TRƯỚC KHI CÓ THI CỬ QUAN LẠI ĐƯỢC CHỌN NHƯ THẾ NÀO?

I LOVE BINH DUONG
1.4K followers
#BLVHảiThanh #History #Examination
TRƯỚC KHI CÓ THI CỬ QUAN LẠI ĐƯỢC CHỌN NHƯ THẾ NÀO?
You know every exam season we always see the image of modern-day scholars sacrificing everything—staying up late studying nonstop—hoping to change their fate
But have you ever wondered how our ancestors chose an official before the blazing examination halls and sacred scholarly texts became the measure of merit
Just because someone is healthy or a royal descendant does that mean they all get appointed to high office Or is there some hidden force behind the scenes orchestrating it all
Today we’ll embark on a journey through time tracing dynasties from China to Đại Việt to uncover this story
Imagine you're in Vietnam during the Dinh Early Ly or early Ly dynasties—there's no concept of taking exams yet so how would you become an official
The quick answer is to check your household registration buddy
During this period the primary selection method was hereditary succession Though the term sounds academic it essentially meant father-to-son inheritance
If your father was a loyal minister who helped the king quell rebellions or a noble within the palace court
Congratulations—you're guaranteed a government position from the moment you're born
But why did those kings choose this
approach Simply put it was trust
In a society just emerging from a millennium of foreign domination the people's hearts were still unsettled and chaos prevailed everywhere
The king needs allies whose fortunes are closely tied to the survival of the dynasty
Who could be more trustworthy than one's own children who have shared the same trials and hardships
Yet this very loyalty also has its drawbacks
If the father is a brilliant general
but the son only enjoys cockfighting or drinking alcohol where will the state machinery be headed
That is why the later dynasties had to continually upgrade this system
By the later Lê and Nguyễn dynasties the hereditary system had evolved into a well-established tradition official privilege
But don't think that just being a bureaucrat guarantees a life of idle comfort and luxury
The Nguyễn dynasty imposed extremely strict regulations Only the children officials
ranked fourth grade and above were eligible Most
importantly the practice was completely abolished
These young scholars were required to pursue the path of Confucian scholars to continue their studies
Every three years the state conducts an assessment meaning a performance evaluation is carried out once
If you study hard you'd still only end up as a minor official at best
If you were truly capable you'd have advanced based on your own merits not by riding on the coat tails of your grandfather
To gain a clearer understanding of Vietnam we should also look to its neighbor China
After all it was they who gave birth to many highly intricate civil service examination systems
Before the Sui dynasty established the imperial examination system around the year 600
For hundreds of years China struggled with two systems: the surveillance officials and
the impartial civil service The surveillance official system originated during the Han dynasty
The court required local officials to be closely involved with the
people Here "sát" means personally observing the people's conditions
Whenever someone is known for filial piety—loving and respecting
their parents—and for integrity—free from greed—then recommend them
That sounds very humane doesn 't
it But life isn't a dream
The local tycoons have already started playing their game
Some people pretended to live in their parents' tomb for years to prove
their filial devotion others feigned poverty to demonstrate their integrity
As a result the most skilled performers rise to power while truly talented individuals are overlooked
Next came the mid-level official selection system during the Jin dynasty
This was a true catastrophe
The court sent an official known as the Central Justice to each region
to rank talents into recommended ranks also called the rank of ability
The criteria include lineage talent and moral integrity
Yet alas these upright officials are all still human beings
Everyone fears power once they're human
So they keep judging people based on their family background
Those born into wealth and prominent families are naturally ranked at the top considered superior
Even the most talented children from poor families are inevitably relegated to the lowest social class
Chinese history records a poignant saying from that era:
The noblest have no humble origins the lowest have noble lineage
In the upper echelons there are no traces of the poor
while in the lower strata the wealthy are completely absent
Society was deeply divided and that was also why the dynasties of this era collapsed so rapidly
The entire system is filled with useless well-connected elites
Recognizing the stagnation caused by hereditary rule the kings understood that to preserve
the nation they must appoint capable individuals rather than relying forever on relatives
And thus the imperial examination system was born In Vietnam the first exam
took place in 1075 during the reign of King Lý Nhân Tông
This is a great turning point For the first
time an ordinary person simply needs to diligently read books
Being a scholar meant one could ascend the pedestal of glory receive robes and headwear
from the king and be welcomed home by the entire village in celebration
But did you know just how spotless your background had
to be back then to even qualify for the competition
For example under the later Lê regulations you had to have good conduct and official
confirmation from the local community the following individuals were completely barred
They are people who lack understanding and moral
disorder those in mourning must first uphold filial duty
In particular those engaged in singing were known as "sướng ca vô loài " and their descendants were
also barred from taking examinations Under the
Nguyễn dynasty this restriction was further tightened
The brothel keepers jailers servants and sailors
Why such strictness
Since successive dynasties regarded officials as
parents to the people and the highest moral exemplars
How can someone with an unsavory past hope to win the trust of the people
Besides taking exams and being
a descendant
officials there is another way to become a government official: being recommended
For example you're a high-ranking official
and you notice a remarkably talented young man in your hometown
who's too poor to afford the exam fees
or perhaps he lacks practical military experience and
though he's not proficient in military classics either
You may speak to the king I hereby recommend this person
But wait recommending someone is not so simple
It comes with a law known as
sponsorship If you sponsor someone
you must put your honor and reputation on the line as guarantee
If that person performs well in the future you'll be rewarded
But if that person acts recklessly commits a crime
or is simply unsuitable yet you still recommend them
You will be punished with the same crime as
that person This law made ancient officials
break out in a cold sweat every time they tried to introduce someone
Consider it with the utmost care—there's no room
for reckless attachments not when
the cost is your entire career
even one's own head
Once the right person is hired
effectively utilizing that new hire is the pinnacle of management
There are two regulations
that promise to be extremely
interesting The first is
called "quán khứ nha tồn "
This is an excellent management philosophy Here "quan" refers to a
commander or leader those in
leadership must be decisive and resolute
That means constant rotation is required
But here in this house
the domestic staff and local secretaries remain
That is they are kept fixed in
place Why Because the official coming from the central
government to the local area is like a visitor unfamiliar with the local terrain
But the long-time officials were the ones who
truly knew every tree blade
of grass and household
The combination of a visionary thinker and a
pragmatic doer keeps the
machine running smoothly
The second regulation is known as the law of return
This is the law I admire the most
from our ancestors particularly from
during the reign of Emperor Minh Mang The term "hồi tị" means to avoid specifically prohibiting
one from holding office in their native hometown
to prevent favoritism and conflicts of interest
Avoid favoritism toward relatives you must not hold office in your wife's hometown to prevent factionalism
from her family Likewise
within the same organization you must not
There are two people who are brothers father and son and master and disciple
working together If you serve as an official in one
place for too long you must be transferred
Go somewhere else What's the purpose
To ensure the
official is completely independent with no ties or connections whatsoever to the local area
Only then can justice be
administered fairly and free from corruption
And as for the evaluation officials—do they get assessed or not
You think KPIs are a product
of the modern era Big mistake
Long ago there were KPIs too though they were called
inspection tours At regular intervals
usually once every three years the imperial court would
Send someone to inspect and evaluate each official individually They will
assess whether the people in that area
are living comfortably and prosperously
Was there a wrongful conviction
Were the taxes fully paid
The outcome of the audit will be decisive
Promotions meaning those who excel are advanced first Demotions meaning those who
perform poorly are moved down first Or
dismissal meaning they are fired immediately
Even if the inspector is afraid to report the truth when caught the inspector
will still face consequences
Being free from serious guilt doesn't constrain
This is precisely how the
system remains perpetually alert
You can see the recruitment process
and employing feudal officials was
not merely a matter of literacy
or credentials but a sophisticated system intricately combining
Morality is personal integrity competence
is academic merit responsibility is
appointment based on trust and oversight is
accountability the examination of performance
Although feudal society is far behind us principles such
as avoiding appointing relatives and ensuring
rewards match merit remain essential
so that people won't be tempted and penalties must be strict enough to
deter recklessness—these have always
been timeless invaluable principles
rough any era
I hope today's historical story has given you
a fresh and fascinating perspective
about how his grandson built the country
If you find this video helpful don't forget
to like share and spread the word
o support the channel But now
please don't say goodbye
