Economic Duress - Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
11 Video Views·Mar 15, 2026
In the previous lesson, what we did was spend some time talking about duress as one of the
vitiating circumstances in which a contract can be brought to an end. Now, in the previous lesson,
we spent some time talking about what is arguably the most common, the easiest to understand,
maybe not necessarily the most common, but the easiest to understand form of duress,
which is just a threat of violence. Sign this contract or I'll do this violent action to you,
which of course makes sense and obviously is very understandable as a form of duress
and is obviously very understandable when we take into consideration the fact that
when it comes to contracts, in order for an agreement to be valid, people must enter into
that contract voluntarily. There must be a certain amount of voluntariness in in relation to coming
to an agreement. This lesson is going to talk about economic duress, which is a little bit
more subtle and is probably a little bit more common, arguably, because it's not as explicitly
violent in terms of what a threat of violence would constitute duress. But it is still duress
and it is still something that can vitiate the circumstances of a contractual arrangement and
cause contract to be voidable. So, as I mentioned, the easiest form and the easiest way of understanding
duress is obviously to just talk about the concept of violence to induce a contractual
agreement. Economic duress is a little bit more complicated and, of course, this refers to the
duress to make threats to economic property or economic livelihood or something of that
kind of nature. And I want to begin with the 1979 case of North Ocean Shipping Corporation
versus Hyundai Construction Corporation. Now, this gives us an indication of the circumstances
in which we can think about economic duress. So, it was a case, essentially, where we see that
economic duress refers not necessarily to threats against a person,
but rather to threats in relation to some kind of financial or economic well-being of a person or
one of the parties to a contract. That's really what the heart of the problem is in relation to
duress in this kind of circumstances. The case itself involved a contract for the construction
of a ship. The ship would be used for a lucrative shipping deal. And so, as a result of which,
the contractor was very keen to see that that ship gets built, as you can probably understand.
Now, during the process of the building of this ship, the construction firm sought to increase
the price of their work and their supplies owing to a number of economic changes, specifically
changes to the exchange rates. So, things got a little bit more expensive for them and they
sought to increase the price of their work and supplies in relation to that,
essentially, in order to try and mitigate some of those losses. Despite not wishing to, the
claimant did in fact accept the deal on the basis that he wanted the ship to be built and he wanted
specifically the ship to be built in the time that was allocated. And so, he believed, in response
to this, that a refusal to essentially pay for this increased price could alter the terms and may
threaten this arrangement, may threaten this relationship. Many months later, the claimant
sought to recover, in fact, on the basis that making the decision to accept these changes
wasn't actually a change that was made voluntarily. They argued that instead this
was done under duress because he felt threatened by the fact that he felt, sorry, more specifically,
that the terms of the arrangement, the terms of the contract, may be threatened if he was to
not accept the deal which sought to change the exchange rates. The court held that while the
concept of economic duress had been present in this case, he could not bring a claim because
he had left it too long. So, ultimately, they didn't find for the claimant in this case. However, they
still did find that economic duress did exist in this case. And you can sort of understand why that
is the case. You can understand why economic duress existed in this particular case.
The claimant would not have, likely would not have, altered these terms if he did not have,
he did not feel threatened by the fact that the ship that he wanted built would not have been
built in the time that was allocated. And so, he would have lost quite a lucrative commercial
shipping deal or there was a threat to losing commercial shipping deal. Now, it wasn't necessarily
a direct threat, it wasn't necessarily a threat in relation to if you do not accept this new change,
we will not continue and this will then lead to you losing this commercial deal. It was more
implied, it was more indirect, it was more implicit, but it was still nevertheless a decision that was
made by the claimant on the basis of a threat to the terms of this agreement. So, this brings us to,
brings us quite nicely to the question of indirect duress. Because the vast majority of economic
duress cases, like that one, don't actually sound like explicit direct threats to the parties,
either sign this or we will do something that that threatens your economic well-being.
They're often more indirect, suggesting the implication of economic hardship being a
motivation for the decision, rather than necessarily specific statements directed to them.
That does not necessarily mean that everyone in the, every party to the contract doesn't
subconsciously or indirectly have an idea of why certain agreements are made and maybe that
they, the people who induce an agreement under economic duress, sort of deep down know that the
reason why the other parties accepted is because of the potential economic hardships that could be
levied as a result, but it is still not necessarily the case that you have threats directly to the
economic prosperity of an individual. They're more, they are more indirect, they're more subtle.
I want to draw your attention to another case from 1983, Universe Tank Ships versus the
International Transport Workers Federation. This was a case which involved a ship by the name of
the Universal Sentinel and it had been blacklisted by the International Transport Workers Federation,
who were a trade union, henceforth known as the ITF. The ITF had instructor tugmen who were
under the remit of their union to refuse to operate the tugs and as such render the ship
unable to set sail. The union argued that they would remove the ship from the blacklist if the
claimants agreed to make substantial payments to the ITF's fund. They agreed and as a result of
which they were then able to set sail. Not a particularly fruitful arrangement as you can
probably understand, we are basically stopping you from being able to set sail because we of course
have instructed our tugmen to refuse to operate the tugs on the ship and so as a result of which
unless you pay us this substantial amount to our fund, we will not take you off this blacklist.
After this, after they agreed and they were able to set sail, the ITF were then sued by the owners
of the ship, the Universal Sentinel, and they sought to get this contract, the contract which
was a contract for the substantial payment into the ITF's fund, they wanted to get that voided
on the basis that they had made that decision under duress. Now it was held quite obviously
that this did in fact amount to an economic duress and as a result of which it was able to be
remedied under the law of restitution and really this is an example almost of direct economic
duress. So whereas a lot of cases of economic duress are often quite indirect, they're quite
subtle, this one is direct in terms of what is actually being instructed by those involved in
the case. Now Lord Diplock would actually develop the law on what actually constitutes economic
duress in this case. He says, quote, the rationale is that his apparent consent was induced by
pressure exercised upon him by that of the party which the law does not regard as legitimate,
with the consequence that the consent is treated in law as recoverable unless approbated either
expressly or by implication after the illegitimate pressure has ceased to operate on his mind.
And this takes us back, if you will, to the previous lesson when we were talking about
duress in a more general format. We were talking about what duress actually meant
and we made mention of the fact that duress is where there is the inducement to contract,
there is the inducement to sign and enter into a contractual arrangement, but on the basis of
illegitimate pressure. Pressure which is not considered to be legitimate and often an outside
pressure that is exerted upon the individual which otherwise if that pressure did not exist
it is less likely that a contract would have been signed and agreed to. This pressure could be,
like I said in the previous lesson, direct threats of force or this pressure could be direct
threat of economic well-being as is in the case of this, the case here of Universal Tank Ships
Incorporated, or it could be indirect. It could be a more subtle form of economic duress where
individuals subconsciously know that if they do not sign to that agreement then there may be
a defacing of economic hardships and nothing really needs to be said between the parties
necessarily, but there is almost this collective understanding that if you do not sign this
contract there will be economic consequences, which of course also represents economic duress
and therefore could vitiate a contractual arrangement.
