Hon Gilbert Kaplan

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Feb 26, 2026
27th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, DC🇺🇸- December 4-5, 2024
-Hon. Gilbert Kaplan
Former Under Secretary of Commerce for International Trade; Senior
Fellow, Manufacturing Policy Initiative
To everyone who has organized this incredible forum, it's very important, and we're going
to talk about economics and trade, which is central, of course, both to the well-being
of our populations, but also to national defense and national security.
I'm going to speak about one of the biggest issues in the United States, where there's
a nexus of trade and economics, and that is about the manufacturing sector.
It's a very important part of the country in terms of productivity, obviously, in terms
of jobs, in terms of keeping our communities whole and safe.
I know we have delegations from more than 60 countries here.
When I was undersecretary, I had the privilege of meeting a lot of heads of state and other
senior economic officials, and almost every time I walked into a meeting, the first thing
they would say to me is, we need manufacturing.
As a matter of fact, four heads of state in Africa said that to me, before I said anything
almost, because they have so many young people coming up that need jobs.
But why are we concerned in the United States about manufacturing?
Let me take you back to 2015, one year before Donald Trump was first elected president,
and many of you know this, but I'll quickly review this.
Up to 2015, we had lost 7 million manufacturing jobs in the United States.
80,000 U.S. factories had closed.
We had achieved, and I use that word ironically, a trade deficit of $745 billion, all of that
in manufactured goods.
Entire industries had been wiped out in the U.S., many of which started in the U.S., or
were in the process of being wiped out, including solar panels, semiconductors, computers, glass,
silverware, cell phones, and televisions.
Manufacturing policy was a major issue in the 2016 issue, and has been a major issue
in every presidential election since that time.
2015 is also the year that we started the manufacturing policy initiative at Indiana
University.
I came to the conclusion, and with other colleagues, we realized that there was no institution
in the United States that was focused on what public policies had to be put into place to
rebuild manufacturing.
That seems amazing, because universities have centers on almost everything from tobacco
to aging to race relations, but there was not one on manufacturing and public policy,
so we started it.
Over the years, we have come to the conclusion that there are 10 major areas that contribute
significantly to manufacturing policy, but we don't have time to go into all of those,
and maybe in the question period I can if people are interested, but it's quite clear
that the two most important areas are international trade and the level of investment in manufacturing,
and that investment in the U.S. is both from U.S. government sources and U.S. government
companies and foreign sources.
Also subsidies for manufacturing is part of the investment picture.
There's no one answer to rebuilding manufacturing.
It's not like building a road.
If you want to build the road, the policy is build the road.
If you want to rebuild manufacturing, you can't just say, you know, build a plant, because
there are so many other factors involved, having the right technology, having a workforce,
having enough capital, there are multiple factors.
If you look at the eight years from 2016 to 2024, and you'll remember that was the Trump
years and then the Biden years, something very interesting happens with respect to manufacturing policy.
And that is that we had one president who was totally dedicated to looking at the international
trade aspects of manufacturing issues, and that included tariffs, and we'll talk about that.
And one president who was totally interested in putting more capital into manufacturing
from the government.
Unfortunately, President Trump, who I'll talk about first, was not very interested in government
investment in manufacturing, but he did, I think, an incredible job to raise the level
of awareness of international trade problems as they relate to manufacturing and take on
some of the issues raised by China.
In the four years from 2016 to 2020, President Trump took major trade actions, including
the Section 301 case on China intellectual property theft, which led to high duties on
billions of dollars of imports from China.
He also renegotiated NAFTA to create the USMCA.
He put high duties on all steel imports into the United States and negotiated phase one
of the trade agreement between the United States and China.
At the end of that period, obviously, Biden came into office.
He kept the Trump tariffs in place.
As far as I've seen, he's never explained why or given President Trump credit for that.
Obviously, a lot of disputes between the two of them.
But then he added another wrinkle on manufacturing, which was to invest over one trillion dollars
into US manufacturing.
And that was through the Infrastructure Act, the Chips and Science Act, and the Inflation
Reduction Act.
And I used to say, before he did that, that if we could ever get one trillion dollars
to help US manufacturing, we'd solve the problem.
And it has been very helpful, but unfortunately hasn't completely solved the problem.
But I would argue that if you combine the Trump and Biden approaches to policy on US
manufacturing together, combining trade policy and investment policy, you have a pretty good
manufacturing policy overall.
And the data bears this out.
Despite the interruptions of COVID, the US has increased manufacturing jobs by over 500,000
from 2016.
And in 2024, and this is truly amazing, spending on construction for manufacturing plants has
increased from about 80 billion per year at the beginning of this period to over 200 billion
dollars a year.
So there's a real boom in building factories in the United States.
There may not be a message for other countries in that, that's certainly specific, but that's
certainly a message to the United States and US policymakers.
I now want to turn to the hot topic of the day, just for a couple minutes, and that is
tariffs.
You've all heard that our president-elect has a lot of plans on tariffs.
25% tariff on goods entering from Mexico and Canada, 100% tariffs on members of the BRIC
group if they create their own currency, tariffs of 10% or higher on all goods coming into
the United States.
That's everything, theoretically.
He wants to put a collar around the United States, he says.
New tariffs of 60% or higher on all goods entering from China.
There's not time to go into all these individually here, we can answer questions, but I wanted
to make some general comments about the idea of using tariffs so expansively.
And one thing that has not come out, which I see in my work, and is really important,
is that I don't think there's a CEO in the United States that wants to put a factory
in China.
He just knows that the risk is too high, and CEOs like to keep their jobs, you can't invest
a whole lot of money in China and then the next week they're tariffs and the whole thing
is shot.
So they don't even talk about that anymore.
More broadly, they think they need to be in the United States, because who knows, once
you open the tariff spigot, it could put tariffs on really anywhere.
I think tariffs are helpful to manufacturers, more helpful if they are accompanied by major
investment in the U.S., including government investment.
Tariffs on their own are helpful, but not the whole thing.
I'll add that many opponents of tariffs have said they're very inflationary.
If you look at the actual inflation impact of the first round of Trump tariffs, and this
has been done by the Fed and by serious academics, the effect they had was less than .5% in terms
of inflation.
So very, very limited, and what that would mean if more extensive tariffs go on is, you
know, people are studying that.
I would also say that tariffs are very helpful in the context of individual tariffs on products
where there's dumping or subsidies or other unfair trade practices.
Tariffs have saved many industries from decimation, and if they're selectively used, can do that.
I support, definitely, I definitely support selective use of tariffs, and other tariffs
too, but the selective use of tariffs has worked.
In terms of criticisms of the potential Trump tariffs, high tariffs on a whole range of
products creates major difficulties for manufacturers who need those imports to manufacture in the
U.S.
One strategy that companies have done is keep large plants here, but then import many of
their inputs, and that's a way to control costs, but with the tariffs, that may be harder.
And of course, if we put tariffs on, we can expect at least some of our trading partners
to retaliate with tariffs on U.S. exports.
So with that, I'll stop and turn it over to Diana, I think, is next.
