ECONOMIC SECURITY/TRADE- Ms. Diana Furchtgott Roth

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Feb 26, 2026
27th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 4-5, 2024
-Ms. Diana Furchtgott-Roth
Director, Center for Energy, Climate, and Environment; The Herbert and Joyce Morgan Fellow in Energy and Environmental Policy, The Heritage Foundation
This panel, we hope to have you engaged also.
So the rest of us are going to talk for five to seven minutes
each, and then we hope to get your questions,
and we hope to have some audience interaction.
I'm Diana Furch Scott-Roth.
I direct the Center on Energy, Climate, and Environment
at the Heritage Foundation, and I
served in the Trump administration
as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Research and Technology
at the Transportation Department,
and also Acting Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy
at the U.S. Department of the Treasury.
And I've also served in both Bush administrations
and the Reagan administration.
Well, today I'd like to talk about our Chinese handcuffs
project at the Heritage Foundation.
For the past four years, everybody
has been talking about climate change.
But for China, the weather is about to change.
Our Chinese handcuffs project was built around the thesis
that the United States is voluntarily
putting itself into Chinese handcuffs
through our energy policy.
Voluntarily, with Biden administration regulations,
we have been requiring the purchase
of Chinese renewables, Chinese electric vehicles,
and Chinese batteries.
Chinese wind and solar companies are seven
out of the largest 10 wind and solar manufacturers
in the entire world.
China makes 80% of the world's batteries.
And Chinese electric vehicles are going into Europe
undercutting European vehicles.
For example, next month, BYD, the Chinese global vehicle
exporter, is going to be selling a car for 11,500 euros
in Germany.
That's a very inexpensive car.
But it's a nice car.
It's a sedan with four doors.
And it's called the Seagull.
And quite naturally, people are turning
to these kinds of vehicles rather
than the traditional Volkswagens, Mercedeses, BMWs,
Audis.
And this month, Volkswagen is laying off workers
from three plants.
The net zero dependence on China is hollowing out Europe,
resulting in de-industrialization
and unemployment.
So these policies are making the United States weaker
and China stronger.
But the good news is that we can fight back.
Unlike in the EU, where these net zero policies are law,
or in the UK, again, where they are law, in the United States,
these are just regulations.
Regulations mean that an incoming president
can roll them back.
Especially if there are legal challenges.
And there are legal challenges to President Biden's
regulation that 70% of new vehicle sales
have to be electric by 2032.
Interestingly enough, at the same time,
President Biden passed another regulation
that says that if power plants do not sequester or bury
95% of their carbon emissions, they have to close by 2040.
So we have a perfect storm under the Biden administration
regulations.
More people have to buy electric vehicles,
and the price of electricity goes up
because power plants are closing.
This is really incoherent policy.
And President-elect Trump has said
that he is going to roll it back.
The Justice Department can do this
by accepting the challenges, accepting
the many legal challenges to these rules,
and crafting a new rule, a different one
that is more sensible.
And by the way, the same Environmental Protection Agency
also released a particulates rule
calling for reducing particulates,
which are these little smog-like things in the air.
Without mentioning that electric vehicles create
more particulates because they are heavier,
and so the wear of the tire on the road
creates more particulates.
To just talk about more incoherence in this policy,
EPA's three rules, particulates, power plants closing down,
required EVs, don't mention the other rules.
So the electric vehicle rule doesn't say,
oh, by the way, electricity is going to be more expensive.
And the particulate rule doesn't say,
oh, by the way, we're going to have more EVs
that are going to create more particulates.
So these are incoherent rules that play us
into the hands of China, and these need to be changed.
So in our Chinese handcuffs papers,
and there are four of them online.
I've written two of them myself,
and then there are two by some of my colleagues.
We have four major recommendations.
Roll back these mandates for renewables, EVs,
and power plants.
Spur U.S. production by increasing domestic production
of oil and natural gas,
which will keep our electricity costs low.
And by the way, Gil, it'll help manufacturing
because manufacturing wants inexpensive electricity prices,
which is why, by the way, we're getting a lot
of manufacturing from Germany these days,
displaced manufacturing from Germany.
Third, we need to target Chinese malice.
We need to ban these Chinese EVs,
both coming from China and through Mexico,
from China through Mexico, because they can spy on us.
They can send back telematics,
and they can also be controlled
from the Chinese Communist Party,
which has a stake in all these automakers.
They can spoof the navigation system,
interfere with the braking system, disable them.
And if you don't believe me, look at OnStar.
GM's OnStar says, if your car gets stolen, let us know,
and we will stop it right there and then.
So I can assure you, if GM can do it, China can do it.
And the fourth is pursue federal and state reforms
on the permitting process so that it's easier
for us to get critical minerals here in the United States.
The Biden administration has taken 66 actions
against Alaska, many of which prevent Alaskans
from developing their critical minerals,
even the offshore ones around the Arctic
that China and Russia are developing right now.
So with that, I will stop.
I will turn it over to Nels.
