Unilateral Mistake Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
7 Video Views·Mar 13, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In this lesson we're going to spend some time talking about the final type of mistake which
can exist that can bring a contract to an end. This is of course the concept of unilateral mistake
and given the context of the previous types of mistake we've looked at and given the name of
this type of mistake you should probably come to the conclusion that you know what this type of
mistake essentially entails. This is the final lesson on the subject of mistake. We'll talk
about like I said the final kind of mistake this idea of mistake being unilateral in nature.
Now unilateral mistake pertains to those situations where rather than both parties
being mistaken to something only one party is mistaken. Remember common mistake was where
both parties had a common mistake i.e. they were both mistaken about the same thing.
Mutual mistake is those circumstances where the both parties are mistaken but they are mistaken
about different things and then unilateral mistake finally is relates to those situations where only
one party is mistaken. In addition the other party is aware of the mistake and so a unilateral mistake
will often take place in circumstances that relate to a contract where the contracting party's
identity or the specific terms or the nature finally the nature of the signed document is
mistaken. So that there are that there are mistakes in those kinds of circumstances
and I would like to draw your attention first to the 1878 case of Cundy and Lindsay. This was a
case in which a fraudulent third party had written a letter pretending to be part of a firm and send
a purchase order for handkerchiefs from the claimant. The third party was called was called
Alfred Blencahn and the firm the firm he impersonated was Blencairon
Corporated. The invoice was sent by the claimant for the order and it addressed to the corporation
not the third party. The property was then sold on to a further defendant and at which point we see
a litigation taking place where the claimant sues the defendant on the basis of the tort of
conversion. Now because the identity of one of the parties was mistakenly thought to be
Blencairon Corporation the courts determined that the contract was void on the basis of mutual
mistake. As such the claim for the tort of conversion by the claimant against the defendant
was in fact successful. Another case that illustrates the idea of unilateral mistake
more specifically is the case of Hartog versus Collin and Shields from 1913.
This illustrates the idea of unilateral mistake as it relates specifically
to the terms of a contract. So this was relating to a mistake on one side relating to an offer
which was to be put into writing. The defendants had been hide merchants who were in discussion
about the specific sale of some items to that of the claimant. The discussion had amounted to the
selling of hair skins. Specifically it was 30,000 hair skins at 10 pence per skin so quite a lot of
hair skins in fact. When the discussions had been more formally finalized the terms were written
differently. The terms were written as such 30,000 hair skins per at 10 pence per pound.
So rather than it being per skin it was then now per pound so it was measured in weight not in
quantity. The shift in metric from 10 pence per skin to 10 pence per pound resulted in a
significantly reduced final sum for the 30,000 hair skins given the fact that it was not relating
to each individual hair skin it was relating to the weight of the weight of the collective of
the hair skins. In fact it was a significant reduction given the weight of hair skins on
average. The claimant wanted to maintain this lower price as you can probably imagine and so
as a result of which sought to bring a claim to ensure that the terms that were written down
had been adhered to. So the terms essentially the dispute that existed here was in relation to the
terms which were that were made vocally or made orally before the terms were put into writing
which was 30,000 per skin oh sorry 10 pence per skin but then the dispute then arises when it
comes to the claimant's argument that it should be the thing that is written down that is
essentially adhered to which is obviously 10 pence per pound. You can obviously understand why the
claimant would want this to be advocated for given the fact that they would be able to get 30,000
hair skins at a significantly reduced price than what was originally agreed before it was put into
writing and formalized. The court held that it would have been clear the error on the part of
the defendants by there would have been a clear error on the part of the defendants by the claimant
and so as a result of this given that there was a unilateral mistake as to the term and that this
was known to the other party and that nothing was said about this mistake the contract was made
void on the basis of unilateral mistake. So you have to make it very clear here that what clearly
was the case was that the claimant knew that there was a mistake in the when it was formally written
down in the contract but they remained silent. They remained silent on that mistake because
obviously that mistake would have incentivized them to get a lower deal and get a better deal
and to maintain this better deal. So they thought well we won't say anything about the mistake that
you clearly made here because we want a better deal. It was concluded therefore that because
there was a mistake as to the terms and because the claimant knew about this mistake but decided
to say nothing about it because that meant that they would get a better deal the contract was
void on the basis of unilateral mistake. You can't really do that it wouldn't be
just or equitable for that to stand.
