NATION STATE RISK AND THE FUTURE INFLUENCE IN SECURITY FROM CHINA, RUSSIA AND NORTH KOREA

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 2, 2026
25th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
London🏴🇬🇧- August 31- September 1, 2023
-Hon. Ravi Batra
Esq., Chairman, National Advisory Council South Asian Affairs, USA
Thank you very much, Baroness, and I will address your question at the end.
So let me start by first thanking you, Baroness Pauline Neville-Jones, for your kind introduction,
chairing this panel, and for your important service as Lord Chair of the Joint Intelligence
Committee.
Up front, I want to acknowledge the important work of Congressman Robert Pittenger.
I saw him here before.
He's here still.
Robert.
As he enhances the knowledge and judgment of parliamentarians across the world.
And for dear Elisa Kearns, Chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, I thank you for
tempering England's foreign affairs away from mutual assured destruction, for hosting us,
and I bring you warm greetings from dear Greg Meeks, the rancor of our House Foreign Affairs
Committee, and former Chairman Eliot Engel.
I also thank Qatar's dear Ambassador Fahad Ali Adia for supporting Robert's noble initiatives.
Before I jump into my remarks, quote, need to embrace Chamberlain and Churchill now,
as first step is first strike, I pause to celebrate our special relationship with Mother
England and appreciate my dear family and friends present.
Not everyone's present because Robert moved the program up, and in fact, we may have lost
some people from the UN and the Security Council to get into a live stream.
But nevertheless, my amazing wife, Ranju, so she knows I did mention her, who got the
Diwali stamp issued by the Postal Service, and now has a Diwali Stamp Power 1 award supported
by over 80 countries in the UN, led by the EU, for world-class diplomats.
Our miracle daughter, Angela, and my brothers in hope, Kazakhstan's Ambassador Makhzon
Ilyasov, who is seated right here, and Philippines Ambassador Teddy Lokson, who I'm not sure
he's in Manila or in Beijing, but his lovely wife, Louie, is here, and Teddy is hosting
England's Foreign Secretary James Cleverly in Manila before he goes to Beijing as Philippines
Special Envoy for China.
Finally, I want to salute the sacrifices of the intelligence community for verifying truth
so we can trust allies and adversaries.
If I can be permitted to be candid, geopolitics of hope is on life support, as diplomats are
not allowed to warmly engage adversaries and instead are to be wolf warriors, and the doomsday
clock is kissing midnight, as the word of many a great power is too often dishonored.
But what an honor it is to be in Westminster, the place that withstood the test of time
– armadas, the Black Plague, the Battle of Britain – and saw the rise of the calibrated
Neville Chamberlain and the fearless Winston Churchill.
Still, Chamberlain made two mistakes, his 1938 Munich Pact falsely thinking he got peace
of our time and being unprepared to stop Hitler from invading Poland in 1939.
But his mistakes are no reason to curse him for eternity, as he was redeemed by Stalin's
Vyacheslav Molotov, who worked into the wee hours of August 24th and signed a non-aggression
pact, Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, only to see Hitler invade Poland eight days later.
Churchill is why FDR and Stalin worked together, and Churchill is who pushed America to embrace
our natural destiny, protector of freedom, not just navigation in the South China Sea.
With Lincoln's motives, with malice towards none and charity towards all, paraphrasing
the great philosopher William Shakespeare, the fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars
but in ourselves, that we are overlords.
Yes, we first win, and then in our victory we seed our future loss.
We won World War I and choked the Weimar Republic, enough that Hitler was elected Chancellor.
Then as allies, we won World War II, created the United Nations, the Vatican of Hope, including
the P5 and the Security Council, which in 1971 we switched Taiwan for mainland China,
and now two of the five cast vetoes, grinding the mighty Council into a stalemate and allowing
regional conflicts all over the world.
And North Korea's King Jong-un, no longer acting crazy when China wanted our attention,
is now his own master with a nuclear store of deadly ICBMs.
Today, I know we need Chamberlain as much as Churchill, as we are cursed with nuclear
armed adversaries.
So absolute victory is not possible, and allowing the first step is as bad as the first strike.
Over a year ago, I wrote an op-ed about Mr. Putin's Ukrainian misadventure, entitled
Russian Roulette Results in Mexican Standoff, and then last September proposed a six-point
peace plan that restores Ukraine's sovereignty and territorial integrity, and gets Russia
to pay rent, and in Toralia creates a joint war commission with Russian and Ukrainian
judges presiding over a televised court that harnesses the power of shame.
Our problems include, one, the gift of democracy is that we have the greatest individual freedoms
guaranteed by governments of limited separated powers, which autocracies structurally lack.
But the strength of autocracies, long-term leaders, is institutional memory, freedom
to plan long-term and honor their word, which is a structural weakness of democracies where
our newly elected leaders freely ignore the word of their political predecessors.
So for democracies to win this contest, and I thank Robert for holding these forums, because
that's where rubber meets the road, our leadership must rediscover sacred honor, a secular epiphany
which we collateralized in 1776, and one we must now compel our leaders to re-embrace.
Exhibit A. We didn't honor our sacred word, memorialized in the 1994 Budapest memorandum,
more binding than Article 5 of NATO, as Belarus, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine gave up thousands
of their nukes in detrimental reliance, thereby binding us without annual dues.
That Russia signed the same memorandum and then invaded Ukraine is beyond the pale.
Exhibit B. I see Colonel Bob Stewart in front of me, and it's his regiment that burned down
the White House, which he told us over dinner last night, and we are still a family.
Exhibit C. Senator Gerard Crogwell of Ireland, who after a civil war is seated next to Colonel Bob.
Number two. While we celebrate Prime Minister Modi for restoring pride to Indians, we look
askance at President Putin's dreaming of Peter the Great and President Xi Jinping's rejuvenation of
China. The answer is Prime Minister Modi is not seeking to attack a neighbor and make her part
of India. While Mr. Putin is doing exactly that in Georgia since 2008 and Ukraine since 2014,
and Mr. Xi continues to draw nine dashes and occupies reefs and shoals that belong to our
neighbors, and also continues to use debt as a sovereignty-piercing weapon to take ports and
minerals. Number three. Ukraine's bravery is a Churchillian moment, as it is a sad result of our
breach of the Budapest Memorandum in failing to protect by creating a no-fly zone, which would
simultaneously open the negotiating table, and Mr. Putin would have to welcome, as he needs to negotiate
a new security architecture. Number four. The humble President Xi Jinping, since his ejection
of Hu Jintao last October, confirmed to me that he's a man of honor and a real-life
count of Monte Cristo, but who is now seeking to be like POTUS, a real-life commander-in-chief
of the PLA, because CCP never controlled the PLA fully. Otherwise, we would not have seen
wolf warrior Chin Gang's promotion to foreign minister as bait, and then the removal of the
treasonous cancer by changing leaders of the rocket force and consolidating foreign affairs
authority in a unique man without personal ambitions, and who I respectfully disagree with
on most issues, the great Wang Yi. I submit the solution to our problems is, A, revive Neville
Chamberlain to a position of honor in this era of no wars, and channel Churchill in us to act
timely so as to prevent the first step of conventional war, as if it was the first strike
in a nuclear war, as possession is nine-tenths of the law. Just ask Ukraine or Philippines,
so in the South China Sea, we should merge, partial answer to Pauline's question, we should
merge the Quad, AUKUS, and NATO into a new South China Sea NATO. B, honor our word, and impose a
no-fly zone over Ukraine, and if necessary, over Taiwan Straits, to stop any war between great
powers. C, ban insults, public insults, private is okay, public insults from our public foreign
affairs and diplomacy, and rediscover respect for our adversaries. As King Priam told Achilles
after kissing the hand that killed his son, even enemies can show respect. D, don't squeeze allies
or adversaries and take everything we can, so we avoid the Weimar Republic syndrome.
And finally, realize that after 20 years of our being in Afghanistan, with our cultural
influence, it didn't grow local roots. Today, imposing our secular human rights culture
disturbs the faithful. Instead, dear Miguel A. Moratina, Spain's great former foreign minister
and current head of UN Alliance of Civilizations, has the correct answer with cultural cohabitation.
Alliance, not competition of civilizations. This honors Pope Francis' advice that we respect all
faiths and hence prevent Koran burning from impeding admission into NATO. We need to free
truth from petty needs of politics to have honor. Gone are the days when kings were on the battlefield
and risked their lives. If the samurai tradition of committing seppuku applied to all leaders,
we would see honor return very fast. I think Colonel Bob would agree.
Our problems are old. Remember the Charge of the Light Brigade by Alfred Lord Tennyson was about
the 1854 Battle of Balaclava during the Crimean War. We need to govern better without spilling
precious blood of patriots. I'm told to finish up, so I will. I close with two quotes, two of
one of Chamberlain. The first is his tribute to Chamberlain. He had the most noble and benevolent
instincts of the human heart, the love of peace, the toil for peace, the strive for peace,
and the pursuit of peace, even at great peril. The second, which I went back in time,
the further backward you look, the further forward you are likely to see. And lastly,
in our mad world with nukes, quote, in war, whichever side may call itself the victor,
there are no winners, but all losers. So let's stop this war in Ukraine,
make Mischief Reef into a tourist resort, and help President Xi end China's Cultural Revolution
and make PLA subject to civilian rule. If we invite Russia to join NATO, we will get her
no-limits partner too. Civilian disputes traded trial by combat for trial by jury 500 years ago.
It's time for sovereigns to do the same.
