Rating Dog Food WORST to BEST (What I Feed My Dog Instead of Kibble)

Homemade Dog Food
318 followers
Mar 13, 2026
Welcome back to Mimi's Organic Eats.
My name is Mimi and this is my pug, Jon Jon.
And today we're going to rate dog food
from worst to best.
And we'll probably ruffle a few tail feathers.
So if you love your little fur baby as much as I do
and you wanna give them the best food
so they're happy and healthy
and can celebrate as many birthdays as possible,
then keep watching.
So we're going to be starting at the bottom.
Commercial kibble is the worst dog food
that you can give your dog and here's why.
So commercial kibble is ultra processed
with high heat, low moisture,
and it can even have mystery ingredients.
Commercial kibble can also have preservatives
and harmful ingredients such as TBHQ,
which you guys can also find
in Reese's peanut butter cups, by the way.
So those ingredients I want to avoid for me
and I also want to avoid them for my dog.
And then coming in at number five is organic kibble.
And now you may think, oh, I'm buying organic kibble.
It's gonna be way better than regular kibble.
And that's true by just like this much,
like not much at all.
And so the thing with kibble,
it's not really the ingredients that are inside.
It's the way that it's processed.
That ultra high heat is just not good.
It creates carcinogens,
which is what can cause cancer in dogs.
Plus all those preservatives can make it shelf stable.
So while buying organic kibble is gonna be
just like a little bit better than regular kibble,
it's still the worst kind of dog food
that you can feed your dog.
So coming in at number four, it's air dried dog food.
And now this is going to be better than kibble
because we're not using extreme heat.
And so we're able to keep a lot more nutrients
than you are with kibble.
And so two of the main brands
that are doing air dried dog foods
are Spot and Tango's Unkibble and Sunday's for Dogs.
And if it were me, I'd rather feed my dog real food
that wasn't organic than an organic kibble.
Both of these brands don't use organic ingredients
and I have yet to see an air dried dog food
that uses organic ingredients.
So if organic is important to you,
you're not gonna find that in the air dried space.
So Sunday's for Dogs and Unkibble
are gonna be like your main ones
that you're gonna see in this space.
And I looked at the ingredients for both of those
and I don't really love one thing
that they're both putting in all of their food.
Both of these companies use spinach and or kale
in all of their flavor varieties.
The only one that doesn't have it
is the Spot and Tango beef flavor.
And now spinach and kale can be okay for your dog,
but I don't like giving it to my dog every single day
because it's high in oxalates.
And so this can cause GI upset,
it can cause bladder or kidney issues.
And I've always learned from all my research
to not feed spinach and kale daily,
to do it in moderation.
And so while you wanna rotate proteins with your dog,
even if you're buying dog food,
it's gonna be hard to avoid spinach and kale
with these brands because they're putting it
in all their flavor varieties,
with the exception of the beef from Spot and Tango.
Now I'm not a vet,
but with all my research that I've done,
spinach and kale should not be given to your dog
on a daily basis,
which is why I rarely ever give spinach and kale to John John.
But I would still choose
one of these air dried dog foods over kibble,
but don't worry, we have even better options.
And so coming in at number three are freeze dried dog foods.
These are going to allow your dog to absorb
even more nutrients than the air dried dog food,
and especially than the kibble.
And so even though eating is fun,
it's not really the main goal.
The main goal is to absorb as many nutrients
as you possibly can.
But I bet your dog is going to think
that freeze dried food is even better than kibble.
And so one of the main brands out there
for this type of food is going to be the Dr. Marty's,
which you've probably heard of that before.
I've actually bought that in the past for my older dogs,
and they've all really liked it.
Rob Lowe also has a dog food company
that also makes a freeze dried food,
and it's basically identical to the Dr. Marty's.
I kind of think the Dr. Marty's
has just a little bit better ingredient list,
but both of them have spinach and kale too.
And so this is the same thing
that I talked about just a minute ago.
I don't want to give spinach and kale
to my dog every single day,
but I would definitely do it a few times a week,
especially if you want to buy this freeze dried food
and do that for a few days a week.
So coming in at number two
is going to be fresh packaged dog food.
So this one is number two
because you are giving your dog real food.
Even though it's been packaged or frozen or whatever,
shipped to your house, that is still real food,
and it is so much better than kibble,
so much better than air dried,
and even better than freeze dried.
So there are quite a few brands out there doing this,
and I'm gonna talk about some of the reasons
why I like and don't like some of them
and which one I think you guys should buy.
And so you guys have probably seen or heard
of Fresh Pet, they have it at pet food stores,
sometimes grocery stores even have it too.
This one is kind of my least favorite option.
And it's really only because they're using some ingredients
that I don't really think should be in a fresh food,
such as natural flavors, cassia gum, and carrageenan.
And so these are all things to use to enhance flavor,
stabilize the food, and I don't really know
why they need to put that in dog food,
I just don't really think it's necessary.
So while that would definitely be a better choice
than kibble, it's not my favorite of the fresh food options,
I think there's better ones.
So everyone knows about Farmer's Dog and Ollie,
and this is super convenient if you just simply
can't cook for your dog and you wanna get fresh food
and you wanna get it portioned
and you just wanted to show up at your door.
But the Farmer's Dog and Ollie
are also using spinach and kale frequently,
and Ollie I think uses it in all of them,
so even if you're switching proteins,
it's gonna be really hard to avoid those.
The Farmer's Dog uses it in just I think two of the four,
at least that's what I found on the internet,
so it might not be totally accurate
because Farmer's Dog doesn't really have
a great ingredient list on their website like Ollie did.
So that also makes me wonder if they're hiding stuff,
I'm not sure.
But based on the AI info that I was able to gather,
even if I couldn't find it on Farmer's Dog website,
it said I think two of the four
were using these ingredients.
And so one of the things that I love
about Farmer's Dog and Ollie is they're both using fish oils
instead of a vegetable oil or a seed oil,
which I think is wonderful.
But I would still say that Farmer's Dog and Ollie
are gonna be so much better than kibble
and your dog will love them.
But my top pick for fresh dog food
is actually going to be from Portland Pet Food Company.
And this is even way easier than the Farmer's Dog and Ollie
because you don't have to sign up for a subscription,
you can just go on their website and order it,
or you can do like a subscribe and save on Amazon
or something like that,
which is what I used to do when I had my old pug.
So the thing I like about Portland Pet Food Company
is they're using really minimal ingredients,
they're putting all the stuff that you need in there,
and they're not using spinach and kale
in every single one of their flavors.
I think they use like the spinach and kale
in like the chicken and in the salmon,
but the other ones don't have those.
So if you rotate proteins for them
and just get their variety pack,
you can easily give your dog a super balanced meal
with very little effort.
But Portland Pet Food uses vegetable oil
instead of a higher quality oil
like olive oil or coconut oil,
which is what I would much rather be feeding my dog.
And this is why no store-bought
or packaged dog food is going to be perfect.
The only and best way to customize it
is to make it yourself.
But we have yet to talk about the number one
best kind of dog food for your dog,
and you know what I'm gonna say.
Of course, it is homemade in your own kitchen.
This allows you guys to choose organic ingredients
because organic matters just as much for your dog
as it does for you.
It avoids pesticides, GMOs, and all kinds of other things,
and yes, those things can affect your dog
just like they can you.
So when you're cooking at home,
you guys can choose organic ingredients,
you can rotate proteins, you can choose your veggies.
If your dog doesn't agree with something,
you can just simply omit it.
So if you guys are new to fresh feeding
and you're not sure where to start,
I have a course on how to cook homemade dog food
that is vet approved,
and I'm going to link that in the description.
So if you guys are timid about homemade dog food,
I want to tell you that I'm here
to take all the fear out of it
because if you can cook food for yourself,
for your partner, for your kid,
then you can definitely cook food for your dog.
And I show you exactly how to balance meals
and rotate your proteins and vegetables
so that your dog is getting a variety of food.
My course is a quick read,
so you can read it all in one day
and you could be cooking fresh homemade food
for your dog tomorrow.
Plus I have a list of super food toppers in the course
that are perfect for giving your dog boosted nutrition.
And you can add these food toppers
onto any of the dog foods that I talked about today
or even into your homemade dog food too.
So I always tell pet parents, it's not all or nothing.
You don't have to only cook homemade dog food
or only feed kibble or only buy fresh dog food.
As much fresh food as you can incorporate
into your dog's diet is only going to benefit them.
So if that's one day a week,
then that's still better than nothing.
If it's three days a week, that's even better.
And it's every day,
then John John and I are cheering you guys on.
But the one thing that I do want you guys
to take away from this is ditch the kibble.
There's definitely other options out there
that are so much better than kibble
and some of them are just as easy.
And for watching this video,
you can take 25% off our course,
how to cook homemade dog food that is vet approved.
Just use code John John at checkout.
If you guys ever have a question about homemade dog food
or just dog food in general,
feel free to drop us a comment, send us an email.
John John and I are always here to help.
We're just here to share that cooking for your dog
is as easy as cooking for you
and it's only going to benefit them.
So if you enjoyed this video,
be sure to drop a like and leave a comment below.
And if you want more dog recipes,
be sure to hit that subscribe button
and join us next time in the kitchen.
I think we're off to make lunch now.
