Ranking Member Raskin Opening Statement at Spotlight Hearing on First Amendment

House Committee of the Judiciary
69 followers
Feb 26, 2026
TW: @HouseJudiciary | FB: HouseJudDems | IG: HouseJudDems | M: /HouseJudiciary
from Maryland, Mr. Raskin, for his opening statement. Thank you, Madam Chair, and
thanks to our witnesses for joining us. I'm delighted to be here also with Ms.
Jayapal and Mr. Garcia, and our numbers are a little bit diminished today only
because of the snowstorm, which has affected some people's travel, but I want
to thank everybody for continuing forward on this path and for your vision
in calling the hearing, Congresswoman Scanlon. Alexei Navalny, in his book
Patriot, says that to bring down the autocrats, everybody's got to do the one
thing that they're most afraid of, which is to tell the truth every day, to debunk
their lies and to expose the cruelty and injustice of the regime, and it's a
powerful point and a perceptive point because authoritarians detest freedom of
speech. They do whatever they can to crush it because free expression is the
essential threat to their power, their propaganda, and their platforming of
injustice. We have never had a president more thoroughly determined than this one
to stamp out the truth, to violate freedom of expression, to punish free
assembly, to massacre the right to protest, or to destroy, manipulate, and
shake down the press, the media. To be sure, other presidents have singled out
political opposition or protests that they've wanted to repress. John Adams
had his Alien and Sedition Act back in 1798, which they used to round up
supporters of the French Revolution, dangerous French immigrants, and to
stifle the pro-Jeffersonian press. Andrew Jackson deployed the postmaster general
to confiscate and criminalize the sending of anti-slavery newspapers and
magazines and literature into the South before the Civil War, and he worked with
pro-slavery forces in Congress to impose a gag rule against submission of
anti-slavery petitions in blatant violation of the First Amendment clause
favoring the right to petition for redress of grievances. President Nixon
conducted harassment and surveillance against the Civil Rights Movement and
the anti-Vietnam War movement, people on his political enemies list, and he used
the COINTELP program to try to disrupt opposition political movements. But no
president ever transformed the entire machinery of the federal government into
an instrument of political propaganda, censorship, and repression the way that
Donald Trump has. As aspiring presidential dictators go, he is simply
in a class by himself, which is why America now has a no-kings movement of
tens of millions of Americans that has risen up to counter him. Trump makes no
pretense of respecting any part of the First Amendment. He merges his insatiable
greed and his authoritarian politics with his snarling dictatorial desire to
stamp out any political, legislative, social, cultural, or intellectual
expression that he personally disagrees with. The central purpose of the First
Amendment is to safeguard speech, assembly, and protest for the purposes of
democratic self-government and nonviolent change. But Trump and MAGA have
built a mass paramilitary force in ice and unleashed it, along with CBP agents,
to harass, attack, arrest, and even kill Americans for exercising their First
Amendment rights to record and protest government actions taking place in the
public space. Unprovoked and unjustified, Trump's ice soldiers shot down and
killed in cold blood two U.S. citizens, Renee Good, a 37-year-old poet and mother
of three, and Alex Preddy, a VA ICU nurse, both of whom were peacefully observing
and protesting the actions of federal immigration officers taking place on
public streets in Minneapolis. Many others have died or been wounded in
Stephen Miller's reign of terror against American communities. A young man
protesting in California is permanently blind in one eye, thanks to federal
officers hurling a projectile towards him. An emergency room nurse in Oregon
peacefully protesting government violence was hit in the face with a
tear gas canister. Rather than investigate these murders and assaults
on citizens, of course, the Trump DOJ defames the victims, calling them
domestic terrorists and claiming they were going to assassinate ICE officials
or otherwise were themselves at fault. Well, if they're willing to kill
Americans for their speech, you know there's nothing else they won't do to us.
They kicked off the authoritarian parade by issuing executive orders against law
firms disfavored by Trump, purporting to ban their lawyers forever from federal
contracts, federal employment, even federal buildings, including federal
courthouses. These blatantly unconstitutional orders ultimately
struck down on free speech, right to counsel, and due process grounds, succeeded
in intimidating enough law firms to settle with Trump to gain him and his
pro bono services for any causes or cases that Trump chooses. Again, nothing
like this has ever happened in American history. He executed a parallel shakedown
on colleges and universities, threatening their grants, their financial aid
programs, and their student visas if they wouldn't allow Trump to take over their
admissions processes, their faculty hiring, their curricular offerings and
course content. This brutal assault on academic freedom has taken a huge toll
on American universities and continues to this day. Meantime, Trump has
engineered a new trademark shakedown of broadcast and media entities, suing them
personally for millions or billions of dollars on totally frivolous grounds, and
then using the Federal Communications Commission as a weapon and a cudgel to
force their compliance and settlement of fines with the president. Trump sued 60
Minutes and CBS for 20 billion dollars for the frivolous cause of action that
he thought an interview, not with him, but with Kamala Harris, was edited in Trump's
view too favorably towards her. And then he walked away with a cool 16 million
dollars in a shakedown settlement for his personal library, all part of now a
familiar pattern. When he doesn't like the news, he sues the broadcaster and
unleashes the FCC on them until they pay up and agree to have a pro-Trump
mega-government minder or spy stationed in their office. The Republican-controlled
FCC essentially blackmailed media companies Skydance and Paramount into
agreeing to install a spy to police CBS News to make sure that they're being
sufficiently pro-Trump in order to get approval of a merger they wanted from
the FCC. Donald Trump doesn't have a First Amendment bone in his body. He
calls the free press the enemy of the people and the press are the people's
best friend. He calls reporters the most dishonest people ever created by God.
During his first term, he threatened to change libel laws to make it easier for
him to sue the media that publish unflattering pieces, though truthful
about him. The administration has banned news organizations from the White House
press pool for reporting stories he doesn't like. An FBI astonishingly just
executed a search warrant at the home of a Washington Post reporter seizing her
phone, two laptops, and a smartwatch in connection with the case of a
government contractor who was accused of taking home classified material. The
administration has systematically deleted the use of politically incorrect
words on government websites like diversity or equity or science-based
completely Orwellian exercise in the censorship and manipulation of ordinary
language. Trump has turned public schools run by the Department of Defense into
political pawns of his censorship regime, banning books like To Kill a Mockingbird
by Harper Lee and The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini or Native Son by Richard
Wright or George Orwell's 1984 or The Handmaid's Tale by
Margaret Atwood for the curriculum which thousands of children of armed
service members attend. Those books are no longer available to them. It never
ceases to amaze me how they keep censoring books about censorship like
1984 or The Handmaid's Tale. And this administration has been waging a war on
civil society groups threatening to remove the tax-exempt status of
organizations critical of his administration and issuing an executive
order purporting to designate Antifa as a domestic terrorist organization
despite the fact they cannot identify its headquarters, its organizational
structure or its leadership. Well of course not designating the Proud Boys,
the Oath Keepers, the Three Percenters or a host of violent white supremacist
groups. Well all of these attacks on freedom, democracy, the rule of law, the
right to assemble, the right to petition for redress of grievances, right of free
press, all of them have kick-started in an equal and opposite reaction. Millions
of people are standing up for the freedom of speech across the country, for
the rights of people to protest, for the rights of the press to do their jobs
unimpeded and unintimidated. The people of Minneapolis have shown us the way by
engaging in collective solidarity and mutual self-help to challenge
authoritarianism and millions of Americans have been participating in the
No King's protests across the country and are getting for another one coming
up at the end of March. An astounding three million people canceled their
Disney and Hulu subscriptions after ABC under pressure from Trump and his FCC
Chair Brendan Carr suspended Jimmy Kimmel Live in response to a joke calling into
question President Trump's views. The show returned to air a week after the
suspension. So America is still a country that loves freedom and loves the First
Amendment and is standing up for the First Amendment and that along with
courts that are increasingly taking on the president will be our way through
this before we can get to the next election. I thank again Ms. Scanlon for
organizing this and thank our panelists for their participation and I look
forward to the dialogue today and I yield back to you. Thank you.
