John Quincy Adams, son of John, grew up amid the turmoil of the revolution. At just 14, he served as interpreter of French for America’s first minister in Russia. He grew into a diplomat, a secretary of state, a president, and a ferociously anti-slavery congressman—after leaving office. He saw deep into the heart of the Declaration’s logic and made it his guiding light. Browsing the diary of JQA, contributing editor Christopher Flannery and associate editor Spencer Klavan delight in the sixth president’s achievements, his towering ambitions, and his oddly relatable notes of self-reproach. Plus: a peek at CRBs to come! #claremontinstitute#johnadams#foundingfathers#america250#foundinganniversary#americanpresidents
Coming up on this episode of The Close Read.
You know, I read that America goes out abroad and I react to it the way most people would,
but behind it is a massive assertion of the truth and significance of the American Revolution and
the inevitability, the providential certainty that the American Revolution will spread to all
mankind. In God's good time, he says in that speech, you know, he says, I expect there's
going to be centuries of wars between illegitimate power and struggling right in Europe. But the
people there should know they can see in America, there's hope.
Hello, and welcome once again to The Close Read, your official podcast from the Claremont Review
of Books. I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor of the Claremont Review of Books.
And we have been sitting down all this month and actually last month, too, on the show to
talk through our massive banner issue, our double issue for the 25th anniversary of CRB,
volume 26, number one, fall 2025 and winter 2026. And it's my great pleasure to be joined again
today by our very own contributing editor, Christopher Flannery. Chris,
welcome back to The Close Read. Spencer, very happy to join you.
Yeah, this will be really fun because I have been actually wanting to do one of these with you about
John Quincy Adams. We've been talking a little bit off the show about him, and
he's been somebody very much on your minds. I think, you know, you wrote a piece for us,
a really lovely essay in this latest issue called JQA's Ambition that's mostly about his diary
entries, which I hope we will get into. But I'd like to start kind of at a higher level,
at a thousand-foot level, and just talk to you about what drew you to this figure. He's obviously
not a little-known guy. People especially, I think, are familiar with his speech about foreign
policy, that we don't go abroad looking for monsters to destroy. But you really give us
a lot more of him and a lot more of his career, both kind of in childhood with his father,
John Adams, perhaps his more famous father, but then leading up to all of his government posts.
I'm curious what set you on this journey and why John Quincy Adams seemed like a figure that
was important to be studying now. Yeah. Well, I've been interested in the Adams family for
forever, you could say. Of course, they're America's greatest American family. I've studied
John Adams, and some 20 years ago or so, I was asked to write an essay on Henry Adams,
very, very interesting Henry Adams, and I spent a better part of a year or so sort of immersing
myself in him. Partly, he led me to John Quincy Adams. He writes a lot about him, his grandfather,
and I just never got a chance to pursue it myself. So it's really the Adams family that
led me to ultimately John Quincy. And then it turns out, he is a very interesting man
in his own right. Being president was kind of his least accomplishment in a way.
So he had really a 60-year American political career, and he literally gave his life to his
country. And he died on the floor of Congress when he was about 80 years old,
really giving it his last. He was standing up to speak, a stroke or something came upon him,
and that was it. He literally died in the chamber of Congress.
Where do you think that came from? Was that his parents? Obviously, John Adams,
not just a president, but I think somebody with a very deep, deeply ingrained kind of
moral sense of industry and patriotism and service. Is that something he passed on to
young J.Q.? I know you read that little squib on the diary. So his mother and his father both
gave him ambition. His mother told him, your destiny is to look after your country,
take care of your country. His father told him, it's your own fault, your own laziness,
if you don't become president of this country and so on. Of course, he gave much more. So
he had that from the earliest days. But more than even their parental instruction,
they were both revolutionaries. When this kid was seven years old,
his mother took him up to a hill to go look at the Battle of Bunker Hill. His father was so
worried. His father was not home. He was out being a revolutionary. And he had to write home
to say, look, if the British soldiers are coming to your home, run to the woods, take the children
and run to the woods. So he lived the revolution when he was just a kid. And then, I don't know
if you know this, I didn't know this, but in immersing myself in it, when he was about 10 or
11, his father took him to Europe. You know, just getting to Europe was not them. I mean,
it was very dangerous. They could have been hijacked by British warships. The weather
itself could have killed them. Anyway, they went to Europe when he was about 10. And he spent
the years from about 11 years old to 18 in Europe with his father, traveled to Russia,
became fluent in French, really got his primary education from about 11 years old to 17
in France, in Holland, in Russia. And there, I mean, he became very good at Greek, very good
at Latin. He was fluent in French, which is why he went to Russia, because the American who was
being sent there to be our minister didn't know enough French, which was the language of diplomacy
to get on. So the 14-year-old JQA goes with him across Europe in order to translate for
this American mission. So he got his involvement in America, not only from, say, his parents
teaching him, but he lived it. I mean, his father was over there being a revolutionary diplomat,
and his son was his private secretary at age 14 or 15.
Yeah. I think I remember from David McCullough's wonderful biography of John Adams,
some descriptions of those voyages they took together, father and son across the ocean,
extraordinarily perilous. But I did not know that he then became the official interpreter for the
embassy to Russia, it must have been, the ambassador.
Our first, well, it was our first, I think, yeah. I mean, we didn't have,
we were in a revolution. We were hardly a country. And so to get even, to get a minister
accepted in the court was a huge thing. But then you got a minister who didn't quite know enough
French. There's something kind of wonderfully American about that, actually.
So they take a 14-year-old kid over there to do his job.
So yeah, as you say, there's a wonderful quote in this piece. His father wrote to him when the
26-year-old was wavering a bit about his future, you come into life with advantages which will
disgrace you if your success is mediocre, with an accent aigu over the E. So I guess
Adams' pair was also studying French. And if you do not rise to the head of your country,
it will be owing to your own laziness, slovenliness, and obstinacy. Emphasis in the
original, you tell us. So of course, as you say, he did rise to become president, but you just
mentioned that's maybe not the most impressive achievement. Is it his term as Secretary of State
that you think really serves as the climax of his? Well, oddly enough, amazingly, and he could
never have predicted this himself, he was a great Secretary of State. And those words you quoted,
America goes not abroad in search of monsters to destroy, those were his most famous words.
They came out of his time as Secretary of State in a 4th of July oration. That's one thing I'm
writing about now. But yes, he was great as Secretary of State. He had a more or less 20-year
career as a diplomat before that that was very important and very accomplished. So by the time
he became Secretary of State, he was America's most experienced and preeminent diplomatist.
So all that's true, and then he becomes president. But then amazingly, his career that really
eventually became most famous for him was what Samuel Flagg Bemis calls his second career.
He went into Congress. He's the only president ever to do that. He spent nine terms in Congress
after being president. And as I say, he died as a congressman trying to do his duty on the floor.
So his second career became in a way more famous because it was an anti-slavery career. It was a
very different thing for him. And on that one issue, he played hell with the slavocracy for
30 years almost. Wow. Wow. And was that the issue that they were debating when he died?
It was related. It was a related thing. He was against the Mexican War and he was not willing
to approve honors to soldiers who served in that war because he thought it was a bad
cause. And so he was arguing that point at the time, if I remember correctly.
A man of incredible principle, much like his father, and perhaps ornery a little bit like his
father in service of a good cause. The real, to me, standout of this essay on his
diary entries is the series of quotations you give us, mostly from his birthday,
where he's just telling us how miserably wretched he feels because he hasn't accomplished
more. I find these weirdly consoling, I have to say, that this is the way John Quincy Adams still
feels, even though he's done so much. Yeah. It really is amazing. And he is
amazing in that way. And interesting. He was a real porcupine. He was so prickly
that people became scared to approach him. And he just had a really tough exterior. Part of it
was that principledness that you mentioned, that he, I've got my principles and you violate them
and don't come near me. But his rectitude was astounding. And it was very forbidding to many
people. And yet, there's a portrait of him as a young man that's very charming.
And as a young man, he liked to go out singing with his friends, dancing with the young ladies.
He played the flute. He composed poetry. His real ambition, which he stated many times
convincingly, he wanted a life of literature. So he thought, if you're going to make your
place in the world, that's the place to do it. So his early and even lifelong and unsatisfied
ambition was to accomplish something astounding in the realm of literature.
And in the end, he did that with his diary, I would say. Although, of course,
he was very disappointed with that. So we read, I mean, this day completes my 20th year,
and yet I am good for nothing and cannot even carry myself forward into the world.
Forty-five, same thing, two-thirds of a long life are past, and I have done nothing to distinguish
it by usefulness to my country or to mankind. But the diary as his great contribution to American
letters is really quite something to think about. I mean, it's kind of a lost art, but of course,
Samuel Pepys and many others have given us the diary as art object. So do you think this is,
I mean, are there editions available for people to look at?
You know, there was his son produced the first edition of it, a 10 or 12-volume edition in 1875
or so. That was quite a revelation because it had not circulated. I mean, these were revelations
about this man that no one had known. But his son, being the good son he was, left out of it
practically everything personally. So it's as if John Quincy Adams wasn't married, didn't have
children, didn't have problems at all. So it's all about his public life. And even there, it's
careful not to get in too much controversy. But that was the first edition. There was a one-volume
edition after that worth reading. But now there's a two-volume Library of America edition edited by
a guy named Walt Stryker. It came out only in 2017. And that's the one to get, I think.
As you know, the complete diary is available and accessible online, which is an amazing
thing, searchable. But I would say, I mean, nobody, unless you've really studied the stuff,
you don't know what to look for exactly. Unless you want to do birthdays or New Year's or a certain
speech or something, you could do that. So Walt Stryker's two-volume edition is the one to get,
Library of America 2017, Diaries of John Quincy Adams. And one reason it's good is the apparatus
is very helpful. The introduction, the various levels of notes, they tell you an awful lot of
stuff that most people wouldn't know on their own that help you kind of even search the online
diary if you get that interested. So yeah, David Walt Stryker, Library of America 2017.
It's really fascinating to contemplate that a document like this, I'm comparing it in my mind
as you're talking to the Gallic War, which is the work of Julius Caesar that I reviewed for this
issue. And what struck me about reading that again was how astonishing it is to have an insight into
this world historic figure's kind of strategery and camaraderie. It's kind of the inner workings
of his soul. But even that is a publicly prepared document. It's something that people were
intended to read. In fact, it very much is an act of propaganda or self-presentation, at least.
And nowadays, our presidents probably, well, I don't know if they write more,
but they certainly write big autobiographical tomes. I'm thinking especially of Barack Obama's
doorstopper of an autobiography, but they don't probably write diaries. This art is a lost one.
And I wonder whether future generations will have the same degree of insight into the private thoughts
of presidents as we have into JQA. Yeah, that's an interesting thought.
I don't know from what I can tell in our age, we don't do this. It is remarkable.
It's not just John Quincy Adams, but the prior generation of his father's generation.
One thing that their letter writing is amazing. They spent hours, literally hours a day
at a desk with a quill pen, writing letters and then copying them until Jefferson made his famous
little copy machine. Right. The auto pen. His first draft of the auto pen. Yeah. Right.
So JQA, on many days, I mean, he literally spent two, three, four hours physically writing
his diary. And then he had his letters to write and other memoranda for the State Department or
Congress. So a big part of his life was just sitting at a table writing. And by the way,
if you go online, you can look at his diaries, any page of it. His writing is quite impressive.
I mean, you can read it. It's very legible. His father said, big advice from a father,
write clearly, have a clean hand. Wow. Yeah. Penmanship, another lost art. And I can't claim
to be a practitioner of either of these arts. I'm not doing my part to carry them forward.
Letter writing, I mean, we complain now about all the emails we have to answer, but
this must have just been, as you say, a Herculean task and a major part of the business of life.
Talk to me a little bit about the stuff you're writing about now. You mentioned that you're
working on a bigger piece for us about Adams. And is it focusing on his philosophy as Secretary of
State? Did I get that right? It's a little broader, broader and narrower in a way.
So yeah, I had meant to write, I don't know what it was going to be, but a longer piece.
So now this piece is about John Quincy Adams on the 4th of July.
And so he, in anticipation of Lincoln, John Quincy Adams really made the Declaration of
Independence his North Star. It was a guide of all his politics, foreign and domestic. So as
he was in his late 30s and early 40s, while he was still a United States Senator for a time,
he was the Boylston Professor of Rhetoric and Oratory and did that for a handful of years.
So he was officially and deliberately and self-consciously an orator. He was a deep
student lifelong of Cicero. He loved Cicero. That was his model, and he studied him deeply
and taught him. And so it turns out that he gave three official 4th of July orations in his career,
one in 1793 when he was pretty much unknown, one in 1821 when he was Secretary of State.
I'm just trying to struggle to get this into John Kinker right now.
You and I both, my friend.
I know, he mentioned that he had it written on YouTube. And then he gave another one in 1831
when he had been President, he had been Secretary of State, and he was now elected to Congress,
and he hadn't yet gone. So three different eras of his career, three 4th of July orations,
each is very different. And he, being a professional orator, he's very conscious that
he doesn't want to repeat himself. So he makes as much as he can certain that he's
offering something new in these things. So this piece is about John Quincy Adams on the 4th of
July, and it's really going to concentrate on those orations.
Oh, how lovely. Yeah, I did not know this about his professional background in oratory
and the theory of it. You're making me think because I'm teaching Plato's Phaedrus right now,
which is one of his dialogues about rhetoric. Wow, beautiful, yeah.
Yeah. Sometimes paired with the Gorgias, which is also about,
is rhetoric an art? And in both of those, Socrates, in his kind of cheeky way, ends up
interrogating people about whether rhetoric is an art. And it always turns out that
actually the true art of rhetoric is philosophy, right? In order to really write a great speech,
it's not some separate discipline. It's actually, do you know sort of the ideals and the truth?
And I would imagine that for a guy like John Quincy Adams, that's a very appealing thought,
that he's a rhetorician, but his rhetoric is sort of informed by this, as you say, this deep
attachment to the principle of the Declaration. And that's a major Claremont theme, of course.
I wonder, yeah, if you could talk a little bit about how that makes itself felt in this speech,
which people, as you say, quote a lot, but maybe haven't read as much in full recently. Can you
talk about how the Declaration kind of informs that?
Yeah. And the other thing too, so John Quincy Adams, a student of the classics, he knew,
he understood that man is a political animal because he is a rational animal. That man was
Logos' speech and reason. And he understood as an American statesman that you needed to
base yourself on the Logos of the Declaration of Independence. The word fitly spoken,
the apple of gold in the Declaration was his word, his Logos, that really he built his politics on,
and his oratory. And he was, by the way, he was a very serious Christian man. And he re-read the
Bible every year. He would translate it from the Greek into the French, or into verse. He read it
very seriously. He took it very seriously. And it informed his politics and his understanding
of the Declaration as well. In his view, the reason that informs the Declaration emerged in
the history of the world, among other things, through the religious struggles in Europe
that led through the Protestant Reformation to a recognition of the access to reason that
human beings have that they have not seen before. And that reason, the Logos,
informs the Declaration of Independence for him, and in God's providence, will make its way in the
world everywhere. And so the one thing that probably, when we hear that America goes not
abroad in search of monsters to destroy, we quite reasonably think of things like George
Kennan and containment policy. This is a kind of realist expression that America is not out
for forever wars. We're not trying to impose American systems in the world. This kind of,
there's a restraint in that phrase, right? And there is. But in his speech, which as usual,
was full of what we would certainly reasonably see as grandiloquence. I mean, he would throw
things, you know, Cicero, John Donne, you know, John Milton, the Bible, anything, it's all going
in there. But in that speech, his real emphasis is that America is the city on the hill. It's
founded on the principles that are true. The only true legitimate principles of government
are our principles. And those principles will come to prevail against the feudal monarchies in Europe,
against savagery and barbarism in the world. In God's good time, they will make their way in
the world. But we go not abroad in search of monsters to destroy. We're not going to be the
overthrowing monarchies and so on. But we want you to know that your time
is coming. Freedom is coming to you too, all the peoples of the world and so on. So that emphasis
in his speech is very strong. And his denunciation of European colonialism, for example, is very
strong in that piece. And so that's really the setting for that famous America goes not abroad.
I find this so interesting. I mean, we talked a little bit about it earlier, not on this podcast,
but exactly as you say, this is a speech which is associated with that big I word,
isolationism, right? And it is perhaps the most elegant slogan that isolationists have.
And yet the brand of isolationism that we're most familiar with now, I think, is rooted actually in
a radical skepticism or agnosticism about what the best form of government is for other people.
It's, I think, made in major ways influenced by the failures of the Middle East wars and this
sense that has sort of crept upon people that maybe places like Afghanistan just simply aren't
fit to have democracy. Whereas the critique that Adams would make, it sounds like is,
no, it's simply that you aren't fit to determine when democracy comes or when self-government comes
to Afghanistan. That we are not God's agents across the whole world, but that we do have a
real confidence, like this very passionate confidence about what God ultimately intends
for the civilizations of man. I just think that's a really key distinction to recover.
I'm excited to read you more on it because I think it has real valence,
wouldn't you say, for a lot of the foreign policy discussions we're having now?
Yeah, it really does. And that's the thing I'm struggling with now to try to get
down to send in John. And I think I've got it more or less, but yeah, I mean,
it surprised me in a way. I read that America goes out abroad and I react to it the way
most people would. But behind it is a massive assertion of the truth and significance of the
American Revolution and the inevitability, the providential certainty that the American Revolution
will spread to all mankind. In God's good time, he says in that speech,
I expect there's going to be centuries of wars between illegitimate power and struggling right
in Europe. But the people there should know they can see in America, there's hope.
Wow. Well, that's beautifully put and I think a fitting place for us to end until
our listeners all rush to newsstands to pick up our next issue. The issue we're currently
discussing is the double issue, which is online now. And just as a reminder, of course, you can
find it at claremontreviewofbooks.com. It's up there, although Chris's essay currently at least
is behind the paywall. So that means if you haven't subscribed, you won't be able to read
John Quincy Adams as he thrashes himself year on year for his inadequacies and laziness.
And who wouldn't want to read about that? Seriously, it is a great piece.
The shorter piece by Chris is up there. And of course, the longer one will be in the new issue.
So one more time, it's claremontreviewofbooks.com to become a subscriber, which if you haven't
already, we very much hope you will. But Chris, this is just so delightful. I could learn about
John Quincy Adams from you all day. And I hope we will continue to discuss him as the years go by.
Thanks for coming.
Glad to be your assistant. Thank you.