Mistake Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
14 Video Views·Mar 11, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Hello everybody and welcome back to the law of contracts. In this lesson we're going to talk
about the next major circumstance in which we can bring a contract to an end and this is by
reference to the doctrine of mistake. Now in previous lessons we spent quite a lot of time
examining the nature and the extent to which misrepresentation could be representative of a
vitiating factor within contract law. We noted that there are various different kinds of
misrepresentation ranging from the idea of innocent misrepresentation on the one hand
all the way to fraudulent misrepresentation on the other. This lesson is, like I said,
going to speak about the doctrine of mistake within the law of contracts. Another major
doctrine and another major element of doctrine that we need to explore in more detail. So the
doctrine of mistake does exactly what it says. It provides a stipulation that where a contract
is essentially done on the basis of a mistake and that contract can be made void or at least
voidable by the parties to the contract. We can divide the doctrine of mistake into three major
types of mistake that can exist in contract law. The first is this idea of common mistake.
This is the first type of mistake that can exist. The second is mutual mistake and then the third
is unilateral mistake. And you can probably come to a conclusion as to what these things mean
just by looking at how they are written and what they're called. We will get to this in
more detail throughout this lesson. So common mistake exists where there will be an agreement
but both parties are mistaken in relation to the fundamental part of the contract itself.
This is often in relation to some fundamental part of the subject matter of the contract itself.
So they are mistaken as to what the fundamental condition of a contract may be. Remember that
there are various different ways in which we can delineate terms of a contract and we've done this
already and we noted that conditions of a contract strike to the heart of the contractual arrangement
such that if a condition is to be misrepresented or to be mistaken then you are mistaken as to
what the even the very nature of the existence of the agreement even is. An example of this taking
place can be seen in the 1856 case of Cortiura and Hastie. In this case the first kind of common
mistake is illustrative, is illustrated in this particular case where there is a mistake as to
the existence of the subject matter of the contract itself. This is known as res extinctia.
Essentially it involved the sale of Indian corn which was in transit as cargo. During the transport
of this cargo however the corn itself became unfit for sale and use and so as a result of this midway
through the journey the captain decided and made the decision to to sell the cargo off to a third
party. All while this was happening while the sale was going off in a different period in a different
area, the parties were contracted for the sale of the cargo under the assumption that it
still existed, that it was still under the control of the captain of the ship.
While some may believe foul play on the part of the captain it was actually common and customary
practice for a captain to go about selling cargo in this fashion if it was deemed to have been
unfit for further transport. So it was actually quite a common feature basically essentially
saying that if rather than having the cargo be unfit and arrive at its destination unfit and
unable to be actually utilized sell it as quickly as possible. If it's deemed to be unfit later on
in the in the journey in the voyage then sell it now essentially. But then when it comes to the
contractual ideas related to mistake it argues here that when the claimant made the argument
that the defendant should pay for the corn owing to the fact that they had taken on the liability
in its transport the courts held that the contract itself was rendered void and it was rendered void
of course because the contract did not exist owing to the fact that the subject matter did not exist.
If the subject matter of the contract did not exist then the contract itself would not exist.
If I contracted with my friend to purchase an alien spaceship I couldn't then
sue that individual if I don't get my alien spaceship. I've made a contract on the basis
of a subject matter that did not exist that does not exist an alien spaceship at least if you
believe if you don't believe the conspiracy theorists at least. And so as a result of that
there's no subject matter. This is known as a res extinctia. In this instance we have here that
like I said there is a contract of a sale of corn but that's that that went off and disappeared.
A similar thing can take place if you've got the transport of property that's going in cargo you
make a contract for the purchase of that cargo but at some point along the journey prior to your
making of this contract the cargo falls overboard or it gets destroyed in a fire or something like
that. You don't know that that has happened so you're basically contracting for the sale of an
object that no longer exists or is no longer available to you as such as a result of which
you have the idea of common mistake. In the case of Cooper and Phibbs from 1867 we can illustrate
the second type of common mistake that can exist. This time we're not talking about the very
existence of the subject matter in terms of common mistake but rather we're talking about common
mistake between the parties as to who the true owner of the subject matter is. This is known as
this case specifically there was a mistake relating to the renting of a fishery. The
claimant had rented the fishery believing that it was owned by his cousins. In reality this wasn't
true it was actually the owner of the property. He was actually the owner of the property should I
say so he was renting it believing he didn't own the thing that he owned. He was renting his own
property essentially and then as such he sought to get a contract rendered void on the basis that
there was a common mistake here. We're not talking about a mistake as to whether or not the subject
matter existed but the true owner of the subject matter. He was already the owner of the subject
matter so there was a mistake as to the who owned the subject matter in the contract so it should
be rendered void. In reality this is what happened it got rendered void on the basis that there was
this common mistake because you can't of course make a contract on the basis of there being a
failure to know the true owner of the subject matter. If this happens and you are wrong about
those two owners of the subject matter then you can render a contract void on the basis of common mistake.
