It cannot be denied that during Lionel Trains' O gauge Postwar era from 1945 to 1969, production values, especially for low-budget starter set trains, continually degraded as the economy and demands for toy trains changed. Metal trucks and couplers were slowly replaced with all-plastic designs, and couplers changed from the remote electromagnetic coil type to so-called thumbtack types, often to couplers that did not operate at all. Details and features disappeared, and motors became simpler and less powerful.
Did this same trend follow during the so-called MPC era of Lionel O gauge train production? Let’s compare two train sets - one made near the beginning of the era in 1971 and another made at the end of the era in 1986.
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, I may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Were Lionel Fundimension's MPC trains better at the beginning of their production era,
or at the end? Let's explore on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks.
Hello again, this is Mike. I recently picked up a Lionel starter set from 1986,
the end of General Mills MPC era production, and I immediately noticed many similarities
and differences to common Lionel starter sets made throughout the 1970 to 1986 production era.
It cannot be denied that during Lionel's post-war era, from 1945 to 1969, production values,
especially for low-budget starter set trains, continually degraded as the economy and demands
for toy trains changed. Metal trucks and couplers were slowly replaced with all-plastic designs,
couplers changed from the remote electromagnetic coil type to so-called thumbtack types,
to often couplers that did not operate at all. Details and features disappeared, and motors
became simpler and less powerful. But did this same trend follow during the so-called MPC era?
Let's compare two sets, one made near the beginning of the era in 1971,
and another made at the end of the era in 1986.
So here's my eBay box. Honestly, I need another starter set like I need a hole in the head,
but I felt kind of sorry for this set. It had a very low price and no bidders,
and I felt compelled to at least post up the minimum bid. I think this set fell through the
cracks because there were quite a few other starter sets listed at the same time, and
many of them had their original boxes, track, and transformer.
In any case, let's see what we have. Leading the set is the number 8617442 Nickel Plate Steamer.
The glossy black body is accented by a yellow frame stripe and MKP markings on the steam chests.
The model features smoke, a headlight, classification lights, and green jewels,
and a separately applied silver bell. The valve gear lacks an eccentric mechanism,
and it includes only a representation of a reverser through the cast-in details.
But both drivers are connected to the side rods,
which is an improvement over many of Lionel's starter set steamers.
The shell appears to be a modified version of Lionel's time-tested 242 body
that dates back to the late 1930s. There's no unsightly reverse lever poking through the top,
as a small switch under the cab controls the lockout mechanism
of the electronic reverse unit for the can motor. By the way, if you see a can motor with
no lockout switch, it usually indicates a locomotive that runs on DC power only.
This one has the switch, so AC track power is fine.
The tender is an updated square freight tender with the so-called bean can,
or mechanical sound of steam, feature. As the train rolls down the track,
the large wheel rotates, alternately picking up and dropping small beads,
simulating the chugging sound of a steam locomotive.
The tender rides on the typical Symington-Wayne XL70 trucks of the era,
and the rear truck includes a working knuckle coupler.
The No. 7926 Nickel Plate Box Car is a descendant of Lionel's Scout products of 1948 to 1952.
This colorful car rides on XL70 trucks with operating knuckle couplers at each end.
The car's plastic frame includes cast-in underbody and airbrake details.
The black No. 6254 Nickel Plate Gondola is a direct descendant of Lionel's post-war 6462 cars,
and in fact 6462-2 is cast into the underbody of the car, along with airbrake details.
Like the other cars in the set, the car rides on XL70 trucks with
operating knuckle couplers at each end.
My eBay seller lost the original gray No. 6137 Nickel Plate Hopper,
but substituted a gray post-war Lehigh Valley car in its place,
which is fine with me because I needed another
Lehigh Valley car to complete a unit coal train for my layout.
The Nickel Plate car rides on XL70 trucks with operating knuckle couplers on each end.
Pulling up the rear of the train is a red No. 6919 SP-style offset cupola caboose.
The caboose includes a separately applied smokestack, steps, ladders, and end rails,
and battery box and brake line details are cast into the plastic frame.
The car rides on XL70 trucks with operating couplers on each end.
With operating couplers at each end, the caboose in cars would typically
sell at a local train show for $10 each or more.
The trucks themselves are worth that much.
I have seen similar bean can tenders sell for $20 or more by themselves.
And add in the die-cast locomotive, and you can see that my purchase price of
just over $50 including shipping was a pretty good bargain.
The original No. 6-1602 set would also have included eight 027 curve sections,
four 027 straight sections, a plastic manumatic uncoupler,
plus a transformer, wires, and track lock-on.
According to an ad in the November 1986 issue of Model Railroader magazine,
Owen Up Railroader Supply in Brookfield, Wisconsin,
and Train World in New York were both offering the set for $149.95 plus shipping,
or about $439 today with inflation.
This is normally the part of the video where you would see the set in action on my layout,
but due to a construction project, that is not an option at this time.
Channel members have been able to keep up with the progress on the layout additions
through exclusive photos and videos.
And speaking of members, if you would like access to more exclusive photo and video content,
consider supporting the channel with a membership and stay up-to-date
with all of the behind-the-scenes activities on all of my YouTube channels.
Of course, you can also show your appreciation by liking,
sharing, and subscribing to this channel,
and hit that notifications bell so that you never miss a video.
And now, back to our feature.
As mentioned above, Lionel produced similar 442 lead starter sets
nearly every year beginning in 1971.
So let's compare my nipple plate set with the original No. 1184 C&O The Allegheny set from 1971.
There were several different versions of the Allegheny set,
both catalogued and uncatalogued, offered in 1971 and 1972,
differing mainly only in the road names of the included rolling stock
and the type of on-board sound system included.
The No. 8142 was the first 442 steamer offered by Lionel.
This die-cast steamer featured a boiler casting that was a modified version
of the 2-6-4 casting used on the post-war 2026, 2036, 2018, and similar models.
The traditional universal motor featured a two-position electromechanical reverse unit
with a lockout lever sticking up through the boiler top.
The model included an add-on bell and jewels in the classification lights.
The running gear included a simulated reverse mechanism in addition to the two main drive rods.
The Chesapeake and Ohio tender was the same square freight-type tender body
used with most of Lionel's 442 models.
This one, however, included the then-new electronic mighty sound of steam.
A wire connected the tender to the locomotive,
and when a special contact on the smoke unit was start by a side rod,
it made electrical contact that generated white noise in the tender speaker,
more or less simulating the sound of a steam locomotive.
Like the later tender and all of the cars in both sets,
Simonton Wayne XL-70 trucks were used, but this time with a non-operating knuckle coupler.
Original Allegheny sets from 1971 feature an orange Wheaties scout-type double-door box car,
while later catalogued and uncatalogued versions used a number 9042 Ford Autolite car.
Both cars included cast-in underbody details on their plastic frames
and had one operating coupler and one non-operating knuckle coupler.
The number 9141 Green Burlington Northern Gondola was also based on the post-war 6462 car
with an all-plastic body and one operating and one non-operating knuckle coupler.
Next up was a number 9013 Tennessee, Alabama and Georgia Twin Bay Hopper car.
Again, based on the post-war number 6456 car,
this car also included one operating and one non-operating knuckle coupler.
An additional car for the 1971 version was the number 9022 Santa Fe flat car with bulkheads and
stakes. This car can come in red or black and also featured a single operating coupler and one
non-operating coupler. Later editions of the Allegheny set often substituted a different
flat car with stakes only or omitted the flat car from the consist altogether.
And guarding the rear of this train was the number 9064 Chesapeake and Ohio SP Type Offset
Cupola Caboose. Again sporting a separate smokestack, steps, rails and ladders along
with a detailed plastic frame, the caboose again features only a single operating coupler.
The original set also included eight 027 curves, four 027 straight sections,
one uncoupler, two figures, and suggestions on how to turn the foam packaging
included in the set box into buildings. The set was listed in the 1971 J.C. Penny catalog
for $44.99 or about $357 in today's currency with inflation. A little bit cheaper than the
1986 edition. So did the quality of these sets decrease between 1971 and 1986? Let's compare
them side by side. The biggest difference between the sets comes right up front with the locomotive
and tender features. The 1971 version has better side rod detail but has the unsightly e-unit lever
protruding through the top. Although different castings, the two boilers are similar in their
level of detailing. Whether the change from a conventional motor to a can motor is an improvement
or a detriment is mainly a matter of taste. Original motors tend to have a bit more lugging
power but they are noisier and not as smooth as the can motors. Visually the tenders are the same
except for the operating coupler on the nickel plate version. And the sound system is also largely
a matter of preference. Some prefer the electronic sound while others find it to be distracting
noise. The bean can sound is basic but effective at higher speeds. As for the cars, the 1986 edition
wins hands down. Having operating couplers at both ends of the cars and even on the caboose as well
more than offsets the added value of the extra car. Overall I would give a slight edge to the
nickel plate set in terms of quality and value. When comparing dollars to dollars it is a bit
more expensive than the 1971 version but considering that Lionel produced less variety
in 1971 and thus more units of each item that could account for the relatively lower price of
the Allegheny set. It could also be that General Mills had pockets deep enough to accept a lower
margin on their Lionel train investment at least in the early years in an attempt to re-establish
the brand name. In any case comparing these two sets side by side shows us that unlike post-war
Lionel which experienced a significant decline in product quality between 1945 and 1969, MPC era
trains remain relatively stable in quality and may have even improved a bit over the course of their
run. Once again the once common expression among hobbyists that Lionel MPC trains were junk
compared to post-war era trains has been debunked but whichever brand or whatever era you prefer
keep the trains running and we'll catch you next time with more toy train tips and tricks.