The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021). M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimers:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
These vidoes are intended to represent the law at the time of recording to the best of my ability. If there are any updates and/or mistakes, I endeavour to make sure these mistakes are corrected. Where you find a mistake, comment under the video and I will check and make the appropriate amendments.
The reality of law is that it is an ever changing and deeply complex subject. As such, mistakes and updates are inevitable. I feel that this it the best approach for this kind of educational content, given its static nature.
Image(s) Copyrights: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back everybody to our studies in the law of contracts. In this lesson what we're going to
do is talk about duress as a method by which a contract may come to an end or be made void.
Now fundamentally the lesson itself and the next lesson that we're going to look at are going to
talk about a number of major doctrines within contract law that relate to this bringing of
a contract to an end. The first is the common law doctrine of duress. The second is the equitable
doctrine of undue influence. So these are sort of tangentially related to each other in some way,
one obviously being a little bit more extreme than the other, this being of course duress,
but these are both ways in which we can bring a contract to an end. So let's begin with this
lesson then and let's begin with the concept of duress. The concept of duress in contract law,
so not duress as a defense in criminal law for example, although there are similarities
between the two but don't forget these are two different subjects, but fundamentally the concept
of duress within contract law strikes at the very heart of what it means to enter into a contract
in the first place. Remember if we go all the way back to our very very very early lessons on the
law of contracts we noted that one of the key and major elements of the contract is this idea that
in order for a contract to be valid, in order for an agreement to be valid, the parties to that
agreement ought to enter into that agreement voluntarily. You can't have somebody be forced,
threatened, coerced into entering into an agreement and for that contract to then be
legally binding onto them if they then decide that they want to essentially pull out of that
agreement or to not adhere to the terms of that agreement. If they weren't voluntarily entering
into that agreement in the first place then there isn't a validity in terms of that contract,
there is no validity in relation to the contract that has been created.
So these lessons that we're going to look at where we look at the common law doctrine of duress
and the equitable doctrine of undue influence look at situations and circumstances where there
isn't this voluntary entering into an agreement, there is this involuntary agreement that is made
where an individual has been coerced or has been subjected to some kind of undue influence or has
entered into an agreement that they would not otherwise have signed or have agreed to.
So duress essentially may vitiate an agreement that is established between the parties to a
contract. If one of the parties has acted or been forced to act in a way which is the result of an
illegitimate pressure then it can be argued that they have acted under a form of duress
and that this would essentially allow that contract to be voided, it would essentially
make the contract voidable. So this is quite a broad definition, essentially you are acting,
if you have some kind of illegitimate pressure placed upon you to come to a conclusion of a
contract then this then makes the contract voidable, you are able to then void that contract
yourself. Obviously the most common example and the easiest to understand example is the idea of
a threat of violence, if you have violence against you, threatened against you, then of course this
is a common form of duress within contract law and we'll examine it briefly here. Essentially
if an individual has forced you into a contract as the result of a threat of violence
then that individual has acted under duress. So if I say, if I have an agreement that is in place,
I have a contract on a table and I say if you do not sign this contract, if you do not agree to
the terms of this contract I'll beat you up, I'll hit you in the face, I'll stab you, some of these
really are quite egregious threats of violence. If you then go about and
respond to that threat of violence in a way that is essentially as instructive of what I want you
to do in the first place, if you then go and sign that contract, you cannot be said to have acted
in a way that was freely of your own choice, of your own volition, of your own free will
because otherwise if you had acted voluntarily in entering into that contract I would not have
needed to use threats of violence in the first place. It was only because of the violence that
I threatened upon you that you entered into this agreement. So if you wouldn't have otherwise
entered into this agreement, if it wasn't for, if it was but for the threat of violence that I
essentially instructed upon you, then you would, then the contract would not have happened,
would it? So then you would have acted under, you would have acted under duress and therefore
the contract may be initiated. So generally speaking, in terms of this kind of duress,
there are generally two requirements for a contract to be voided. The threat of violence
must be of a sufficient level to constitute duress. The impact of the threats of violence
had over the person who entered into the contract as well must also be sufficient.
So if I said to you, sign the contract or I'll slap you, and let's say I'm five foot two and
this individual is is six foot seven, okay, then theoretically the impact of that threat of
violence isn't particularly strong. So the question of, and as well as this, the threat of violence
isn't particularly sufficient. So then at this point you might question whether or not it was
truly this quite menial threat of violence from a relatively small impactful individual that
actually was the cause of my entering into this contractual arrangement. You remember,
the threat of violence has to be the reason for the entering into the agreement. If it wasn't for
the fact that you entered into the agreement, sorry, if it wasn't for the fact that there was
a threat of violence, you wouldn't have entered into the agreement. That is essentially the point
of a threat of violence. And I will point you to the case of Barton and Armstrong from 1976.
Now this case looks to examine the nature of a threat to a party and whether or not this would
constitute falling into this doctrine of duress. Now the claimant in this case had been the director
of a company, the defendant had been a chairman of the company. Now the question of duress came
when the former chairman of the company had made threats to kill the claimant if he did not
purchase a number of shares. The claimant did so and claimed that the contract was void on the
basis that it was done under duress. I was threatened, my life had been threatened, he had
threatened my life and as a result of which I entered into this contract. So therefore the
contract should be void, it shouldn't have any kind of meaning to it. The court actually concluded
that despite the fact that the claimant did also have other commercial considerations in relation
to the purchase of the shares, the threat of violence was substantial in terms of making
that decision and so the contract was therefore rendered voidable. So the court acknowledged the
fact that the claimant having also been threatened of course with their life, they threatened to kill
them, they did also recognize that there were other reasons that were commercial that would
have had benefits to you that would have also led you to enter into that contract. So remembering
here the point that essentially that should be noted is that there could be other reasons why
you enter into a contract but if there is a sufficient threat of violence and that this
threat of violence actually impacted your decision, that is what would actually come to the conclusion
of whether or not duress takes place in this case. So obviously the threat was quite substantial
in this case and it was found on the on account of the fact of the case that it was this threat
of violence that caused the individual to decide to enter into this contract and so as a
result of which you could say that there was a successful claim of duress even though there were
other subsidiary considerations which were commercial in nature that the claimant could
have also considered in relation to the purchase of those shares.