🔴 [Interview+] No YT ads. Bonus Part. FREE for everyone https://www.patreon.com/posts/152001833/ The heart of the Milky Way is full of dust. This makes it super hard to observe. Fortunately, we have great tools like ALMA and JWST at our disposal which came together to image this really cool region. Finding out, what did they find there.
00:00 Intro 01:28 Central molecular cloud 06:50 Observations with ALMA 16:54 Observations with Webb 22:45 The role of the SMBH 24:19 What comes next 29:41 Searching for salt in the Universe 38:03 Current obsessions
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
I continue to be obsessed by the center of the Milky Way.
You've got this region where stars are packed as densely as like a globular star
cluster. Just imagine what it would look like to be at the center of the Milky Way.
And yet there's a lot of really weird stuff happening.
You've got giant clouds of molecular gas that block your view like a fog.
You've got regions of star formation, in some cases more active than any other
place in the local group obscured at the center of the Milky Way.
There are many mysteries, but fortunately, there are many tools that we have at our
disposal to be able to peer through that.
One of these is ALMA, the Atacama Large Millimeter Ray.
The other is James Webb.
And with those together, astronomers are piecing together and puzzling out what's
down there at the center of the Milky Way.
My guest today is Dr.
Adam Ginsberg. He's an associate professor at the University of Florida and a
co-principal investigator of the ACES Collaboration.
And this is a team of astronomers who are gathering data on the center of the Milky
Way to give us these incredible images of this very poorly understood region.
And understanding how the center of the Milky Way operates will give us answers
about how material joined the supermassive black hole that is in the region.
What is it like at the centers of other galaxies that are out there?
So if you're fascinated by this region as much as I am, I think you'll enjoy this
conversation with Dr.
Adam Ginsberg. Adam, it's good to see you again.
So I I'm kind of obsessed with the central molecular zone.
And there's a bunch of reasons we'll probably get into in this conversation.
But transport us there to the center of the Milky Way.
If we could sort of reappear, disappear here and reappear somewhere close to the
center of the Milky Way, how would our perspective of the galaxy around us change?
Right. So the center of our galaxy is totally different from our solar neighborhood in
that instead of there being a star every parsec and change around, there's something
like a thousand stars per cubic parsec.
So we'd have a lot of much closer neighbors.
There'd be a lot of stars around us.
But depending on exactly where you are in the center, you might have a very bright sky
if you're in a nice dust free zone, or you might have a completely dark sky because
you're in the middle of an extremely dark cloud, darker than almost any of the clouds
in within a few hundred parsecs of the sun.
And I'm going to say parsecs instead of light years, just parsecs, three light years,
give or take. Yeah. Yeah.
Multiply by three, everybody.
You can't you can't help it.
You're going to probably consider anything heavier than than helium to be metal as
well. And we're just going to roll with that.
But like I think about what it would be like to be in a globular cluster where you've
got probably stars within one light year on average of you.
Is it even more dense than that?
Like. No.
So like the center of a globular cluster is denser than the center of our galaxy as a
whole. Until you get to like the central parsec of our galaxy, you're starting to get
to those densities. The difference is in a globular cluster, you know, OK, a globular
cluster today, if you transport it to the middle of one of those, you're surrounded by a
bunch of stars that are less massive than the sun.
They're less luminous in the sun.
They're wimpy. Plus, maybe a couple of red giants that are things that are evolving
off the main sequence in the galactic center.
You have those stars.
You have the 11 or 10 billion year old population, which is most of the stars.
But you also are surrounded by a young population of very luminous UV emitting stars
that are just spread all over the place.
So that's different.
And, you know, the sort of the classic thing about the center of the Milky Way is that
you have the zone of avoidance.
You have this region which you are really not allowed to point your visible light
telescopes into because there's nothing to see.
You've just got dark clouds of molecular hydrogen that are blocking your view.
You've got it's everything is obscured.
But if you were in there, you know, you talked about this idea that you might be
surrounded by stars, but you're not going to see any.
Would you see kind of like swirls of this of this gas and dust around you?
Yeah. Again, depends on where you are.
Like in the darkest places, you'll just actually be surrounded by darkness.
But in a fog, yeah, there are going to be places around where there will be these
wispy, very bright things.
So, you know, the closest thing we could imagine is if you look, you can actually see
through an eyepiece on a telescope, the Orion Nebula.
It'd be kind of like being surrounded by Orion Nebula stuff everywhere.
There'd just be that's all over the sky.
At least that's sort of the first thing we know.
But there are some things that are just truly different.
You know, so one of the things you've highlighted previously is the meerkat images
of the Galactic Center and some of the ones that we're going to talk about are show
these filamentary structures, these wispy things that are spread throughout the
Galactic Center. Now, as far as I understand it, these are they're they're ephemeral.
They're, you know, closer to the aurora than to they're not going to form stars.
They're not going to form any lasting thing.
They sort of trace where a magnetic field is and where some particles have been
injected into it. We'd be surrounded by that in all different directions.
And, you know, we we see from our eight kiloparsec away vantage point.
So really, really far away.
Well, we see the brightest of these, but they're they're probably also spread
throughout the medium. And so if you're sitting inside, you know, maybe you're
sitting inside a nebula, you see a lot of these linear features getting sparkling all
over the place. And I guess the reverse would be true.
We can't look into the center of the Milky Way with invisible light, but you
wouldn't be able to look out like you wouldn't see other galaxies.
You would just see walls of gas and dust.
You know, that's an interesting point.
That probably is not the case because you could still look up and down.
Now, if you're inside a dark cloud, totally fine.
You can't see anything. But if you're in one of these lit up places, there might be
some foreground in front of you. But this is sort of wispy, thin stuff you can see
through it. And so if you're looking out of the plane of the galaxy,
we think there's actually not much there.
There's there's plenty of just open volume above.
What we actually know is that there we have a lot of signs that our galaxy, our
galactic center is producing a giant outflow.
So there are things, you know, the Fermi bubbles and the Rosetta also discovered
some some X-ray bubbles that are a little bit smaller and a little bit higher
energy. But these all point back to an outflow being driven from roughly within
the central hundred parsecs. Now, there still remains controversy about is it
driven by feedback, by supernovae, a lot of supernovae blowing up or is it
essential black hole? But whichever it is, it creates this relative vacuum above
and below the galactic plane.
So you would actually be able to see, I think, maybe even have a clear advantage.
Well, huh. But you'd have like a you'd have a donut of avoidance around you as
opposed to that. You would add that.
Yeah. OK, so then let's talk about your research, because you and your
collaborators just released a paper.
We got some really cool pictures from the the European Southern Observatory.
So what were you guys doing?
OK, so we went with the ALMA telescope, so the Atacama Large Millimeter
Submillimeter Array, which is a joint project between the US, Europe and Japan
and Chile. And we wanted to map out as much of the galactic center as we could.
There are just a ton of different questions that you can really only ask in
the galactic center by looking at these long wavelengths because then you get to
see through and see stuff there.
And all the previous observations that had happened at these wavelengths.
So basically between, say, 24 microns, that's kind of where Spitzer stopped
working, all the way out into the radio at like, call it five centimeters with
the VLA and, you know, more recently, Meerkat.
But at the time we started this, Meerkat hadn't taken these images.
Anywhere between those wavelengths, the best resolution we'd ever got was
something like 10 arc seconds.
And 10 arc seconds is not so great, you know, if you're observing from the
ground, from your backyard telescope, you'll probably have one arc second
seeing. And the optical telescopes, the best, if you're lucky, you'll have one
arc second seeing. If you're observing from Florida, it's more like three or
five arc seconds. You know, that's what you get from being at sea level.
So with that, you know, one arc second, you resolve stars pretty well.
Modern telescopes with adaptive optics can readily get down to a sub arc
second and sometimes down to 0.1 arc seconds.
And Webb is getting below 0.1 arc seconds, a lot of wavelengths.
But OK, we were kind of sitting on this 10 arc second data.
That means a lot of things were blurred together.
We couldn't resolve individual sources that well.
I left a lot of questions open.
So we wanted to go in there and just get, I mean, really get better resolution.
Well, then, OK, better resolution on what, though, is the next question is, what
are we actually seeing when we look with ALMA and a bunch of different things?
One is we see dust in a mission.
And I can explain why.
I'll explain why dust is important, because that's like the main thing.
Yeah, we we have a sort of a relationship with dust here on this channel.
But yeah. Yeah, exactly.
Well, yeah. So astronomers should have a love-hate relationship with dust,
depending on what wavelength they operate in.
I'm on the love side. Oh, good.
Dust is my glowing source.
That's what I want to find.
And so we see dust.
We also see plasma emitting.
So there's like hot plasma.
And that can emit in two different ways.
You can have free, free emission, which is like two particles pass each other
and accelerate and produce radiation.
That's free, free emission.
We see a lot of that.
And we may see, but we're not really sure about it, synchrotron,
which is from particles looping around magnetic fields.
So those are three continuum processes.
We say continuum because they don't produce sharp lines.
But the other thing that we were able to do with ALMA and that radio telescopes
are particularly powerful at doing is doing Doppler observations of spectral lines.
And so we targeted several spectral lines from particular molecules.
And we picked some that we knew were optimal for the galactic center.
We had a lot of questions that we wanted to answer.
So like the big questions are like really, really big questions.
How does stuff get in from the galaxy
to the galactic center to the black hole?
We're trying to answer that question.
How does gas get into the black hole?
Because we know that black holes grow.
We know that black holes accrete.
We know that ours is not doing so much right now.
But it's at four, ten to the six, four million solar masses.
So it had to have grown quite a bit.
Well, we think it has grown.
It didn't just start at that mass.
So how does it get that?
How do black holes get that?
That's one side of the question.
Then we have some big questions about how does star formation work?
So listeners to your channel have heard that star formation
in the galactic center is less than expected,
given how much dense gas we see there.
And we're trying to figure out why that is.
Why does gas get dense without forming stars in the galactic center?
And yeah.
And is it like is an issue of the temperature?
Like I know that the temperature of the gas sort of will define
whether or not the cloud is willing to collapse into into a star.
So do you have like the right temperature gas
and yet not the levels of star formation that you're hoping for?
That's really the question that we're trying to get at.
Is it just the temperature?
So the temperature creates thermal pressure
and thermal pressure always fights against gravity.
So thermal pressure is always a supporting force.
But even though the temperature is higher in the galactic center,
we see molecular gas being 50 Kelvin instead of 20 Kelvin.
So a little bit warm.
You know, it's still well, well, well below
anything you would ever hope to experience.
Liquid nitrogen evaporates at 70 Kelvin, if I remember right.
So, you know, these are really, really cold temperatures.
It's those temperatures are high for higher than other dark clouds near us.
It's still not enough to really suppress star formation and really hold it back.
So we think that there are other effects in play.
But we we still have not fully answered that question.
We've taken the data.
We've started analyzing it.
But answering that question, we actually have to go in
and now figure out what all the sources are.
So we found sources.
We found objects.
We have to figure out what they are.
And we're in that process.
We also have to measure the gas and see how is it moving
when we resolve it really well.
That was one of the key science goals is when you see these big blurry
things moving, you can say, OK, it has a lot of velocity inside.
It's moving fast.
That that could be as moving fast outward, which would explain
why it's not star forming.
If it's if the all the gas is moving away from the other gas.
OK, fine.
Something is causing it to move outward.
If it's moving inward, then that should form stars.
So we should got to figure that out.
And so we're sort of figuring out what happens as we go from large
scales to small scales.
So it is the key question for mapping the gas kinematics.
So kinematics is motion of the gas.
And so so with it, you know, I urge people to look at the images.
And, you know, if you're listening to some podcast, I'm sorry,
because there's some really cool pictures here.
But if you look at the images that were released as part of the European
Southern Observatory, you get these sort of images in different
I guess the different molecules or the different chemical fingerprints
for what you're seeing, the carbon monoxides and the silicon oxide
and the different kinds of chemicals that are that are there.
What does that what does that tell you?
What are you looking for?
Like, are there chemicals that are going to be present to show you
that star forming is happening in a certain kind of way?
What is the what are the clues you think you'll get from this
kind of spectral signature?
OK, so we picked a few different lines, spectral lines
very intentionally and got some others
less intentionally is that we had to pick a way band
and we knew anyway, but we look at we're going to get some molecules in it.
And so we tried to tune it to pick ones we liked.
But, you know, some of it was just luck of the draw.
So some of the molecules like HNCO
and HCO plus, we put really, really high spectral resolution on.
So we can see motions.
We can resolve motions of about 100 meters per second in those molecules.
And we pick those because they kind of trace in the galactic center.
They serve the role of showing us where all the gas is, we think.
So you said you mentioned CO, carbon monoxide.
That's our most common tool for measuring where gas is
and how gas is moving in the galaxy in the galactic center.
There is too much CO, so it's totally optically thick.
We can't use it for kinematics.
It's just it's it's just too confused.
So we gave up on we just knew that that was going to be a problem.
We gave up on carbon monoxide and went to these slightly
less abundant molecules that still basically trace the bulk gas.
Right. Because I know like carbon monoxide is sort of like your tracer gas
for star formation, finding clouds of hydrogen that they're hard to find.
But the but the carbon monoxide is there.
And you think there's too much yet to switch to something else.
That's right.
And, you know, so one of the classical things in the last few decades
is that while carbon monoxide is the best tracer of molecular gas,
it's actually not that good a tracer of star formation.
Other molecules like HDN and HCl plus are in most cases
good tracers of star formation.
But in the galactic center, it's not working out that way.
Instead, it's like, well, we went to the next best tracer,
the tracer denser gas, yet it's still showing us gas
that's mostly not star forming.
And so we're trying to figure that out.
But OK, we picked the bulk tracers to try to get us the gas motion.
That was the first thing.
There are a couple other molecules we picked that sort of are serving
the same role of showing us where all the gas is.
And we're trying to figure out, well, they don't all look the same.
They look subtly different.
We don't understand exactly why yet.
And that's one of the things we want to pick out.
But then there are some other molecules that are like complex molecules,
so complex organic molecules to an astronomer.
A complex molecule has more than five atoms in it.
So methanol, so CH3OH, that's a complex molecule.
And everything with more letters than that is complex.
So methanol, very common.
We have a few lines of methanol.
We also have methyl formate and dimethyl ether.
You don't really need to know what these molecules are.
You just need to know they've got methyl groups on them.
They're complex.
Those show up in a smaller set of regions and they do trace.
Those we think are now only showing us where there is ongoing star formation.
And in particular, it's high mass stars that are forming stars that produce
enough heat while they're forming to cook the dust grains around them
and release those complex molecules into the gas phase.
So it's like biosignatures.
You guys found a chemical fingerprint for star formation
that you can reliably use to track.
The astrobiologists wish they could do the same.
Yes, and unfortunately, high mass stars are making all the molecules
that you would want to use as biosignatures.
They're all out there and confusing things for you.
Yeah. So so that is the work that you did with ALMA, but you also used Webb.
Yeah. So with ALMA, we met this huge area.
What is now a huge area for us, it's like a degree wide by 0.2 degrees tall.
That's a huge, huge area for ALMA.
With Webb, Webb is also not a super mapping machine.
It is. It does small fields.
It's bigger than sort of more area than ALMA per pointing,
but it's just as hard to map.
And we've been looking at a couple of sites in the galactic center
with the same general goal of trying to figure out
where the stars are forming and how they're forming.
So previously we've talked about the brick.
That's a non star forming cloud that is very dark.
We also recently got data on the cloud that is forming stars
and is really just absolute.
It's the most star forming cloud in our galaxy.
Maybe the most star forming cloud in the local group today called Sagittarius B2.
It is extremely dusty.
It is also extremely dark.
But with Webb, we go into far enough into the infrared
that we can actually see all the way down to even the most deeply embedded.
So like more than the Tarantula Nebula.
Well, yeah. So the Tarantula Nebula is actually a bigger site
of recently formed stars, but it's kind of done forming stars.
Those stars are very young.
They're, you know, a million years old.
But the gas is gone right in the LMC.
So the Large Magellanic Cloud Tarantula Nebula is in there.
The 30 Doradus is where we're going to hold on.
Tarantula is 30 Doradus, right?
Or am I? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Good.
Just want to make sure.
There's also another one in M33 that I confuse sometimes.
Yeah, there's a there's a furious star for me
with a lot of like super like A and B stars in the M33.
I forget the name of it, though.
Yeah, I know I get these two confused sometimes when we talk about
the colloquial name, but I know 30 Doradus, I know.
And the cluster is like R136A is one of the big stars in the Tarantula.
Yes. And so R136 is this really massive cluster.
It may have stars up to 200 solar masses in it.
Sagittarius B2 is kind of an analog to well, so Sagittarius B2 M and N.
So they're just called M for middle and N for north.
You know, we're very clever in radio astronomy about how we name things.
Those are two sites where clusters of stars are forming
and they're roughly analogous in mass scale.
So they might be basically forming R136 ish things.
So there could be a site,
you know, they might not be quite as massive as that,
but it is those stars are still forming.
This this is new to me.
Like, I had no idea that there were stars,
that there's this much star formation going on inside the heart of the Milky Way.
Oh, yeah. And it's only this one site.
This is the interesting thing.
So the ACES survey, we surveyed 100 parsecs around the galactic center.
And in that footprint, roughly half of all the star formation
is happening in this like two parsec region called Sagittarius B2.
So we're within the Sagittarius B2 cloud.
Maybe we go up to 10 parsecs there.
But it's a very tiny fraction of the volume accounts
for most of the star formation. Wow.
And again, like I think to give that context,
like we think about things like the Orion Nebula,
like so much bigger than that.
And you've got this just this much star formation going on
in this tiny little area close to a supermassive black hole.
Right. So, yeah, the Orion, we can actually done the fun exercise.
What would happen if you looked at the Orion Nebula
at the distance of the galactic center?
And you'd be able to see it in Sagittarius B2.
It would look like one among 30 different H2 regions.
So H2 regions of the ionized gas produced by the massive stars.
You could see it there.
You'd be able to detect it with with Alma or with Meerkat.
And it would just show up as one of these kind of
unremarkable blobs among dozens of others.
It's interesting to me.
This sounds like weirdly analogous
to the dark ages of the universe, this sort of attempt to try and see the
the population three stars at the beginning of the universe,
which are shrouded by clouds of gas at the same time,
sort of similar challenge, totally different epoch in the universe, though.
Yeah. So the challenge with POP three stars is just that they're so far away.
The advantage that we have with them is there's no dust blocking the path.
So sunlight would get through in theory.
The the but the analogy is actually good here in that
if this is a site where, you know, this super, super dense
gas is forming very massive stars, it's a it's a fairly rare event
in the local universe, but it was very common in the early universe.
You know, Webb is looking back
and seeing the times when globular clusters were forming.
If you look at these high redshift galaxies, not the ones of redshift ten.
They kind of just look there.
It looks like little dots, right?
The ones that redshift four with Webb, you see all these specks around the galaxies.
Those are globular clusters that have just recently formed.
And the Sagittarius B2 region is our closest analog to those.
It's reaching the same mass scale, the same kind of star formation rate.
And so, you know, that's one of the angles we're pursuing is, well,
maybe the stuff that's happening here in our galactic center
can tell us about the physics of what's happening
way back then when most stars were forming
because the conditions are so much denser, hotter.
Just everything is more active in those small zones.
Huh. Yeah. But probably not how we get globular clusters.
Not exactly, but it might be like so.
The only reason we well, the main reason we don't have globular clusters
in the disk of our galaxy, arguably they're not quite old enough.
But if a globular cluster did form in the disk of our galaxy,
and they probably they did, they get torn up.
Whereas the ones that go above the halo are orbiting perpendicular.
They get to live the age of the universe.
They don't get destroyed.
So probably globular clusters or things of the size
the globular cluster did form in the Milky Way disk.
But they didn't survive till today.
They got shredded. Right, right.
And so, I mean, you are not specifically looking at the supermassive
black hole at the heart of the Milky Way, but it, you know, plays a role.
What sort of influence do you think it has on on on the regions around
that you're looking at?
So currently, what I think is that has only a very indirect role
in that we can it helps us see them.
Sometimes you can see X-ray echoes off of the molecular clouds.
So when when Sag A star or black hole accretes a little bit, it lights up
and X-rays bounces those X-rays off the clouds and we can see them.
But it's not changing their dynamics much.
It's not heating them very much.
It's having only these very indirect effects.
And even the gravity, even though four million solar mass black holes,
that's a very big blob of gravity.
But once you get about 10 parsecs away from it,
the cluster that is orbiting Sag A star actually is dominant.
There's there's more mass in the cluster than the black hole
when you get only a few parsecs away.
And so what actually matters is the the nuclear stellar disk
and the nuclear stellar cluster.
So the stars still are the dominant source of mass in this inner hundred parsecs.
The stellar gravity, the gravity from the stars is the most important thing
for influencing how the gas behaves and how new stars form.
So, yeah, like that, but this is one of the fundamental arguments
in galaxy evolution is, are the black holes really important or not?
In our galaxy right now, the answer is not.
Look back in time, it gets more controversial.
But we won't speculate about that anymore right now.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So so what comes next then?
I mean, you know, you guys have been sort of releasing
sort of new piles of papers,
which I've been following and sort of new updates on what's happening in this
in the central molecular zone.
But you have a lot of questions still.
So what comes to us both in terms of observations and
and the kinds of answers that you're looking for?
Yeah. So the first thing like immediately what's happening now
is we're analyzing the data.
We're we're taking that raw data, which we turn into images.
We have the images now.
Now we're doing the next step of trying to fit models to the data,
try to figure out what each source is classifying things.
So that's sort of normal work.
So we can figure out how many stars are actually forming in the galactic center.
We have a lot of estimates, but these estimates still are informed
by the low resolution data.
So with the high resolution data, we want to do better.
High resolution and better coverage.
So CMZoom, the previous survey had the same similar resolution,
but less sensitivity, less coverage.
So that's like the first thing we're going to do.
And hopefully the science results that are going to come out of that
are just where is star formation actually happening
and how is the gas moving around to enable or prevent that?
That's with, you know, with the ACES data as we have them now.
There are a couple of different directions in the future we're looking at.
And one, of course, is higher resolution.
So with ALMA, it's an interferometer.
It can go to longer baseline.
So we can look at selected regions at higher resolution.
And we're, of course, in the process of doing that.
It is also a very flexible telescope
in that it covers a large, large range of frequency space.
So we picked the three millimeter window,
which was for a number of good reasons that we optimized for that.
We can go to lower frequencies.
There's a a seven millimeter window that ALMA has just very recently opened.
It actually only became available about two years ago.
So that's one we can we can do.
We can also go to higher frequencies.
But the lower the frequency, the more area we can map out roughly.
So there's a lot more to do with ALMA.
And then like that's talking, you know, the couple of your time scale
five ish years from now, roughly almost going to undergo an upgrade.
It's called the Wideband Sensitivity Upgrade,
which is basically they're going to replace the electronics on ALMA.
They have to because the electronics are now out of date when they're doing that.
What they do is they increase the bandwidth of the instrument.
So that means with ACES, what we did is we observed a couple windows.
We targeted a few lines
and we got whatever sensitivity we could from them.
With the upgrade, we're going to be able to do is cover
the entire observable window basically in one shot.
So we could repeat and it would be very valuable actually to repeat the ACES
survey just with about ten times more bandwidth
covering all the spectral lines, getting a ton more sensitivity.
We would see like it would it would be another complete game changer.
And so you're going to see that coming along with ALMA
in not too long.
That's like that's sort of pretty much definitely going to happen
because they have to do. Yeah.
I mean, one of the things that I see when we saw the first images
from Meerkat of the center of the Milky Way, it was like for the first time
that I had seen a radio wave image that looked like the kind of picture
you would see from a visible light telescope or infrared telescope.
It looked like a picture.
And, you know, most of the time you see these sort of really blobby
radio results because, you know, they just don't have a lot of pixels.
But we're moving into this regime now where they do have a lot of pixels.
And I think about what's coming with, say, the square kilometer array
that you're just going to that it's going to come.
It's going to join the rest of the telescopes in this way
of producing images in this radio wavelength.
We just can't see with our eyes.
And yet, in a way that makes them so much more accessible and interesting.
You know, I always feel like, oh, I want to include a picture
from a radio telescope, but people are going to find it very boring.
It's not as pretty as a picture from James Webb.
But radio telescopes are getting there now.
So I'll say I've always also felt the same way.
That's that was a lot of what motivated me
to start working on the Galactic Center originally, is that
part of what you said is true, that like radio images just look kind of boring,
except when you look at the Galactic Center.
And so even the VLA images of the Galactic Center
looks pretty awesome 20 years ago.
And part of that is just there's more signal.
There are just there's a lot more to see when you look in the radio
and it just keeps getting better, right?
Like part of what you're going to see when we increase the bandwidth
is going to take all day.
OK, we have a noise floor.
You can see some noise in the images we tried to show.
I try to show it.
So, you know, where there's real stuff and there's not real stuff.
But every time we upgrade the instrument, that noise floor gets lower
and you get a higher and higher dynamic range and it starts to be like,
oh, no, that black background, that's really there's nothing there.
Not there's just noise.
So that like that's the exciting thing is that, well, at some point
we hit what's called the confusion limit.
We actually detect something in every pixel.
With ALMA, we're not really at risk of that for a while.
With Webb and Roman, we are.
So the ground sorry, the infrared telescopes do hit that limit
rather than the the sort of black sky.
I like that term, the confusion limit that you you're essentially
it's hard to even observe any more detail
because there's something in every pixel at this.
That's right.
Yeah, yeah.
There's a star or many in every pixel.
Right, right, right.
Well, I want to shift gears and talk about your work
searching for salt in the universe.
Right. OK, so this is a completely different topic
that started in a different location, actually in Orion.
So picture behind me here there.
That is that's the trapezium right in the Orion
right in the center of the Orion Nebula.
Behind the Orion Nebula is this orange blobby thing
called the BNKL region.
So that's not a very exciting name.
They're named after people who first observed them in the late 60s.
They're infrared detected things.
And what this thing at the BNKL Nebula is a site of an explosion.
There's an explosion there that we seem like they're hydrant.
We looked at the center of that thing with ALMA
for not entirely the right reasons.
But what we ended up finding was a disk, an edge on disk.
And we found that that disk was glowing in some weird molecules.
And it turned out that they were salt.
So we found salt, NACL, KCL and another molecule.
It's not really a salt, but related aluminum oxide, ALO.
So these molecules are unique in that they are
they're more refractory than other molecules like in
if you're talking to somebody who studies the solar system,
they're not refractory.
But if you study and talk to astronomers, generally, they kind of are.
These are things.
So refractory means they like to be in the solid phase, not in the gas phase.
They've got very high evaporation temperatures.
So in most of the interstellar medium,
salt or sodium is mostly either in the solid phase
in things like salt on dust grains or it's in the atomic phase
because it's just the dust grains have been destroyed.
And at least that's roughly what we think.
So, OK, we found salt.
We didn't we didn't really entirely know why it was there.
And we still don't completely understand why we're seeing salt emission there.
What we can what we do know is it's very rare.
You don't see NACL or KCL under very many conditions.
In this case, it was tracing a disk.
So we found that.
Then we said, OK, well, if we found it in one disk around a high mass star,
let's see if we can find around others.
And we did.
There are a handful of about 10 sources, plus or minus a few
that we know have salt in disks orbiting relatively massive stars.
The lowest mass star we think
has a salt disk around is about six solar masses.
And the most massive one is about 40.
Now, when you say disk like like an accretion disk, like a Kuiper belt,
like a leftover planetary disk accretion disk, these are
they're relatively massive.
Well, they're massive disks in the sense of like they're they're maybe 0.1.
The one we measured is 0.1 to 0.5 solar masses.
So that's pretty big on some scales.
But remember, the star that it's around is 10 solar masses.
So it's not a very these are disks that are there.
There are a significant fraction of the star's mass,
but they're not big enough to grow the star double its size. Right. Right.
But like the story, I just don't understand here.
So this is a star that that is in the main sequence phase of its life.
It is several times the mass of the sun
and yet has formed a disk around it, not the protoplanetary disk,
but some other disk.
We think this is the protoplanetary disk.
This is leftover from the protoplanetary disk. OK, well, yeah.
So this is still the disk around forming young stars.
So all the ones we found are disks embedded in dense gas regions.
Now, it is interesting.
You said these are main sequence stars.
You're probably you might be right about that.
We actually because massive stars start are on the main sequence
while still accreting.
We don't know for sure what their spectral types are,
but actually it looks like they might be accreting fast enough.
They're accreting enough material that they're still pre-main sequence,
even though they're they're very massive.
So these are massive stars, but they're still they're still accreting.
They still have accreting disks around them.
They haven't blown out their surroundings yet.
So this is the very rare phase in our galaxy.
There are only a few hundred
massive stars forming in the galaxy at any given moment.
And we're looking at a reasonable sample of them.
So that that's the really cool thing is that we can see them actually orbiting.
We see the salt molecules are directly tracing the orbital motion of the disk,
and they don't seem to be coming from anything else.
This is not a thing that you see in lower mass stars,
stars like the sun or, you know, smaller protoplanetary disks.
Some of my favorite images are these these protoplanetary disks taken by ALMA.
We're seeing them at different orientations.
It looks like little galaxies.
And and you're seeing this kind of cut off on a on a mass regime
for these salt disks around them.
Yeah, that is that is right now.
Right now, we're I'm not 100 percent sure whether that is a sensitivity limit
or an actual physical limitation.
So the area in that's producing the salt emission is a few hundred Kelvin.
And to get to temperatures that high around a solar mass star,
you'd have to look into, you know, an AU, right?
So the orbit, the distance from the Earth to the sun,
you have to look at roughly that size scale to see temperatures that high.
And even with ALMA, when you look at pictures of HL Tau
and these beautiful disk images, that central
several astronomical units, you see a mission there,
but it's optically thick.
The dust is actually thick enough that we can't we can't see in there.
So it is possible there actually is some salt emission
coming from the very inner disk where it gets hot enough.
And we just haven't been able to pick it out.
But nobody this is something where nobody has looked with
quite enough sensitivity yet.
But it's it.
So I'm really curious about that myself.
I would love to know, you know, to actually go in and make the measurement
and see if it's there.
It's quite challenging, though, because the sensitivity becomes a real issue.
But I guess that, you know, we know that there are planets
around these these massive stars as well.
And you would think that the creatures around it
is going to scale up to the mass of the star, the big star, big disk.
And that if you have a smaller star, smaller disk,
and maybe if there is that salt ring around the star,
that it's so close into the star that you just can't pick it up with ALMA.
So does that next generation ALMA get you what you need?
Maybe. Next generation ALMA might do it.
Next generation VLA might also be the thing to do it,
because with the VLA, you go to longer wavelengths
where dust becomes less opaque still.
But the convenient thing about the salts, salt, NACL and KCL,
they both have emission lines that are at these lower frequencies
where, you know, a lot of molecules like CO's lowest frequency transition
is at 115 gigahertz.
ALMA can do it, but the VLA.
Well, actually, NGVLA might be able to do it just barely.
But like you can't go to longer wavelength with CO.
There just aren't any more longer wavelength transitions.
With salts, there are.
So that also gives me some hope that it is actually a tool
that we will be using more regularly in the future.
So, I mean, obviously, I'm thinking about oceans, right?
Do we think that there's some kind of connection that maybe that
that there's like, is this a a fingerprint?
Does this give you any connection to maybe where the water on Earth
came from and maybe associated chemicals like that?
Or is it just a completely different
presence of salt in the in the in the presence of this of this star?
I would love to make that connection.
I don't know.
I mean, we do see actual we see water kind of in the same place as salt,
but it's more that the water we see in these high mass
are from reading the stuff that's flowing out.
So we know that salt and water both exist in the interstellar medium.
OK, can you form a beach out of that?
Let's let's play. Right.
But I wonder if, you know, again, with the carbon dioxide being used
to help find regions of molecular hydrogen, I wonder if there's
some kind of connection between the presence of the salt
and the presence of the water, if there's some connection between this.
But yeah, right now I'm going to say, I don't know.
You know, yeah, you probably have the same thoughts.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Totally. Very interesting.
Well, the question that I always like to ask my guests,
and this is fairly recent, it's been a while since we've talked.
So I want to know what you're obsessed with right now.
So always higher resolution, better images.
So like I'm spending a lot of time staring at JWT images
and trying to figure out what they tell us.
I've been particularly with Webb looking at ices and what they're telling.
But, you know, the next big thing is always something on my mind.
And what's coming up soon in the end of this year is the Roman Observatory.
And you'll find many astronomers this month are focused on that
because there is a proposal deadline on March 27th.
And we're focused on that.
So I'm looking at, well, what can we learn about the galactic center with Roman?
And really that for me, that's going to be about figuring out
what the distance is to all of these different blobs of gas along our line of sight.
Where actually are all those things?
That's what I it's really been on my mind.
That's interesting.
So like I know Roman has its infrared field of view and sort of one of its big jobs
is to map out the the regions of the large scale structure of the universe
to look for these kind of clumpings of galaxy clusters and so on using infrared.
So you're sort of doing a scaled down version of that inside the Milky Way itself.
Yeah. So, you know, the center of our galaxy, you were calling it the zone of avoidance.
It is pretty optical.
But once you get into the infrared, oh, my God, it's all stars.
And, you know, we have what is a ten of the nine,
ten of the ten stars within the galactic, the inner bulge.
They're all crammed into the small area.
Previous, you know, telescopes with Boris resolution can't do much.
Do you hit that confusion limit very quickly?
Roman is is really just custom built for.
Well, it's not custom built for this, but it's perfect for this.
It can resolve the stars very, very well.
It's going to stare at part of the bulge just to study the stars
and going to stare at the inner midplane of the galactic disk,
right where we've been talking about to study the stars and the gas and how they interact.
Yeah, it's going to we're going to have more stars than we know.
Well, actually, we know exactly what to do with them.
There will be a lot of study them, study them to death.
But does this get us the great attractor?
Right. So actually, you might have to remind me what that is,
that there's a thing that, you know, the mass, the over density of mass
on the far side of the Milky Way.
And it's made it blocked by the zone avoidance.
And it is made up of galaxies.
You know, the Atlantic supercluster, all of these sort of larger structures.
Many of them are hidden.
You need infrared telescopes to be able to peer through.
And and astronomers have been mapping this out.
They've been using James Webb and using other telescopes to to pick out
and actually start to catalog the the galaxies that are on the other side
of the Milky Way.
But I sort of think about, you know, Romans going to do these really detailed
surveys both above and below the the Milky Way.
But but stare right through it, hopefully can pick out
as many galaxies as possible through the infrared clutter.
Yeah. So that's a it's a fair question.
And that's that's out of my way.
OK, I would say is that in the inner 10 degrees or so,
the bulge of our galaxy,
I think the stellar density is too high to get really any background galaxy.
So there's still the zone that you're avoiding, not because of dust anymore,
but because there's just too many stars, too many stars.
Yeah, that's that's another problem.
That's a that's a good problem to have for you for what you're looking for.
Well, absolutely fascinating work that you're doing.
I will continue my obsession with the central molecular zone.
I look forward to that next those upgrades to Alma and the very large array.
And of course, the unleashing of the square kilometer array we should have.
And, you know, the upgrade when Meerkat joins
with merchants in and we get this this super telescope,
it's going to be a pretty exciting time.
So keep us posted on what you guys find at the center of the Milky Way.
Absolutely. All right. All right. Thanks.
I hope you enjoyed this conversation with Dr.
Adam Ginsberg.
I'm going to give you some final thoughts and some other references.
But first, I'd like to thank our patrons.
Thanks to Abe Kingston, Andrea Pedretti, BarelyGroofing, Brian Boddy,
Caridwen, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Baylock, Cooper and Ellie, Darkfinger,
David Gilton, and David Matz, Evan Dot Pro, Greg Feeley, James Clark,
Jeremy Madden, Jim Burke, Jordan Young, Josh Schultz, Marcel Switz,
Michael Purcell, Nordspace, OneStepForAnimals.org, Parobak Rankedu,
Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Fowler-Munley, Team 49,
Telescopes Canada, Wolfgang Klotz,
and Zeldaborg Galactic Defender who support us at the Master of the Universe
level and all our patrons. All your support means the universe to us.
We cover a lot of stories about the center of the Milky Way,
the central molecular zone on the universe today.
And I come serious. I am kind of obsessed about it.
And this sort of reached a new level when we got new surveys
from James Webb revealing information about this region.
And I actually did an interview a few months back with Dr.
Kara Battersby about the same region, part of the ACES collaboration as well,
and sort of an earlier implementation and sort of a different aspect of that.
But there's a lot of mysteries.
Like we know that there is an excess of gamma radiation
that's coming from the center of the Milky Way.
Is that due to dark matter colliding and annihilating and producing radiation?
Is it pulsars at the center of the Milky Way?
Why is the black hole at the heart of the Milky Way quiet and not active?
What will it take to make it be active?
How did it grow so big when we don't see a lot of gas information flowing into?
We see outflows of material coming from the center of the Milky Way.
What is causing it?
So I have a lot of questions.
And don't be surprised if I bring on more guests
to to try and get my answers and your answers.
All right. We'll see you next time.