Cheapest Car Insurance in New York From 20 Month

Auto Insurance
2 followers
Mar 1, 2026
You already know that living in New York is expensive.
Rent?
Expensive.
Groceries?
Expensive.
Parking?
In a garage?
Don't even get me started.
And car insurance?
Yeah, that's expensive too.
But here's the big surprise.
It's not that car insurance have high rates in New York, it's that many New Yorkers are
massively overpaying.
I'm talking thousands of dollars per year in car insurance costs.
And while New Yorkers might pay an average of around $60 for minimum coverage or $120
for full coverage, our guide defines that you could be paying as little as $20 a month
for car insurance in New York.
So why isn't everyone paying $20 a month?
In this video, I'll show you the absolute cheapest car insurance companies in New York
on average, when buying minimum coverage makes sense, when it's a financial trap, and which
are the cheapest companies if you have a violation on your record like a speeding ticket, accident
or DUI.
Because in a state where everything costs more, there's no reason why you can't save
a little on insurance.
Let's get into it.
On average, New Yorkers pay about $63 a month for minimum coverage and $120 a month for
full coverage.
But certain companies are over 60% cheaper than others depending on your driver profile.
I'm talking about companies like NYCM, Kemper, Progressive, and even in some specific cases
Erie Insurance.
But let's start with the headline numbers.
If you can get it and you just want the lowest price possible for minimum coverage policy,
we found that NYCM insurance averages about $20 a month.
That's 44% below the state average with the next best options being Kemper and Progressive
Now what does getting a minimum coverage policy actually buy you?
In New York, that's going to be $25,50,10 in liability limits, $50,000 in personal injury
protection or PIP, and $25,000 in uninsured motorist coverage.
This is the legal minimum and that doesn't always mean financially safe.
In a couple of minutes I'll explain when minimum coverage can be safe and when it's riskier
than it should be.
But first let's move on to the cheapest full coverage options.
If you want to add comprehensive and collision insurance to your car insurance policy, meaning
damages to your car are actually protected, we found that the cheapest options on average
in New York are NYCM at $46 a month, Progressive at $56 a month, or Kemper at $57 a month.
But here's a key decision.
If minimum coverage is always cheaper than full coverage, when is it worth the risk?
Let's talk about it.
You can get minimum coverage if you own your car outright, but it only really makes sense
if your car has value of less than $5,000 or if you could pay to replace any damages
or replacing it out of pocket tomorrow.
But if you financed your car purchase or leased your vehicle, you're probably going to have
to get full coverage.
But what if you own it outright?
Well, if you still own it outright but have a very valuable car or you couldn't replace
it out of pocket tomorrow, you should probably get full coverage.
A mistake you could make if you fully own your car is only getting minimum coverage,
that car still being quite valuable, and then being wiped out after an accident to the tune
of $10,000, $15,000, which your insurance could have covered.
But let's get back to rates and get more specific about costs in New York because those rates
can change a lot depending on who you are and where you are.
Now like other states, your age is one of the biggest factors affecting your car insurance
rates in New York.
Not just your driving history, not your credit score, your age specifically.
For example, a 16-year-old can pay double, almost triple what a 25-year-old is paying
for the exact same coverage.
Why is that?
Well, risk.
Insurers consider younger drivers much riskier and more likely to be in accident than others.
The good news is, even within those ages, there's huge variability in what insurers
charge you.
So by shopping around, you can find much more affordable rates and save even thousands of
dollars per year for a young driver.
Let's start with teens.
If you're insuring a teen driver in New York, that 16-year-old is going to be as expensive
as they will ever be on car insurance, period.
But even here, one company consistently comes up on top and it's once again, NYCM.
It's consistently the cheapest for a teen policy in New York for both full and minimum
coverage.
So teen car insurance is never cheap, but NYCM is usually 40% less than the state average.
And of course, if your teen lives with you in the house, you can put them on your policy
and lower the risk overall of the policy and save.
It's much cheaper than an individual policy they would have if they left the house.
Now between 16 and 25, rates drop a lot.
You'll see a significant decrease in those car insurance rates.
For 25-year-olds, NYCM is still the cheapest for minimum coverage, but for full coverage,
Progressive actually comes out on top.
Same state, same age, different coverage, different cheapest company.
And that's how car insurance pricing can work.
Now let's look at seniors.
Once you move into the age 65 and up category, rates have usually leveled out for a while
or they might keep increasing as drivers go into their later 60s, early 70s.
But you can still find pretty competitive rates.
It might sound like a broken record here, but for seniors, once again, the cheapest
option for minimum and full coverage is NYCM.
Now here's something seniors can take advantage of immediately.
A defensive driving course can knock 10% off your New York rates.
And if you're driving less in retirement, getting a low mileage discount can save you
on rates even more.
Small tweaks, but they can add up over time.
Now let's talk about rates for drivers with violations because here's where people can
really overpay.
This is where rates can spike fast.
In New York, one violation can raise your rates 20% to 40% overnight.
And the company that was cheapest for you before the violation might not be the company
that's cheapest for you after the violation.
Money Geek found that on average, the cheapest car insurance after a DUI for minimum or full
coverage was Progressive.
Now after an app fault accident, we found it was NYCM.
And then for a speeding ticket, it goes back again to being Progressive as the cheapest
option for minimum or full coverage.
Same state, different violations, different cheapest company.
That's why loyalty doesn't pay in insurance.
If you ever have a violation on your record, it might be time to shop around and find a
new option.
One more thing.
Once again, if you take a DMV approved defensive driving course, you can get a 10% discount
from your car insurance.
If someone's suffering from higher rates due to a violation, all of that can make a big
difference.
But what if you're a safe driver and you just have a poor credit score?
Now this is the unfortunate reality that New York is one of many states in which they can
charge you based on what's called a credit based insurance score, kind of like a credit
score to charge you higher rates that has nothing to do with your driving.
We found that in New York state, having a poor credit score can more than double your
insurance rates.
But if you do have poor credit, we found that the cheapest options on average are Erie at
about $56 a month.
Once again, NYCM at about $65 per month.
Improving your credit score is one of the most powerful ways counterintuitively to lowering
your car insurance rates over time.
That might take a little bit of time and investment, six months to a year.
And in the meantime, shopping among carriers can find you ways to save.
Now, if you live in New York state, you know that where you live or your zip code can have
just as big of an effect, if not more, as your driving record on how much you're paying
for insurance.
Why is that?
Because insurers are pricing risk by location.
Things like car theft rates, accident frequency, claim frequency, those are all correlated
to certain locations and insurers will calculate higher rates for riskier locations based on
those factors.
In a lot of upstate locations like Syracuse, Buffalo, Rochester, Hempstead, you're going
to find that the cheapest option for both minimum and full coverage is NYCM.
But once you move into higher density areas, that calculation can change.
For instance, we found that in Brooklyn and Manhattan, Kemper is the cheapest option.
And the difference isn't small.
We found that in some cities, switching from the most expensive to the cheapest option
can get you savings of 50%.
Same state, different city, big cost savings.
And that means you shouldn't just rely on recommendations from your friends who live
in different parts of New York state because those calculation differences can be huge
for your personal rate.
So if you're a driver in New York, here's the bottom line.
Cheapest overall, NYCM.
Cheapest if you have driving violations, usually Progressive.
Cheapest if you have a poor credit score, Erie.
And cheapest if you live in Manhattan or Brooklyn, Kemper.
But the cheapest company can change completely depending on your driver profile.
That means shopping around is the best way to ensure you're getting the cheapest rate.
Now if you like this video, please like and subscribe and check the description for our
full breakdown of cheap car insurance rates in NewYork on MoneyGeek.com.
And if you're moving or you have interest in another state's car insurance rates, let
us know in the comments where we can prioritize those ones that you guys want to see.
Thanks for watching.
