Misrepresentation Intent Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
8 Video Views·Mar 6, 2026
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
AI Generated·May contain errors
In this lesson we're going to continue talking about the concept of misrepresentation
in relation to the law of contracts and we're going to focus on this idea of misrepresentation
and intent. The idea of intentionally misrepresenting a certain factual matter of the
case which then obviously induces an individual to contract which then presents an ability for
voidability of a contract. So this is a continuation of our studies and an examination
of the concept of misrepresentation. We noted that misrepresentation is what is known as one
of the quote vitiating factors which can be said to void a contractual arrangement or even render
it voidable on the part of the parties that are agreed. We noted that voiding a contract, a
contract is void if it never existed in the first place, it had no legal implications, had no legal
concept attached to it. Voidability relates to the idea of it having the potential to be void
but is only if it is on the part of the agreed parties to allow it to be void. The previous
lesson we looked at the concept of opinion as not necessarily meeting the threshold of
constituting an actionable misrepresentation but if you remember we looked at the case where there
was the sale of a piece of land which allegedly could farm 2,000 sheep. Now given the fact that
this was a piece of land that had not ever farmed sheep it was considered that that statement was
not a factual representation and therefore a misrepresentation given the fact that it was false
rather it was an opinion. It was a reasoned opinion on the basis of the size of the land
and having no knowledge of how much land is required to farm sheep. In this lesson we're
going to talk about the future intent of the parties highlighting some case law on the matter.
So what do we mean here about future intent? Well the general rule when it comes to future
intentionality made by statements is that it cannot amount to actionable misrepresentation
and it's easy to see why this is the case when we think about what is required of misrepresentation.
One of the key requirements of misrepresentation is the view that it must be a statement of
material fact and we noted previously as I said that opinion does not constitute
a statement of material fact. A statement about the future intentionality of the parties however
also cannot be a statement of material fact owing to the nature of the statement as being a mere
speculation and therefore cannot represent any kind of statement of material fact. So if a
statement about the future intent by the parties is given and this is false then this cannot
represent actionable misrepresentation. However the exception to the general rule is that while
mere speculation about the future could not represent a material fact for the purposes of
actionable misrepresentation. If the party deliberately misrepresents their epistemic
foundations and if on this basis they will falsely represent their future in taste intention
then this can represent an exception to the general rule and therefore be actionable
misrepresentation. What do I mean by epistemic foundations? Well for those of you who are law
students and not philosophy students epistemology is the philosophy of knowledge. So your epistemic
foundations is the knowledge that you have and your the foundational knowledge that you have
about a particular thing. So what this is essentially telling us is if I misrepresent
the knowledge that I have about a particular situation and I do not communicate that
knowledge to the other party then this could represent false falsity and be falsely
misrepresentation and so as a result of which could actually render a statement or a contract
void avoidable. Let's think about how this actually is operational in practice and we can use the case
from 1885. Essentially what this case illustrates is the view that future intent this idea of
future intentionality can in some circumstances represent actionable misrepresentation. Now
what we think about here is that this is actually an exception to the rule. Remember this this is
the exception to the rule because future intent generally speaking does not represent actionable
misrepresentation but if it can have the ability to be a statement of fact then it could be
actionable misrepresentation if it is false of course. The case itself involves a number of
company directors who had collectively released statements on the basis of the prospectus of the
issuance of a bond. In reality however these prospectuses were fraudulent and that they were
based on false information and that they were based on false information for the purposes of
getting the purchase. So they did this false thing intentionally did this false thing for the
purposes of getting a purchase for the purposes of inducing contracting okay. They had informed
the purchaser that the bond revenue would be used for the building of a business expansion
when in reality they were going to use the revenue to settle company debts that they had
okay. So they falsely misrepresented what the use of this bond revenue would be for.
They said build a business expansion we're going to use this revenue for business expansion when
in reality they were going to settle debts for as a result. The claimant made the case this case
sorry the claimant in this case made it clear that he would not have purchased the bond
if he had been informed of the true nature and purchase purpose of the revenue from the purchase
of that bond and as such he made the claim that the statements made to him were actionable
misrepresentation. So this is a statement of future intent a future intent as to what they're going to
do with the revenue okay it is a false statement of future intent. However according to the
application of the ordinary rule a statement of future intent does not represent actionable
misrepresentation. So on the general rule it would essentially represent speculation rather than
material fact because you cannot know for as a material fact whether what that money is going
to be used for in the future. However the court held that it was more than just a statement of
material future intention because it was an untrue statement of future intention and so as a result
of this the person who purchased the bonds the claimant were induced into the contract on the
basis of false pretenses for a false statement of future intention and that this could therefore
fall into the category of actionable misrepresentation and so as a result of which
would represent an exception to the rule in relation to future intentionality.
