Unexpected Views with Amalia Pica on Panini's 'Lottery in Piazza di Montecitorio' - National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 17, 2026
Hi, my name is Amalia Pica. I am an artist. I am from Argentina and I'm based in London.
My practice is generally concerned with what brings people together, communication,
miscommunication and failures and attempts to talk to one another. I'm particularly interested
in gesture and that is why I chose this painting. Thank you so much for joining us this evening.
My name is Priyesh Mistry. I'm the Associate Curator for Modern and Contemporary Projects
here at the National Gallery. I've got that lucky job of working with artists who are living to
respond to the collection. I'm thrilled that you've all come to join us this evening for our
Unexpected View talk. This is a series where we invite a contemporary artist to come in,
choose a painting in the collection and use it as a springboard to explore the shared themes,
the ideas, some of the aesthetics of the work that might be shared with their own practices.
Not only so we learn a little bit more about the painting but also the different ways that
artists work today. I'm absolutely thrilled to be joined by the wonderful artist Amalia Pica this
evening and to be hosting a very special performance that you might have seen just outside
as you're walking in and to be standing in front of this beautiful work, this painting,
by Giovanni Paolo Panini titled The Lottery in Piazza Monteciterio from 1743.
And it's a really interesting work for us to be looking at today because
I hope we can explore some of the ideas around not only this kind of moment of celebration of
this kind of bringing together within the painting but also a little bit about how
Panini's thought about exploring this idea of a public square and a public setting
and the action within it. So I've been a fan of Amalia's playful and thoughtful work for many
many years and her work is one that considers moments of joy, methods of communication within
groups of people but also within broader society. So I'm really delighted that we've chosen this
work today to explore some of these themes together today. Panini is, as a painter,
best known for his cityscapes portraying the most important and picturesque sites of Rome.
So before I introduce Amalia more formally I'd like to thank Hiscox for supporting this
event this evening as the National Gallery's Contemporary Art Partner.
Amalia is an artist based in London, born in Argentina, who works across a very different,
a broad range of different media including sculpture, performance, installations,
video and drawing. She's held numerous exhibitions internationally. I won't name
them all but just to name a few of her recent projects. Most recently at the Centre for
Contemporary Art in Brighton, the Museum Haus Konstruktiv in Zurich, New Art Gallery in Warsaw
in the north of England, the Power Plant in Toronto and Ente Arte in Bogota. So really
spanning the world there, Amalia. Using seemingly simple materials and found objects, her work
investigates human modes of interactions, systems of communication and what brings people
together. In our conversation I hope we'll touch on Amalia's interest in the language of visual
codes that surround us and the objects and signs of cultural celebration that she is drawn to.
We may even touch on some other paintings in the collection that Amalia finds interesting
but to begin, Amalia, can I ask you, how did we come to choose this painting
out of all of the paintings in the collection to hold our conversation in front of today?
First also I'm just going to say hello and thank you for having me.
It's obviously an honour for me to be here and thank you everyone. So we sort of walked around
and one of the things that I said was like, can we look at paintings of crowds? I'm often sort of
interested in sort of the collective and the tension with how we also hold the collective
in our minds when we are by ourselves. And so we saw, you brought me to see this one and I sort of
love the absurdity of this big painting with sort of the main object of the painting is this
very tiny white speckled which is the lottery ticket. So I just sort of really love that very
tiny detail and how it becomes the excuse for this sort of portrayal of civic monuments but
also Roman society and it's that sort of tension in scale but also that reference to paper
in a non-artistic way. So paper is a material that I use not only to draw on, let's say,
but sometimes to draw it. But I think it's really interesting in the way that you have picked up
on this moment of detail. Panini was really interesting in these moments of celebrations
that happened within everyday life in Rome and he's really constructed the scene around this one
tiny moment but the moment is very far into the distance. So actually for us we know that the
title is the lottery of this square in this famous piazza and this it became quite a popular event
around this time so it was only really consistently instituted perhaps a couple of years before this
was made but he would have been commissioned by a patron to produce a painting like this to have
in their home to capture this kind of particular moment. But I think what really drew us is this
moment is happening very far in the distance, there's a crowd gathering but there's all these
sort of vignettes of different kind of moments of different people across the painting. You've
recently spent time in Rome as well Amalia. Yeah. And do you remember this building, the square?
Yeah absolutely. I think that was also, I sort of was lucky enough to do a residency
slash exhibition in Rome with the Fondazione Emmo and so it was just so fresh in my mind to have
been there and remembering this building which then becomes the parliament of the lower houses.
So then it is not that at this moment in time where when it's painted but then it became that
it was a building that was commissioned always to be of public use and so it sort of has changed
throughout so it's quite sort of an important political backdrop if you want of the city.
Shall we talk about this one small piece of paper that's being dropped from the balcony? So
on the balcony we have a young child, a young child who's been drawn in,
co-opted into taking out this piece of paper and throwing it into the crowd. But paper is something
that has reoccurred, or small bits of paper in fact, is something that's reoccurred in your work
quite frequently. So first of all I'm going to tell you this one thing that I didn't want to tell
you before but it is that my first job as a child, teenage boss, was to draw the lottery on
television. No way! Which is not why I chose the painting but so basically it was for Lotteria
La Neuquina and it was the Christmas special which is the biggest prize and I was in the thousands
so the way that it's structured is somebody says 40,000 and then the other child says 172
and then the last person is the one that that says the location of that number in the lottery
so if it is number 20 it gets like said like ubicación 20 but if it is number one it's like
and it gets like it's a big draw so that was my first job which I didn't want to tell you in
advance. I want to talk more about this, forget about the painting. How old were you when you
were doing this? I was like 13, 14 so that very awkward sort of being between sort of a
child and a teenager. That's incredible, you're the child in the painting. Yes.
Except mine was broadcast in local television which I didn't think was a big deal but then
it sort of because it was the Christmas special they interrupted the most popular TV show at the
time and then it was very embarrassing because I went out on Christmas Eve and then everybody
sort of was telling me that they saw me on TV. It was the last time I saw it, I did it.
Did that connection also sort of, is that somewhere in your work in a sense
because of that early exposure to perhaps television as a way of communicating?
I don't know, I don't know, as I said I did not, this had, it was just yesterday that I
remembered, I was like it's so weird that we've chosen this one. So let's go back to the use of
a small paper, let's ignore that but I just I couldn't not say it, it was a thousand.
Anyways, so yeah there's this small work but that was that I always show in a room by itself,
it's from 2005 and it's called Nostalgia and all you see is like a little
strip of paper which has perforations and it is what was left after the word nostalgia was typed
into a telegraph machine so it's basically Morse code for nostalgia and it's just framed and then
there is a caption that I write. So it's the tape that comes out of the machine,
of a telegraph machine, so it's sort of pierced with the code of Morse code.
So we have the odd job today to sort of let you see my work in your minds obviously because we
don't have, but that's what you see, you see a little piece of paper and then you see a typed
caption which is something that I often play with, I sort of bring the caption into the foreground
or as part of the work so it's often sort of becomes a fight with the curatorial department
to see where the caption for the caption goes but the caption that is part of the work says
this is the word nostalgia typed in telegraph code and it was typed in the first machine that
connected America with Europe so when it was first thought to send a telegram across the ocean
there were several attempts to sort of draw a cable and obviously by the time the signal had
sort of travelled that distance it had become too weak to be recognised so later on that sort of
that was solved by the invention of the electric repetitors of signal but it was first
solved by putting a halfway station in Iceland where every message was received and retyped
and relayed onto so what I did is I went to Seyðisfjörður to the museum of, to East
Iceland museum of technology and asked for permission to use that machine to type the
word nostalgia so all you see is a very sort of small piece of paper but it's meant to sort of
give you the sense of scale of two masses of land and a small speckle in the middle of the ocean
which is Iceland which actually became the connection between the two continents.
I always think about that work as in there's a sort of fragility implied by that work not just
the idea of this sort of small piece of paper within the large you know this large gallery
space and that's the thing that you encounter this only this small strip of paper but also
this idea of the fragility of communication in a sense you know the fact that the message
had to be retyped halfway through because otherwise it would have been too faint to
really understand or too lost to kind of so this idea of trying to communicate or trying to
cross the far distance but this kind of vulnerability in that.
You've also used paper in other kind of works as well. We've got an interesting performance
happening right now. You might not have seen it. With lots of small bits of paper but could you
talk about where that performance originated? Yeah so this is let's say the sister performance
to a performance called the drip where there's a person that has a small bag of confetti and
they're throwing confetti into the air but instead of like throwing an explosion of confetti
they're throwing one piece of confetti at a time and watching it fall which
it's called the drip because it was sort of I was thinking about the way in which we might
want to ration joy sometimes but it sort of stems from a long interest of mine in
things and the material culture sorry and the material culture of celebration and how it often
overlaps with protest but it's because I think I'm interested in popular celebrations and
carnival and moments in which you come together with other people in this sort of festive joyful
moment even if you're protesting there's a sort of an euphoria that is sort of that comes from
being together with other people in the public space sharing a cause and it's sort of a metaphor
of how we could live together better in that you might not know this person but you have this sort
of cultural intimacy or invisible bond so I've sort of taken to exploring confetti in different
ways like there's another piece called Stabile which is where sort of I type one by one
I tape one by one confetti to the floor with scotch tape so it's like trying to hold on to
sort of this moment of celebration in this case because of this you will see later but
Iris is drawing raffle tickets and then it sort of went into something more to do with like
fate and this sort of weird relationship yeah and expectation but it's interesting that you've
adapted the drip after thinking about this painting and the lottery to something else
and hosting it in the gallery it's really it's really wonderful I wanted to focus on this idea
of the moments of celebration because obviously in this painting by Paolo Panini we see really
the focus of the celebration happening in the background where everyone's gathering to try and
catch this tiny piece of paper but it's kind of where the moment of celebration happens
there's another work which I'd like to talk about where you've also used a sort of ready-made
object as it were something that signifies a celebration bunting and but using the bunting
to enact a moment of connection between strangers and in fact that's the title of the work Strangers
so it's a very simple performance that I often sort of think the same as this one that's
now called The Draw rather than The Drift but it functions a little bit more like a sculpture
rather but it is performed because it's made by people or actors it's called Strangers and
basically it's two people holding a string of bunting I'm not sure yeah and then their job is to
not let it touch the floor so they have to stand quite far from each other a string of bunting is
around 10 meters so there's that sort of distance in which you're sort of doing something with
someone but you couldn't have a conversation and these two people have never met before and that's
the requirement for the recruitment let's say of the people and they just have to stand there and
sort of decorate the space but their job is quite dull in fact so it's this sort of
also tension between celebration and sort of the banality of when it happens
because there's not really a moment where they can really talk because they're almost kind of
too far to be able to have a sort of conversation yet they're sort of brought together in this act
of trying to hold up the bunting you know and now this kind of sculpture to exist there's
something really beautiful in that the idea of kind of bringing together people collectively
in order to kind of enact something what's interesting about Panini's painting if I can
bring it back to the lottery is that you have sort of such a myriad of different people within
this kind of public space when Paolo Panini was thinking about this work and there were numerous
drawings that he had made in preparation now held in different collections across the world
he actually planned a sort of quite a raucous group of crowds in the square but actually
for the final work you he sort of dispensed with that and created these sort of vignettes of
different moments of interactions from people of very different backgrounds of different classes
and there's something interesting about the idea of kind of fictitiously perhaps in
in Paolo Panini's case but this idea of being able to bring people together in order to kind of
collectively produce something there's another work I think which sort of does this perhaps less
than a sort of anonymous way but but also within a sort of civic space as well could you talk a
little bit I don't want to give too much away I would love to hear you kind of talk about it more
is it about assembly yeah yeah so this is a performance that I that I did it's been repeated
several times but the first time that I did it was in Buenos Aires and is where I invited to
some people to take part and they had to bring a chair so everybody came with a different chair
and then there was someone who was my lead performer who was more in the know of what we
were going to do and the instruction was very simple and it's to follow the first performer
and do exactly what they're doing and so what ends up happening in the performance is that
they are walking in a line carrying a chair each it's a group of around 40 people and then
the first person starts to sit in a circle and so they start to sit in a circle and then by the time
the last person is about to sit down the first person gets up and goes to form a circle somewhere
else and it's a sort of reflection about through sort of the form of politics let's say like this
sort of this idea of the circle as a as a shape of gathering like from Stonehenge to the round table
and how they're sort of trying to build this moment of assemblage how they're trying to
come into assembly but how the process is often so difficult to self-organize and so
it starts and it's it sort of loops infinitely but the first time that it was performed I did
it in front of the in the in the square of the what is called the square of the two congresses
which is in front of the parliament building in Buenos Aires and so I've often sort of returned
to civic architecture as a backdrop to my work when it's performative which was one of the reasons
why I was also very interested in this painting because knowing that that was sort of a very
important civic building in Rome and sort of understanding how he's used it pretty much
as a backdrop. And it's interesting to know to kind of draw that connection because
Paolo Panini was well known for making these kind of paintings of these kind of very
picturesque kind of scenes of Rome but he also sort of constructed the space a little bit so
if you visit the piazza it's sort of it's probably less crowded than this he sort of invented even
this little building on the side just to help the composition and this column the column of Marcus
Aurelius is actually a bit further away so he sort of brought it into the composition as well
so it's also a slightly constructed space but yet one which is about I think the power and prestige
of Rome of that location in Rome. Also this idea of kind of using a civic
building or of civic space as a backdrop is something that you've used throughout your career
right so you told me about a very early work that you made. Yeah so I often think of
this work that I'm going to describe now as my first artwork even though obviously I had
finished art school so I had tried to make other artworks but this was the first time that I was
like oh I'm a bit proud of what I had done and it's basically it was I guess you could call it
maybe a public space intervention but basically it was a sort of a light bath or to a public
building which was and the house where independence was first declared from the
Spanish colony in Tucumán so in Argentina in 1816. The way that the process of independence in
the South Cone of Latin America worked was that there was a project to liberate the entire South
Cone so after this they fought a war they went they headed to Chile and they had to cross the
so they decided that they needed to formally declare independence before crossing the big
chain of mountains and so this wasn't done in Buenos Aires which is the capital of Argentina.
Argentina is a very large country geographically speaking and so it was done in a city which was
important but it's quite sort of remote called Tucumán in the north of Argentina and so it was
declared in a private home with 40 people they just signed independence and then at some point
it became a national monument by the time it became a national monument it was very ran down
and so it was torn down and then it was rebuilt again and it went through different periods of
history in which they just kept the room or they rebuilt a different facade and then they tried to
excavate the original facade but year after year this house and it's also known as the
little yellow house sort of comes back as backdrops for school plays and I was I studied
I'm a national professor of sculpture but I studied basically I was an art teacher in private school
in sort of my early years as an artist as well and so I was sort of trying to make work that
was sort of important to me and at the same time every year I was like redrawing this little house
and one of the things that I found incredible was at some point I just got tired of like looking
at icon I just went to look at the original at a picture of the monument and I realized that the
house is actually white so what the what the work is is me it's called class period and I was wearing
a pinafore which is the uniform for both students and teachers in state school in Argentina and I
just rang a bell and I lit up the facade yellow so I sort of turned it into this little house of
the school book and then after 14 minutes which is a class period it's sort of I rang the bell
and I turned it down but it was very much using the public building I say yeah as a backdrop.
So I would just want to touch on you know this idea of using the public space as the sort of
starting point for or the sort of first iteration of many of these performances but also you know
bringing it back to assembly that work was then reenacted within a museum space within an art
gallery space and it was is it now in the collection of the Guggenheim? Yeah. Could you talk a little
bit about what that transition means? Yeah sure so there's a this work was then acquired by the
Guggenheim which is kind of an interesting moment where museums are trying to see how to collect
performance and how obviously for me it's great it's a great collection it also sort of means
trying to work out what it means for that to exist beyond me and but so we sort of performed it again
at the Guggenheim and it and inside the museum became a completely different thing because
one might think of sort of the white cube as a sort of a vacuum but obviously the Guggenheim
has this sort of spirally architecture so it became extremely choreographic and theatrical
and it was sort of not having that sort of civic building as a backdrop really changed the
performance in a way that I think I thought might happen but I wasn't sort of anticipating
to see how much but one of the interesting things about sort of that process of a work like that
becoming part of an institution is also how it sort of came from okay I've been invited to this
performance festival in Buenos Aires there isn't a lot of budget let's just get some people together
and do something and then suddenly it becomes it enters a collection and then you because the sort
of the process to learn a painting can take several years they just don't have a different
way of learning so you have to let them know with two years in advance that you're going to ask
people to bring a chair and it sort of becomes this sort of paradoxical thing about a very simple
work like she's there sort of throwing raffle tickets up in the air and then if it becomes
part of a collection then it it's treated in an entirely different way yeah but I sort of wanted
to bring it back to the performance in the way you sort of led us there because you've
adapted the performance that from the drip to now this idea the performance called the draw
could you what's interesting about it is that we're hosting it within the National Gallery
but you're using raffle tickets and it's almost like you're taking the action from the painting
but taking it again into sort of this art gallery the museum the institutional space
there's something really interesting about that you know I think there's something interesting
about the idea of the lottery as a concept you know within society you know this idea of
the lottery as full of expectation you know this idea of hope and expectation of being
able to do a big win and then perhaps climb the social ladder there's something really
interesting about that as a sort of aspiration but also as a sort of a form I don't
can you hear me yeah as a form of almost social control which is also what carnival or these
celebrations that I've been interested in also had that sort of valve or valve sort of function
which can we talk about the rhinoceros yeah we can absolutely yeah one of the paintings that I
really wanted to talk about as well when we were deciding was a sort of a small painting of the
rhinoceros by Piero Longhi so another Italian artist but working in Venice who was very well
known for painting sort of small scenes of daily life within Venice but particularly around the
carnival and we have this beautiful tiny little painting of a rhinoceros which was quite a
spectacle in that day you know rhinoceroses were very rarely seen in Europe during that time and
it's a specific rhinoceros called Miss Clara who toured Europe and was hosted within this
carnival so she became very iconic yeah I know at some point I also became really interested in sort
of animals being used as diplomatic gifts and I did some work around great apes and their ability
to sort of acquire language and things like that so that would have been a different talk
but it also does relate to to this idea of carnival and I think one of the things in which
like thinking about why am I also called an artist if I work in such a different way and I
don't do painting and what it means to work in this way and it is that often we'll sort of
look back and it's that now that performance isn't necessarily about this work but it obviously now
it's somebody's like throwing raffle tickets up in the air in relationship to this painting and
then that might exist somewhere else and that might be taken somewhere else and what it's like
as an artist to sort of allow yourself to sort of be inspired to be almost also invited to do things
and change your ideas around these things that happen to you the things that you see and where
your work is taking you as well it's not this thing that we work in in sort of a vacuum and so
I sort of imagine imagining what that performance will be like when there isn't this painting
as a backdrop to it and that maybe it sort of becomes more about fate or the absurd or
because I feel like those sort of themes are really inherent in the work one thing that I
think is really beautiful about this idea of changing the confetti you know so this idea of
the celebration to a raffle is almost as when Iris who's performing the work throws the work
throws the raffle ticket in the air there's almost this kind of this sort of ingrained hope
in this idea of throwing it out there but then as you sort of as it falls quite beautifully as it
falls to the floor suddenly you're surrounded by perhaps slightly absurdly all of these raffle
tickets that haven't really flown anywhere and there's something really quite beautiful about
that perhaps also Sisyphean in the way that you know she's sort of throwing all of the raffle
tickets out one by one which reminds me that one of the things that I did want to do as an
Argentinian artist was not to finish a talk about the painting that is called the lottery without
a quote in Borges who famously has written an amazing short story about the lottery so I'm just
going to read a quote from my poem sorry to bring it up so it's the lottery of Babylon where he's
imagining that the lottery is not just a way in which the in which you might get lucky but also
extremely unlucky and how in Babylon it sort of became an institution that ruled people's destinies
for the good but also for the terrible I just wanted to read this little bit that says
once for an entire lunar year I was declared invisible I would cry out and none would heed
my call I would steal bread and not be beheaded I have known that thing that Greeks knew not
as uncertainty I don't know there's something about sort of a bit of a funny thing about
being Argentinian and quoting such a writer but it is also it was so educational that I cannot
not think about the lottery and think about this sort of sense of fate and the absurd but also
that thing that you are not in control of yeah wonderful so I think on that note
please join me in thanking Amalia for joining us this evening
