Incorporation of Terms Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
#learning #law #education
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
In this lesson, what I want to do is talk about the incorporation of contractual terms. What does
this mean? How do I explain it? And what can we glean from this particular area of the law?
All of which are questions we're going to explore in this lesson.
The previous lesson took an introduction to contractual terms. We made the distinction
between PUFs, representations and terms. The idea here of a PUF was something of a,
for the most part, we could make it akin to, shall we say, a marketing slogan. Some kind of
thing that doesn't really have any kind of legal obligation attached to it,
owing to the fact that it is just simply a statement of advertising, if you will.
So the advert that we used as an example of this was, Red Bull gives you wings.
Now of course, Red Bull doesn't actually give you wings. You couldn't sue Red Bull on the basis
that you drank one of their energy drinks and that I didn't get given wings, therefore
there's a breach of contract here. That's not how it would work.
Representations, we noted, were a little bit more serious. They were statements or they were
information, shall we say, given about a particular product or a particular service
that induces a person to contract. So if I was told about the quality of a product and I was
told this, that and the other about the quality of this product and that information causes me to
want to buy the product and enter into a contract for the purchase of the product
and then it turns out that that representation was false, it was not actually what the
representation said it was, then this would represent something of me being induced into a
contract under false pretenses. And so the result of this is often likely to be able to get some
kind of remedy in the basis of misrepresentation, but it is interesting here that representations
are a little bit more serious than false. The final of which we were talking about was this
idea of terms, the terms of a contract. The terms of a contract are the specific things that are in
the contract itself, either expressly stated in a clause or implied through the contract
itself. And these, of course, if you were to breach a term of a contract, the person would actually be
able to sue for breach of contract. This lesson is going to talk about how one is able to determine
which pre-contractual statements are kept as representations and PUFs and which are incorporated
into the terms of the contract itself. So if we go through the arduous process of a potentially
lengthy negotiation between different parties in relation to contracts and we find ourselves in
the position where we have made lots of different statements, we've made lots of different
representations, some of which may or may not enter into the contract itself, we are now asking the
question, well how do we determine, how can I determine which pre-contractual statements are
kept as representations and which ones are not? Well the incorporation of terms is an interesting
element within the law of contracts. When it comes to which statements are incorporated into the
terms of the contracts, the courts will often look at a number of considerations, a great many
different considerations. For example, what are the intentions of the parties in the contract
in the first place? That's an important question that needs to be asked. What did the people who
were creating the contract intend? If there was clearly an intention that something be incorporated
into the contract, then arguing that it should merely stay as a representation is
probably not going to slide very easily. Now given the difficulty examining the intention
of parties, as well as all the other considerations that need to be ascertained, the courts have been
able to develop a number of tests and procedures for examining the incorporation of terms into a
contract and I will refer us firstly to the case from 1976 of J Evans and Son Portsmouth Limited.
In this case an agreement had been made between the parties for the shipping of products into the
United Kingdom. The contract itself was in writing and it gave, and there was a clause within the
contract, which gave the transporters a certain amount of discretion in respect of quote the
procedure to be followed in the handling and transportation of the goods. So the handling and
transportation of the goods was something that the people who were actually doing the transporting
had a certain amount of discretion over. They weren't going to control every single element
of their job and this was in the contract. This was a clause that was in the contract.
In addition to this term that was clearly stated in writing, the parties had also come to an oral
agreement that they wanted their product to be transported below deck. This was something however
that did not happen. So you sort of have a bit of a clashing of terms if you will, not
a complete contradiction of terms. They still had discretion in terms of the procedure and
the handling of transportation but they said can we have our goods transported below deck please
and this was an agreement that they actually said yes to. We will transport your goods below deck.
Because the items shipped were above deck the container would fall off and be lost overboard.
Of course not very good. The claimants then would sue on the basis that the defendants
had breached their contract in terms of carriage. So this is quite interesting. They didn't just
sue on the basis that they lost the the goods themselves, which they may or may not have had
a successful claiming, but they sued on the specific point that they had breached a term
of the contract through this little oral agreement that was had. Now the question was,
was this oral agreement incorporated into the contract such that it represented a term that
was as valid and as gold standard as the term that was actually in the contract which gave the
procedure to allow the procedure to be followed in the handling and transportation of the goods
in terms of the discretion that they gave to the defendants. It was held that the oral agreement
which was made between the parties, despite not being in writing expressly, was incorporated
into the terms of the contract. The courts took an approach of examining the holistic
set of circumstances as well as the evidence, rather than just looking at what was literally
written down. They looked at the entire circumstances, all of the situation, everything
that was being spoken about and they came to the conclusion that yes it was clearly the intention
of the parties to have the goods below deck. It was clearly agreed upon that this would be the case,
something they failed to do and the result of which led to a breach of contract. When we think
about written terms, for the most part when we are looking at what is incorporated into a contract,
the strongest indication that something has been made into a contract is if it is actually written
in the contract. That is almost, well that is a silver bullet in terms of argument that something
has been put into a contract, if it actually has been put into the contract. It's almost
tautological and so this is something that I'm not going to spend much time thinking about
for the most part, given the fact that when we have written terms they're incorporated into
the contract, it is often either terms that have been put in writing that are separate to a contract
or things like oral agreements that need to be incorporated into a contract as well,
as well as implied terms which are implied to the contract, all of which we'll get to in future lessons time.
