Almost 2 million Californians work through staffing agencies, and most of them assume that someone on the other side of that arrangement is responsible if they get hurt on the job. But in many industries, staffing companies in California aren't required to prove compliance before they operate, so who is actually checking?
When something does go wrong, the workers, the businesses that hired them, and California taxpayers often end up sharing a cost that was never supposed to be theirs.
In recent years, fraudulent operators have identified the staffing industry as an entry point, using the lack of oversight to undercut legitimate businesses and avoid accountability.
In this episode, we sit down with Shaddi Kamiabipour, Former Senior Deputy District Attorney for Orange County, Mike DiManno, CEO of Employ Insure, and Jennifer Snyder, Former LA County Deputy District Attorney, to explore how the staffing industry actually works in California and what separates the legitimate players from those exploiting the gaps.
AI Generated·May contain errors
There's a major loophole in California's employment law
where some companies are able to hire employees
without giving them adequate worker comps,
insurance, and other benefits.
At the same time, it's questionable
what they do with their payroll taxes.
It is now significantly more profitable
and less risky to engage in workers' comp fraud
than it is to rob a bank.
So we're inviting these criminals
who sort of understand that into a system,
and they use the workers' comp and the staffing
to generate a tremendous amount of cash flow.
Our guests today are experts within the industry.
We also talked to some former prosecutors
that know specifically what these companies are doing today
to bypass California's employment law.
And all of this is so far potentially legal
and doable for these agencies.
Today, we'll dive into how they're doing that
and what's the impacts.
And a lot of taxpayer funding is going to have to cover
for these worker comps fraud.
I'm Siamak.
Welcome to California Insider.
Shadi, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Thank you.
Thank you for having me.
I'm happy to be here.
We want to talk to you about a phenomenon
that's happening in California and nationally,
but you have dealt with.
People are going to agencies and getting jobs,
and there's a lot of shady things happening
to the people that are getting employed
by staffing agencies.
Can you tell us what's happening?
A lot of it really started, I want to say,
with Amazon and some of these other big companies
that came about, where they have seasonal jobs, right?
You have seasonal jobs, you have manufacturing jobs,
you have warehouse jobs.
And post-pandemic especially,
temporary jobs just became something
that became just more available.
A lot of employers don't want to pay the benefits.
They don't want to have people year round.
They want to have staffing during their high season, right?
When they're doing the kind of work.
And so whether it's in construction,
whether it's in office work,
whether it's in manufacturing areas,
they tend to gravitate to temporary employment
in order to fill in the staff,
and then that way they don't have to pay for salaries
and stuff during the rest of the year.
So that's how the whole thing starts.
As a prosecutor, one of the things
that we used to see a lot in this world,
in the staffing world, is we were really unable
to prosecute a lot of the abuses
that happened in the staffing age.
Things like wage theft, where people are given
less than 40 hours a week.
When they're not given sometimes less than minimum wage
because let's say the business is charging the employer
$20 an hour for this person,
but they're giving the person less than minimum wage
but for the hour.
They were withholding taxes from their W-2s
or their paychecks, but not sending it over to the IRS,
right, not sending it over to the tax authorities.
So these people thought that the money
that was being withheld from them was gonna go for taxes,
and then they can file a return and get their money back.
And then lo and behold, there would be no evidence
of the fact that they had even worked.
So it wasn't even in the EDD.
So this was happening to them.
So then the question becomes,
well, why don't you complain about it?
I mean, if this is happening to you
and you find out somehow along the line.
Is this happening to a lot of people right now?
A lot of people.
Right now.
A lot, and you know, actually,
if you were to just Google right now
the recent prosecution at the federal level,
you'll see multiple staffing agencies
that have been indicted and charged for tax evasion.
What is the basis of the tax evasion?
It is taking people's money,
withholding taxes from their payroll,
and then not turning it over to the federal government.
Now, the federal government
doesn't necessarily care about the workers.
They're worried about the fact that you withheld taxes
and then you didn't forward it over to us, right?
That's the basis and the theory of liability
to go after them.
But that's just a recent example.
That's like 2025.
Yeah, I think the last two indictments
were in the last two years,
2024 at the federal level, not at the state level.
At the state level, you don't see it.
And the reason you don't see it
is because if someone comes forward and complains,
what do you think happens?
They get retaliated against.
Let's say you get injured on the job.
You come back and you tell them I got injured.
Now, in California, we have joint liability.
So both the employer who got the staffing agency
to bring it over and the staffing agency
are technically liable under Work Comp
to give services to the worker.
But if the worker goes and asks for it,
then they retaliate against the worker.
So all of a sudden, they stop giving you work.
You're not getting it as regularly as everybody else.
One of the big schemes that was happening
right here in Tustin, right before I retired,
especially with cleanup groups,
remember the hangar that burned down in Tustin?
So a lot of the labor that went over there
to clean the asbestos, to clean everything
with Public Works taxpayer money
were temporary workers.
They were temporary workers.
So they were not trained.
They were not given healthy working conditions.
They had to give kickbacks to the local contractor
to be able to secure, be able to come back.
In other words, the contractor says,
okay, yeah, you're the people,
you're the same person I'm gonna ask for next week.
So they gave financial kickbacks for that.
If they were harmed on the job
and they complained and wanted Work Comp benefits,
they got retaliated against
and they were not asked back.
So if you were in a situation where
your livelihood depends on being asked back
to come back to the job,
that appears to be a long-term job,
what are you going to do as a worker?
Are you gonna complain about it?
You're not gonna complain about it.
So how do I know this?
How do I know what I'm telling you
if they don't complain about it?
How you know about it is there is a lot of
compliance groups in unions.
So the compliance people go out there
to try to talk to the workers for multiple reasons
to find out what's going on,
to see if there's any abuses
so they can refer it to law enforcement.
They're the ones who find out.
They're the boots on the ground.
It's not law enforcement
because detection doesn't come from law enforcement.
Detection always comes from the private sector.
It comes from the people who are in it.
So it's either the compliance agencies
with the union groups,
it's either the employees themselves complaining
to the Department of Labor.
Because if you think about it,
it's white-collar crime.
White-collar crime is designed to be legitimate,
is to have the appearance of legitimacy.
There's a legitimate way to do business.
You pay taxes.
You pay people money.
Working is not illegal.
Paying people money is not illegal.
None of this stuff is illegal.
How you go about doing it becomes illegal, right?
So law enforcement can't detect
that something's going on.
Are these agencies you're talking about,
because there's good staffing agencies too
that actually do the real work.
Right, right, we're talking about the abuse, right.
And are these agencies set up like that,
where they're doing that all the time?
Is it all fraud?
How does that work?
In my experience, even the cleanest have problems.
And the reason they have problems,
and the reason abuses exist,
it may not be as overt as me taking taxes
from your paycheck and not turning it over
to the federal government.
It may not be that.
But it may be as subtle as workplace retaliation.
Meaning, if you don't work the hours
or do what I'm asking you to do,
then I'm not going to give you future assignments.
Or I put you in a job,
and I tell you this is going to lead to permanent work.
They call it perma-temporary,
where you kind of stay there for two years,
and that never leads to a regular job.
And you don't understand why,
because that's the reason you went there.
So abuses can be soft abuses like that,
where they are getting $25 an hour for your work
and giving you $11 an hour or whatever for the work,
and you find yourself there permanently.
They're not giving you the benefits
that the worker gives you.
As a status as a temporary worker is always lower
in a company than a regular employee.
That's just the reality, the reality of what happens.
So it could be something as soft as that.
But the retaliation exists in every single one.
The reason it exists is because there's no oversight.
Even in California, there's only a small category
of businesses have special licensing for staffing.
I think it's farm workers, garment workers,
maybe the Hollywood industry, acting industry.
I think there's four or five of them.
It's not for the construction industry,
what you would think is such a high risk.
People get hurt significantly.
It's not necessarily for the manufacturing industry,
which is where the blue collar workers
where they have seasonal jobs,
where there's a risk of getting hurt.
All of these don't have that special licensing.
So what's the significance of a special licensing?
When you're dealing with regulation that is gray in nature,
meaning it all depends,
unless someone comes forward and complains,
and you can hold them liable under certain laws that exist,
you can't do anything.
How are you gonna hold them accountable?
If there's no accountability, then there's always abuse.
There just is, because they can get away with it.
Before we move on with the rest of this interview,
we wanna tell you we're gonna have an event in our studio
with our colleague Jan Jekielek,
who's the host of American Thought Leaders.
He has written a book called Killed to Order.
This book is very special
because it highlights organ harvesting in China
by the government.
He's here to tell us his findings in this live event.
The event is gonna be on March 21st.
There's gonna be one in San Diego in the morning,
and we're gonna have one in the afternoon
here in our studio in Irvine.
We highly recommend you come to this event,
check out this book, and meet with us.
We look forward to seeing you here.
Now let's move on with the rest of the interview.
What about the laws that apply to normal companies?
Because when you employ someone, it's not easy in California.
There's so many laws and regulations.
Are they bypassing those laws?
So when you're an employee of a company,
there's certain lights and issues that exist.
So let's say I work for you
and you don't have safe environment,
and I file a complaint with OSHA,
or I file a complaint with, you know,
Department of Industrial Relations,
and they come investigate it.
The anti-retaliation laws protect you in California.
You could sue them and become a millionaire, right?
If they retaliate and come after you.
If they retaliate, they take away your,
they fire you illegally because you complained.
Or they retaliate and limit your work.
You have avenues you can pursue.
If they fire you,
you can go to the Unemployment Development Department
and get unemployment until you find another job.
So there's some checks and balances
for you as a worker to stay on your feet,
and you may complain anyway,
because, hey, listen, you're gonna get your paycheck,
you're gonna find another job, and you're gonna move on.
When you're in a temporary setting,
so you work for a temporary agency,
technically you have an employment.
Do you get unemployment for EDD?
No, because you have a job.
If they don't assign you work, what happens to you?
You don't make money.
What if they assign you 10 hours a week, 20 hours a week,
instead of the 40 they promised you?
Can you live on 20 hours a week?
You're employed, EDD's not gonna give you any money.
And if you go complain about it, what's going to happen?
You're not gonna get another job.
You're not gonna get another assignment.
Who do you go and complain to?
If you complain, by the time
Department of Industrial Relations
or somebody comes around looking at it.
So it doesn't fall into the same Department of Labor
because you're not really employed.
Well, I mean, yeah, if you go to the Department of Labor
and you complain to them
and say, this is what happened to me,
they'll look into it.
I'm not gonna sit here and say they're not going to,
but there's no incentive for the employee to do that.
Because by the time they, first of all, it's government.
The law, especially in the white collar world
and the financial world moves extremely slow.
And it's because of due process.
So you wanna make sure people are not wrongfully accusing
other people of other things.
You want time to look into it.
So there's a method to the madness.
I'm not being critical of, you know,
why is it taking forever?
Well, there's a reason for it.
I get it.
But if you're someone who's living paycheck to paycheck,
you're living on a poverty line,
you really can't afford not to make any money.
Are you inclined to go and complain about it?
Or are you going to just deal with it?
For law enforcement of any kind,
whether it's agencies, whether it's my office,
you know, when I was a DA,
for anybody to get involved,
there has to be some basis of a law violation
of something that you can point to
that says this is the law you broke.
This is what you did.
And you have to have a remedy available for that person.
Otherwise, there's not anything you can do.
Now, Shadi, how big is this?
Is this something that a lot of Californians
are impacted by, but we don't know about it?
We don't, it's not talked about?
California has the biggest employment market in the country.
And it has the biggest temporary employment market
in the country.
If you were to just do a search,
we have minimal enforcement of abuses
in the temporary employment market.
And the reason we have that
is because we don't have clear enough laws
that allows enforcement by an agency
or the prosecutor's office or anybody.
The very fact that a senator,
the Senate's representative in California
is trying to sponsor a bill,
and talking about it in 2026.
We need to create a safe act.
We need to expand this to other agencies.
What that tells you,
even though there's no public prosecutions,
is telling you that there's a huge problem.
There's a huge problem.
Because the legislator is always after the fact.
So the very fact that there's conversations about it,
what that should tell you
is that there's been complaints about the fact that,
look, there's numerous cases that are investigated.
The prosecutors won't take it.
They can't prosecute it.
They can't do anything about it.
We are aware of the problem, right?
They're saying, hey, we're aware of the problem.
But there's no laws we can hold people accountable for
other than tax evasion.
It's expensive to run a company
and a business in the state of California.
Since I've retired from the DA's office
and I have my own business, it's expensive.
It's expensive.
And there's a lot of liability with having employees.
So the way they sidestep that
is they hire people from temporary agencies.
That's the way you sidestep it.
But the legislator has not gone far enough to say,
okay, well, you have the option, Ms. Kamyabipour,
if you wanna hire people from a temporary agency
to work for you during this period of time.
But the temporary agency and you have to be on notice
that these things apply
and we're gonna be watching over you
and there's gonna be more scrutiny
and there's gonna be...
The only thing that applies to me right now,
if I were to get someone from a temporary agency,
is joint liability if they get hurt.
So if I have them do something for me and they get hurt,
they can hit my work comp and the temp agencies work.
But what if both of us don't have it?
What happens?
So essentially what you're saying
is that we have made it very difficult
for the businesses that are employing people.
At the same time, we have allowed this area
where it's kind of gray area
and some players are coming there, abusing the laws.
The market is...
We've made it attractive.
We've made temporary work attractive for employers
because it's such...
It's difficult to run a business.
I'm a big advocate for a lot of the employment laws
that exist in California
because they're very unique actually in the country.
A lot of places in the United States,
or maybe two or three,
maybe Massachusetts, New York, California,
there are very finite number of states
that have good laws that actually protect employees.
It's very employee-centric.
However, there are minimal incentives for an employer
to have a full staff,
do the things that they need to do.
It's very, very expensive for them.
It's just expensive for them.
That's the problem.
The balance is gone.
So there's a lot of laws that exist
to protect the consumer, the workers,
and it should be there.
They have to be protected.
Absolutely, absolutely.
But there also has to be either an incentive
or a disincentive for the employers
not to gravitate and kind of transfer liability
to a temporary agency, right?
Instead of carrying that liability themselves.
Now we go to Mike DiMano,
who's actually a player in the staffing industry
to see what he's seeing and how the industry is doing.
I think one thing to recognize
is the contingent labor force in this country
is getting very large.
And it's supported by demographics
that are gonna make it continue to get bigger
and bigger and bigger.
And so workers' comp, particularly in staffing,
is very difficult.
And so there's been a underground market
that has existed for workers' comp and staffing
since as long as I've been here, 30 years.
It's held in check by a couple of things.
Number one, customers are unwilling
to accept certificates of insurance
from the staffing agency
because they know that if the certificates aren't legit,
then they'll be responsible for the claims.
So that's always kept the kind of little shady gray area
staffing agency with no insurance
or maybe borrowing someone else's insurance.
It's kept that in check.
What's happened is over time,
the demand for labor is so great
that businesses try one of these,
I'll call them left-handed certificates,
and they try to get a few more employees
where they can't get them.
And the regulators don't do anything.
And so the rates that these illegal agencies charge
are significantly less
because they're not paying for workers' comp.
In that case, the workers' comp cost
is the second biggest cost next to the wages itself.
So it's a significant number, right?
And these agencies who were shunned before,
now all of a sudden are welcomed by customers
with open arms because they're looked at like,
I can't get the employees I need.
Maybe these guys can do it.
So they try it.
The state doesn't slap them on the hand.
And so now, especially after COVID,
there's a complete, absolute disregard
to check and make sure
that a staffing agency has workers' comp.
And so if you can come in
and undercut the legitimate players,
the market share goes to you, right?
Now, all of the honest staffing owners can't compete.
They start leaving the business,
and they're replaced by criminals.
Workers' comp fraud, recently there was
a state-of-the-state address by the WCIRB.
And so they monitor all the records for the state.
And so once a year, they put on a thing
to talk about all of the trends
and things like that that are going on.
And at the end of the meeting,
they were doing Q&A and someone said,
what do you think about all the fraud going on
in the workers' comp market today?
And her statement was something along the lines of,
it is now significantly more profitable
and less risky to engage in workers' comp fraud
than it is to rob a bank.
So we're inviting these criminals
who sort of understand that into a system.
And they use the workers' comp and the staffing
to generate a tremendous amount of cashflow.
And once they're getting that cashflow,
which 90% of it belongs to the employees for wages,
the government for taxes,
and the insurance company to insure them.
So if you have 1,000 employees temps, let's say,
that's about 40 million in payroll,
it's about 55 million in total billings.
Most of that money, 51 million out of the 55
is held in trust so the workers can get their wages,
the government can get their taxes and so on.
But when you put a criminal in charge of that
with no governance, they start stealing tax money
and they start stealing wage money from these workers
who don't have attorneys to defend themselves
and all that kind of stuff.
And they don't have the knowledge
to really understand what's being done to them.
So you're in this space, you're seeing all of this,
how big is it?
To give you a scale of the whole thing,
it's in the many, many billions.
And so we're losing tax dollars,
employees are losing benefits, et cetera, in the billions.
There's a single entity that everybody knows.
They've been to court and lost and the judges said,
this is a fraudulent transaction
and even posted in the paper,
you are not allowed to do business with these entities.
So everybody knows it.
But they're still in business.
And we had gotten their request for insurance.
It's one of the things our companies does.
And I saw how big it was.
And there was $4 billion of payroll
with one company that was being done
with no workers' comp.
Four billions of payroll with one company
without workers' comp.
Yes.
So it must have been a huge company
that's hired them.
Well, what they do, very similar to me,
is they tell staffing agencies,
I can give you workers' comp.
And so what they do is they give them a piece of paper
that's not valid.
It's doctored up.
And so it's made to look like it's valid insurance,
but it's not.
And so what they'll do is they'll buy
a little landscaping company
with let's say 12 employees on it
and they'll go get the policy
under that landscaping company.
So if you call the number on the paper
and it's Zurich and you say, is this number valid?
They'll say, absolutely.
But they will back up a billion dollars
of payroll onto that cert.
And they use that number to show clients,
look, we have a valid cert.
And it's literally a multi-level marketing.
There could be four different layers of entities
using this one cert.
The insurance company has absolutely no idea
that any of this is done.
So when an injured employee comes in,
they pay the claim under the table
and they don't cover the long-term exposure of the claim.
So in other words, I might, if you twist your ankle,
I've been keeping all the money.
I'm not giving it to the insurance company.
So I have a big pot and I might pay for you
to go get your ankle fixed.
If you break your back, I just shut the company down
and I start up another company next,
even at the same address.
And I go, yeah, that company went out of business.
And the state of California will pick up
a four or $500,000 claim because these companies just,
when the liability gets too big,
they just say, yeah, we're out.
And the state has to pay for that, right?
Yeah, we have two funds.
One is the uninsured fund.
So it's designed to be a catchment for an employee
who maybe got hired by someone who didn't have insurance
or they fell in the cracks somehow.
The state's like, okay,
we'll make sure that employee is taken care of.
And the other one is called a subsequent benefit fund.
And that's when whatever the settlement they reached
isn't enough and that employee may have
some additional exposure or some additional needs.
We have a fund to kind of say,
well, the system didn't really cover them well enough.
So we're gonna provide some additional coverage for them.
But those two funds, the frauds look at as their backup,
right?
So they go, eh, we'll bring it up and shut it down.
I'm gonna go back to my network of staffing agencies
and brokers and customers who are using this fraud.
And I'm just gonna say, we got a new one.
They all know.
If you talk to some of these staffing agencies,
they'll say, I can't get insurance in California, right?
Like no, not a lot of insurance carriers
are willing to write staffing agencies in California
because of the fraud.
And that's part of what got it to just grow so big.
So another example of that is one of the things
that kept the staffing agencies in check
is you couldn't get funding.
You couldn't get factoring to pay for these employees
and send the invoice to your customer.
And the customer usually gets 30 day terms.
So you go to a factoring company and you use your invoices,
sell your invoices to the bank.
So you get the prepayment kind of like,
so you can make the wages now before the client gives it to you.
So the banks have laws that prevent them
or try and prevent them from doing business with criminals.
So the banks traditionally would never finance
these illegal operations.
Then COVID happened.
And so when COVID hit, all of these staffing agencies,
legit and non-legit, got PPP money
and they paid off their bank lines.
So all of these factoring companies and banks
are sitting there with a lot of money
that they have to put out in the market.
They're essentially losing money
for not having it out there.
And they started realizing like,
nobody's really prosecuting the frauds.
Maybe we should look at them as an opportunity.
And so once the factoring companies
accepted illegal certificates,
because it's their job to check
and make sure they have legitimate insurance,
it exploded.
Now everybody and their brother just said,
if I can get financing, the clients love it
because the rates are low.
I got some guys who say they handle the claims, you know.
Why not?
No prosecution anywhere in the food chain, right?
And if there is a prosecution, it's so small.
People get, it's like seeing a guy on the side of the road
that got caught speeding.
This workers' comp practice is kind of like the gateway in.
Now the criminals have entered this trust business
called staffing, where I can undercut somebody
and get all of the cashflow, the wages, the taxes.
And you tell the client, we're taking care of everything
and I'm, you know, it's my liability.
And I just steal.
You're in this space and there are some laws
that people are working on.
Is there a fix to this?
There's so many people now benefiting, right?
And all of their businesses are sort of entrenched
in the economics of the fraud market.
So banks are benefiting, lenders.
So a bank, a factoring company,
it's like why would they risk getting caught
when there's legitimate staffing agencies out there
that they can fund?
And the answer is they make three or four times as much
financing a fraud, right?
Because they're, I'm willing to accept
your fraudulent certificate,
but you're gonna pay me 50% interest.
You see what I mean?
And so now the banks are making more than the frauds are.
It is very complex.
It did happen over time.
You know, everybody's kind of culpable,
but there's no one who's totally culpable, you know?
And so that's this underground market
that turned into this moral hazard.
Nothing's wrong here.
And the moral hazards on a foundational piece
of our society, right?
Workers comp exists for really good reasons.
It protects business owners and the employees,
and it's supposed to do so
in the most efficient way possible.
When that falls apart and all of the things
that are dependent fall apart along with it,
it's this multiplier effect.
The state's already right now losing billions of dollars
of tax money, and you can kind of point them
to that direction, but it's so big
and it crosses so many departments,
it's difficult for one entity, one business,
or one part of the food chain in the state to say,
I'm gonna take care of this.
And so they all point the finger at each other.
What should they do tomorrow?
If you were in charge, what would you do to fix this?
So the number one thing that you have to do
is eliminate the moral hazard.
So the banks, the customers, the brokers,
all the people who are making money on the periphery,
they have to understand it's not okay anymore.
There's a new bill being proposed
to just suggest licensing.
So it's not a complex bill.
It doesn't have all the things that we could put in there.
So having a licensing that just says,
we just wanna make sure you're not a bank robber
or some type of a federal felon
because we can't put you in charge of that kind of money.
The second thing is in order to run that kind of a business,
do you have any experience, right?
Are you from the industry?
Cause it's really hard business to do
and just do some basic background checks
so we can eliminate the people
who are being creative in the fraud.
Like they're in the door and now they're like,
let's get everything, let's leave them with nothing.
You get rid of those people.
So those owners would not be able to get a license
cause the license will say essentially,
give it, tell us your experience
cause this is not an easy industry.
And if you had a staffing agency,
show us your workers comp certificates.
If you don't have them, you just, you don't qualify.
So now the people who are doing it right,
the value of their business is gonna go up.
The markups are gonna go into where we can pay the bills
and that will have a massive impact.
The other thing is you gotta let a couple people know
that you're participating in a underground labor scenario
that has lots of detrimental effects,
not just to the workers, to the insurance community, right?
We end up paying for all of their fraud.
The other thing is, if you think about all the businesses
that are using these staffing firms,
it's been a slow growth.
Those businesses, the economics of their businesses
now run on an assumption of a cost
that can't pay for taxes and workers comp.
Forget about all the other things that you need to do.
And so that's a pretty stubborn metric to move.
And the brokers, there's a whole network
of some of them are licensed, some of them are not
that market these products.
And so when a new one pops up,
it just like electricity,
it just goes through the system
and a billion dollars of illegal businesses
popped up overnight.
Now we go to Jennifer Lynn Snyder,
who's been a prosecutor
and who's been looking into crimes
that these companies are committing.
I think it's first of all,
important to put staffing in context in California,
because it's not something
that some people think about very often.
When I think of staffing,
before I found out what the problem really was,
I thought of Kelly Girl or Apple One
or temporary agencies that might place workers
in clerical and so forth.
The truth of the matter is,
according to the American Staffing Association,
there are more than 1.9 million employees
in California that work through staffing.
That was as of 2023.
Here's what's striking about that.
In California, according to
the Department of Industrial Relations,
the working, the workforce in California,
non-farm is 19 million.
That means that almost 10% of the non-farm workforce
in California is involved in staffing.
Staffing covers a variety of different industries.
It's not limited to clerical or office.
It can be in virtually any setting.
And the fact that there's 10% of that workforce
that is involved in an industry
that is not even licensed in California is staggering.
Here's the problem.
When you work for a staffing company,
the workers are assigned to a location
and they work for another, an existing company.
And smaller companies want to bring in staffing
when they have absences or when they are growing at a pace
that prevents them from being able to onboard enough people.
And so they rely on staffing companies
to come in and fill those needs.
So the staffing companies hire the people
and then send them to-
The staffing companies have the employees
and they assign those employees to their client employers.
The staffing company is responsible for the employees.
They are the employer.
So they're responsible for things
like workers' comp insurance and payroll taxes
and all of that.
So when staffing companies go to businesses
that are in need,
the business looks at what the cost is gonna be
and the problem has been identified
when staffing companies come in
and offer deals that are too good to be true.
They'll offer to bring in staffing at a rate
that does not permit them to pay into the payroll tax funds
that legitimate businesses pay into,
that pay for workers' comp premiums and so forth.
So the workers go into these jobs
thinking that they work for a staffing company
and they get injured
and find out the staffing company wasn't insured
and that they were underinsured
and find out that their payroll taxes
that have been submitted didn't include payment
into those funds that are maintained
through assessments on payroll.
And suddenly you find workers
that aren't covered for their injuries
whose cases go through the WCAB
and when the non-insurance situation is discovered,
that means that their case has to go
to the Uninsured Employer Benefit Trust Fund,
which is a trust fund created to cover circumstances
where workers find themselves uninsured
because their employers weren't insured.
That sounds like a real easy problem, it's not.
Workers' comp fraud in California
is valued between one and $3 billion a year
and that's by NICB.
If we're talking about 10% of workers' comp fraud,
10% attributable to the staffing sector,
then that's $100 to $300 million a year.
And it's gone under the radar
as part of what is now called the shadow economy.
We used to call it the underground economy
about 10 years ago.
And the shadow economy is an environment
where workers get assigned
to various and sundry places to work
and the real employer is in the shadows.
They have multiple identities,
they may be out of state,
there's no transparency,
and there's no accountability.
So the problem with staffing is that the staffing agencies,
the purported employers,
the actual who should be the real employers
are hiding their identities,
not paying their fair share,
and competing unfairly
with the legitimate staffing companies that do exist
and that do provide valuable service
at an appropriate price
for that 10% of our non-farm workforce.
From what you're saying,
a lot of Californians are getting employed
by these staffing agencies.
There are legitimate staffing agencies
that actually do the right thing,
they file the taxes,
they pay the workers' comp,
they're legitimate.
And then there is another category
of these staffing companies that don't pay taxes,
they don't pay for workers' comp,
and they're coming in and getting business at a lower cost.
They're competing unfairly,
they're absolutely taking advantage of the workers,
and they're lining their pockets
at the expense of the legitimate businesses.
In an environment where we wanna create a robust
and maintain a robust economy in California,
the last thing you need to do
is to permit this cheating to continue.
And the laws in California,
the employment laws are so complicated,
you might wanna as well just-
Well, in some ways, yes,
and in other ways,
workers' comp has been around since forever, right?
And the payroll taxes have existed for a long time,
and they're there generally to try to help workers
when they run into a difficult situation,
either disability or illness or unemployment, all of that.
None of those funds get paid by the cheating entities.
The legitimate entities have to pay
more than their fair share.
Their workers' comp costs are skyrocketing, why?
Because the legitimate people always pay for the cheaters.
So the staffing companies have gotten together
and have gotten legislation proposed called the SAFE Act
for Staffing Agency Fair Employment, pretty simple.
What it will do is create a registering requirement
for any staffing company in California.
So the legislation is designed to require
that staffing companies to do business in California
have to be registered.
They have to identify who the fiscally interested parties are
they have to identify where they do business,
they have to identify that they are financially sound,
and they have to identify who they are insured by.
They have to show proof
of legitimate workers' comp insurance.
Now, you are in the prosecution.
How come this is not getting tackled?
Because a lot of, in California,
if you don't follow the employment laws,
there's a lot of consequences,
but it seems like this is a huge loophole.
What are your thoughts on that?
Well, I think it is a loophole,
and I think that's exactly why
the legislation is so important.
It's not trying to change the general environment
except to legitimize the legitimate compliant businesses,
to give them credit,
to give employers the opportunity and the obligation
to check to make sure that the staffing company
that they're gonna do business with
is registered in California
so they don't end up victimizing the workers
as well as the businesses that needed the workers' help.
And ultimately, we are creating a more integrous,
a more honest, and a more transparent business environment
for staffing agencies throughout the state,
especially the legitimate ones.
You mentioned 1.9 million.
For people that may not know,
what percentage of this is,
I'm sure it's very hard to guess this,
what percentage is legitimate and what percentage is not?
It's because they're not registered
and because we don't know
who all the staffing agencies in California are,
and there's no real way to do that,
we can only use some smart
and selective deductions, right?
We know that staffing is 10% of the non-farm workforce.
We know that there are cases that have been reported
as recently as three months ago in Ventura County
where staffing on staffing was occurring,
which is another problem.
When a staffing company claims that it's the employer
and then it actually assigns its employees
to another staffing company,
it's essentially creating layers and layers
of impenetrable nonsense to hide what they're doing
and to frankly darken the shadow economy
in which they're operating
so they can avoid accountability and they leave
or they create a new entity or a new name
and they just reinvent themselves under a new name
and a new address somewhere else
or sometimes they even use the same address.
How come they don't get caught
when the people that are behind these agencies,
what are your thoughts?
Is it because of the laws?
What's the violation?
There's no requirement that you have to be registered
and the fact of the matter is it takes enormous resources
to prosecute or investigate fraud.
The whole idea of fraud is there's a lie at the core of it
but that core is buried inside a veritable knot.
Imagine like a big knot of yarn
with all different colors and all different strands
going in all different directions
and they create that chaos so they can't be detected
because they know it's gonna take too long
and it's gonna take too many resources
and at the end of the day, even if they get caught,
they probably spent all the money.
So what's the incentive to go after these cheaters
when you don't really know who they are,
you don't really know where they operate
and you don't expect that at the end of the day,
they're gonna have any resources
that you can collect for restitution?
So it's pretty typical of most fraud schemes.
The only difference is it puts workers
at a much greater peril because it's the workers
who are really being taken advantage of
and it is poisoning the work environment
for smaller businesses and for burgeoning businesses
because we're not tracking the staffing companies.
We should be rewarding the legitimate companies
and instead, they're being brutally burdened.
They're paying the costs and it's wildly unfair.
With your experience, Jennifer, in this space,
do you think this registration
and license would solve this problem?
I don't know that it will solve the problem
but it's an absolutely essential first step.
You have to know who it is that's responsible
for the employees who are being assigned to these jobs
and you have to know who is financially interested
because that's gonna identify who's making the decisions
and you have to know that they have to be insured
just like every other employer in California
and as you try to even the field
by preventing unnecessary
and difficult lack of accountability,
you're providing a way for us to know
who's working for whom and who's making the decisions
and who's profiting.
That's essential.
Every employer in California has to have workers
in comp insurance or be self-insured.
Why should staffing agencies be any different?
Jennifer Lentz Snyder, former prosecutor,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
It's been my pleasure, thank you so much.
Let us know what you think about the situation
with temp agencies.
Do you think they need to get regulated more or not?
Do you have a thought about how we can solve
the workers' comp fraud in California?
Make sure to email us at ciamacacaliforniansider.com
or comment.
We'll read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Ciamac, this is California Insider,
we'll see you next time.