Mutual Mistake Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
8 Video Views·Mar 12, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In this lesson we're going to talk about the concept of mutual mistake in relation to contract
law. So we're moving on to what is known as the second type of mistake. The previous type of
mistake is of course common mistake and we noted that common mistake can exist in various different
forms. Noting for example that mistake as to quality is representative of quite a weak form
but then you also have mistake as to the existence of subject matter as well as mistake as to the
true owner of the subject matter. Both of which are far stronger concepts of common mistake.
Mutual mistake is a different type of principle that exists within contract law.
We'll explain in this lesson what mutual mistake is as well as how it operates at the common law
with some case studies and some case examples. So mutual mistake is very similar to that of
common mistake. Both parties have made a mistake as to the terms of the contract or potentially
its subject matter. So that's another point that we need to make. The key difference here is though
there is that with mutual mistake when it comes to mutual mistake unlike that of common mistake
the parties have made different mistakes. So previously when we looked at common mistake
they both had made the same mistake. So the example of making a contract about a subject
matter that didn't exist. They're both making a contract on the basis of a subject matter
and they're both mistaken as to the existence of that subject matter. That is what we mean by common
mistake. But in cases of mutual mistakes there are two different mistakes at least two different
mistakes and when we see that and we say that the parties are at quote cross purposes and so when
they're at cross purposes we get mutual mistake. Let's illustrate this with some case law okay.
So the 1864 case of Raffles and Whittle House which is another word that I am unable to pronounce
is a case which involved the delivery of cotton on a ship. The ship itself was called the Peerless
and the contract said that it would be delivered on this ship and it will be arriving out of Bombay
but it did not specify the month that it was going to arrive. Especially in the 1800s the
mid-1800s it was probably unlikely to actually have a good understanding of when the ship was
going to arrive given that the journeys of that nature in that time period took
probably a very long time an inordinate amount of time. Unfortunately for the people who contracted
in this particular agreement there were in fact two ships two different ships with the same name
that were both arriving out of Bombay and one was arriving in the month of October the other was
arriving in the month of December. So unfortunately there were two Peerless that were
arriving out of Bombay and one was arriving in the month of October one arrived in the month of
So two ships, same name, same place, roughly the same time. When it comes to shipping and all this
kind of thing the difference of two or three months is not really that huge especially in
the 1860s as I mentioned so quite ironic and quite difficult to understand. Both the claimant
and the defendant had different views about which ship the contract was in fact referring to.
The claimant believed that it was a contract for cotton that was arriving in December the
defendants believed it was for cotton that was arriving in October. Oh yeah I forgot to add as
well that both the same ship of this sorry two different ships of the same name that were both
arriving out of the same place in roughly the same time period and carrying the same cargo
so there was also that problem. It would have been easily solved if one was carrying something
other than cotton because then you come to the conclusion ah it's the one that's carrying cotton
that is the ship that we're referring to because our contract is for the delivery of cotton on a
ship. Unfortunately they were both delivering cotton so unfortunate there. So litigation was
brought on the basis of a breach a breach of contract because there was a disagreement as
to which ship in fact belonged to the to the agreement which ship actually was the one that
the contract was referring to. The courts were tasked with the job of identifying the operational
the operationalization of mutual mistake and they concluded that if on reading a contract
a neutral third party would be able to find a common intention as to which ship the contract
was referring to this would render that contract valid and binding. So if you take a neutral third
party and you get them to read the contract and you can see and they can come to a conclusion
as to what the contract is referring to then this common intention would therefore render that
contract binding and whoever was wrong in that instance in fact would have to pay damages out of
by way of breach because they have breached that contractual arrangement. However when reading
these contractual terms there was in fact no indication whatsoever as to which ship was being
referred to. Because they were both the same name they both arriving out of Bombay and it wasn't
specified necessarily which month it was going to arrive. So the only distinguishing feature of
these two ships essentially for our purposes was which month they were going to arrive at
because they were the same name they were going from the same place and they had the same cargo.
So the only difference between these two ships was that one arrived in October and one arrived
in December but because the contract doesn't specify which ship sorry it doesn't specify the
month that it was going to arrive it doesn't specify that then the distinguishing feature
the only distinguishing feature is not part of the contract. So there is no distinguishing feature in
the contract there is no indication as to which ship the contract was referring to and so there
was therefore a mutual mistake and the doctrine of mutual mistake was therefore valid and the
contract was therefore void. Another case is the case of Scriven brothers and Coe versus Hindley
and Coe from 1913. This principle that was established in the previous case relating to
The defendants in this case had made bids at an auction it was for two different lots
with the belief that they were bidding for hemp in both cases however it later transpired that
one was hemp and the other was toe as such one was significantly more valuable than the other.
Again the court would have to consider whether or not a reasonable neutral third party would
be able to make a determination in the contract as to whether or not they had bought hemp or toe
whether or not a distinction could be made here that is able to essentially delineate which lot
was which. They considered that in both lots they contained the both they both contained the same
label SL which was a mark the purchasers believed indicated the presence of hemp. The courts
concluded that a third party therefore would be unable to determine the difference between
these two different lots and these two in with it specifically within the contract
and so just like in the previous case the contract was void on the basis of mutual mistake.
