Why has this painting had so many names- - National Gallery

Art Galleries Worldwide
11 followers
1 Video View·Mar 14, 2026
What's in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
These are the famous words of William Shakespeare taken from his 1597 play Romeo and Juliet.
In this context the phrase spoken by the play's heroine Juliet suggests that the names and labels
we give or indeed are given are of no importance and have no bearing on innate quality or
characteristics. For Juliet there is nothing inherently meaningful about a name. But is this
really the case? I'm Melissa Baksh and I'm an art historian, writer, curator and educator
based in London. Today I will be discussing Portrait of a Woman Inspired by Lucretia
painted by Venetian artist Lorenzo Lotto in around 1530. We have an exquisitely dressed
woman who looks out at the viewer assertively. She wears a sumptuous orange silk and green
velvet striped dress lined with squirrel fur with a headdress made of curled wool and silken bows.
She stands between a simple wooden chair and table. In her left hand she holds a drawing of a
woman about to plunge a dagger into her chest. The drawing is of the Roman heroine Lucretia
who lived in the early 6th century BC as told in Livy's History of Rome. Her mythological story
is one of violence and sexual assault. Lucretia was celebrated for being both beautiful and chaste.
One evening Sextus Tarquinius, son of the king, crept into Lucretia's room sword drawn and raped
her. Unable to live with the dishonour she kills herself in front of her husband and father. Upon
the table is a piece of paper with Lucretia's final words Nec ulla impudica Lucretiae exemplo
vivet which translates to no unchaste woman shall live by Lucretia's example. Lucretia's tragic
story was popular in the 15th and 16th centuries and therefore the name Lucretia would have struck
accord with most educated Venetians at the time. She was recognised as a figure of moral integrity
and impeccable chastity. Paduan scholar and dramatist Sperone Speroni said there is no one
so vulgar that he does not know who was that Lucretia in Rome who was so famous as she lived
because she killed herself. However this is a curious painting which throws up more questions
and contradictions than it does answers and accord. Who is this woman? What is her story?
And why is she aligning herself with a Roman heroine who met a horrific and gruesome end?
And what would viewers at the time have thought about it? The identity of the sitter is unknown
although it is thought to be Venetian noblewoman Lucretia Valie who married into the prominent
Pizarro family in 1533. But this is inconclusive and in the past some refuted this for the fact
that she wears provincial rather than Venetian dress and she behaves with anything but
aristocratic reserve. Others believed she was a courtesan and the painting was once entitled
La Cortigiana meaning the courtesan. However it is likely that this is a marital portrait given the
dress, wedding band and headdress that she wears. When there is ambiguity the body can be a powerful
investigative tool. As with other historical portraits we can use the body, its pose and
gestures to assemble together some of the disparate clues the artist has left for us.
The body is worth taking note of as Renaissance authors wrote on body language and gesture
as a matter of not only character but of civility and national pride. It is likely that Renaissance
viewers would have viewed the woman's pose as inappropriate for a lady. For example at the time
ladies were instructed to sit or stand calmly with their arms close to the body and legs closed.
The idealized constrained movements were referred to as leggia dria meaning gracefulness, delicacy
or loveliness. In the book of the courtier Renaissance author Baldassare Castiglione
cautioned ladies against movimenti troppo galliardi meaning movements that are too bold,
strong and vigorous. The terms leggia dria and galliardo described movements clearly
differentiated and defined in relation to gender. Here the woman's contorted and forceful pose is
highly unusual when compared to portraits of other women at the time. It is what would be described
as galliardo, suitable for a man but not a woman. But considering this portrait was likely
commissioned to convey the woman's character as well as her wealth and status why would she have
wanted to be represented in such an unconventional way? The clues to this lie in the drawing she
holds. Technical analysis shows the work was extensively modified during the process of
We know that Lotto toiled over the sketch of Lucretia. Infrared x-rays reveal the image
was initially in colour. The representation also seems to have been on a smaller sheet of paper,
presumably a carta azzurra, blue paper, the popular choice for drawing in Venice.
The reworking and enlargement of the sheet in white paint over the blue gives the illusion of
The final representation is ultimately defined by line not colour. At this time colour was seen as
feminine whereas line associated with disegno was inherently masculine and therefore superior.
The medium can be said to define masculinity in art. Lucretia was also posed differently with her
head facing in the opposite direction, one leg resting on a plinth and her left arm raised above
her head. Here rather she stands firmly with one hand covering her modesty and looking towards the
sitter. Lotto does not shy away from the violence of Lucretia's death. The modern Lucretia creases
the paper but not the figure of her namesake who is resolute in her representation as well as in
her action. The paragon's self-sacrifice was seen as the utmost embodiment of marital faithfulness
and chastity. What is interesting is that Lucretia's suicide was viewed ultimately as a masculine
endeavour. Literary versions of Lucretia's story consistently described her in masculine terms
perhaps because it was so difficult to imagine a woman acting with such courage. Even Ovid called
his Lucretia a matron of manly courage and Valerius Maximus spoke of a male spirit in a female body.
Bahadur Schofelin's German translation of Livy noted how Lucretia had a manly heart concealed
in a womanly breast. What is courageous about Lucretia's death then is subsumed under masculinity.
This is echoed in the strangeness and the duality of Lotto's portrait. One of the first things we
notice is her arresting gaze. In most portraits of women at the time women are being looked at,
something John Berger coined as the male gaze. Here however the sitter looks out at us almost
confrontationally demanding that we meet her eyes. She is looking at us looking at her almost weighing
up our integrity asking if we could act so courageously. This is accentuated by the tilt
of the head and slight upward direction of the gaze. We can also look at the way her hand is
placed with her elbow jutting out sideways. This is known as arms akimbo. In 16th century portraits
increased importance was given to the outwards elbow which indicated boldness protection and
control and was almost always confined to male subjects. Secondly the way she holds the drawing
is curious. She clasps it so vigorously that she creases the paper. Meanwhile with her other hand
she points to the inscription on the table by crossing her arm rather uneasily around herself.
The force of both her gestures and expression breaks with conventions of female portraits
at the time. Moreover the strangeness of the pose coupled with the directness of her gaze
draws attention to what she is wearing and importantly how she is wearing it. Her movements
are so vigorous that her veil which should be tucked neatly into her bodice has pulled loose
from the gown and rests behind her right shoulder. The necklace she wears composed of a large gem
flanked by two putti on cornucopias is an affirmation of wealth. However it is not worn
as we would expect around the neck but unconventionally pushed down her bodice hanging
from her breast. This can be read as an alliance with Roman Lucretia and her story. Perhaps to
suggest that she will heed Lucretia's instructions and live chastely but rather than perish she will
survive and even thrive. We can also look at the space in which the woman occupies. She is penned
into a tiny space. There is no luxury in the setting which we can only find in her. The woman
stands between the table and a wooden chair and leans back against the chair which is turned away
from the table. Why do the table and chair not face each other and why does Lucretia stand so
awkwardly between them? The setup of the scene is highly contrived and artificial meaning that
it is intended to provoke notions of an ideal character and exemplary moral code. The style of
the furnishings are also worth noting. In contrast to her opulent dress, jewels and headpiece the
table is covered by a rather plain red cloth upon which are yellow wildflowers, common flowers in
Italy. Here they likely signify love as sanctified by marriage. The Savonarola chair with its
x-shaped frame is equally plain and was favoured by scholars at the time possibly signifying her
moral and intellectual prowess. Rather than simply being a practical furnishing the chair is a bearer
of meaning and a vowel of the modern and Roman Lucretia's enduring dignity. In a patriarchal
Renaissance society where women's bodies were the possession of their husbands by law, the sitter
has taken matters into her own hands and is represented in a way that goes beyond gender
stereotypes and norms of the age. And in a world today where women are not the legal property of
men in marriage, but women's bodies and clothing are still policed and critiqued in the public
arena, we can find great affinity with this woman. By donning the costume and animating the props
like an actor on the stage she affirms that she can play the part. She can be who she wants to be.
She can be both feminine and masculine, beautiful and chaste, bold and virtuous.
