Expert testimony is taking center stage in the landmark case over whether social media platforms were designed to addict young users. For analysis, NTD speaks with Andrew Stanner, a social media professor at the University of Florida. -- 📺 Watch NTD News 24/7 on cable, broadcast, and streaming: https://www.ntd.com/watch
And more on that trial.
Expert testimony is taking center stage
in the landmark case over whether social media platforms
were designed to addict young users.
For analysis, we welcome Andrew Selipak,
social media professor at the University of Florida.
Good to have you with us today, Andrew.
This trial centers on whether social media companies
deliberately designed platforms to be addictive.
So from a research standpoint,
has social media addiction been clinically established
as a real phenomenon?
Well, this is one of those things
where what we're looking at is we can find
lots of correlations, not necessarily causations.
And that's usually what we're looking at in social sciences.
And this is important because even in the story
that we just watched, what we found is that
this particular individual who's the heart of this case
has recently been diagnosed with body dysmorphia.
So what we're often seeing is that there are underlying
issues that are involved here.
It's not sort of a causation one-to-one.
And that's where, whether it's traditional media
with movies and TV shows blamed for people watching it
becoming violent or social media,
people consuming it become addicted.
One of the things that we're finding is that
there's often other issues that contribute
and lead to these problems,
and that it's not a clear causation of one to the next.
That doesn't mean that social media cannot be addictive.
It is designed to be addictive,
but at least in terms of the level of addiction
that a person might have simply from using it
and consuming it, that's different
depending on the individual.
So how might that adjust?
What's a useful way for people to understand
this mental health disorder aspect of the addiction
when it comes to social media?
Well, again, if we were to kind of use something
that kind of give us a sort of a comparison,
there are people who are addicted to gambling.
Some people can go play bingo.
They could go to Vegas.
They could buy lotto tickets and scratcher tickets,
and it not sort of take over their life.
There's other people who just become overly addicted,
and now you have all these betting apps
and everything else that make it more prominent,
but even then still not as accessible as social media.
But what it comes down to is, again,
that your brain acts differently than my brain
compared to the person next to us,
and again, depending on who you are,
you might be more addicted to certain activities than others.
Now, this is especially true
because there's sort of a reward system
that we also see with gambling.
That's why they're often compared
as opposed to, say, a drug addiction,
which is sort of separate.
But you can compare sort of an internet addiction
to something like a gambling addiction
where it's really about the accessibility of the thing,
whether it's gambling or social media.
But at the core, there's still going to be
some underlying issues
that are gonna be contributing factors to it.
It's not, again, just a one-to-one.
There's other things involved.
You have social media.
I have social media.
It doesn't mean that we aren't as addicted
as this particular person has reported in their court case.
It's sort of individually dependent.
And yet we're hearing that testimony
that up to 40% of teens may show
high or increasingly addictive use patterns
when it comes to social media.
Does that number reflect addiction or something else?
And what do you think is particularly pushing children
and young people to become addicted?
Well, again, the platforms are designed to be addictive
in sort of two ways.
The first is just the fact that they give you
this sort of constant dopamine hit
of every time you get a notification,
you wanna check the notification,
you wanna see what that was.
Did someone like your comment?
Did someone comment on your content?
Did someone share your content?
Did you get a DM?
They're also a bit addictive
because you can do that sort of constant scrolling
and keep going.
But this is sort of the two things
that potentially make them addictive for an individual,
not necessarily guaranteeing.
But one of the things that we have now with young people
is that they're simply spending a lot more time
on these devices that are addictive.
It'd be the same as if somebody
was constantly had access to gambling.
They're more likely to gamble
and more likely to become addicted
to the sort of the dopamine hit of winning potentially money
or just the rush of gambling.
So it's the sort of availability
and then the two parts to the design
that make the social media so addictive for so many people.
I personally, yeah, I spend a lot of time
on social media consuming content,
but it comes down to whether or not the individual
can kind of set the phone aside and move away from it.
For young people who these days
are not necessarily spending as much time
face-to-face real world with friends,
they're not engaged in as many outside activities
as say previous generations.
It just is more accessibility
to something that's addictive,
which is leading to these problems that we're seeing
as opposed to maybe for older people.
At the same time, let's be perfectly honest,
we're kind of Petri dishing all of these kids.
Social media is only, if we look at Facebook,
it's only 22 years old.
We as a species have been around for a very long time
and it's only a brief window of this
that we've had this very addictive form of technology.
And we don't necessarily know long-term effects.
We don't know exactly how it's impacting us.
We have some good ideas,
but even from a long-term perspective,
22 years over the course of us as a species
is a very short amount of time.
And we've heard during this trial
how this young woman, the plaintiff,
got around a lot of the initial roadblocks
put in place by the platform.
What's your advice for parents and families
looking to really help their kids navigate
through this clearly addictive platform?
Well, I mean, one of the things that in the report
that we just heard was that this was somebody
who's creating multiple YouTube accounts,
multiple Instagram accounts,
encouraging family to create their own accounts,
to engage on their content.
So we don't want to victim blame in this,
but on the outside of the actual,
in this case, a young girl, now a 20-year-old,
there was a lot of enabling on the part of those around her.
I mean, at six years old, okay,
you can access YouTube on different ways.
But then to have family and other people
right there in the household, extended family,
creating accounts, encouraging it,
sort of allowing this to continue
and seeing the negative consequences of it,
there is some aspect where this would have only happened
because of the fact that you have a parent
who's allowing this young person
to access social media on her phone at a young age
and then enabling it through creating accounts,
liking the content and encouraging this to occur.
And even if, in this case,
this particular person was talking about being depressed
and potentially even making comments
of wanting to engage in self-harm,
that sort of should be up to the parent
as you're dealing with a minor
to then go seek out help for this person
in terms of these things that are going through,
especially now, again, in your previous report,
it being said that she's suffering from body dysmorphia,
which is probably something that's occurred,
not just recently, but been going on for quite some time.
And we're not sure, based on the current story,
how long that's been occurring,
when it should have originally been diagnosed
and the help that this young person
could have gotten long ago.
That's it.
No doubt the family themselves and other families,
multiple families around the world
must be reflecting at this point the best way forward.
They are the initial gatekeepers here.
So thank you so much for your time.
And your insights.
Andrew Selipak, good to speak with you.
Thank you.