When I saw the Boy and the Heron, I had a take on the film's metaphor that my friend group told me was worth sharing. So here we are, 2 months and 40 minutes later with my attempt at explaining what is now my favorite Ghibli film. Many scenes were recreated from memory and I'm sure I made mistakes, see Errata below, but I did my best to put forth my sincere thoughts! If you are among the many who didn't 'get' the film, I hope this gives you a place to start!
My second video essay on the film Suzume is now live! If you enjoyed this piece on Boy and the Heron, I hope you will consider giving it a look: • The Metaphor of Suzume ~ The Meaning of Re... If you want to continue any discussion beyond the comments below, please join our art/gaming/chatting streams on twitch! / densetsuvii
Errata: Leto gave birth to ARTEMIS and Apollo not Athena, this is totally my mistake. I blame the video game Hades for not having Leto as a character.
Barthes is pronounced 'Bart', not especially an error so much as an Americanization, but a couple people pointed this out. To be honest, I tried to say it as Bart, but I kept messing up and ultimately just kept the takes which felt like they got the sentiment most correct.
The image comparison for Kiki's parent's house includes an image I found in a thumbnail I swore I saw in the film, but upon reexamining the film, I could not locate this image. I do still think there are parallels with Kiki in the pelicans, though it's definitely one of the least referenced films in Boy and the Heron. I think that's kind of interesting, considering Kiki also touches on the process of creation in its metaphor, but TLDR, the comparison image listed as from Boy and the Heron should not be there. I stand by my overall point about the references.
Films is misspelled at 16:46. Sustenance is misspelled at 27:50.
Chapters: 00:00 Intro 01:40 Metaphor 08:02 Approaching The Boy and the Heron 11:30 Resemblances 16:43 Of Films and Film Production 22:13 Explaining The Boy and the Heron 31:47 The Authorial Metaphor 34:23 How Do You Live 35:41 One Last Idea 39:20 Conclusion
Sources: "The Boy and the Heron Is So Personal, Hayao Miyazaki Needed A Year to Grieve Before Pivoting in a New Direction" - Bill Desowitz, Indie Wire Nov 22, 2023 https://www.indiewire.com/features/an...
"The Boy and the Heron Producer Says the Anime Is the Most Expensive Japanese Film Ever Made" Hayley McCullough, CBR, Aug 19 2023 https://www.cbr.com/the-boy-and-the-h...
"How Do You Live" Genzaburo Yoshino, Translated by Bruno Navasky, Introduction by Neil Gaiman 2021
"Sharing a House with the Neverending Man" Steve Albert, 2020
"The Kingdom of Dreams and Madness" Dir. Mami Sunada, Dist. Toho Co., Ltd. 2013 #anime#movie#review
In October of 2023, I was able to attend the West Coast premiere of Hayao Miyazaki's
Boy in the Hair at the Grauman Chinese Theater in Hollywood.
Eric Beckman, the head of the film's U.S. distributor GKids, introduced the film by
quoting Guillermo del Toro, who had introduced the film at its international premiere in Toronto.
We are privileged to be living in a time where Mozart is composing symphonies.
I attended with a group of six friends and family. All of us enjoyed the film. A little
over half described the film as cryptic. There was a sentiment that it held a deeper meaning
that they were unable to grasp. This take seemed to be echoed in the passing conversations of
others in the theater, opining about what it all meant. A couple in our group compared
the film to Spirited Away in terms of the feeling it evoked and implied it to be their
favorite of the Ghibli pantheon. It wasn't hard to find other members of the audience
name-dropping Spirited Away, echoing this feeling. I held a different view. I felt the
film to be the crowning achievement of Miyazaki's career, an ingenious film that only he could
have made and whose underlying meaning was not just clear, but empathetic, cathartic,
and unforgettable. The internet already abounds with reviewers who describe the film as confounding,
mystifying, and inaccessible. And for any viewers who had that experience,
this video is for you. I want to share the metaphor I found in the film, a metaphor that
makes sense of the film's fantastical elements and imparts beautiful, positive meaning, and
hopefully an opportunity for us all to see the film in a new light. We need to start with the
nature of metaphor itself. Even if you're not used to viewing art through a metaphorical lens,
you probably understand the concept. It's looking at the events or components of a piece of art
and deriving a non-literal meaning from them. The word comes from the Greek metaphora,
and its literary practice can also be traced back to the Greeks. In her essay Against Interpretation,
Susan Sontag pinpoints the origins of metaphorical interpretation to the Greek rationalists.
The rationalists believed, among other things, that the gods are good and therefore moral,
but they had a problem. If they took the stories about the gods literally,
they had to explain why their moral gods did seemingly immoral things. Sontag points to the
story of Leto, the woman with whom Zeus had the famous affair which birthed Apollo and Athena.
How can Zeus be so promiscuous and still worthy of respect? Rather than throw away their myths,
they began to interpret them in non-literal ways. In the Leto case, they might assess Zeus and Leto's
affair as an allegory to the union of power and wisdom, as represented by Apollo and Athena's
births. So when Sontag views metaphor, she sees it as a way to find new meaning in an old text,
especially if the original was problematic in some way. In fact, she argues that this
approach creates new problems, especially as it's applied to newer works of art.
Interpretation has the potential, she points out, to erase the work's original meanings and
establish unintended meanings as authoritative. It can even separate ourselves from the raw
emotionality of art. Sontag points to Franz Kafka, Tennessee Williams, and other authors
whose works were losing their internal sense of drama in favor of interpretations of what it all
might mean. These seem like bad things. We do not want our metaphorical interpretations to take away
from the majesty of the art we're experiencing. But what if the nature of art is to be cryptic?
The fact that so many viewers of The Boy and the Heron find themselves puzzled is something the
work itself brought to bear. Perhaps the implication is that if meaning has been purposefully inserted
by its author, it's valid to try and unravel it. The idea of an author is itself a human
narrative invention, just like metaphor. Roland Barthé notes how primitive societies do not
assign the idea of narrative storytelling to a person, but only a mediator, who can tell the
story and be praised for telling it well, but doesn't really own its content. The idea of one
individual, responsible for the story, comes from the individualist enlightenment, and through a
combination of humanism, capitalism, and rationalism, society began to view art as the product
of one person, a genius creator, whose talents, perspective, and intentions became intertwined
with what they had made. This doesn't seem like a bad thing, and even today, interviewers, writers,
and fans seek to understand art through their creators. Barthé points out how Van Gogh's
paintings are seen as products of his madness, for example. But here, too, Barthé sees problems.
The idea of a single, true, authorial reading works great for critics, who can act as though
they've found the one actual intent of the author, but it imposes the idea of a single,
godlike, true interpretation that shuts down any subsequent or different interpretations.
And this mirrors Sontag's impressions of external meanings supplanting an original experience.
In a word, it's gatekeeping. Anyone experiencing art in a way that the author didn't want is doing
it wrong, and that doesn't seem right. Fundamentally, Barthé says, narrative is
open-ended. Once something has been created, it exists independently of how it was made.
Every reader will bring their own life experiences into it. The true nature of a line of text in a
An author might not even know the infinite possibilities their words create.
It's easy to misinterpret Barthé's iconic essay, The Death of the Author, as a statement that
authors have no more control over their work and don't matter, but its true thesis is summarized
in the essay's iconic final line. The birth of the reader must be ransomed by the death of the
author. There can be no authorial authority, because it would come at the expense of our
experience, and it's the reader, or in our case the viewer, who will ultimately derive meaning
from the art. So metaphorical reading cannot override or replace the text it's interpreting,
nor can it be solely focused on the intentions of its creator. So what constructive purpose does
metaphorical reading serve? I found the answer somewhere I never expected, but in truth it was
the most perfect place. The English version of How Do You Live, the book which inspired Miyazaki's
The Boy and the Heron, contains an introduction by Neil Gaiman. The book itself we'll discuss later,
but suffice to say it's very different from the film. It alternates between quaint pictures of a
young boy's daily life in 1930s Japan and deep meditations on science, ethics, and the nature
of humanity delivered by the boy's uncle. Gaiman notes that this dualistic structure may seem
strange to some readers, but much like the uncle in the book, Gaiman takes this opportunity to
explain a fundamental truth. Sometimes the joy of books that seem to contain opposing elements
is in realizing that without both things you'd have a lesser book. This is the truth of metaphor.
Both the raw and natural experience of the text and the interpretation of it can create something
more through their harmony. Gaiman, for his part, takes the example of Moby Dick and its own split
focus between the doomed hunt for a white whale and essays on the topic of whaling and whales
generally. Some people like one part of the story and some the other. For me the joy is that the book
contains both parts pulling at each other and that if you removed either part you'd have a less
interesting book. This gives us a workable, constructive definition of a metaphorical reading.
The metaphor cannot override or ignore the original text. It shouldn't rely or defer to the
author's intentions and view the author's statements on their work as more inspiration than rules.
It should exist in harmony with the original work and make the experience of it better than it would
be on its own. But to reiterate, no interpretation, even this one, is the final right way to see the film.
It's the second half which together with the original text creates a richer experience.
Let's see if we can find this experience in The Boy and the Heron. The most obvious line of inquiry
to Hayao Miyazaki's The Boy and the Heron is its inspiration, Genzaburo Yoshino's 1937 book
How Do You Live? In Japanese the film is actually titled How Do You Live?
Kimi wa dou ikiru? Same as the book. But most sources now list the book as an inspiration
for the film and it's easy to see why. The book shares almost nothing in common with the movie.
Its protagonist goes by the nickname Copper and takes place in 1938 instead of 1943 and the
protagonist's circumstances are so different it's almost comical. A couple lines in the book really
emphasize this. Copper's father passed away about two years ago. After he died, Copper's family moved
from their mansion to the old city in a modest house in the suburbs. The film's character Mahito
has the opposite experience. His mother passes away at the start of the film in dramatic fashion
and their family moves from the suburbs to a mansion. Copper's friendship with his classmates
is at the core of the book and its message. Mahito's classmates reject him and we don't even
hear them speak throughout the film. And just to emphasize, the book contains no supernatural
elements of any kind. No towers or disappearances and no heron. If you find the movie confounding,
the book holds no overt answers as to why. Despite Miyazaki himself calling the book a childhood
favorite of his, any allusions to the book, including the most obvious one, are not the most
key to the film's meaning. The movie we do see does beg to be interpreted, more so than perhaps
any other Ghibli film. Many of its events are both inexplicably strange and remarkably coherent,
as though they abide by a deeper meaning and set of rules, but we aren't privy to what they are.
The entryway into the mystical tower, with its inscription taken from Dante's Inferno,
the strange ecosystems of the Otherworld and their oddly detailed interactions,
the fact that every bird in the movie except the heron is ravenously hungry, and most confounding
of all, the 13 blocks. Why are they so important? What do they mean? And why 13 of them? While I was
watching the film for the first time, I wasn't consciously thinking about these questions.
Like most, I imagine, I was drawn in by the technical achievements of the film, its sense
of wonder, and the flow of its real-world plot. But one moment got me to sit up and pay attention.
One shot seemed to tap me on the shoulder and say,
something is off. In this part of the movie, recreated, Mahito and the older maid Kiriko
are about to advance towards the tower, following Natsuko. It's very graphic, framing the characters
with the round contour of the bushes in the foreground, and leaving just a hint of the house
behind. It's really deliberate, unmistakable, especially when the following shots move through
the round bushes and emerge out the other side. We've seen all this before. In My Neighbor Totoro,
Mei is framed identically, as she follows the supernatural Totoros into their lair.
The following shots, too, are similar, down to the side shot after leaving the brush.
It's not news that Miyazaki reuses some vague elements in character designs across his films,
but to my knowledge, he's never reused an exact composition in a different film. After all,
it's not like he's saving time or money. This is the most expensive Japanese film ever made,
and it took six years. This shot is purposeful. It's screaming Totoro at us, out of nowhere.
Why is it there? Something else began to creep on me.
Many of the characters in this film bear remarkable resemblances to other Ghibli characters.
Himi's resemblance to Nahoko from The Wind Rises is truly uncanny. Several of the maids
resemble other Ghibli characters, like old Sophie, and even the boss from Kokoroso's Mama Yudo gang.
Some compare this maid to Yubaba because of her pinned bun and wart, but she's also wearing the
exact same colors as Totoro's granny character. And there's another detail involving that particular
character that many have missed. In the scene where the maids tell Mahito's father that not
only has his wife and son gone missing, but that there's a history of such things, there's a
particularly interesting line. The subtitle's translated as,
This is an understandable translation of the Japanese, but it loses an important nuance.
The word that's being translated as strange disappearances is the word kamikakushi. If that
word sounds familiar as a Ghibli fan, it's probably because you may have heard it before.
To be spirited away is not uncommon here. Now, Ghibli films have referenced themselves before.
Castle in the Sky literally shows the fox squirrels from Nausicaa in a cameo role,
and the engine in Kokoroso famously says Ghibli on it. Many commentaries and reviews on the film
are opining about Miyazaki retreading old ground and debating about whether this is lazy on his
part or whether it makes the film a boring watch, but I'm not sure these viewers have grasped the
totality of the situation. This isn't just one reference, or two, or three. They aren't easter
eggs. They're unavoidable. They're everywhere. And they reference everything. Every Miyazaki film
is given several allusions, subtle and overt. Some feel like jokes. Others are huge parts of
the plot. These are just the ones I can remember more than a month after seeing the film. Some are
one-off moments that come and go quickly. The Totoro sequence, though, has three backgrounds
in a row which almost directly copy their original. You don't reference everything you've
ever made by accident, and it's not just the Ghibli films. The Castle of Cagliostro, the first
film Miyazaki directed, is well-represented here, with allusions to its iconic car chase,
the design of the Parakeet King, and other clear visual references to its iconic ruins.
And unlike any film in Miyazaki's history, I believe this film finds a way to reference itself.
We see it in the scene where the distraught, injured Mahito discovers the book his mother
left for him, How Do You Live? As previously discussed, not only is the Japanese title of
the film How Do You Live?, but the book has nothing to do with the film in terms of its
events and characters. As Mahito begins to cry, we see an illustration in the book,
something you won't find in it today. Moreover, it's an image of a car going to the countryside.
This event is not present in the book. The book depicts the opposite event, and it takes all of
a single sentence. It's not important. Whereas, in the movie, Mahito's move to the country is
inciting his life, the thing he's so frustrated with as he languishes in bed. He's seeing his
own life in art. The book as depicted in the movie is not the book of our world. It is the movie,
referencing itself. This means that the film references each of the movies Hayao Miyazaki
has directed. But there's one more piece, one experience Miyazaki deemed too important not to
allude to. It's the most evident in the form of Mahito. A variety of sources have pointed out how
unusual a male protagonist is for a Ghibli film, and while The Wind Rises took a historical figure
as the basis for its protagonist, there's no such impetus for Mahito, particularly given the other
ways the movie departs from the book. Even Mahito's design, his spiky hair and asymmetric cut brought
by his injury, are unusual for a Ghibli work whose characters so often appropriate a more rounded
visual style. Mahito isn't from here. He's from another place, from another time, long ago,
and somehow still in the future. Most Western audiences are only familiar with Future Boy
Conan by name, despite the fact that it was Miyazaki's true directorial debut. As a TV
series from 1978, it was never aired in the States and only recently dubbed, but once you see it,
you won't be able to unsee its references again and again through The Boy and the Heron.
Watch the intro to Conan and note the ship they ride on, a two-person sailboat uncannily similar
to the ship Mahito and Kiriko ride. The design of the crashed spaceship, a tower from another world,
eerily similar to the tower inherent, both in composition and even color. In the first episode,
Conan fights a rampaging shark with his wooden harpoon, which the shark bites into and splits
in two. In the second episode, wracked with grief, Conan repeatedly lifts up large stones from the
roadside. There's even a character who carries a bow with a single arrow and no quiver, and never
seems to miss with it. It seems evident that for the purposes of The Boy and the Heron, Future Boy
Conan is treated as one of the Miyazaki canon. Including Heron itself, this means we can lay
out the Miyazaki creations, like so. I have traveled across time and space to deliver you
these 13 blocks. When I heard this line in the theater, like Mahito, I also cried.
The Boy and the Heron is a Ghibli film about Ghibli films. The 13 blocks are the 13 Miyazaki
canon, and the other world is the world of Ghibli, the magical realm his movies have crafted for so
many of us. The travails of Mahito in this world are the struggles of creating a film, and the
great uncle's whole life has been consumed by the upholding of the legacy those films have created.
To fully understand the implications of this, we need to briefly discuss the nature of filmmaking,
particularly as Miyazaki experiences it in the Japanese animation industry. To create industrial
art, that is, art meant for a commercial audience and requiring a team for its creation, you need
a creative lead. For films, this is the director, particularly in the Japanese system where the
auteur-based production is still common, and especially Ghibli, where Miyazaki is director,
writer, and storyboard artist for his films. He can be thought of more generally as a creator.
The creator's strength is to make art. Their priority is to make the best art possible.
As Barthes noted, our culture as a whole has, for many centuries, glorified this creative role,
perhaps a little too much. But in Miyazaki's case, it's demonstrably true that he's provided the soul
to a great many movies. But art of a certain scale requires resources for its creation, and this is
where a producer becomes necessary. A producer's strength is to facilitate art, and their priority
is to make art as smoothly as possible. They amass funding, coordinate schedules and negotiations.
In The Kingdom of Dreams and Madness, we see that Suzuki, not Miyazaki, calls Hideaki Anno to
convince him to take on the role of Jiro. And in Sharing a House with the Neverending Man,
we see that Suzuki takes the primary role in negotiating with Harvey Weinstein during the
dubbing of Princess Mononoke, famously mailing a decorative sword labeled,
No Cuts. This brings us to the last piece of the industrial art puzzle, the distributor.
The distributor's job is to sell the art to an audience, and their goal is to make the art that
is the most profitable. They are the businessmen and the marketers, the farthest removed from the
process of making the art itself. But it goes without saying that without distribution,
industrial art cannot make money, and therefore the system cannot sustain itself.
The distributor cannot be discounted just because they are the farthest removed from the creative
process. Indeed, they are the closest to what makes it possible. Each group's goals are subtly
opposed. The famous story of Harvey Weinstein attempting to edit Princess Mononoke to obtain
a more palatable PG rating is an extreme example of a distributor attempting to maximize profit
at the expense of quality. But creators are also guilty of their own shenanigans,
and Miyazaki's no different. The stories of Crunch at Ghibli are legendary and at times
heartbreaking. They are, effectively, instances of Miyazaki sacrificing a smooth production for
a quality one. Producers, too, are not without their stake in this ecosystem, as Goro Miyazaki
was supposedly on time and under budget with his Tales of Earthsea, but the finished product
languishes as a low point in the Ghibli pantheon. And let it be said that this balance is sometimes
necessary, as Suzuki famously pressured Miyazaki into creating the ending for Spirited Away,
as schedules and budgets buckled, creating the iconic non-violent climax at the end of
Spirited Away because the budget couldn't support a more eventful conclusion.
My first film teacher once said, that any movie gets made at all is a miracle,
and until you try to make one yourself you may not quite understand. Each production is a fight
against time, fatigue, and an outside world bearing down on you. Original creative sparks
need people who nurture the fire, but too often find only indifference not just in audiences,
but in the producers, distributors, and even collaborators if things get out of hand.
You don't usually hear about them, but a great many projects never reach any audience or
completion. And when your projects wither, it's hard not to feel yourself withering, too.
And somehow, Miyazaki has come out the other side, time and time again, for over 40 years,
with quality, iconic works of art, successful critically and commercially. But to say that
Ghibli is without problems would be naive. The industry as a whole has been sliding off,
wages for Japanese animators are untenably low, and like the western film industry,
recent films tend to chase trends and capitalize on established IP, particularly in the field of
young adult light novels. Miyazaki's ire for this trend is evident in his famous line,
often mocked but rarely seen in context, as an admonition that his industry is languishing.
And even if Miyazaki himself has known, for the most part, only success, his studio's future is
not bright. Miyazaki is now 82, has tried to retire at least 3 times, and in its 40 year
history, Studio Ghibli has been functionally, structurally unable to find a successor to it.
The most prominent director at Ghibli besides Miyazaki, Isao Takahata, passed away from lung
cancer, aged 82. Yoshifumi Kondo, a promising director who Miyazaki had stated he would pass
his studio onto, succumbed to an aneurysm, thought by some to relate to his overwork,
in the late 90s. Miyazaki's son Goro has admitted on camera to loathing the work he's had to do,
claims he directs out of obligation, and his critically panned earwig in The Witch has only
reinforced this, and Hino Masayori Beyashi left the studio when Miyazaki finished The Wind Rises.
Whatever Ghibli was able to create, is it really worthwhile if no one will remain to uphold that
craft while they're gone? This dance of creation and legacy fuels the metaphor behind Boy in the
Heron. It's the core of the struggle that the characters go through that explains the motivation
Who, then, are these characters? Producer Toshio Suzuki has removed some of the guesswork here.
In an interview with IndieWire, Suzuki states very clearly that the entire film began with
Miyazaki asking to make a film about himself. He goes further, marking in very clear terms who he
feels the other characters are. Miyazaki is Mahito, Takahata is the Great Uncle, and Suzuki is the
Miyazaki, as Mahito, is one aspect of the story most critics seem to understand.
The words autobiographical or semi-autobiographical are even in the film's official GKids description.
There are literal aspects to this, like how Mahito's father, like Miyazaki's, created planes
during the war, but as far as the metaphor, what it means is this. Mahito is a young creator. He
hears the call of his art, and, drawn by the promise of recovering the things he's lost or yearns for,
he enters into it. When I say lost or yearned for, I refer mostly to how, in their review of
The Boy and the Heron, the New York Times makes reference to a quote from interviews in the
Miyazaki biography's starting point. Miyazaki referred to a universal yearning for a lost
world, which he refused to call nostalgia, since even children experience it. We long
not for what we remember, but what we've never experienced at all, only sensed beneath reality's
surface. Mahito lacks experience, but he has creativity, constantly inventing new solutions
to his problems, drive in that he never backs down even from what he perceives as a trap,
and sincerity, as is overtly mentioned when Kiriko breaks down his name's meaning.
Sincerity, to Miyazaki, is the key to the creation of art. And for Miyazaki, the master of that art
is Isao Takahata. He is the Great Uncle, master of the world. He alone understands it, knows how
to maintain it and how fragile it is, and he knows he cannot keep it forever. In the same interview,
Suzuki recounts his logic. It's eminently clear that Takahata's passing, which occurred during
the lengthy production of The Boy and the Heron, was a great influence on Miyazaki.
Earlier drafts of the film seem to have focused primarily on the relation between Mahito and the
Suzuki as the Heron is a complicated role. He appears as an antagonist at first, drawing Mahito
into the tower, but he's not what he seems, his bird body just a cover for his human form.
He can create illusions, but they don't last. He is the elements and creator, but what he really
does is motivate creators. While his relationship with Mahito is strained from time to time,
and he's crafty with his words, by the end, they're on the same side, and Mahito's journey
would not be possible without him. With this interpretation as a guide, we can unravel the
world of Boy and the Heron through a filmic lens. When Mahito arrives in the other world,
he's almost immediately attacked by the pelicans, and after being saved by Kiriko,
he's immediately taught to dredge the depths of this world's sea for fish, and tossed into
the grimy experience of gutting it. The fish, once gutted, gives rise to the wadawada,
pure and innocent souls, floating to the heavens to be reborn. These too are attacked by the
pelicans, and we soon learn that the pelicans are starving, unable to eat the fish in this sea
the grand uncle brought them to. It seems that the fish itself represents raw creative potential.
To an artist, this is our bread and butter, or rather, the meat and bones of any project,
but from the outside it may appear rough, even ugly, certainly not ready for consumption.
An artist's task is to prepare the raw idea, to make it appealing and delicious. The wadawada
that arise from this, pure and good in nature, seem to embody the good of creation. Note how
airy and emotional they are, how free in comparison to the thirteen blocks. They appear to represent
the first steps of a new idea, rising up towards birth, and indeed, towards the thirteen blocks
themselves, represented as being at the top of the tower. Why do the pelicans consume them?
We should take a moment to discuss consumption in the film generally.
When the pelicans consume the wadawada, it's framed as a sad and violent occurrence done
out of desperation. They're predators, but not without a sense of grandeur.
When the parakeets consume, it's framed relatively comically. They have schemes to do it,
it's all they think about, and they aren't the most competent at it. And of course,
when Mahito himself eats with Himi and Kirikou, it has a warmth and sustenance.
Consumption is of course intertwined with modern society, and it's not just about eating,
but the obtaining of sustenance. We get something out of the things we consume.
Consumption isn't inherently malicious, but it can be unsustainable. Gluttony describes consuming
beyond your needs, beyond your healthy balance. An incumbent in the term balance is the idea of
giving as well as receiving sustenance. The use of animals in the metaphor helps us connect the
Everything must consume to survive, but if the top of the food chain eats until it's all that's
left, soon they too will starve. Life and death must be balanced for this world to survive.
In the world of The Boy and the Heron, and the world of creation,
we can understand sustenance's creativity. Artists are the source of it, and others
consume and facilitate it. Some consumption is necessary, and the most positive consumption
is that of artists, who are certain to give it back to the world. The most negatively depicted
is that of the parakeets, who think only of taking sustenance and stop at nothing to achieve it.
The pelicans consume, but they know they can't consume forever. They are trapped by their fate.
This is the ecological disaster that's made the other world what it is.
The character who's the most proactive in solving this issue, surprisingly,
is the Parakeet King. The Parakeet King is trying to save the world. He knows the
Great Uncle's at the crux of the world, and it's crumbling around him. He's implied to have spared
Natsuko directly, and takes Himi to the Great Uncle in pursuit of this goal. Why Himi?
Himi uses fire to protect the warawara. Kiriko uses fire to fend off the pelicans.
Fire is what creates food from the raw ingredients of the fish. It's not hard to see fire as connected
to passion and creativity. Himi literally wields it with magical prowess. Fire, it seems, is the
passion that feeds creativity. It is, of course, not lost in the film that fire can be a terrifying
thing as well. The opening in which Mahito's mother dies is all about fire, and the traumatic
fires of the birthing room reflect this too. Fire can be born from pain. Emotion, good or bad,
can fuel creativity, and it can be a harrowing process. But Himi, the embodiment of Mahito's
mother reborn, seems to show us that good can be rocked through fire, even if its origins are
hurtful. Himi is inspiration, a muse of sorts. With this in mind, the Parakeet King takes Himi
to the Great Uncle, the Great Uncle who created the world in the first place, the greatest source
of its power. The King is, essentially, trying to inspire him from his limited understanding of how
creativity works. But as we can see, while the Great Uncle is very cordial with Himi, she herself
cannot create. And nothing will allow the Great Uncle to stave off his own age. With the totality
of the interactions mapped, we can start to assign the different characters, outside of Mahito, the
Heron, and the Great Uncle, roles in the filmic process. The Parakeet King takes on the role of
a distributor. He gets the creations out to an audience, knows of their importance, but doesn't
truly understand how it all works. When he meddles in the specifics, he only makes things worse.
The Parakeets themselves are the audience. They sustain themselves in consumption, but can
themselves contribute nothing to it, following the distributor with bated breath. The Pelicans are
treated differently, and there's a temptation to say they are also a form of audience member,
but I'm struck by their similarity to the Heron. They're more animalistic than the Parakeets,
treated with more respect, and Mahito's sympathy for the Pelicans is what begins to win over the
understand their need for each other, and it's shortly after that they meet at Kiriko's table
to undertake their journey. I think that the Pelicans are failed producers. They are Herons
who have no Mahito, who cannot help but eat up the ideas they're given. It is a tragedy.
And so we return to where this metaphor started. The blocks. The film presents the 13 blocks as
core supporting the magical world. They stand in an uneasy balance, and the Great Uncle spends his
entire life watching them, studying them, making them. He wants Mahito to add his own block to
join the tower, to join the world of creation. Mahito is reluctant, perhaps lacking in confidence
or wishing to retain his connection to life's true emotions as sown through his adoptive mother.
But the Great Uncle is insistent. He can do whatever he wants, but he must add a block
if the legacy is to survive. The Parakeet King tries to steady the tower, but ends up knocking
it over and destroying everything that was built, and in the end Mahito is left with but one humble
block of his own. Rough, but enough of a start for something new. And so we see the story as Miyazaki
would have us tell it. The Boy and the Heron is the story of Miyazaki as he came into storytelling.
How Isao Takahata saw his potential and inducted him into their world. How Suzuki came to their
world as an outsider, but became a staunch ally. And how when Takahata's time came, Miyazaki felt
he couldn't take on the legacy of his lifelong friend, but only proceed in his own way. Something
Suzuki himself calls out as surprising. In Miyazaki's own words, it's a story for his grandchild,
a testament to his life, for when he's gone. If you're here to find the meaning which is most
emphatically advocated by its creators, this is probably it. I think many people will be satisfied
with this understanding of the film, or even view it as definitive, because it's what Suzuki
stated, whether they're satisfied or not. I, for one, am not entirely satisfied. And if you're
willing to listen, I want to take us down the road Barth has made for us, and go beyond what
the author has defined his work to be. I think viewing the film as Miyazaki's life story is
limiting. It gives the film a kind of egotistical bend I don't think it deserves. And moreover,
it seems to say, these are someone else's experiences, in the way a film like Spielberg's
Fable Lens does. What if we aren't Miyazaki's grandson? What if we aren't practiced professional
animators? There's a certain distance that this interpretation imposes on us. The less interested
you are in Miyazaki, or Japanese anime, or even film in general, the less impact the film will
have on you if this is its message. And Sontag warned us against metaphors that reduce the
emotionality of a work. But the biggest sticking point for me is Takahata's role as the grand
uncle. Takahata didn't make 13 films. None of his films are referenced in The Boy in the Hair in the
way Miyazaki's are. And most importantly, the relationship of Takahata and Miyazaki was so much
more than a mentor-student relationship. It's true it started that way, with Miyazaki animating on
Takahata's Horace, Prince of the Sun in 1968, but by the time Miyazaki made his own debut with
Future Boy Conan ten years later, it was Takahata who storyboarded for him. They were only five
years apart, after all. Both of them left Toei to pursue their own paths and joined together in
founding Ghibli in the 80s. To reduce their relationship to that of an incomparable master
and a reluctant student is certainly endearing and humble of Miyazaki, but at its best it reduces the
film to only being about the beginning of his career, and at worst it seems disconnected from
what their relationship truly was. When Miyazaki began Boy in the Hair in, he seems to have started
from how do you live, understanding the relationship between him and Takahata the way that Copper and
his uncle relate in the book. Many critics have opined about Miyazaki's film fundamentally
answering this question, but I think that view is reductive. I do recommend the book highly,
even though it contains nothing of the fantasy that characterizes the Ghibli films. What it has
in spades is heart, empathy, sincerity. Everything that happens to Copper, his uncle ties into the
wider world. To spoil one of the earliest chapters as an example, Copper realizes while looking out
onto the streets of Tokyo that every person out there lives their own interconnected lives and
that he's connected to all of them, but not central to any of them. On hearing this, his uncle reflects
on the story of Copernicus, who realized that Earth was not the center of the solar system,
and relates Copper's epiphany to Copernicus's in terms of magnitude. It is from this that Copper
gets his nickname, translated by some as Koppa or Koparun, short for Copernicus. Through a kind of
metaphor, how do you live wants to speak to us about our lives, and I believe this spirit resides in
If you're still with me, particularly if you're also a creative soul who's grown with the Miyazaki
films, then indulge me one last idea. I don't think of the Grand Uncle as Takahata. I think
it's Miyazaki himself. He has crafted the worlds we were raised in, thirteen of them across almost
fifty years. The only thing he couldn't do was find a successor, someone else who could hear the
call and add their block to the pile. But if the Great Uncle is Miyazaki, who is Mojito? Who is the
sincere one who can take over where Miyazaki left off? Who has lived in his worlds and heard his
call to create? I have journeyed across time and space to bring these thirteen blocks to you.
When I heard that block, I cried. It wasn't because I saw that The Boy and the Heron was
a metaphor for films. It was because I heard Miyazaki speak of the endeavor he devoted his
whole life to, and in that moment, he'd given it to me. Mojito is us. Miyazaki has spent decades
crafting worlds of beauty and warmth that we've consumed heartily for years. We that took to the
arts. Whether or not you went to school, whether or not you film, draw, write, build, or just
imagine, we are the children of Miyazaki's legacy, and it's time for us to give back.
Most of you watching don't have a studio at your fingertips ready to make an animated film.
I imagine some of you don't consider yourselves artists. Personally, I studied film and animation
for years, but I never cut it in the industry, and maybe I never will. Maybe the industry is the
world of death, and we are the water being eaten. But even if I were lifted up to that tower, I
wouldn't be another Miyazaki. I can't be. Not even the other Ghibli directors could. And maybe that's
what Miyazaki has come to understand. That no one can be him. But that's not what he's asked of us.
At the end of Mahito's journey, after almost being eaten, captured, burned, and seeing what's
important to him both within and without this magical world, the Great Uncle gives him one
request. Create beautiful worlds, untainted by malice. Beauty, sincerity, heart. These things
are core to all the Miyazaki films. They are perhaps core to life itself. All of us can create
beauty in our own ways, and when you create, you are vulnerable to malice. You're vulnerable to be
eaten up by criticism, capitalism, indifference, insecurity, and above all, the temptation for
insincerity. The temptation to act like you don't care. To hide your true self so at least you won't
get eaten. But the sincere ones are those destined for the world of the dead. For the dying world of
creation, where so many pure ideas will see their end, but that can't compare to the power of our
calling. Create beautiful worlds, untouched by malice. If you have only passively consumed the
beauty of Miyazaki's worlds, if you have drudged on letting beauty be compromised for whatever you
thought was more important, if you have lost your sincerity, this is Miyazaki telling us in simple
terms what to do. In How Do You Live, Copper and his uncle explore life through their back and
forth. His uncle doesn't tell him what to do, but rather expands on what he's already doing,
connects it to something bigger. To the best version of who Copper can be. The boy in the
For most, the meaning of Ghibli has always been clear. It is, in large part, the whimsical
worlds of Hayao Miyazaki. But that cannot be true forever. Nippon Television acquired Studio Ghibli
this past September, and even though the 82-year-old Miyazaki stated that he's not retiring
and will return for his next movie soon, the age of Miyazaki is coming to a close. But the age of
We can be the successors that Miyazaki never found. His film is our rallying cry. I know not
everyone will resonate with the interpretation I've put forth here, but I hope you'll consider
re-watching the film with this framework in mind. Spot all the allusions to the Ghibli films,
assess the meanings of this world through the lens of Miyazaki's life, the life of any creative
figure, and maybe even your own life. But when you're done, I hope you'll join me in taking his
creed to heart. Go forth and create worlds without malice and full of beauty. And so we return to
where this metaphor started to click. The blocks. Yes, the blocks. Meow.