The First Image of St. Francis- Subiaco, Italy - EWTN Vaticano

Artifact Archives
9 followers
1 Video View·Mar 4, 2026
High above the Aniene Valley, a monastery clings to the rock.
This is the Holy Cave, built around the grotto where Saint Benedict of Nursia
withdrew as a young hermit, letting silence, prayer and work shape a new path for the Church
of Western Monasticism. But deep inside these caves is an unexpected glimpse of another saint,
Saint Francis. Father Maurizio Vivera, prior of the Sacro Speco Monastery, reveals that Saint
Francis of Assisi came here searching for what Benedict found here first, silence, prayer and
the beauty of creation.
Francis came here and stayed for a time and then he was, in a sense, immortalized because we have
this very famous fresco. And he surely remained here in prayer, out of devotion to the Benedictines
who would later inspire him in some way. In fact, we can say that when Francis first begins his
journey, he has no idea of founding an order. He wants to live on his own. His model is Saint
Benedict. But later, he sets that idea aside and founds the Franciscan Order.
That immortalized image is still here in the caves, drawing pilgrims in to witness Saint Francis
as a living man. And few know this place better than Martina Amati, an art historian who welcomes
hundreds of visitors each day. She calls Francis the most famous pilgrim of them all and she takes
us inside the Chapel of Saint Gregory to show what she describes as an ancient photograph of his visit.
Welcome to the Chapel of Saint Gregory, where the true effigy of Francis is kept.
This portrait was probably made during Francis of Assisi's visit here in 1223.
He came to accompany Ugolino d'Ostia, who would later become Pope Gregory IX.
During that visit, he consecrated a small chapel and that is probably why an anonymous monk
of the monastery decided to paint Saint Francis's portrait.
And in that image, Francis appears in his early 40s, not as a saint, but as a friar. Simple habit,
rope belt, holding a message of peace.
Here, Francis is portrayed probably at his real life size, more or less what people's average
height was at the time. First of all, there's no halo, which suggests he was still alive.
He's identified simply as Brother Francis. He's wearing that ash gray habit, which indicates this
is before the formal approval of the Franciscan order, which would come a few months later under
Pope Honorius III. And he has no stigmata, which he would receive the following year at La Verna in 1224.
Up close, the Byzantine-influenced style invites a spiritual reading. In the language of iconography,
some interpret the enlarged ears as attentiveness to the word of God, the strong throat as a sign
of being filled with the Holy Spirit, and the hand at the heart as the source of peace. And in his
left hand, a scroll reads Pax Vic Domui, peace to this house. But the fresco doesn't speak
only in symbols. It also preserves a striking historical detail, one that points to the real
Francis. What tells us this is Francis is a detail in his face. You can see that one eye is larger
and the other smaller. This is probably the sign of a harsh eye operation Francis underwent at
near Rieti before coming to Subiaco. In treatment for what is thought to have been an eye infection,
he likely contracted in the Holy Land.
For centuries, pilgrims have come to this sanctuary and many have left something behind.
Names, prayers, and marks etched into the walls, often near the saints they felt closest to.
And on Francis's portrait, Martina points to a signature that surprises visitors.
For example, on the portrait of Francis, you can find what he might call
an illustrious signature because it reads, I was Pope Pius II. We know that Pope Pius,
il piccolomini, passed through here in 1461, visiting the monasteries and he left his name.
Martina Amati says this portrait became a model, an image of Francis that began to spread,
shaping how later artists would picture him. Even in Cimabue's famous fresco in Assisi.
And you can see that spread already here, a later copy on the opposite wall. Together,
they form what art historians sometimes call a double portrait of Francis of Assisi,
pointing even more strongly to his visit to this place.
