Prof. Mike Parker Pearson - The New Archaeology of Stonehenge Q&A - Megalithomania podcast 2021

Artifact Archives
9 followers
1 Video View·Mar 2, 2026
It gives us great pleasure to welcome Mike Parker Pearson to Megalithomania 2021.
So we've got a few questions for you. I'll just run through them. Firstly, thank you for taking
the time to do this. We know how busy you are. We know it's kind of late at night now and we hope
it's not too much wine with your meal, but it should be fine. So we've got a first question
from someone you know, it's Simon Banton. He asks, I'll relay the questions, otherwise it'll
get a bit chaotic, but I'll just relay it for you. So he says, hi Mike, when you say that on
a clear day you can see the coast of Ireland to the west, do you actually mean the site of
or from the top of the ridge above it? Jonathan Morris and I have been doing some
view shed analysis. As far as we can tell, you'd have to climb up the ridge,
unless you can tell us differently. So any clarification?
No, you really can see it from the area of the circle itself. So you've just got to be there on
the right day, Simon, when the visibility is very clear. And yeah, there is no doubt about it. So
I don't know if you had a chance to go over the ridge onto Bank V, the Neolithic causeway
enclosure, which was also reoccupied around 3000 BC, but you've also got fantastic views there
and you can actually see Lundy, the very vertical cliffs of Lundy again on a fine day. So it's a
fantastic area for getting these really long distance vistas. Okay, and we've got a question
from Hugh Evans, and he's got a couple of little points here. One of them is, you know, what does
Wayne Morn or Wayne Moun mean? You know, what is the meaning of that name? Is there a translation
of that? Yes, it means PT Moreland. So yes, it's a very unexotic name. And he asks, what happened
to the people there? You know, from that particular area? There seems to be not much information.
Yes, and that's something we're hoping to do a bit more investigation with, because
the radiocarbon dates just fall away after 3000 BC. And the same goes for monuments and other
known archaeological sites. We've really got nothing until the Beaker period, shortly before
2000 BC. So it's all very mysterious. It's a big problem for the whole of South Wales, in fact,
that late Neolithic monuments are extremely scarce. So one of the things I want to find out,
working out different ways of how we might find out, is whether we have got some kind of desertion,
large scale desertion of that entire land. We've got a handful of radiocarbon dates,
I think, for the whole of North Pembrokeshire, maybe just three radiocarbon dates fall in that
1000 years after 3000. So not everybody left, if that is the case. But I'd like to be sure of that
and see if we can develop ways of being able to find out more. But it's a fascinating possibility.
Ali Cooper asks, kind of a follow on to the last question, really,
why do you think people move from Wales to Stonehenge? He's got a couple of ideas, but he
suggests and also asks about the bones of people who grew up in Wales, were they buried beneath
one of the Welsh stones, I'm guessing either in Wales or at Stonehenge? Basically about why did
they go to Stonehenge? That's the main question. Yes. Well, if you ask your students, they'd say
it has to be because of the appalling weather. Our excavations there each September, we've had
some really trying weather conditions. And I think it's possibly more than that. What we see across
Britain after 3000 BC, so 400 years later, is that there does seem to be an economic and
population decline. That's what my colleagues at UCL are suggesting from looking at a whole range
of evidence. But this is that much earlier. And it could be that we are seeing a phase of
soil exhaustion, loss of crops and fertility and so on. I really don't know what it is that
drives, I have to say. But you know, that's something we can start trying to find out.
Okay, thank you. Thank you. So we've got a question from actually one of our other speakers,
Howard Crowhurst. And he asks about the fact that the outer ditch diameter is the same as
Wayne Mound. And it indicates a careful measurement method. And he asked what your
view is on that. Well, I was lucky enough to work with a former colleague, Professor Andrew
Chamberlain, who is, although he's an osteologist, he's got a very good head for numbers. And he
proposed back in 2007, that the Stonehenge diameters were actually laid out according to
a method of a metrological system. One that he'd actually noticed in the work of John
Michel, which is known as the long foot, which is somewhere just over 32 centimetres.
And what he proposed was that actually, you could see that they were using this in
multiples of 10, as for the diameter of the Aubrey holes, the bank and the ditch at Stonehenge.
And he was also able to apply this to some of the other monuments at Durrington Walls,
the timber monuments such as the Southern Circle. So it's very possible that that could be
the same unit of measurement. Interestingly enough, it's very specific, that although it
works in southern Wessex, there is no such system of measurement at Aubrey at all. And
it would seem that in northern Britain, where Alexander Tom formulated his megalithic yard,
they're working on a different measurement system too. So that's one possibility.
That's really interesting. I'm so glad you mentioned John Michel, he's kind of
many of our hero. So that's fantastic. We've got a question from another one of our speakers,
Caroline Wise. And she's talking about the kind of, you know, driving pigs down over large
distances. They must have been very important to do so, but huge amount of effort. And do you
have any ideas about the routes they may have taken? Yeah, I think one of the interesting
aspects that we're learning from the isotopes is that we can reconstruct some of these kinds
of routes. For example, 800 years before Stonehenge, 700 or 800 years before, we have
people buried at Haselton, Long Cairn in Gloucestershire. And a recent study has shown that
people in their childhood were moving back and forth to the other side of the
Severn estuary to the carbonates, the coal measures of South Wales. So that we can,
you know, we can actually estimate the likely routes that they're going to be taking
in what would have been a transhuman movement. And we also know that we have stone axe exchange
right across Britain. So places like Langdale really are producing on an industrial scale.
And these axes are, these axe heads are being exchanged all across the country.
So yeah, I think we have to recognise that there is long distance movement. It's also an island
where sea travel, coastal travel is going to be relatively easy. So you can make these long
journeys by boat along coasts, up rivers, so that the pigs and the cows don't necessarily
have to walk themselves. And indeed, the first Neolithic farmers to arrive in Britain had to
bring their own domesticated animals in boats. So yeah, you know, there are many ways of moving
around the country, but I suspect it was, it wasn't the dense impenetrable forest that is
sometimes characterised as, that we have really quite sophisticated networks of communication.
Okay, thank you. We've got a few more questions coming in. We've got one from Viv, and she asks,
is there any evidence for the removed wooden posts being reused?
Ah, yes. So the posts at Darrington Walls, when they pulled out the circle,
the posts of the circle, from exactly the same date is when they built, or rather extended,
the southern circle within Darrington Walls. So it goes from a relatively tiny
monument to six concentric rings, and somewhere around 200 posts. So it's very possible that
that's where some of those posts go. The other thing is that as they're pulling them out,
they're digging the ditch. And that ditch was dug to a depth of five and a half metres,
10 metres wide, near vertical sides. So you have to have some kind of ladder to get out,
because you're basketing chalk ultimately up five and a half metres. And at that point,
your spoil tip, the bank of the hinge is going to be, we estimate about three metres high.
So one possibility is that they're also reusing them as ladders. So basically notched poles,
and you climb up the notches to get out.
We have a question from A. Williams, and they ask,
can Mike elaborate on solution hollows at Darrington? Just ask what are they?
All right. It's one of the things that we find in calcareous landscapes, in limestone and chalk,
is that water percolating through the rock and underground creates these erosional holes.
And you'll have seen sometimes on the television that a car has fallen straight down a hole that's
opened up underneath the road, or in some cases, somebody's house. And there was a recent case in
America where someone was actually killed because they were in bed when a solution hollow opened up
underneath their house. So these things occur throughout the world on these calcareous geologies.
And they're relatively frequent in the Stonehenge World Heritage Site. But to find them in a kind
of perfect spatial arrangement like that is pretty unheard of. They're normally utterly irregular
in terms of their geographical, their spatial arrangement.
Yeah, okay. We have a question from Nicola Ray, and she asks, has Professor Mike considered the
findings of John Michel at Stonehenge in terms of the rather precise geometry?
As I say, I don't know, Nicola, if you know Andrew Chamberlain's work, but his work really
informed Andrew. And I think Andrew came up with some quite convincing
ideas about the measurement system.
Okay, and just a little comment from Simon. He says, thanks very much for the answer. That's
my summer holiday sorted smiley face. So that's good news. I'm glad there's a smiley
face in there for you, Mike. And we've got a question from John Lord. And he's asked,
am I able to understand your theory that the stones of Waymore represent those at Stonehenge
were most spotted dolerite? Also, when was spotted dolerite? Oh, he's just pointing out that wet
spotted dolerite looks like the night sky, which I think you're aware of. But he just,
you know, basically asking, you know, is that what made you realise that they're from that
particular site, because they're the same type of spotted dolerite?
The ones that are still there at Wyne Mound, the four of them are actually unspotted dolerite.
And we know that the chippings we have from the stone that was removed there,
those are also unspotted. And of course, we've only dug a tiny, tiny part of the circle. So
we have no idea. Firstly, if there are more stone holes, and if there are, what's what stones they
would have would have contained? Yeah, I think one of the things that we're realising is that
this, although the spotted dolerites, the majority at the moment at Stonehenge,
of course, there's only some, what, 43 bluestones plus the altar stone.
That's only just over half of the grand total. So we've got a question of knowing how representative
the spotted dolerites were. Now, I think one of the great things that the geologists,
Rob and Richard have been doing is to, in a way, redress the balance and just point out how many
different kinds of Welsh stone fall within this category of bluestone. And one of the things I'm
really hoping that we're going to be able to do in future years with the geologists is to actually
pin down more of these sources of the different kinds of stone. So we can get an idea of all of
their relative importance. I mean, the spotted dolerites, they've taken all the credit and all
the glory from amongst the bluestones. But I think we do need to recognise that they're
the dominant type out of all the others. Okay, and we've got a question from Rollo,
and he asks, what is the solution connected with Professor Gaffney's pits? And is there any
evidence for the rest of the Wayne Morn stones having come to Stonehenge, other than the grooved
hole that seems to fit that one in particular? At the moment, no, because as I said, it's early
days for that. For Vince's pits, sorry Rollo, what was the point? Maybe you can explain it.
Yeah, is there any other ones? Because in the documentary, and I think in the lecture,
you mentioned that there's one that kind of fit that you found, it kind of fitted. But
are there, you said, are there other ones that are likely to be connected with Wayne Morn as well?
Yeah. At the moment, we know there are four stones left, and we found another six stone holes
that we can be sure had bluestones of one sort or another in them. But it was only this one
that had chippings from the stone that had stood in it. Unfortunately, the others all seem to have
been pulled out much more cleanly, and didn't leave any debris behind. So we couldn't actually
say what type of stone it was that had been sitting in there. But you know, they're bluestone
sized, that is, and at the moment we can only guess. Steve Marshall asks, regarding the isotope
analysis of animals eaten at Stonehenge, attention has shifted to whales as a possible origin, but
couldn't Cornwall have been just as likely? He also says there are already proven links between
Cornwall and Wiltshire, much earlier pottery found at Windmill Hill, but this is rarely mentioned
these days. Yeah. Well, that's interesting, Steve. We've been trying out, I say we, our
isotope colleagues have been trying out another method of isotope analysis, lead isotopes. And
it's possible with the lead to distinguish the southwestern, particularly granitic areas,
so Dartmoor, Bodmin Moor, and so on, from other areas that otherwise might look similar in terms
of those high strontium values. And they are clearly different. So we can be fairly sure that
if we have got any animals coming from the southwest peninsula, they are very much in
the minority of those that have that unusually high strontium value. So our suspicion is that
actually very few, if any, would have come from Cornwall or Devon. Okay. And a question from
David Schwartzman. He asks, I think we've kind of partly answered this already, when choosing
the precise site to place Stonehenge, why were they drawn to this location? And he also asked,
what, why do you think, do you think the glacial striations would have been visible back then?
Yeah, yeah. Yes, I think that the periglacial stripes and the ridges that define them on
either side of them may well be the reason why it's located precisely there, that Stonehenge
is literally sat on the end of that particular feature. And I initially was sceptical,
but it was our geomorphologists, Charlie French and Mike Allen, who said, well, actually,
do remember that in the early post-glacial, you've got very little in the way of developed soils.
And in what would have been a relatively open landscape up on the Chalkland,
which was never properly forested after the last ice age, such features would show up,
especially in very dry weather. So that if you had a summer period of parching,
they'd show up very clearly. And in fact, it was, someone else pointed out,
they'd been working many years before for the late Roger Mercer at Grimes Graves,
and they pointed out that you can actually see one of these very clearly at certain times of the year
nearby the Neolithic mines there, just to show that such things can be quite visible features
in the landscape. I think we also have to remember that the ridges themselves
would have been more prominent because of course, since then we've had 5,000 years of
weathering, which has reduced them as topographic features.
Okay. I've got a question from Gail Higginbottom, one of our speakers. I've got to just lean in a
bit because it's a tiny text. And she was wondering whether any of the earliest burials at Stonehenge
able to be sexed, in particular those that came from a distance like Wales,
or has any correlation been observed between sex and place of origin?
There doesn't seem to be a correlation between sex and place of origin. Of course, numbers are
quite small to be able to make such observations. But one of our most interesting burials is burial
007. And she was actually buried right on the very edge of Aubrey Hole 7. And she was an
undisturbed grave when we were removing the cremated remains from Aubrey Hole 7. And we
were able really to construct quite an interesting life history for her in that, yes, she grew up in
the west of Britain, so consistent with being West Wales. And I'm trying to think she died
somewhere around the age of 35. She had a hard life, what we think was probably a nasty abscess
in her jaw, and also quite extensive osteoarthritis. And her grave goes with a
single animal tooth, and a piece of sarsen was placed on top of her grave pit. So,
yes, and she's one of the very first people, basically to be buried at Stonehenge.
Martin Sweatman, another one of our speakers, asks about the axe-like symbols seen by laser
scanning at Stonehenge. Have you found tools like this in the excavations? Or he questions,
are these not actually axe symbols? Right. What's interesting about them is that
their forms can be very closely compared to the types of bronze axes that were being used in the
period between 1700 and 1500 BC. So, we're in the later part, well, the very end of the Early
Bronze Age. So, of course, this is, you're right, saying Stage 5 was the last stage of
monuments construction. And I think their shape, it's a type of axe that we find throughout Britain
and northern France. These are flanged flat axes. I forget, they've got a typological name that
evades me at the moment. We don't have any from Stonehenge itself, but they're well-known from
southern Britain. They often occur in hordes as well as separately as stray finds.
Okay, we've got C. Eliezbert has asked about the cranial deformation and about, you know,
that's quite unusual to find in Britain. I mean, obviously, you get a lot of that in places like
Peru, you know, so is there, can there be any possible connection?
Well, it was even being practiced in 19th century France. And there were old ladies who had special
skills of actually moulding infants' heads to create a particular shape. And there are many
different parts of the world at different times that cranial modification has been practiced on
infants from South America, Central America, North America, Europe, Asia, Africa, so pretty
much every continent at some time or another. But I think what has been interesting for us was
this wasn't a new discovery. This was noticed in the 19th century by antiquarians,
people like Thomas Bateman, digging in the Peak District. And then it really just got forgotten.
And it was only the osteologists on our Beaker People project that actually rediscovered it.
And as we were going through the literature, we realised that somebody had already found out
well before us.
Cool. We have another question from David Schwartzman. He asks about why were there
the four stones left at Wayne Mound?
I don't know. We've thought about this. We've come up with possibilities.
Maybe those are the stones that belonged to the groups that didn't want to go.
And said, no, we're staying here, actually. Thank you very much.
We're going to keep our ancestral symbols, our emblems here. Or of course, it could be that if
they were the kind of property of certain lineages who'd been responsible for putting
them up, maybe they died out. They didn't have any successors. Or somebody said, we've got enough.
Thank you very much. We're not going to take those. Or it's the sense that if you're dismantling the
monument, you actually want to leave something which is actually a memorial rather than removing
the whole lot. And all I can say is, thank heavens they did. Because I don't think we would
ever have found that site. Because everything we threw at it in terms of geophysics and remote
sensing just did not work at all. So good job they left four stones to show us the way.
And Simon Banton, he's got the last little question or answer here. He thinks the site of
the bronze axes was Ayrton. Yes, very good. On the Isle of Wight. Yes. Well done, Simon. Thank you.
Okay, cool. So I think, yeah, well, that's all the official questions. And I've got a question.
What's the next plan, especially the whole Bluestone area and the developments and
discoveries you've made there? Have you got a plan for the next few years about what's going to
happen? Yeah, I think so. Every season we go there thinking this is going to be it,
finished, done and dusted. And then something else turns up. One of the things that may well
be the case is that quite possibly, Wine Mound was never actually completed. We know we've got a gap
on the northwest side. It's not a full circle. How many more stones were there? And of course,
it's just possible that there weren't that many stones actually put up in that circle.
And we've been wondering whether there might have been a series of other circles
that were also contributing to Stonehenge and Bluestonehenge. And the fact that there were
two of them in the Stonehenge area should alert us to the likelihood that there was at least more
than one in the Preseli area that would have been drawn on. And we know that the Altarstone
likewise comes from somewhere completely different. And I wonder if that comes from
another monument. The Bluestone sandstones, although that type of sandstone extends into
the Preseli area, none of the outcrops that we've seen are really quite the right type of sandstone.
So they tend to be more mudstoney rather than sandy. And I wonder if the Stonehenge sandstones
of Bluestone type actually come from maybe another site within South Wales, possibly
nearer the centre of the Paleozoic deposits that contain these sandstones, maybe somewhere north
of Carmarthen, for example. So that I think is what we'll be looking for is more needles
in haystacks. Are there actually other circles that contributed Bluestone to Stonehenge? Whether
we'll be successful? Who knows? It's in the lap of the gods. Okay. Thanks so much for your time,
Mike. We really appreciate it. We know it's getting late. We know you're super busy.
So just want to everyone is probably clapping and want to thank you for your lecture for your
taking time to answer these questions and all the work you've been doing. And it's a real pleasure
to have you after three years of trying. It's taken a while, but we've got you. So thanks again.
And yeah, you can just unmute yourself, turn the camera off. Now I'll just say a few farewells.
Thanks again, Mike. Everyone's saying goodbye and hopefully speak to you again soon. Thanks a lot.
