Parol Evidence Rule Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
6 Video Views·Feb 28, 2026
For early access to content, as well as additional revision content, make sure you become a channel member: / @thelawacademy1
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back to another lesson in the law of contracts. In this lesson what we're going to
do is talk about the parole evidence rule and this is just something of a minor point that
we need to make reference to when examining contractual terms. We'll talk about what the
parole evidence rule is, the general principle therein, and then talk about a couple of
exceptions to this principle. So essentially what the parole evidence rule does is it provides the
which is not incorporated into the written contract itself. So when you're examining as
a court the various different terms of a contract, the question that you have to think about is
if there are things and there are points and there are things that may or may not be
incorporated into the contract itself, to what extent is evidence that isn't in the contract
admissible to the terms of the contract? Well essentially a contract which is written down
is presumed to be all-encompassing and anything which is not in the contract itself is considered
to have not been an intended term and so as a result of which it would not be valid. So
obviously there's a little bit of an exception, a little bit of difference when we're talking about
oral agreements and agreements which are not written down, but essentially the point that
it is trying to make here is that there is a basic presumption of contracts that where they
are written down the writing that exists is the all-encompassing beginning and the end of the
contract and that there are no other terms that exist outside of this contract. This obviously
is useful for courts to basically draw the line at what may or may not be included into a contract.
If this rule didn't exist, if it was just presumed that anything could even if it isn't written down
could be still part of the contract, then parties will continue to make various additional claims
as to what may or may not be in their contract which goes beyond the scope of what is written
down, which of course would eventually lead to a bit of lunacy. So the parole evidence rule
essentially tells us that when it comes to contractual disputes something known as parole
evidence, evidence which is not incorporated into the contract, is presumed to be and is deemed to
be inadmissible. And so there are notable exceptions which includes the previously examined
cases from previous lessons, but it also like I said will include other exceptions too. And I just
want to talk a little bit about the J Evans and Sons Portsmouth case from 1976. In this case an
agreement was made between the parties for the shipping of products into the United Kingdom.
A contract in writing and a clause gave the transporters a certain amount of discretion
in respect of quote the procedure to be followed in the handling and transportation of the goods.
So an agreement was made for the shipping of these products and the handlers, the people who
were actually doing the shipping themselves, had a bit of discretion in relation to the procedure
to be followed in the handling of transportation. So it wasn't determined and specifically cited
where and how these products would be shipped, but just that they would be shipped. In addition
to the term that was in writing here, the parties had actually come to an oral agreement that they
had wanted their products to be transported below deck, just a specific requirement, something which
actually did not happen in the conduct of the shipping. They failed to follow with it along
with this particular request. And because the items were shipped above deck the container
actually would fall overboard and be lost, obviously causing quite a lot of financial loss.
The claimants would then sue on the basis that the defendants had breached their contracts in
terms of carriage. So their their breach of contract came from the oral agreement. It came
from their alleged breach of the oral agreement because they wanted it to be shipped and transported
below deck, but it had not been shipped and transported below deck. And of course if it hadn't
had been shipped below deck they probably wouldn't have gone overboard. It was held that the oral
agreement, which was made between the parties, despite actually not being made in writing,
was in fact incorporated into the terms of the contract, representing something of an exception
to the parole evidence rule. Because if you were to just take the parole evidence rule at its face
you would come to the conclusion that if this oral agreement is not part of the contract,
then it is deemed to be inadmissible. But what the court did was, instead of a very strict
application of the parole evidence rule, they took a holistic examination. They examined a set
of holistic circumstances and evidence rather than just which was written down in the terms.
And so from that conclusion they came to the view that the parole evidence rule was not
really applicable, or this represented something of an exception to said rule. Other exceptions
include various different instances where the parole evidence, where parole evidence, generally
evidence which is not incorporated into the contract, may be admissible for contributing
to evidential claims. Parole evidence, for example, can be used for equitable purposes.
So, for example, where there is not an accurate representation of an agreement there is the
equitable remedy of rectification. According to the case of Houghton and Warren from 1836,
evidence which is not incorporated into the contract can be admissible, quote, to annex
to written contract in matters with respect to which they are silent.
What the point here is that, essentially, if you have a contract that is all written down
and there is some parole evidence, there is evidence that is outside of the contract,
and this parole evidence actually seeks to and exists and actually contributes to an area of
the contract to which there is silence, to which there is no actual writing and no actual
conduct for how that should act, then the parole evidence could actually be used to basically fill
in the gaps to find and to essentially annex incidents to written contracts in matters which
with respect to which there is silence. It could also be admissible for the determination of a
time period of a contract. Sometimes the time period is not specifically cited in a contractual
arrangement, and so parole evidence may be determinative in that regard as well.
