Episode 121: Is this the best Lionel operating car ..EVER??
In this episode, we take a look at what must be considered the most successful operating car in Lionel’s Postwar era. In terms of catalog longevity, ease of operation and maintenance, and the all-important fun factor, Lionel’s milk cars reign supreme.
But the story of the milk car begins with another operating car - the #3454 Automatic Merchandise Car.
The 3454, cataloged in 1946 and 1947, used an ingenious mechanism to open the door of the O27 boxcar and fling miniature crates of Baby Ruth candy bars into a trackside bin - or, depending on the track voltage, BEYOND the bin. The crates were loaded into the car through a hatch in the roof. As the operating button was pressed on the special operating track - a #6019 section for O27 operators or a UCS section for regular O track - the pickup shoes under the trucks completed a circuit to an electromagnet connected to a ratchet and pawl system inside the car. The crates slid down a loading chute one at a time and landed in a rectangular launching seat. Pressing the button once opened the car door and simultaneously launched the box of candy. Releasing the button closed the door and reloaded the mechanism for the next launch. The original crates actually had “Baby Ruth” inscribed on them - reproduction crates generally do not.
There was also a #3854 merchandise car in 1946, using the same mechanism but in a scale-sized, Prewar carryover boxcar. These are very difficult to find today.
While the #3454 was fun and worked well, it was missing a human element. So, beginning in 1947 Lionel’s design team changed the mechanism slightly by adding a human figure that pushed metal milk cans out the door and onto a trackside platform and, like the #3454, used an undersized O27 boxcar. Original cars came with either 6 or 7 cans, depending apparently on the whims of the production crew. Operation of the new #3462 required the same UCS or #6019 track section as the merchandise car. The #3462 was produced in 1947 and 1948. Later, Lionel made subtle changes to the inside operating mechanisms of these cars, creating the #3472 Milk Car made from 1949 through 1953, and later the #3482 for 1954 and 1955. There are subtle differences in the appearance of these different versions, such as white plastic or unpainted aluminum doors and type of trucks, but the basic operation of each of these cars is identical.
In 1955, the mechanism of the Milk Car was moved into a near-scale refrigerator car that better matched Lionel’s line of #6464 boxcars. The #3662 operated essentially the same as the shorted milk cars, except another mechanism change, allowed the action to occur at a slower pace than on previous models. As a result, the milk cans supplied with the #3662 were non-magnetic, unlike their predecessors, as the slower speed allowed them to remain on the platform without the assistance of magnetism. #3662 cars were offered off-and-on through 1966 with only minute changes.
In 1959 and 1960 a special version of this car, the #3672, was decorated for Bosco syrup. This attractive yellow car features a special matching platform as well as special yellow cans with Bosco markings in red. The attractive color scheme and unique style of this car make it very attractive to collectors, but the operation is identical to the #3662.
While Postwar production of the various milk cars ran from 1947 through 1966, the cars mainly went on hiatus from then until the new millennium, with the exception of a few limited runs. However, the cars found new life in the 2000s as Lionel has made a number of versions, from Postwar reissues to Christmas Egg Nog cars.
While #6019 and UCS track sections have been out of regular production since the 1960s, Lionel makes a FasTrack section to operate these cars today - although it will set you back $40 or so for a single piece of track!
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Are these the best Lionel operating cars of the post-war era? The history and operation of Lionel's
operating milk cars on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks. Hello again, this is Mike with
Toy Train Tips and Tricks and in this episode we take a look at what must be considered the
most successful operating car in Lionel's post-war era in terms of catalog longevity,
ease of operation and maintenance, and the all-important fun factor Lionel's milk cars
reign supreme. But the story of the milk car begins with another operating car,
the number 3454 Automatic Merchandise Car. The 3454, cataloged in 1946 and 47,
used an ingenious mechanism to open the door of an 027 boxcar and fling miniature crates
of baby Ruth candy bars into a trackside bin or, depending on the track voltage,
above and beyond the bin. The crates were loaded into the car through a hatch in the roof.
As the operating button was pressed on the special operating track, a number 6019 section for 027
or a UCS section for regular 0 track, the pickup shoes under the trucks completed the circuit to
an electromagnet connected to a ratchet and pawl system inside the car. The crate slid down
a loading chute one at a time and landed into a rectangular launching seat. By pressing the button
once, the car door would open and, simultaneously, boxes of candy were launched into the air.
Releasing the button closed the door and reloaded the mechanism for the next launch.
The original crates actually had baby Ruth inscribed on them. Reproduction crates generally
do not. There was also a number 3854 merchandise car in 1946 that used the same mechanism,
but in a scale-sized pre-war carryover boxcar, and these are very difficult to find today.
While the 3454 was fun and it worked well, it was missing that human element. So, beginning in 1947,
Lionel's design team changed the mechanism slightly by adding a human figure that pushed metal milk
cans out the door and onto a trackside platform, and like the 3454, it used an undersized 027 boxcar.
Original cars came with either six or seven cans depending, apparently, on the whims of the
production crew. Operation of the new number 3462 required the same UCS or 6019 track section as
the merchandise car. The 3462 was produced in 1947 and 1948. Later, Lionel made subtle changes to the
inside operating mechanisms of these cars, creating the number 3472 milk car that ran from 1949 to 53,
and then the number 3482 for 1954 and 1955. There are subtle differences in the appearances of
these cars, these different versions. For example, some have white plastic doors, some have unpainted
aluminum doors, the types of trucks vary, but the basic operation of each of these cars is identical.
The differences are mostly on the inside. In 1955, the mechanism of the milk car was moved into a
near-scale refrigerator car that better matched Lionel's line of number 6464 boxcars.
Thus, the number 3662 was born. It operated essentially the same as the shorter milk cars,
except another mechanism change allowed the action to occur at a little slower pace than on the
previous models. As a result, the milk cans supplied with the 3662 were non-magnetic, unlike their
predecessors, as the slower speed allowed these cans to remain on the platform without the assistance
of magnetism. The 3662 cars were offered on and off through 1960, with only minute changes.
In 1959 and 1960, a special version of this car, the number 3672, was decorated for Bosco
syrup products. This attractive yellow car features a special matching platform, as well
as special yellow cans with Bosco markings in red. The attractive color scheme and unique style of
this car makes it very attractive to collectors, but the operation is identical to the 3662.
While the post-war production of these various milk cars ran from 1947 through 1960, the cars
mainly went on hiatus from then until the new millennium, with the exception of a few very
special limited runs. However, the cars have found a new life in the 2000s, as Lionel has made a
number of versions, from post-war reissues to Christmas egg nog cars. While the number 6019
and UCS track sections have been out of regular production since the 1960s, Lionel makes a fast
track section to operate these cars today, although it will set you back $40 or so for a single piece
of track. So, let's look at the operation of these cars. First, we have the platform. There are
several variations of the platform over the years, but honestly, the platform is not really
required for operation of the car. You can take it off and the milk cars will fling on their own.
Unlike, say, the cattle car, the platform really has nothing to do with the operation. There's
no wiring whatsoever involved with the platform. All it does is, one, provide a place for the milk
cans to be deposited, and it provides little tabs to help keep the track the proper distance away
from the dock. Other than that, the platform really doesn't have a lot of purpose in the
operation of the car. The deck is metal to catch the magnetic cans, which these are non-magnetic
for the 3662, but even with the 3662, it came with a metal deck for durability purposes. This
is an all-metal construction platform. Proper operation requires this number 6019 special
control track for 027 or the UCS operating section for 0 gauge track, and you can see it better here.
And since most of these pieces of track have been out of production for going on 70 years,
the original wiring, the black 4 cable wiring, most of the insulation you find today is cracked,
and there are short circuits in them. These are, however, very easy to rewire,
and I have a video posted on how to do this, although please bear with me. It was one of
the first videos I did, so it's rather long-winded, a little on the boring side,
but all of the information is there. I'll have to redo that video and make it a little more
presentable. The original Lionel controller for the 6019 sections or the UCS sections
had two orange buttons side-by-side on a black controller that was hard-wired to the track.
Taking the opportunity to rewire this, I have my own setup. I 3D printed this box, which actually,
this is my very first prototype, and I'm going to make some changes to it so it's not posted
anywhere yet for download. I will once I get a better version of this. But anyway, all this does
is hold a momentary contact double-pull, double-throw, center-off switch. So what I have
is, when I lift it up, it completes the circuit on the track to unload. When I push down,
it activates the center magnet and the outer rails to simply uncouple cars. That way, I can
use the same loading platform for, say, the operating post office car that uses the plunger
with the electromagnet in order to operate. I would simply hit the uncouple button,
and mailbags would be flinging onto the platform instead of milk cans.
Since the car uses these pickup shoes to complete the circuit to activate the mechanism,
it must be situated properly on the control track in order to function. Now, the earlier,
shorter milk cars, it's a little easier. There's a little more play, wiggle room. These longer
36-62s, because they are really longer than the operating track, in order to get it situated to
where both shoes are in proper contact, your margin for error is much less as far as where
you can situate the car. And so I recommend using a bumper so that when you park the car
up against the bumper, it's in the proper spot. Because if it's not, nothing happens. You see,
I'm askew, but as I move the car to the right spot, there we go, there our milk car guy appears.
So let's take you through the operating sequence of the car first. We've got a hatch right here,
and you can see with the shape of the hole, the milk cans go in only one way. And there's a little
plastic spring tab there so that you can load one at a time. And an original car would have
six or seven of these cans. I only have five. I bought this one secondhand. I've got five cans.
And you just load it and then push it so it clears that spring. It will roll down the chute
and into its spot. I'm going to load all five of them in here. I think it'll actually hold eight
or nine cans all together. You can hear it rolling down the chute. Okay, and then I'm
just going to close that chute. And then you can run it around the layout or whatever. And then
when you're ready, you park it down your siding, hit our unload button. Every time I press the
button, I get one cycle. One can per push of the button. Now, you can adjust the speed and
ferocity of this by altering the amount of voltage going to it. Right now, I've got this hooked up
temporarily to a full 18 volts, which is really too much. But it will work all the way up to the
18 volts. When I rewire mine, I do them off of accessory power. The original track section,
as wired by Lionel, uses track power. But by using accessory power, I can park it on the siding.
I don't have to be running any other trains. And the operation of the Milkman is not relying upon
the speed of the train. Keeping these in good operating order is actually very simple.
One, make sure that the contact shoes stay clean. Because with the dirty shoes, you're not going to
have contact and you won't have operation. Check the wires, especially if they're original, for
fraying. Or sometimes the solder joints might come loose from the trucks and that would end
operation. As you run these around the layout sometimes, especially if you have a derailment
and they get turned on their side, sometimes the milk cans, if it's preloaded, the cans can
jostle in the chute, sometimes turn sideways and get jammed. To fix that, all you do is take out
the screws to remove the shell from the frame and you can get in and have easy access to the chute
to straighten those out to fix any jams. Speaking of operation with these, with this mechanism,
this is a very heavy car, so you will want to run it at the front of the train. As I mentioned, Lionel
has kind of updated this car with different types of loads, although the cans are the same shape for
the operation. Sometimes it would be a Christmas car that is, you know, unloading eggnog or such
instead of milk or maybe hot chocolate. These cars are pretty much bulletproof, they're easy
to maintain, and they're fun. So, if you haven't added a milk car or two to your layout, it might be
something for you to consider, just for the fun factor and the ease of use. Buying these second
hand on the market today, depending on condition, of course, always. The Bosco car is probably
the hardest to find, the most expensive, because of its special graphics, followed by the larger
car. There were fewer of these made, and also, you know, the larger scale size generally makes them a
little bit more expensive, it shows. The shorter versions were made much longer, there's lots of
them, and so, in good condition, you can generally find those, you know, with a decent platform.
In the $40 to $50 range isn't unreasonable for a cool operating car, you know, especially if you
can get it, you know, with a good piece of operating track. And as I mentioned, the track itself,
the 6019 and the UCS, if it has all original wiring and the wiring is in good shape, those can
come in at a premium, $50 or so, or you can buy the new Lionel Fast Track version. Again, if you're
willing to rewire these, you know, you can get them for five bucks a piece at most shows.
So there it is, I hope you found this interesting, and if so, like, subscribe, share it, leave a
comment about your favorite milk car memories, or if you have a nominee for an even better Lionel
operating car of the post-war era, you know, leave that in the comments. If you think that
something is better than the milk car, go ahead and leave that. Tell your friends, tell your
neighbors, keep the trains running, and we'll catch you next time on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.