Warranties Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
#learning #law #education
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In the previous lesson what we did was spend a little bit of time talking about
conditions as a type of term within a contractual arrangement. We talked about what a condition is
and we talked about how conditions really strike to the root of a contract, they really strike at
the heart of a contractual agreement. And we noted that this is reflective in the ways in which this
would then relate to the breach of a condition and how this would change the scope of remedies
that may be available in those circumstances. This lesson is going to talk about warranties,
warranties being a different type of term that exists in a contract and what they mean,
how they operate and how we can determine what the warranty may be. So we noted in the previous
lesson that conditions are fundamentally the main and most fundamental contractual terms
available to the parties. The next type of terms that are expressed terms, at least within a
contract, are warranties. Of course there is this existence of what are known as implied terms which
we will get to in future lessons. So the key element of the condition within the contract
is that a condition speaks to the heart of the contract itself. It is the main thing that the
contract is established for and it is the main thing that the contract exists to achieve. If
we remember back to the previous lesson, the Poussard and Spiers case, the key element which
was identified to be a condition within the contract was that the singer in question is able
to perform at the operetta. This was a contract between the operetta and the singer for the
singer to perform. So the purpose of the contract is for the singer to perform for some payment
and so the heart of the contract, the fundamental part of the contract,
the fundamental part of the contract is actually the idea of them singing, the contractual
obligation for them to be singing. This is because without this action on the part of the
claimant, i.e. the contract itself, the singing itself, then the contract would be rendered
effectively useless. So we can essentially make a distinction therefore between a condition on
the one hand and a warranty on the other, given that a condition pertains to the ability for a
contract to continue. And so as a result of this you might have lots of different terms in a
contract. All of these different terms and conditions do all different kinds of
things. Conditions are required to allow for the contract to continue and then warranties may
may or may not be breached and there may or may not be any kind of remedy in place,
but that there could still be the continuation of the contract if this was to happen.
And so this gives us a very interesting illustration of what a warranty is. In some
cases contracts will have terms which are somewhat subordinate to that of the key conditions, to that
of the main element of the contract itself. These are terms which will still require performance
and if they are not performed, for example there could still be the attachment of a remedy, but
they are not terms which necessarily destroy the whole purpose of the contract. Let's remember then
back to the case of Poussard and Spiers and let's say we have a contract therefore between
the singer and the operator for the singer to sing at the operator. Let's assume that within this
contract there is also a term that says that the singer has to sing wearing a purple hat.
They should sing wearing a purple hat. The contract itself is a contract for them to perform
at the operator and there is another condition here that says that the singer has to really
perform in a purple hat. If the singer was not ill, as is the case in this particular
illustration, but in fact was able to sing but didn't sing in a purple hat, this is still a breach
technically of the contract. There was still an obligation to perform that part of the contract
but it doesn't render the contract meaningless. The contract can still continue because they can
still go and perform and do the singing. So whereas the condition is the part of the
contract that says that the singer has to sing at the operator, the warranty might be the
condition, or the term should I say, that they do it in a purple hat. Because if they did not,
if they fail to do this, there could still be a remedy maybe. There might be a financial
penalty for not performing in a purple hat. But the terms themselves do not destroy the
whole purpose of the contract. So if a warranty is breached, it is likely that this would not
break the contract itself. It is for this reason that the remedy available to the injured party
will be lesser than if it was with a breach of a warranty, compared to that of a breach of a
condition. If a breach of a condition takes place, then this strikes the heart of the contract.
Likely the contract cannot be performed, it cannot continue, and likely therefore there will be quite
a significant remedy. With a breach of warranty, there may only be damages available, rather than
a discharge of one's obligations. Remember, owing to the principle of consideration, when a contract
exists, there is obviously requirements for both parties to actually do something in order for that
contract to actually be valid. So if a condition is breached by one party, then you might be
discharged of your obligations as the other party to actually perform or do whatever it is that you
were required to do as part of your consideration. But if it is a warranty, then there may only be
damages available, and you might still have to continue with your obligations. So the case of
gives us a very strikingly similar set of circumstances of Poussard and Spiers. In fact,
in this case, in both of these cases, we can compare to show the different distinction between
a condition and a warranty. It involved a singer who was under contract to perform in a number of
different theatres. Just like with the previous case, he was in fact replaced and sued for breach
of contract. But this wasn't because she failed to turn up to the performance because she was ill,
like in the case of Poussard and Spiers, but rather she failed to turn up to the rehearsals,
something that was also stipulated in the contract. So the contract was for you to perform
at an opera or perform in a theatre to do some kind of theatre performance. And there was also
another term in the contract that says you also have to turn up for rehearsals. They failed to
turn up for rehearsals, and so they were replaced, and there was a suing for breach of contract
similar to that of Poussard and Spiers. Unlike the previous case, however, the claimant here was
successful. This was because the term which stipulated that they go to rehearsals was not
considered to be a condition, but instead it was considered a warranty. Okay, so therefore,
if it was a condition, it would have meant that there was a breach of contract and there would
have been a breaking of the contractual arrangement. Instead though, it was a warranty.
The defendants would have been able to sue for damages for the breach of warranty. They may have
been able to sue for some kind of compensation for failing to turn up to rehearsals. But because it
was a warranty and it wasn't a condition, it wasn't something that struck at the heart of the contract,
they were not entitled to repudiate and terminate the contract in its entirety.
