Promissory Estoppel Contract Law

History of Law
11 followers
#law #learning #education
The Law Academy is a project designed to provide legal education for students studying law in the UK. Subscribe for more content.
Citations and Sources
A. Naidoo, Complete Contract Law: Text, Cases, and Materials (Oxford University Press, 2021).
M. Chen-Wishart, Contract Law (Oxford University Press, 2022).
Disclaimer:
At no point are these video lessons intended to provide any sort of legal advice. These are for educational purposes only!
Image(s) Copyright: This Photo by Unknown Author is licensed under CC BY-SA
Welcome back everybody to the Law of Contracts. This is the final lesson where we're going to
be covering the creation of contracts and we're just going to talk about the requirements for
promissory estoppel. So the previous lesson introduced the doctrine of promissory estoppel
and what it fundamentally meant and what it entailed. We noted that what promissory estoppel
is an example of an equitable doctrine whereby an individual cannot renege on a promise. They
would be stopped from doing so. This lesson is going to talk in more detail about things that
are required to ensure that promissory estoppel can be applied. What is needed for promissory
estoppel fundamentally? So last lesson all we did really was take some time to talk about
the case that illustrates promissory estoppel, the High Trees House case.
This lesson is going to talk about what is actually needed to show promissory estoppel
or to have a successful claim for promissory estoppel. So as noted it relates to the idea of
one party in a contract waiving their rights to a certain thing and then the other party in that
contract acting on the basis that those rights have been waived and that this promise will be
kept. In that circumstance if the person who is waiving their rights then try to go against that
and try to renege on that promise then they will be stopped from doing so in the law of equity
fundamentally. It is a defense against parties being put in difficult positions having acted
on the basis that they had that a certain promise would be kept. So if you have an agreement with
one person and another person and one of these people says that we're going to waive our rights
to this thing and then you as a result of that act on the basis of the fact that you believe
that those rights have been waived and the person then comes in and says well actually we're going
to renege on that promise we're not going to I want to enforce my rights to do this thing
well then you've been put in a difficult position because you have now just acted on the basis of
the fact that that that right has been waived and the person has promised that they would not
enforce this right. If they then go on to enforce that right then it is seen in equity that they
should be stopped from doing so. Now it can only ever be the the doctrine of promissory estoppel
can only ever be a defense to this kind of action. The reason why is because equity must be a shield
and not a sword. One of the most important equitable maxims here. Equity steps in to protect
those who have been who may have been treated inequitably fundamentally. It is not used and
wielded as a sword and to essentially attack parties with. That's how equity works. So what
are required? What are the things that are required for the promissory estoppel to be applied?
Well the first thing that is needed is a clear and unequivocal promise. If we remember back to
the previous lesson to the case of Central London Property Trust versus High Trees House Limited
the owners of the block of flats made a very clear promise to the defendants. The clear promise was
we will not ask for the full rent of £2,500 a year because there had been a limited occupancy
owing to the Second World War. Now given that the lessees had acted on the basis of that promise
they had not charged so much rent it would be inequitable for this promise to then be reneged
upon because it would put High Trees House Limited in a very difficult position owing to the fact
they had acted on the basis of the fact that the promise would be kept and that their rights under
the contract would continue to be waived. The next part is that the promise in question
has to be a promise which waives the rights of one of the parties but it also has to have an
impact on the legal relationship between the parties. So what does this mean? Well if we go
back to the previous lesson what it had done is it had altered the legal relationship between
the claimants and defendants because the legal relationship was for a contract that existed
between these two individuals about a certain price of rent which was going to be owed.
That legal relationship then changed as a result of the fact that the claimants agreed to and
promised to waive their rights by reducing the rent. So there has to be a waiving of rights
and this waiving of rights has to change the legal relationship between the parties.
The next point is that the promise in question to waive the rights must be one that the other party
relies upon and that acts upon. So again if we remember back to the previous lesson what had
happened here is that the other party as a result of the fact that they had been promised that their
rights would be waived altered their behavior in relation to the promise in such a way that
it would put them in a difficult position if the promise was then to be reneged upon if they went
and tried to enforce their rights. And then this is the final point it can only ever be a defense
and so it is only in circumstances where the promise is then reneged upon and the party then
tries to claim the full rights which they had originally waived that the equitable doctrine
of estoppel comes in where they can be stopped from doing so. So those are
the requirements for promissory estoppel. There has to be first a clear and unequivocal promise.
That promise has got to be a promise which waives the rights of one of the parties and has an impact
on the legal relationship. The other party then has to rely upon this promise and change their
behavior in accordance with the fact that this promise has been made and if this promise was
then reneged upon would put them in a difficult position. And then finally it can never only ever
be used as a defense owing to the fact that equity is a shield not a sword. Finally then let's
illustrate this point in the case of Combe and Cone from 1951. In this case a husband had made
an agreement to pay his wife a certain amount of money each year. This was a total of a hundred
pounds per annum each year which in 1951 was actually quite a lot of money. When he then
refused to pay at one point his wife then sued. The claim would fail completely owing to a lack
of consideration. But it was also noted and it was also held that the doctrine of
promissory estoppel could also not be relied upon in this case given that the doctrine is only ever
a defense and not a cause of action. So if they would have relied on the doctrine of
promissory estoppel in this case it would have been in an offensive manner. It would have been
in a way that would have been used to cause an action not ever to defend against an action.
And so in quoting this point here seeing that the principle never stands alone as giving a
cause of action in itself it can never do away with the necessity of consideration when that is
an essential part of the cause of action. So the cause of action would have been the stopping of
the husband from paying the money. From not paying the money should I say. From refusing
to pay the money to renege on that promise. That would have been a case brought by the wife. So
they would have brought a case on the basis of promissory estoppel which would have meant that
promissory estoppel would have been used as a sword rather than a shield. Therefore cannot
be relied upon given that it can only ever be a defense.
