My first reaction from Lionel Trains' 2025 October catalog was sticker shock! $3600 train sets, #2100 locomotives, and $400 starter sets!
But, after calming down, I began comparing these prices to those of Lionel catalogs from previous year - and the results may be surprising!
**As an Amazon Associate and a member of other affiliate networks, We may receive commissions on qualifying sales generated from the links on this channel.***
Toy Train Tips And Tricks is a channel devoted to the operation, repair, history, and collecting of classic 3-rail O and O27 gauge trains made by Lionel, Marx, K-Line, Menards, and other manufacturers.
Have you seen these prices? Has Lionel Trains totally lost their minds? Well, maybe and maybe
not. Let's find out on this episode of Toy Train Tips and Tricks. Hello again, this is Mike, and
recently Lionel introduced their October 2025 edition of the catalog, along with the September
2025. And of course, back in the spring, the 2025 Big Book catalog came out. And every time Lionel
Trains in particular releases a catalog, my comments on my page just explode with, look at
these prices! Who can possibly afford these Lionel Trains these days? Now, granted, I have pretty
much the same reaction. I look at these modern train prices, and you know, these things are too
deep for my wallet as well. And that's one of the reasons why over the last five, six, seven years,
the only new trains that I've purchased have been from Menards. $3,000 for a passenger set? $2,000
for a single locomotive? What are they thinking? Who can afford these things? And $400 for a starter
set? I mean, come on folks! Are these trains really priced for the average American to buy?
Well, let's look back at the history of Lionel Trains and check out some old catalogs. And
with the help of some old statistics from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and our handy inflation
calculator, let's try to compare apples-to-apples Lionel Trains of yesterday to Lionel Trains
of today. Now, of course, this is not going to be a perfect apples-to-apples comparison.
The Lionel Trains of 40, 50, 60 years ago, yes, they were all American-made, and there wasn't as
heavy a reliance upon electronics. So, yes, there are some differences that way. But when we compare,
say, top-of-the-line sets for a particular year to top-of-the-line sets of another given year,
the best of the best of each year, is there any comparison? Similarly, what about the
bargain basement sets of this year versus this year? Let's investigate and see.
As a beginning frame of reference, let's check out the most expensive Lionel Train set in the
2025 Big Book catalog, the new 20th Century Limited Passenger Set, consisting of a true
O-scale 464 steam locomotive and five scale-size heavyweight passenger cars,
with a suggested retail price of just under $3,600, a whopper of a price tag that is roughly
three weeks' salary for the average U.S. worker today. Well, let's hop in our time machine and go
back 85 years to 1940. While the prelude to war has brought back a number of manufacturing jobs,
America is still suffering from the economic hangover of the Great Depression.
Many are still unemployed and money is tight. So, what was the top-of-the-line Lionel Train set of
1940? Well, it was the No. 707W Freight Set, led by a scale-sized No. 700 New York Central-style
464 steam locomotive, the same prototype as our 2025 model. Tagging along are a scale-size hopper,
a scale boxcar, a scale tank car, and a scale-size caboose. Unlike the 2025 set,
this set did include an oval of T-rail track. And the price? $97.50.
Now, while a scale Hudson set for under $100 sounds like a steal to us today,
remember this was 1940 and $100 was a lot of money. In fact, for the average American
worker at the time, if you were lucky enough to have a job, it was a full month's pay.
For a toy train? Who could possibly afford such a thing? When the total cost of living and
relative average wages are compared, the 2025 set is actually the less expensive of the two,
despite having more features. Well, certainly things must have improved after the war, right?
So let's move on to 1948, where we find that, well, things really haven't changed much.
The highest price line I'll set that year was of course the new Space Age High Tech
No. 4110WS Electronic Control Set. Essentially an early effort at command control,
the locomotive tender and all the rolling stock in this set were operated by remote radio control,
including the whistle, the dump car, and the couplers of each car. The list price of $199.95
represented about a full month's wages for the average US worker at the time,
still significantly more than the three weeks wages of our 2025 set.
But Mike, you say that was a totally unique set with one-of-a-kind features.
That's not an apples-to-apples comparison. Well, good point, but is the remote operation
of the Electronic Control Set really much different than the digital control and sound
features found in all but one car of the 2025 set? Okay, okay, so Lionel marketed trains to
the super-rich both then and now. But what about trains for the average family? How many American
families can afford to give a new Lion Chief set to their kids? Well, the 2025 Lionel catalog
features two Lion Chief Starter Sets for $399.99. One steam featuring an 080, a traditional-sized
box car, a flat car with girder, and an N5C porthole caboose, and one with a diesel featuring
a US Navy RS-3, a flat car with operating submarine, a derrick car, and a caboose.
The $400 suggested retail price of these sets translates into roughly $29 in 1948 currency.
Aha, you say, I know that Lionel offered starter sets for as low as $15.95 in 1948.
That proves that Lionel was more affordable then than now. Well, sort of.
And I'd like to pause the video for just a moment and ask that if you're enjoying the video so far,
please like it, share it, subscribe to the channel. Just let YouTube know that you like
this type of content. And you may even consider supporting the channel financially through a
membership. Members have access to exclusive video content, early access to regular videos when
possible, plus shout outs, special messages, special photos, and other special features.
Just click on the membership button at the bottom of the video near the subscribe tab.
And whether you are a member, a subscriber, a regular viewer, or just stopping by,
thank you for watching the video and thank you for your support. Now, back to our video.
1948 was the first year for Lionel's Scout Sets, a bargain-basement, no-frills line of
sets designed to go head-to-head with the budget-minded train sets made by Louis Marx and
Company. In order to cut costs, these Scout Sets featured cheap, plastic-framed motors
with finicky and hard-to-maintain reverse mechanisms, boxcars with non-operating doors,
and, worst of all, couplers that were not compatible with any other Lionel couplers.
At least, not without some modifications. In fact, the original No. 1001 Scout steam locomotives
were so anemic they could not even pull their own three-unit consist around the track,
and had to be replaced at the last minute with die-cast steamers.
When all of these factors are considered, you can't really compare today's Lion Chief sets
with the 1948 Scout Sets. But did Lionel catalog a $29 train set in 1948,
a comparable price to today's Starter Sets? Well, indeed they did. The least expensive
027 Starter Set in 1948 that was NOT a Scout Set was the No. 1423W, priced at $29.95.
This set was led by a die-cast 242 steamer with headlight, a 6654W whistling coffin-style tender,
plus a short gondola, twin-dome tank car, and SP-style caboose.
In this apples-to-apples comparison, the 2025 set features superior rolling stock,
more realistic locomotives, and the features of Lion Chief control for essentially the same price
as a basic 1948 set. Okay, okay, let's try a different year. We'll go back 60 years this time
to 1965. All across Lionel's product line, the company was looking for ways to cut costs and
make their trains more appealing to average families. Certainly, the firm did not offer
any super-premium sets in 1965. Or did they? Enter the No. 13150 9-unit steam freight set,
led by an updated and somewhat cheapened version of the classic No. 700 464 Hudson.
The set featured 6 cars, 3 of them operating cars, and a caboose, along with a large oval
of Super-O-Track and a ZW Transformer. Listed for $225, which was about a two-and-a-half-week salary
for the average American worker at the time, the set was anything but budget-minded. Although,
at around $2,400 in 2025 currency, it's not quite as expensive as Lionel's top-of-the-line 2025 set,
but it's nearly twice the cost of Lionel's second costliest 2025 set, the Florida East Coast
Scale Autorack set. So, again, when we compare dollars versus dollars and features versus
features, Lionel's 2025 prices from the cheapest starter sets to the most expensive feature-packed
mega-sets are comparable in price to where they've always been. What has changed is the value of the
dollar and our perspective, which may be influenced by nostalgia bias. Joshua Lionel Cohen did not
build his business on affordability, but instead on innovation. From the onboard whistles and
remote operating couplers of the late pre-war era, to the puffing smoke and realistic knuckle
couplers of the early post-war era, to the diesel horns and magnet traction of the 1950s,
and on today to command control, Lionel trains always cost more than their competitors
because they had more features than their competitors. The Lionel Corporation was
usually content to let their budget-minded competitors like Marks, Kusan, General Models,
and Sakai, among others, wrestle with each other over the cheapest prices. And when Lionel did try
to compete on price, such as with the original Scout sets or with the plastic four-wheel rolling
stock and DC power packs of the budget-minded mid-70s sets, it usually backfired. It is true,
however, that the selection of starter and intermediate train sets is less varied than in
In fact, Lionel and Menards are now the only firms making any effort at all in this market.
MTH, Atlas, and others abandoned the starter set market long ago. One reason for the reduced
variety is the hope that making more copies of a single set type will reduce the overall cost per
unit, helping to keep costs as low as possible. Another reason? Well, if you take a glimpse at
the Lionel 2025 Big Book catalog under the Still Available tag, or even scroll through the offerings
on my own Walmart.com storefront, you will see lots of two- and three-year-old starter sets
still stuck on dealers' shelves. Even at Menards, you can find many budget-priced 2024 starter sets
on the shelves here in 2025. The bottom line, though, is that when all things are considered,
these seemingly crazy Lionel trains prices today aren't really out of line with what Lionel has
done from the very beginning. It is our own nostalgia that makes things seem like they
were better and cheaper than they were before, when in actuality, with real economics, they
really weren't. But let's think about it for a moment. Why do we put so much emphasis on chasing
after the old trains of our youth? Well, because they were things that were unattainable back then.
There was no way that we or our families could afford some of those things in the Lionel catalogs.
But today, with time and changes in economy, we can finally afford these things, and we can finally
fulfill those childhood wishes that were just fairy tales when we were growing up. So I hope
this little comparison video will show that things really aren't as bad as they seem, and things
aren't worse than they've ever been. It's not the fault of Democrats or Republicans or Libertarians
or whatever, or those who don't even know. It's not their fault that prices are what they are.
It's largely the way it always has been. The best Lionel trains are simply expensive. They always
have been, and always will be. But whatever your budget is, find trains that fit in that budget, and
keep them running, and we'll catch you with more toy train tips and tricks next time. Thanks for watching!