ECONOMIC SECURITY/TRADE- Mr. Daniel Bob

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Feb 26, 2026
27th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 4-5, 2024
-Mr. Daniel Bob
Former staff member, Senate Foreign Relations and House Foreign Affairs
committees
Good morning everyone and thanks to all of you for coming and to JC for organizing this.
It's a real honor to address this distinguished audience on an issue that I believe sits at
the crossroads of trade security, manufacturing and an investment in it, and the enduring
relationship between two of the world's strongest allies, the United States and Japan.
And that's the proposed acquisition by Nippon Steel of U.S. Steel. Just about a year ago,
Nippon Steel offered to acquire U.S. Steel and make substantial investments in the company
to ensure its future. However, the deal encountered political opposition,
including from President Biden, Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, in large part because U.S.
Steel is based in Pennsylvania, which of course is a critical electoral swing state.
But before the election, Biden pushed the deal out of politics and into the hands of
something called the Committee on Foreign Investment in the U.S., known as CFIUS,
for review, a review to be completed after the election based on national security considerations.
The review is scheduled to be finished before Christmas, and if the deal passes muster with
CFIUS, as it almost certainly will, it will move to President Biden for a decision within 15 days
on whether he'll allow it to go through. However, just this past Monday, for the first time since
the election, President-elect Trump restated his intent to block the deal. As he wrote on
Truth Social, quote, I am totally against the once great and powerful U.S. Steel being bought
by a foreign company, in this case Nippon Steel of Japan. Through a series of tax incentives and
tariffs, we will make U.S. Steel strong and great again, and it will happen fast. As president,
I will block this deal from happening. Buyer beware! With three exclamation points at the end.
Now, what those tax incentives and tariffs he references will be remains murky,
and the likelihood of any success from them even murkier. Moreover, it seems Trump may be
hard-pressed to find a way to retroactively block a deal that may have already been approved by
Biden and signed and sealed before Trump takes office. I believe Trump's opposition,
and that of Biden at least previously, has been unfortunate and unfounded. The deal should not
be about foreign ownership. It should be about responsible ownership, as well as the broader
benefits it represents as a critical opportunity, not just for the two companies involved, but for
the U.S.-Japan alliance, for our shared economic interests, and for our collective ability to
compete in an increasingly challenging global environment, especially in the face of China's
growing influence. Now, some of the opponents of the deal have cited national security as a
rationale for opposition, but this position just doesn't stand up to scrutiny. Let's remember that
a strong steel industry is essential to national security, and the integration of Nippon Steel's
advanced technologies into U.S. steel's facilities would modernize and revitalize aging
mills, ensure their longevity and capability to meet critical national defense and security needs.
In fact, Wilbur Ross, who served in the first Trump administration as Commerce Secretary,
and who actually once was a CEO in the U.S. steel industry, has offered his strong support for the
deal, citing its potential to create synergies and strengthen America's industrial base.
Indeed, blocking this deal would actually undermine American security. It would weaken U.S.
steel, delay critical modernization, and leave us less competitive in the face of China's
rapid advancements in steel production. And those advancements have been significant. In 2023,
China accounted for 54 percent of global steel production, an amount large enough to pose a
direct challenge to the interests of both the United States and Japan. By fostering collaboration
between Nippon Steel and U.S. Steel, we can strengthen the ability of allied nations to
counter China's growing global dominance in the industry. The deal is also consistent with
President Biden's foreign policy initiative toward the Indo-Pacific, his so-called Indo-Pacific
Strategy, one which emphasizes the U.S.-Japan alliance as the cornerstone of regional security
and stability. That strategy, by the way, was a direct outgrowth of policies developed and
implemented by the first Trump administration. Nippon Steel's proposal represents a tangible
step in reinforcing policies toward the Indo-Pacific that both Biden and Trump have supported.
And that's because it will deepen economic ties and ensure resilience in critical supply chains.
The United States and Japan share a long, close, and vital strategic relationship,
rooted in economic interdependence, mutual values, and common strategic goals.
Among other things, Japan is already the largest foreign direct investor in the U.S.,
with investments totaling close to $800 billion in 2023. And the U.S. remains the largest foreign
direct investor in Japan, accounting for almost a quarter of the total of that country.
These economic ties not only create jobs and drive innovation, but also enhance mutual security by
solidifying the industrial foundation's essential for defense and infrastructure.
The Nippon Steel-U.S. Steel Deal exemplifies this partnership. It's also an important
demonstration of what is called friendshoring, which means building resilient supply chains
among trusted allies to reduce reliance on adversaries like China, a country that
increasingly weaponizes its dominance in critical industries from steel to rare earth minerals,
which was just demonstrated earlier this week when Beijing banned the export of certain minerals to
the U.S. that have widespread military applications. Meanwhile, the direct economic
benefits of the deal will be substantial. Nippon Steel is a global leader in innovation,
renowned for its advanced technologies that minimize emissions inefficiently
and cost-effectively produce high-quality steel. Its investment would create jobs,
sustain existing ones, and inject new life into communities reliant on U.S. steel's operations.
And that's why union steel workers at U.S. Steel's Irvin plant in Pennsylvania have been
in Washington this week lobbying the Biden administration to approve the deal.
As CFIUS completes its review, it's critical that leaders in Washington recognize the merits of the
acquisition. President Biden should act decisively and allow it to proceed. Doing so will send a
clear message that the United States values its allies, understands the importance of economic
cooperation, and is prepared to lead in countering global challenges like China's rise.
Blocking the deal, on the other hand, risks alienating a trusted partner and undercutting
our alliance with Japan. The Nippon Steel acquisition of U.S. Steel is well more than
just a business transaction. It's a symbol of the strength of the U.S.-Japan reliance,
a strategic move to secure our shared futures,
and a critical step in countering the economic and geopolitical challenges posed by China.
