The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021). M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimers:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These videos are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
Image(s) Copyrights: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Over the last few lessons what we've been doing is talking about the processes which are in place
which bring contracts to an end, the bringing to an end of a contract. This video is going to talk
about undue influence. Now the previous lesson we've spoken about the common law doctrine of
duress when it comes to when it comes to bringing a contract to an end or avoiding or creating
voidability within a contract. This lesson like I said is going to move to looking at something of
an equitable remedy. Now it is an equitable remedy which shares quite a few similarities
with the concept of duress and this is this idea of undue influence when it comes to contracts.
There are differences and ways in which they differ, duress and undue influence. One of course
is derived out of the common law and the other one is of course derived out of equity, but we
will speak about the meaning and the context in which these are created and established in this
video. So undue influence is as I've mentioned an equitable remedy which covers situations which do
not amount to duress under the common law but which do still at least illustrate the existence
of what would be described as an improper amount of pressure by one party which would then ultimately
render an unfair advantage in the creation of a contract. So it is still very similar to duress
in the sense that we see that there is an unfair and improper an undue amount of influence and
an unfair advantage which is created on one party as the result of pressure by the other.
But it is still nevertheless not something which fits into the nice neat category of the common
law doctrine of duress. While the definition of undue influence in and of itself has been
particularly undefined when we talk about the history of this particular doctrine,
the courts have still yet been able to make a delineation between two different types
of undue influence. We have in our corpus of understanding the law of equity and
the rules of equity and our rules within contracts, we have with us two major categorizations that we
can think about with relation to undue influence. Firstly we have this idea known as actual undue
influence, secondly we have this idea that we call presumed undue influence, both of which are
very important. Now this is the subject of the next two lessons, talking in the next lesson about
actual undue influence on the one hand and then in the lesson after that we're going to talk about
the concept of presumed undue influence on the other hand, two very very important topics.
But for now and just finishing this lesson off nicely we're going to think about the way
and the process by which undue influence is shown and to really illustrate this point I would like
to refer your attention to the Royal Bank of Scotland versus Ettridge, a case from 2002.
Royal Bank of Scotland by the way I believe no longer exists as a result of events taking place
in and around 2008. So this case illustrates and involves a number of appeals and all of these
appeals will cover similar circumstances, there are numerous cases in our understandings on
English law which have sort of similar kinds of structures and each case involved the wife of an
as security for their husband's debts and one of these claims sought to seek damages on account
of advice from a solicitor who had advised her under undue influence from her husband,
so had provided what would be traditionally defined as some kind of inadvertent pressure
which advantages one side. The court made a number of considerations in relation to this case,
they made it clear that for example a court will not permit transactions on the basis of undue
influence owing to the fact that those transactions ought not to be treated as being the true expression
of the individual's free will. So we're talking here about the the ways in which
the concept of this external pressure or this undue pressure which advantages one side
has an impact on the genuine free will of an individual in making transactions and making
decisions on this and in this case. They also made it clear that there was actually no rubric
which explicitly makes determinations as to which instances are true undue influence
but and those which are which are not true undue influence and I put in brackets there that that
isn't particularly helpful for us which is of course true given the fact that we are tasked
with the job of trying to identify processes and to identify circumstances in which agreements
contracts and decisions are made under contractual obligations which may have been made under an
amount of undue influence. The court also made a delineation between two different kinds of
undue influence. What I've said is going to be the topic of the next two lessons. The first kind is
this idea of actual undue influence, the second kind is this idea of presumed undue influence
and just as a basic introduction to the next two lessons when we think about actual undue influence
we see here that there is a process by which the burden to show that there is an undue influence
is in fact on the party who is claiming to have been the victim of an undue influence.
When it comes to such cases of actual undue influence the standard of evidence will depend
on the factors specific to the relevant case and then on the alternative where there is
presumed undue influence there will be two points of proof for the presumption of undue influence.
These include the existence of trust and confidence in one party something akin to
a fiduciary relationship and then secondly a transaction which may call for an explanation.
Again something that we're going to focus on in more detail when we get to that lesson in the future.