California has been setting new requirements for what licensed professionals are expected to teach inside their own continuing education courses. The intent behind them is patient protection. Whether that goal is best served by regulating what doctors teach one another is where the disagreement begins.
Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California ophthalmologist who has spent years challenging two of these laws in court, sits down to lay out her case: vague mandates, undefined limits on disagreement, and a licensing structure she argues makes silence the safer career choice.
Her concern doesn't stop at the exam room. The Ninth Circuit precedent set by this case, she argues, could reach any licensed professional in the country, and the mechanism behind it is more durable than most people realize.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Are doctors in California feeling comfortable with their patients to say what they think
and their freedom of speech? Today we sit down with Azadeh Khatibi who's concerned about the
freedom of speech for doctors in California and she's going to explain to us what doctors are
going through right now and a couple of laws that are impacting them significantly. These types of
laws really chilled the speech of doctors. Mandating the speech of anybody, the government,
doing so is unconstitutional. I had so many doctors come up to me and say thank you so much
for fighting this law but at the same time they would say you know don't tell your patients this
or that because they knew that they might get in trouble. It's very very disturbing. I'm Siamak,
welcome to California Insider. Azadeh, it's great to have you and welcome. Thank you Siamak,
I'm super excited to be here. We want to talk to you about a very important issue that's going to
impact physicians in California and many other people if this law and practice goes as it is.
A lot of physicians and people that have licenses in California, could be accountants, CPAs,
they are getting continued education in their field and there are some ruling especially for
physicians that they have to actually not have bias in their continued education. Can you tell
us what's happening with this? Sure, so what's been happening is that what I've seen over the
past 10 years or so is that there's been more and more control by government on the speech of
physicians as well as on what physicians can and cannot do. And this particular law I'm fighting
is I've been active for freedom and medical ethics and medical freedom over the past several years,
something I never thought I would be actively involved in. But as I've seen this pattern I've
become more involved in this particular law that I'm fighting now is AB 241 which says that any
doctor who teaches medical education courses or anybody who organizes any entity that organizes
medical education courses for doctors in California as part of CME or continuing medical education
programming needs to teach implicit bias at every single continuing medical education course
they teach. And that means that they have to teach about strategies to address bias
or to talk about how implicit bias affects clinical decision making and treatment of
patients and how that affects biased treatment of certain populations. Can you tell us about
this implicit bias? Is it towards races or is it towards gender or what is it towards? Implicit
bias is a psychological entity that was described by a couple of psychologists and what it really
is describing is this type of bias that's beyond consciousness. So it's something in the unconscious
or subconscious mind that is an association and something outside of our conscious thinking.
It's something that's still very nascent in its study. So there's not a ton of scientific evidence
of strategies that we can use to address unconscious bias or subconscious bias.
But for some reason people are treating it like there is a lot of evidence behind it and they're
promoting bias training implicit bias training in curricula in various companies and in this
particular law Sydney Kamlogger who was a representative in the California legislature
now she's a congresswoman at the federal level she wrote this law along with some advocacy groups
to mandate that every doctor has to talk about implicit bias at every course that they teach.
And Governor Gavin Newsom signed this bill into law so it's taken a couple years or several years
for it to become implemented but now it's actively being implemented. California is passing a lot of
data privacy laws but I'll be honest sometimes it really hits me how much of my life is online.
My name, my address, my birthday, cell phone number, email address, it's all out there floating around
and I've never actually gave anyone permission to use it. If you're listening to this your
information is probably out there too. Think about it anyone can look us up they know where we live
sell our details to strangers or worse potentially steal our identity. I get a bunch of random phone
calls on a regular basis and it's scary to know that people can access my information so easily
from across the world. The internet that's supposed to be a place for us to connect it's become a place
that makes us feel scared less safe. I'm not accepting that anymore and you don't have to either
that's why I use today's sponsor Aura. Aura goes after the data brokers who profit from selling
our personal lives. They actually scrub our information from those sites and make sure it
stays gone. I've seen other services out there but nothing is as thorough or offers as much for the
same price as Aura. You can see it for yourself try Aura free for 14 days at aura.com slash
california insider. Give it two weeks and let Aura do the heavy lifting finding and removing your
details from those shady broker sites so you can finally take control of your digital life. I've
decided to not leave myself vulnerable on the internet and honestly I don't think you should
either. With Aura you can finally feel safe secure and back in control. Now let's watch the rest of
the interview. So what is the impact of this because there's only 50 hours a year that you guys
have these training sessions or is it longer? It's required to have 50 hours right? Different states
have different requirements for how much continuing medical education each doctor has to do in order
to maintain licensure. In California it's 50 hours over two years so about 25 hours a year and the
types of continuing medical education courses can be things like going to a workshop that has an
accredited continuing medical education hours assigned to it or going to morbidity and mortality
conferences where doctors get together and talk about what went wrong what went right with their
cases if someone got more sick as a result of the intervention or how to approach something
differently and they talk about these things or if someone died how do we prevent that from
happening again something very important for us to do in medicine to talk about these cases
as well as attending grand rounds lectures where we listen to someone who's eminent in their field
and as well research to come and present to us about a certain topic going to medical conferences
like certain professional organizations I'm an ophthalmologist for example so going to an
ophthalmology conference we can get our credits that are accredited through private organizations
and then they count they become our CME hours and then we submit those to the government something
important that your listeners should know is that CME and the CME system is not a governmental system
it's a private system medical education that is continuing throughout the career of a physician
was something that was created by physicians in the late 1800s early 1900s some doctors said you
know this is important for us to do actually maybe even earlier than the late 1800s they said
this is important for us to do we need to not stagnate and just keep doing the same things over
and over again in our own silos and our own practices we need to learn and be continuous
learners it's a very good thing so then they started attending meetings together creating
organizing meetings together and this entity and this this practice grew but CME was created
for doctors by doctors and for the practice of medicine and to improve patient care and now what's
happened is the government has kind of co-opted this system and said this is our system essentially
and the rulings that judges are have been giving us with regard to our fight in this law it's
actually really really backwards what they're doing because it is a private system that's
and it's just utilized by the government to have doctors maintain licensure by having a certain
number of hours so this looks like a peer-to-peer coaching kind of teaching teaching and you
mentioned that you're concerned about doctors speech can you tell us more about that sure
free speech is essential our founding fathers knew that and they knew that if government had
too much power it would actually limit the freedoms of the masses that were the ones who
actually were giving consent to be governed by the government so what the founding fathers did
is they had this first amendment our free speech a right to free speech in the constitution and
what that means is that you have a right to have the government not mandate your speech you have
right for the government to not chill your speech your public speech and there's also something else
which actually affects patients because your audience members are patients and they have a
first amendment right as well in regard to these laws that i'm fighting which is they have a first
amendment right to hear the true and real speech of their doctors not something that is ideologically
mandated by the government so each of your audience members has a right to hear the true
and free speech of their doctors in the exam room and in the consulting room when they see their
doctor so free speech is very important and in medicine it's important because patients have a
right to hear what doctors really think and feel and in their medical opinion as the doctor
interprets the data right it's an interpretation of the available data and gives their opinion to
to the patient free speech is also important because medicine progresses by new and innovative
ideas coming forth bursting forth onto the platform of medical consciousness and
in these conferences we attend in the journals where people debate back and forth by writing
letters in our academic institutions we need to have active free discourse between doctors in
order for good ideas to gain traction bad ideas to be shown through discourse and discussion and
then eventually research to be shown that they're weak and for there to be a supportive space an
open space not necessarily even supportive but open space for people to be free to say their
new innovative ideas that's how science and medicine progresses another reason that free
speech in medicine is really really important is because we need to have medical consciousness
be open and to not be limited by just what the government wants doctors to teach other doctors
what do i mean by medical consciousness i mean what is in the thinking and the speech and the
thought of doctors and in the medical space and what people who studied authoritarian governments
after world war ii realized is that if you're limited in your speech these ideas that would
have been said are not said and so within a generation very quickly these ideas are not
spoken they're held in the minds of the people instead but they're afraid to speak them because
they're afraid of retaliation from the government so they don't speak it and then these people die
and these ideas never reach the next generation and so the consciousness of this next new
generation is actually more limited than before because they never got to hear these ideas and so
the consciousness of the people under an authoritarian regime or authoritarian
leanings of a government becomes more and more limited and so for the medical consciousness to
be open and to be expansive and to be expanding and to be inspired for it to progress so that
the public your audience can benefit from these ideas and the best of these ideas we need to have
free speech in medicine and have less regulation over the medical field as it pertains to
innovation thinking and new ideas so where do you see the regulation so so there's this bias
training is there any other areas where you guys feel that you cannot say what you think
well certainly you know there's some areas of medicine where things are progressing nicely for
example people are now having more access to and you've covered it in your show with Dr. Melamed
more holistic care and institutions are becoming more open and expanding into the possibilities
that's something that isn't just that myopic mainstream medicine way of viewing the human
body you know there's something wrong with it we give it a pill but maybe there's other modalities
we can look at that's expanding that's wonderful but countering that is the government has been
making laws that limit bodily autonomy limit medical freedom and limit free speech in the
medical realm and for physicians and so those are areas that we need to shine a light on
examples of that are another law that I fought that was successfully fought AB 2098 was a law
that was signed by Gavin Newsom its author was Evan Lowe in the California legislature and it
was co-sponsored by members of the vaccine working group during COVID and that law said that any
doctor who engages in disinformation or misinformation about COVID and vaccines can get
their license investigated or their license revoked and that was very concerning to me
disinformation and misinformation are two very different things disinformation is someone
knowingly spreading false information so they know the information is false but they're telling their
patient something that as if it's true right we already have laws on the books for that it's wrong
it's unethical it's illegal because doctors are fiduciaries they have to do what's in the best
interest of the patient and they have to use evidence-based medicine the definition of
misinformation however was really concerning and this was again during the COVID era where
misinformation was like really huge people said we have to fight misinformation and so this word
was used to kind of say that any doctor that engaged in it was at risk of losing their license
but what is misinformation it was very vague right it's it's and the idea was like
information that is false but you don't know that it's false but you say it anyway to your
patient thinking it's true well who's determining what's false and what's not false is it the
government is the government now the arbiter of what is science and what is not scientifically
backed and so this vagueness of this word because we couldn't define it and the lawyer for the other
side couldn't really define it very well either the lawyer for the government because we sued
Gavin Newsom and the medical board of California in that lawsuit fighting that law they couldn't
define misinformation well either so we took them to court with the help of the non-profit
New Civil Liberties Alliance and the judge at the hearing said this law the wording of this law is
nonsense I'm paraphrasing him because he saw that the law was vague and when things aren't clear
that people are going to chill their own speech and when a doctor and especially doctors as a
personality they tend to be the kind of people who conform in order to be more cautious they're more
skeptical and also in order to go through medical training the kind of personality that does well
in that rigid bureaucracy and having to you know follow through the rules that you have to follow
and all the the tests you have to take the requirements you have to meet there's somebody
who at a certain level has to be able to conform well and so that personality of someone who's
malleable to conforming and to being able to go along and do what they need to do that can be very
dangerous when there are laws that are limiting their free speech but they can lose their license
and their livelihood and they may not be able to make a living after sacrificing so much of their
life early on in their early years I certainly did and a lot of probably medical debt for people
right and certainly a large number of them are in medical debt as well so they have hundreds of
thousands of dollars some of them to repay so ideally any doctor would speak up no matter what
at risk of losing everything even because they're following their principles but most people don't
and I had so many doctors during COVID come up to me and say thank you so much for fighting this
law but at the same time they would say you know don't tell your patients this or that to other
people you know if I'm in a party and I'm listening to them they would thank me for fighting the law
and saying I'm so brave but then they would be telling other doctors that were you know having
dinner with oh don't write too many exemptions oh you know don't say that to the patient because
they knew that they might get in trouble it's very very disturbing it's human behavior it's
psychology and so these types of laws really chilled the speech of doctors and chilling the
speech of anybody is unconstitutional mandating the speech of anybody the government doing so
is unconstitutional so we went and we fought that law and the judge gave us a preliminary
injunction against AB 2098 and said the government could not come after us if we broke the law
and a preliminary injunction is not easy to get it's very rare to get but he gave it to us by
saying that the legislature and the governor had violated the 14th amendment constitutional right
that we have to due process and what that 14th amendment says is that a law has to be clear
so things have to be clear to the citizenry if a law is not clear so under the due process
clause if a law is not clear to like a person of average intelligence that's unconstitutional
and so he granted us the preliminary injunction based on the 14th amendment he did not rule
on the first amendment free speech violation although it looked like he was thinking it
was unconstitutional and so we were waiting to get his ruling on the first amendment rights
violation and the 14th amendment's right violation but what happened during that time during that
time very quietly the california state legislature overturned and reappealed that very law that they
had said was absolutely necessary to protect patients and the author of the bill evan low
said we actually have other laws on the books that protect patients so he went and did a complete 180
from promoting this law and saying it's absolutely necessary to saying actually
other laws are covering and protecting patients we don't need this law and what happened is one of
my friends told me that gavin newsom the governor had gone up to him and said it was my idea to
reappeal the law and he took credit for repealing it and said it never should have passed in the
first place which makes me have to say if it never should have passed in the first place
why did he sign it in the first place why did he sign an unconstitutional law to begin with
so you mentioned you have to do implicit bias training now how would it work practically when
you guys are having these gatherings well the law is not very clear on that but it uh so it
leaves a little bit of room for people to become scared whether or not they're following the law or
not um but what the law says is that it has to be at every single teaching that they do so we know
that information the question is how much we know that it has to be strategies and we know that it
has to be strategies or how it actually affects treatment outcomes and patient and perceptions of
patients so but it's kind of unclear if i'm teaching about 25 gauge vitrectomy techniques
or 27 gauge vitrectomy techniques for a certain type of tractional retinal detachment do i also
have to give like a five second on how implicit bias is important and teach a strategy about it
when it's completely unrelated to the topic at hand it just it's not really logical it takes time
away from important stuff that we really do need to teach because it's you know if you're a speaker
in a long day of speakers and you have 15 minutes to teach what you need to teach and the law is not
clear about this do you as the one CME speaker for in that 15 minute period also have to talk
about implicit bias or can the organizer just have a quick teaching about implicit bias and
then we can get on with the day but can they come after you if the government doesn't like what
you're saying about other things can they come after you because you didn't in your 15 minutes
talk about it because you thought it was being covered by the organizer of the CME
it leaves a lot of room for doubt and fear and not really saying what you may want to say because
it's also not clear because this is an implicit bias and teaching of it is very very controversial
and there's not a lot of data behind it it's unclear for if you can disagree with it or not
now the lawyer for the state at our hearing when we were at the appellate level had said oh yeah
if you don't believe in this as a doctor and you're teaching CME you can disagree with it
but when she was pressed to talk about how much you could disagree she couldn't tell the court so
we now have a situation where the state cannot even tell doctors how much they're allowed to
disagree with the law because she said oh you could disagree but she's not she couldn't tell
you how much you could disagree so it's it puts people in a very very scary position
and again chills their speech and makes them have to conform so what's the potential punishment if
you don't do it correctly when you're doing these trainings well if you don't follow the law they
can take away your right to teach CME so you can lose part of your livelihood people whose jobs
are enmeshed in having to teach CME like physicians who teach at academic institutions
who teach regularly at ground rounds or teach residents or teach fellows if they're not following
this law they can lose their jobs potentially so it can have very very severe consequences
potentially you can get investigated by the licensing entity and potentially lose your
license like the specter of this is very heavy on people and so it's it's dangerous now in terms of
the implicit bias so i assume the people that that are passing this law they want to fix that
is there a lot of it in your field do doctors have a lot of bias towards the patients so this is an
area of emerging research and more research is needed for it we do have some evidence that
implicit bias does affect some decision making with regard to doctors and patients that unconscious
bias but we do know that there are other variables that affect patient outcomes at much much higher
rates things like health care access create disparities in outcomes things like socioeconomic
status it creates huge disparities in outcomes between patients and i would argue that these are
the things we need to be focusing more about in CME for example but if you're spending time talking
about implicit bias you're going to have less time talking about these things which is another
argument that we made in the court. So where are we now with all of this? So we appealed and
we lost the appellate level then we petitioned for an on-bank review where all the judges in
the ninth district would review whether or not this ruling was appropriate or not and we were
denied but there were several judges who really disagreed with the ruling at the appellate level
and they wrote opinions very strong opinions arguing why the three judge panels rulings were
wrong. The initial review by the single judge and then the appellate level three judge panel both
had said that doctors teaching other doctors are similar to public school teachers teaching
children and that's why the state can mandate what the doctor can say when they're teaching
other doctors which is ridiculous because public school teachers are working for the government
and they're teaching an accepted curriculum versus doctors teaching other doctors or private entities
private citizens teaching other private citizens and they can be talking about very cutting-edge
topics. This was an apples to oranges comparison that really was erroneous and there were some
other strong arguments that the judges who had dissenting opinions made as well and we now have
their opinions which are very solid and we are appealing to the supreme court now and it is our
hope that the supreme court is going to accept our case and hear it and rule on the side of medical
freedom free speech. Will this law impact other license holders as well because they go through
similar training as you guys do right? Absolutely and that's what's really dangerous and something
your audience needs to know it doesn't just affect their doctors it affects their therapists
potentially their accountants their tax preparers any licensed professional in America is going to
be affected by this law. Now this ruling that we've had so far is for the ninth district but other
states and other districts are going to now look at the precedent that's been set here and say hey
any licensed professional teaching other professionals can have their speech
speech mandated by the state because they did it in the ninth court ninth district so it's it's
basically essentially the law of the land very very dangerous. You are fighting this like and
why did you get involved with it? Well Siamak I never really thought that I would be doing this
I used to be very intimidated by the idea of legal proceedings it was not my cup of tea I
always tried to stay away from something like this and I was almost fearful of these kinds of things
but when the time came and I saw that such terrible laws were being passed by people
under the guise of doing it for the good of the people I had to act and so I worked on myself and
I also just I'm someone who wants to live by principles and has principles and principles
of like medical ethics freedom very very important to me my name Ozode means freedom
and so I had to step up I had to act and when I did I realized hey this isn't as intimidating as
I thought it was going to be and it actually feels good to stand up for what you believe
in a centered way that's why I did it I want to preserve medicine and free thought and free
speech for doctors for the generations to come. I take my inspiration partly from people like
Benjamin Rush he was one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence he was a doctor and
he was a very progressive thinker he absolutely advocated for medical freedom and free speech in
medicine and he was very very concerned even back then in the 1700s that the practice of medicine
was becoming over-controlled and over-regulated back then in the 1700s and he argued that we need
doctors to be able to be free to innovate to think up new ideas to try new treatments
and we need to do it safely but we cannot hinder the medical profession and he's very inspiring
in that way and I hope that the work that I do can be part of that legacy of promoting
medical freedom. Ozode Khatibi, California physician it was great to have you on California Saturday.
Thank you so much Siamak it was a pleasure to be here. Do you guys agree with Ozode and her
assessment and freedom of speech for doctors in California? Make sure to comment below or email
us at siamakacaliforniasat.com we read all of your emails and comments. I'm Siamak Khorrami
this is Californian Insider we'll see you next time.