployment around the lap so almost the the best driver right now can be the most efficient driver
it's not necessarily about going really quick through the corners it's about going very
efficiently through the corners and keeping your speed up but then that gives you payback on the
straight so this was Charles Leclerc in SQ3 on Friday afternoon versus Lewis Hamilton and Charles
was really surprised that he lost four tenths on the back straight here he had a big load of
from the power unit as he'd used more battery around the rest of the lap and it's frustrating
from a driver's point of view because you're thinking I'm on a great lap I'm pushing away
I'm finding a bit more right at the end the soft tyres are working and then you just run out of
juice on the back straight but there's reasons for it and the minutiae of how you're driving
makes a difference as you go around the lap so for Charles here the difference really was his
throttle application in a few key areas where he's kind of trying to find a bit more pace but
it's inefficient in terms of battery usage we have areas like this between turns two and three
where you can see in the red Charles is just more aggressive getting to the throttle than Lewis but
in terms of lap time difference it's really really minimal that difference between the red and the
blue Lewis is quicker in he's not then using battery at that stage he's just releasing and
carrying speed whereas Charles is slowing it down more and then getting on the throttle to try and
make up the difference and that is eating into his battery levels through the lap it's exactly
the same thing coming through turn eight where you see again in the red here Leclerc swinging
back to full throttle as he's coming through the right hustling on fighting the car on the limit
of a little bit of oversteer whereas Lewis is more patient he's waiting and he gives up a
little tiny bit of time but if you see it on the speed trace it's really negligible the difference
between the red and the blue you can see Charles is minisculely quicker on the exit of this corner
but it eats up again another few percent of battery and this aggressive driving style
combined with the fact that he then has to lift off on the exit of turn 10 with a big snap of
oversteer again reduces your efficiency you're demanding from the battery you wait and then you
demand again rather than bring it in and use all of that when you're flat out and not have to
squander your battery power that all means that when you get to the back straight
Lewis is just in tiny increments being able to keep up that battery to a higher level and this
is just an example really of how the drivers behind the wheel the tiny details can make a
difference around the lap it's still about driving quick but it's about driving efficiently now
through the corners so that you can have that energy to spend on the straights as well so it's
a strange way of thinking it's counterintuitive for the drivers Max has been has been kind of
spoken about it as well Charles has to recalibrate sometimes how he can drive it's the same across
the board this was then the the two drivers in qualifying in in q3 and you can see here
the differences that Charles already learned from his day before so firstly the ramp down is the
same for the two Ferraris there's different strengths and weaknesses through the lap but
critically you don't see Charles now racing to full throttle in between these corners he's a
out side by side around the lap with George just sitting back and all of those bits where you think
i'm going to go a little bit more throttle here and try and take advantage it's eating into the
battery and if you are George Russell sitting behind it's no wonder then he has a really easy
pass a little bit disappointed to lose out on the podium but on the other side i'm i'm happy for for
Lewis and i think he he deserves it uh more than i do on a weekend like this where he's been more
top of things than me and just have been stronger since fp1 to now so but it was a
it was a very nice race i mean i i enjoyed the fights
