TECHNOLOGY AND INNOVATION: 5G, ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND QUANTUM COMPUTING- Mr. John Strand

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 2, 2026
25th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
London🏴🇬🇧- August 31- September 1, 2023
-Mr. John Strand
CEO of Strand Consult
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you. I will start to show a little video. It's made by Bloomberg. It's seven minutes
long. It looks like Netflix, but this is the real stuff. Can we run it?
A top CEO and her security team were dining at this Copenhagen restaurant when they noticed
something unsettling outside the 17th floor window. A drone seemed to be monitoring them.
They had good reason to be paranoid.
They were here celebrating the end of a two and a half month investigation that found
that the Chinese company Huawei had conducted this ham-fisted espionage effort to try to
secure a $200 million contract.
This was about more than just money. Telecoms networks are a critical part of any country's
national security. The investigation revealed the extent of the alleged dirty tricks that
a Chinese tech giant would deploy to get a piece of it.
It all started in early 2019 here at the headquarters of TDC Group. It's Denmark's biggest telecoms
firm. It's also where the team dining at Restaurant Cilo worked.
At the time, this was early 2019, TDC had a tender offer out there for a contract worth
more than $200 million to build their 5G telecoms network. And at that time, they had whittled
down the bidders to just two, Sweden's Ericsson and China's Huawei.
The details in those tender offers are very closely protected. Things like pricing. How
much do you charge for things? Ericsson, as it turns out, had offered to do this job for
less money than Huawei. Huawei was not supposed to know that. Huawei somehow found out, and
just hours before the final decision, submitted an emergency revision to its bid. And in fact,
its bid was slightly lower than Ericsson's.
How had the information managed to seep out? TDC called an emergency investigation.
Within that decade, Huawei had leapfrogged other Nordic rivals, including Ericsson and
Nokia, to become the world's biggest maker of telecommunications equipment.
While not as big as Tencent or Alibaba, Huawei is a far more successful Chinese tech export.
The company says that its technology connects over 3 billion people in 170 countries.
The way they did that was not without its controversies, right?
For many years, Huawei has been under suspicion by the U.S. government and others
for potentially being under the control of the Chinese government.
We start with the Biden administration,
which is said to be considering cutting Huawei off from all of its American suppliers.
Huawei is a bad actor. There's a lot of intelligence suggesting that they're
very close to the Chinese military and the Chinese intel.
So controversy has followed Huawei wherever it's gone.
But here in Denmark, Huawei was a trusted provider. Huawei had worked with TDC
since 2013. So for many years, Huawei had supplied the key equipment
that TDC used for its 3G and its 4G networks.
Huawei had an office on this campus, and many of its engineers badged into TDC
every single day to service the network. It was seen as a trusted provider.
TDC becomes very alarmed because it's clear that somebody has leaked to Huawei
Ericsson's sensitive information.
TDC begins an investigation focused on potential insiders,
potential hacking and also potential eavesdropping within their offices.
And in fact, a suite of the boardroom found microphones hidden in the boardroom.
These are some of the most sensitive types of investigations,
because in this case, maybe five, maybe 10 at most people had this information.
What do they find?
What they find is that the head of special projects, a guy named Dov Goldstein,
they find very quickly that he had leaked this information to Huawei.
The investigation as such was fairly straightforward.
However, when they requested CCTV footage of Dov Goldstein's comings and goings,
Dov Goldstein finds out and he confronts the executive team at TDC.
So there was a leak within the security investigation.
This heightened the paranoia even further.
The security team decides we can't trust our own environment.
We need to leave. We need to take our evidence.
They seize the executive's phone.
They seize their laptops. This is a very serious investigation.
They realize we can't hold that information here.
We need to take that evidence to another place,
a secure location where we can conduct this investigation.
So if you look up there, that big brown building is the Plesner law firm.
That's the building where TDC, TDC security group moved their investigation.
They booked a conference room on the 15th floor of these law offices
as the secure place to conduct the rest of their investigation.
But it quickly sort of went awry.
That same night that they moved their investigation from TDC headquarters here,
Plesner's computer network came under sustained hacking attacks.
The next day and after midnight, a security guard noticed a drone
hovering outside the same 15th floor window where the team was working.
One of the reasons they saw the drone, it had lights on it?
It apparently had lights, which adds even more levels of intrigue to it,
because if you lit up that room at that time with the blinds not drawn,
you would have seen the full timeline of this team's investigation.
The paranoia heightened.
Members of the security team started to notice the same strangers popping up around town,
appearing to follow and photograph them as they ate at restaurants
or entered and left their homes.
Even TDC CEO Alison Kirkby seemed to have attracted a persistent tail.
To make matters worse, Huawei managers had written to the Danish prime minister
warning that should Huawei not get the TDC contract,
it would, quote,
severely affect other Chinese companies' investment confidence in Denmark.
The prime minister's office didn't comment.
The reaction was swift.
Goldstein left the company.
The investigation found he had allegedly leaked Ericsson's secret information to Jason Lan.
He led Huawei's operations in Denmark and, investigators determined,
had essentially cultivated Goldstein as a source.
He returned to China.
With the investigation concluded and alleged source of the leaks identified,
a celebratory dinner was called.
They gathered here at Restaurant Cilo.
Alison Kirkby reflected on the paranoia that had enveloped them
and cracked a joke about when she'd next see a drone.
Minutes later, a drone reappeared outside the window.
The security team watched as it descended to the street below.
Men in a white van grabbed it and sped away.
And the contract?
Ericsson still wanted.
No criminal charges were filed as a consequence of the affair.
Goldstein declined to comment.
Ericsson declined to comment.
A lawyer for Jason Lan said his client
believes that he has acted in compliance with all applicable laws
and that his relationship to Dove Goldstein
was of a professional nature
and one that was appropriate in the circumstances.
Huawei said in a statement
TDC said in a statement
You can find the full story on businessweek.com
We talked about there's hundreds of these tender processes
across the world every year.
Huawei's representing in all those countries.
The interesting thing is that the numbers of Danish media
after Bloomberg broke this story in the end of June this year,
they digged into the story.
They not only got confirmed that all these things was correct,
they got even more details.
And just to say it very simple,
someone broke in to the COO of TDC's house.
Nothing was stolen.
The CEO and the COO had personal guards for a period
until Storm was gone and they all confirmed it.
The CEO at that time at TDC is Alison Kirkby.
In the end of January, she will be the CEO of BT here in UK.
This is reality.
This is happening.
It's not only happening in Denmark,
but it's also happening in other countries.
The worst part was how China was threatening
because they mentioned this letter
and we got a copy of the letter they sent to the government
because we have these transparency rules in a democracy like Denmark.
We got access to these documents
and we can see how they put a pressure on it.
We also knew that Huawei sent a letter urgent
to the Prime Minister which they mentioned here.
And the Prime Minister said,
sorry, I can't take a meeting,
but they got a meeting,
the Chinese ambassador to Denmark and Huawei CEO in Denmark,
they got a meeting with the minister responsible
for energy and telecommunication
and tried to put a huge pressure on him,
threatening with a lot of things.
At that time, one of those countries
was being granted pandas from China.
We have been now suing Copenhagen,
build a nice facilities for these pandas.
And the Chinese ambassador said,
maybe the pandas will not arrive to Denmark.
There was a huge pressure.
We have big companies working in China.
We didn't go for the Chinese pressures.
And the former Prime Minister
who is now our foreign minister
was quoted the other day in the newspaper saying,
we are glad we didn't bend over for the Chinese pressure.
So this is Denmark.
We did a report.
We had done a mapping of all the 4G and 5G equipment
as we heard before.
And numbers of European countries
have already gone through the process
of ensuring that we get rid of these things.
It's all built on top of the 5G toolbox,
which actually all member states have committed to fulfill.
So it's not like Breton wants the European countries
to get rid of the Chinese equipment.
The European countries have agreed
and all countries have committed themselves
to implement the 5G toolbox
which basically will be a kind of getting rid
of the Chinese equipment.
The process around it, what's interesting is
that there was a presentation of a status report
which the European Commission came with
here in the end of June.
And it was Breton who presented it.
A lot of people believe
that this is a European Commission report.
It's not.
It's a member state report.
And that would say the things Breton said,
which have been quoted big time in the media,
is not the Commission's opinion,
but it's a member state's opinion.
What's interesting is we have a number of countries
which have implemented these things
and the process of doing these things.
At the time where the report was presented,
we saw that Portugal and Slovenia
was moving in the right direction.
But we also have countries
which have maybe have done the laws
and done the right things,
but they don't use them.
Country like Spain.
We have some countries in Europe
where there's a huge problem
and we'll come back to that.
But the European Commission,
for you coming from outside Europe,
said two things.
Or you come from Europe,
said two things was important.
The one thing they said was
that the European Commission
will in the future not buy
telecommunication solutions
from telecom operators using Huawei and ZTE.
They basically consider them
as non-trusted operators.
And that means that, of course,
a lot of people say,
oh, that's only for Belgium and Brussels and so on.
No, in all European countries,
we have different European agencies,
offices and so on.
And they will in the future,
if they have possibility of buying traffic,
telecommunication solution from operators
not using Chinese equipment,
they will do that.
Another thing the European Commission
have said when the European Union
gives state aid or give aid
to building up telecommunication infrastructure
in the future,
you're not allowed to use the money
for Chinese equipment.
But they even went a step further
because the European Union
have actually made,
allocated a lot of money
to support financially Africa and Latin America.
And some of those money can be used
to build up telecommunication infrastructure
in those countries.
And those grants are not allowed
to be used on Chinese equipment.
So basically, if you live in a country
which gets get aid from Europe,
and you want to use European aid
to build up telecommunication infrastructure,
the European Union is very clear
regarding these things.
The last several months,
I spent a lot of time regarding Germany.
And let me say it very simple.
Germany is a country on Chinese cocaine.
And the way they try to solve it
is by snoring more Chinese cocaine.
The same way as it did with Russian gas.
They became dependent on Russian gas
with Nord Stream 1.
And how did they solve the problem?
Building Nord Stream 2
so they could get even more Russian gas.
In Germany, we have a problem.
If this was a small country,
it was not a problem for me.
But Germany represent 25% of the GDP in Europe.
Germany represent 20% of the population in Europe.
And 58% of all the 5G infrastructure in Germany
is from Huawei.
58.
The Chinese can turn off
the whole digital infrastructure in Germany like this.
It's even worse.
Because the communication solutions Deutsche Bahn,
which is owned by the German government is using,
is delivered by Huawei.
That means that they can also turn off the trains in Germany.
And trains in Germany is not transporting people.
They're connecting companies, industries, and so on.
So basically, because Germany is all European's largest
or second largest trade partner,
all European countries have a problem.
And in case of China invade Taiwan
and has Schultz calls Xi and says,
you shouldn't do that.
We will put sanctions on you.
Xi will basically say, forget it.
Jump Mr. Schultz.
And he will reply, how high?
Right now, Huawei is running a charm campaign
trying to make themselves very sexy across the whole world,
including Europe.
Right now, they have a program called Smart Buses
where they drive around in Portugal and Italy
and educate young people in how to use the internet safe.
Sorry, Chinese company,
which is basically educating kids
how to use the internet and do things safe.
It's sponsored by a Chinese company,
by the Chinese government.
It's absurd.
But Huawei do a lot of activities
where they try to make themselves look sexy, nice.
Fighting for women, right?
Talking about environmental things and stuff like that.
They come with all the soft, nice things
which would make them look good.
Some will call it greenwashing,
which was in the energy sector.
Here's even worse.
One of the questions I've got several times
during this event is, is it worth fighting?
Can we do something?
Can we make it different?
And can we do it fast?
And the answer is, yes, we can.
Last year in Bucharest,
I was speaking at the same event
and I was talking about the French satellite regulator,
a satellite company called EurotelSat,
which is providing with TV, satellite TV,
to 15 million households.
They're delivering the satellite capacity
to two Russian satellite companies,
TV broadcasters,
who distribute satellite TV
to 15 million households in Russia.
When the war in Ukraine started,
Russia reached out to EurotelSat and says,
remove the Western TV channels from the satellite.
EurotelSat did that, says,
yes, Mr. Putin, we do it.
That means that all the free news,
which the Russians have access to, disappeared.
Now they only have access to Russian news,
Russian propaganda.
I spoke about this last year in Bucharest
and we were a group of three people
who reached out and tried to organize
some people to go against these things.
We reached out to EurotelSat and says,
you have to remove the Russian TV channels.
We reached out to the French satellite regulators,
said, remove the Russian TV channels.
And they said, oh, it's out of our restrictions.
Is this a French company?
Yes, and the French government owns 24% of it,
but we cannot do these things.
So we had to start a campaign.
We got them in the front of the newspapers
and suddenly Reporters Without Borders
reached out to us and says,
listen, we would like to help you.
Reporters Without Borders
took the French satellite TV regulator,
a satellite regulator,
to the French Constitution Court.
And in December last year,
they won the case that the French satellite regulator
have actually the mandate
and the possibility of removing these channels.
And it happened.
So basically, this is very interesting
that in this way,
we have been able to remove Russian propaganda,
not only in Russia,
but also across Europe, Africa, Middle East,
and so on, thanks to doing these things.
And this was thanks to what we call
a multi-stakeholder advocacy campaigns
run by quite few people,
but it works.
And we did it in less than six months.
I think it's very important to understand
that we who lives in a free world,
or we who wants to live in a free country,
that we understand how to fight.
The reality is the way the Chinese is working,
the way they are trying to infiltrate our society,
the way they spy on our companies,
the way they hack our companies
and doing all those things,
we have to be aware of those things.
They don't represent the same values.
And this is not like decoupling from China.
We can do a lot of business with China,
but don't build the digital infrastructure,
the fundament of the society,
on top of Chinese technology.
That is not stupid.
It's totally stupid.
So I just want to say one thing.
I hope I could give you some inspiration.
The story about TTC and spying on TTC
seems very dramatic when you see it like that.
And I can tell you there's information
which was not put into those articles
and in that video.
More than half a million people
have watched that video on YouTube.
People are watching it every day.
I think it's important.
This is not about a trade war.
This is about national security
and we have to realize these things.
Thank you.
