How did K-Line rise from obscurity to a major power in the world of toy trains, and how did K-Line fall so quickly and so dramatically into oblivion? Here’s the story:
By the dawn of 2005, K-Line’s future looked bright indeed. Their product line spanned the gamut from scale models of classic steam and contemporary SD70 diesels, to innovative accessories like the Super Streets line, to budget products like the under $50 Husky line of Geeps and the well-built but budget-priced Train 19 line of rolling stock aimed at the starter market.
But it would soon come crashing down.
“Under the terms of the settlement, K-Line and the other defendants, Maury Klein and Robert Grubba, admitted that they paid Lionel’s chief engineer to develop advanced versions of Lionel’s operating systems and features that were used in a number of K-Line’s engines and electrical transformers. They further admitted that these products actually contain Lionel’s technology and are currently for sale in the marketplace.
“In late July, Lionel filed a complaint…against K-Line, its owner Maury Klein and Robert Grubba, a former Lionel employee now working for K-Line. The…train maker claimed that the defendants had enlisted Marty Pierson, then Lionel’s employee and chief engineer, to work surreptitiously with K-Line, and incorporate Lionel’s current sound, speed control and electrical transformers into some of the K-Line products.” The statement pulled no punches in assigning blame squarely on the shoulders of K-Line and its owner. They had cheated and had been caught.
K-Line’s public statement announcing the settlement told a different story altogether. They wrote in part, “While K-LINE hired as an outside consultant a Lionel engineer…he was not hired to develop advances on Lionel technology, but to create superior alternatives. For example, K-LINE's Cruise Control is not related in any way to Lionel's Odyssey System.
The sound and speed control products were developed by Marty Pierson in collaboration with K-LINE engineers. However, certain agreements he signed as a Lionel employee gave Lionel a claim of ownership of this work.”
K-Line flatly denied all guilt in the matter and argued that Lionel was winning the case by a technicality only. This was a monumental mistake.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of the eBay Partner Network, I may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
The rise and sudden crash of K-Line trains. How a single press release wrecked a toy train empire.
On this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Hello again, this is Mike from Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
20 years ago was a magical time for three rail hobbyists.
While Lionel Trains was celebrating a century of toy train production,
an unprecedented number of manufacturers were making quality trains for the O-Gage market.
Baby boomers, then in the prime of their earning years,
were not only buying the post-war trains of their youth, driving prices higher and higher in the
process, but they were also purchasing new products of Lionel, MTH, Atlas-O, Weaver,
Williams, and others. And right in the mix was K-Line. In fact, more than in the mix.
As 2005 dawned, K-Line Trains was firmly established as one of the
big three O-Gage train manufacturers, along with Lionel and MTH.
But by the end of that year, K-Line had all but vanished.
How did K-Line rise from obscurity to a major power in the world of toy trains? And
how did K-Line fall so quickly and so dramatically into oblivion?
Here's the story. Receiving his first train at age four,
Maury D. Kline's train collection continued to grow, and by 1974, he was repairing and
selling toy trains while completing his studies at the University of North Carolina.
He founded MDK in 1975 and was soon selling trains by mail order.
By 1979, the firm expanded into manufacturing, making O and 027 track and later American
under the name of MDK K-Line. In addition, MDK K-Line produced a series of repair manuals and
layout building guides, largely reprints of post-war Lionel diagrams and brochures.
This one is still my go-to source for Lionel post-war repair information.
In 1980, MDK purchased the tooling from the old Marksline of Marksville Plastic Buildings,
and by 1981, K-Lineville featured a supermarket, police station, school,
firehouse, airport hangar, firehouse, ranch, house, church, and more.
Soon, K-Line added reissues of Marks accessories, such as the crossing gate and automatic switch
tower. In an oft-repeated story, Maury Kline and his plant manager Brent Chambers found
the molds for the Marks Model 333 and 1829 steam locomotives in a dilapidated Fisher
Warehouse near Buffalo, New York in 1984. The warehouse was unlighted, unheated,
was missing part of its roof. The K-Line versions of the Alco S2 switcher and RDC
butt cars were also based on recast Marks body shells. Unsuccessful with their own line of
starter sets, Williams sold most of their former Kusan trains to Linked MDK in 1986,
who quickly put it to good use. K-Line was now positioned to challenge Lionel in the
budget 027 trains market with a full line of rolling stock, accessories, structures,
a revamped Kusan FA, and Marks S2 diesels. In addition, a brand new MP15 switcher in 1987
further entrenched K-Line in the starter set and budget 027 train market.
K-Line masterfully arranged for the production of dozens of limited-run,
officially licensed sets for firms like Procter & Gamble, True Value Hardware,
both Hershey's and Nestle products, and somehow both Pepsi and Coke. These sets proved popular
with both train operators and collectors of those various brands. By 1993, K-Line offered a 68-page
full-color catalog, full of colorful trains including the newly refurbished former Marks
Pacific and 464 Hudson steamers, including Smoke and Whistles in the Tender.
K-Line had tightened its grip on the budget and starter set market with competitively-priced,
good-running, colorful trains for the 027 line, but the firm had its sights on more.
In addition to newly-tooled 027 streamlined passenger cars and highly-detailed traditional
freight cars in its Classics line, by the mid-1990s K-Line also offered a line of full-scale,
72-foot heavyweight passenger cars, a growing roster of steam and diesel locomotives,
and contemporary intermodal cars for scale-oriented operators as well.
In 1999, K-Line introduced a series of scale-detailed extruded aluminum passenger cars
in 15-inch, 18-inch, and 21-inch lengths, and many collectors still consider these
to be the finest streamlined passenger cars ever produced for the free-rail O-Gage market.
More scale diesels and steam locomotives soon followed,
many using Lionel's TMC command control system under license.
K-Line's scale products generally held up favorably in both detail and operation,
with the finest offerings by Lionel at MTH at the time, and K-Line products were often
sold for much less. In fact, many of K-Line's scale offerings were priced at or below cost
in an effort to take market share from their two main competitors.
By the dawn of 2005, K-Line's future looked bright indeed. Their product line spanned
the gamut from scale models of classic steam and contemporary SD70 diesels,
to innovative accessories like the Super Street Lines, to budget products like the under $50
Husky line of Jeeps, and the well-built-but-budget-priced Train 19 line of Rolling Stock
aimed at the starter market. But it would soon come crashing down.
Throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, K-Line, MTH, and Lionel frequently ran ads attacking
one another as the competition for toy train dollars intensified. In a move that would prove
disastrous, K-Line hired several former Lionel employees and hired a current Lionel employee
as a consultant in an attempt to speed up product development and improve model technology.
When K-Line introduced a new PowerChief transformer,
Lionel noticed striking similarities between this design and the Lionel CW80 transformer.
Likewise, K-Line's new locomotive cruise control circuitry mimicked Lionel's Odyssey system.
Lionel soon found other similarities in K-Line's new tech and quickly determined the sources of
the apparent information leaks. The Lion roared and took K-Line to court for patent infringement
in July 2005. Mere weeks later, on August 10, 2005, the two sides reached a quick and amicable
out-of-court settlement. K-Line agreed to withdraw all of the tech in question by the end of January
2006, pay back royalties to Lionel for the disputed tech until then, and pay Lionel $700,000 in legal
fees. K-Line would also license some of their new tech to Lionel going forward. This was a very
generous settlement on Lionel's part. The financial burden would certainly have harmed K-Line in the
short run, but with an estimated $7 million in annual sales according to court documents,
K-Line could still have had a successful 2005 holiday season with the products already in the
pipeline and would survive to make trains another day. Lionel's public statement regarding the
settlement said, in part, quote, Under the terms of the settlement, K-Line and the other defendants,
Mari Klein and Robert Grubba, admitted that they paid Lionel's chief engineer to develop advanced
versions of Lionel's operating systems and features that were used in a number of K-Line's engines and
electrical transformers. They further admitted that these products actually contain Lionel's
technology and are currently for sale in the marketplace. In late July, Lionel filed a
complaint against K-Line, its owner Mari Klein and Robert Grubba, a former Lionel employee now
working for K-Line. The trainmaker claimed that the defendants had enlisted Marty Pearson,
then Lionel's employee and chief engineer, to work surreptitiously with K-Line and incorporate
Lionel's current sound, speed control, and electrical transformers into some of the K-Line
products. The statement pulled no punches in assigning blame squarely on the shoulders of K-Line
and its owner. They had cheated and had been caught. K-Line's public statement announcing
the settlement told a different story altogether. They wrote in part,
While K-Line hired as an outside consultant a Lionel engineer, he was not hired to develop
advances on Lionel technology, but to create superior alternatives. For example, K-Line's
cruise control is not related in any way to Lionel's Odyssey system. The sound and speed
control products were developed by Marty Pearson in collaboration with K-Line engineers. However,
certain agreements he signed as a Lionel employee gave Lionel a claim of ownership of this work.
K-Line flatly denied all guilt in the matter and argued that Lionel was winning the case
by a technicality. This was a monumental mistake. Lionel furiously claimed that K-Line's statement
was a violation of the terms of the settlement. On August 22, the court agreed and placed an
immediate injunction on the sale of any and all disputed technology. K-Line filed for Chapter 11
bankruptcy protection the following day, and a new settlement was reached with Lionel on October 27,
2005. This new settlement placed an immediate and permanent ban on K-Line's use of the disputed
technology, required $2 million in damages to be paid to Lionel, and ensured Lionel's royalty-free
use of certain K-Line patents. In effect, it was the death penalty for K-Line. Any disputed tech
that had not already been delivered to K-Line dealers and customers was embargoed, so there
would be no holiday season for K-Line in 2005. The combination of the financial damages to Lionel
and the loss of royalty and sales income, combined with its own legal fees,
made it impossible for K-Line to continue operations. Shipments of products to dealers
were placed on hold, as the embargo affected not only high-end locomotives but also
starter-set transformers. With little income, K-Line was also unable to pay its suppliers,
and the company laid off workers. By December 2005, all K-Line operations had ceased.
It was over. On February 16, 2006, Lionel announced that it had purchased K-Line.
Ironically, Lionel was itself in bankruptcy protection due to its own ongoing $40 million
legal case with MTH Trains concerning Lionel's illegal use of MTH's intellectual property.
After the required approval by the bankruptcy courts, the deal was finalized on April 18, 2006.
Lionel transferred ownership of most of K-Line's assets to Chinese firm Sandakan
to pay off K-Line's manufacturing debts, and they in turn licensed the K-Line name and intellectual
property back to Lionel. Lionel agreed to honor and fulfill any outstanding orders of K-Line
products. Meanwhile, Sandakan briefly formed Sun Models Corp. as a means of liquidating
unsold K-Line inventory. Lionel continued to produce K-Line products under the
K-Line by Lionel banner until 2010, and then the K-Line name disappeared. Sandakan then sold much
of K-Line's tooling to other firms, such as Williams by Bachman, Atlas O, and Readymade
Trains. Today, the only firm producing starter sets for the three-rail market is Lionel. Their
dedication to Lion-chief remote technology means that no one is producing low-cost,
conventionally controlled O-gauge sets. And while Lionel's Bluetooth technology is impressive,
it also comes with an equally impressive price tag that pushes many families out of the toy
train market. Might we someday see a new starter set led by a re-issued K-Line Pacific or MP-15?
Time will tell. Tooling seems to last forever in the toy train market, and someday,
someone may decide that the time is right for a K-Line revival. Until then, K-Line trains will
live on in online auctions, at train shows, and in the fond memories of their former owners.
I hope you enjoyed this episode as much as I enjoyed making it, and if so,
please tell your friends and neighbors, and especially that YouTube algorithm,
by giving us a like, a share, a subscribe, or comment about your memories of K-Line trains.
And don't forget to check the video description for links to some of the trains I mentioned in
this episode. Whatever brand you have, keep the trains riding, and I'll see you next time
on Toy Train Tips and Tricks.