What's Happening to California's Trucking Industry

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
91 Video Views·Feb 20, 2026
California's trucking industry is moving through its longest freight slowdown in decades. Federal compliance changes and nearly $200 million in withheld funds have arrived on top of it. What does it take to keep a trucking company running in California right now?
In this episode, Eric Sauer, Executive Director of the California Trucking Association, explains what operators are facing on the ground. He also gets into a road funding proposal that has been quietly in development since 2014 and where it could land.
AI Generated·May contain errors
California trucking industry is facing unprecedented times.
Freight rates are low.
At the same time, a number of drivers lost their licenses
because of noncompliance,
and the state is losing some significant funding.
Our guest today is Eric Sauer,
who tells us what's happening in the trucking industry.
He also has an interesting view
on the tax per mile concept in California.
It's like competing in an Olympic event,
where if you're able to navigate
through all these rules and regulations,
you can get that medal at the end and be successful.
But getting through it is always the problem.
Trucks service 80% of California communities.
It's a job provider type of industry.
I believe it's one in every 21 Californians
is involved in some mode
of supporting the transportation industry.
I'm Siamak.
Welcome to California Insider.
Eric, it's great to have you back on.
Welcome back.
Thanks for having me on again.
Really appreciate it.
We want to talk to you about the trucking space.
There's a lot of news that's happening
with the federal government,
and also the trucking space is not doing well.
Can you tell us what's going on?
Since COVID, we've seen a sharp decline
in the freight market.
So it's been a very soft freight market
for the trucking industry,
not just in California, but nationally.
I think it's been, we're going on four years.
It's been three and a half,
and I've been with the association for 24 years plus.
And I've been through the 2008 time,
and then there's always been kind of it ebbs and flows,
but this is by far the longest time
or duration of a soft freight market.
And it's a myriad of factors.
You've got a lack of freight demand,
excessive capacity, inventory shifts
where warehousing or stores are not ordering as much
because maybe the demand's not there.
And then also you have the uncertainty with the tariffs
and trade policies that are pretty volatile.
So you factor all those in,
and it's a recipe for what we're going through right now.
And from an association standpoint,
we're talking with members and we're seeing,
unfortunately, some of them,
they view a trade association as a luxury
because it's not a must have to operate the business.
It's not something that we aren't doing.
They have to cut costs.
And so we're seeing some members drop
because they're struggling right now.
And so it's just all these things coming together.
And is there a light at the end of the tunnel?
There always is.
We just don't know when that is.
We're hopefully sooner rather than later.
I mean, you're starting to see some,
in certain markets it gets better,
but yeah, the last three and a half years
have been a real struggle for the trucking industry.
Is California doing worse than other parts
or is California doing okay?
I would say it's doing worse.
You can't ignore the regulatory climate
and what trucking companies have to grapple with
just to be in business in the state.
An example of that is,
you had the advanced clean fleet proposal or proposed rule.
And a lot of trucking companies figured
that was gonna be the rule of California.
And they bought trucks to be in compliance.
They made sizable investments.
Well, that rule gets unwound.
They have these trucks here.
They have huge payments on them.
The market's not going that well.
So it factors in.
California's rules and regulations do factor in
to how these businesses are able to operate in the state.
It's like the state dares businesses to be successful.
And the trucking industry is just,
it's subject to so many rules and regulations.
We just had the CEO of the port, Noel Hasegawa,
and he told us that they had record volume
Is the trucking industry not benefiting from this,
or is it?
You're seeing certain segments that are benefiting from it,
but it's all these other factors that come into play.
And certain segments are doing well.
Others aren't so much.
But I think a lot of these companies,
some of them, unfortunately,
maybe over leveraged themselves over the past few years.
But we're gonna see a slow crawl out of this.
There's another phenomenon with the federal government
and licenses in California.
There are a number of drivers,
English proficiency is not there,
and then there's a number of illegals in the space.
Can you tell us what's happening?
Yeah, so there's two items that have been in the news
quite a bit over the last few months.
Let's start with English language proficiency.
And so that has been on the books since 1937.
And basically what that is,
is drivers have to understand the language,
they have to understand the road signs.
And when they're in communication
with a law enforcement official,
they have to understand being in communication
with a law enforcement official.
For the English language proficiency,
that was relaxed in 2016.
So if you didn't speak good English
or you couldn't understand, you could still drive?
You could still drive,
it wouldn't be part of an out of service requirement.
Now it is.
So the Trump administration back a few months ago,
they gave states up until I believe June 1st
to come into compliance with enforcing it.
And unfortunately, California wasn't in compliance with it.
They are now, since January, they have been enforcing it.
But during that time from when they were out of compliance
until they started enforcing the executive order
from the administration,
they unfortunately over $40 million,
$40.8 million of mix-up funds were withheld.
And so mix-up funds are,
they go to support law enforcement,
truck enforcement,
commercial truck enforcement initiatives,
safety programs, personnel.
We felt the pinch on those funds getting taken away
because every other year,
we work in partnership with the California Highway Patrol
to put on a commercial vehicle safety summit.
And it's open to any trucking company
that does business in California.
And it's basically an all day summit
for folks to understand the rules,
safety rules, regulations, all that stuff.
And we are the ones that are financially responsible
for putting this on.
CHP brings their personnel in because through those funds,
they're able to provide travel and personnel
for those types of events.
Well, unfortunately, when those funds got taken away,
we're still on the hook
for what we have to pay the facility to host the event.
We're working with other groups
to be able to pull that event off.
But yeah, we, unfortunately,
with those funds being withheld,
we've had to kind of shift gears on that summit.
So the funds were withheld because we didn't comply?
Yes, so California Highway Patrol
was not in compliance with the executive order
of basically reinstalling
the English language proficiency understanding
from the executive order.
And so they were able to go through the process
that allows them to enforce it.
So beginning in January,
they started enforcing it.
There should be some data out there
that shows how much enforcement is going on.
But during that timeframe,
that's when the feds decided
we're gonna withhold those funds.
So unfortunately, California is missing out
on almost $41 million in mix-up funds.
Are we gonna get it back after we enforce it?
No, I think the way it's gonna work
is on a pro-active basis.
So there's no retroactive on it,
but moving forward, they'll be able to receive funds
if the data shows that they are enforcing
the provisions from the ELP requirements.
Is the industry gonna lose a lot of drivers
because of this?
It's too hard to tell.
There's 700,000 commercial driver license holders
in the state.
So we'll have to wait and see
on the impacts of the enforcement
of when that comes out,
the data, what it shows from the CHP enforcing it.
There are other things like there was controversy
over illegal drivers too as well.
Yeah, so non-domiciled commercial driver's license.
Unfortunately, there was two tragic accidents
back around the summertime and leading up to the summer.
And that kind of shined the light on drivers
who were issued non-domiciled CDLs
from the state of California that were expired.
And so what happened following those two accidents
is the FMCSA,
the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration,
they audited states and their non-domiciled license,
commercial driver's license programs.
And their audit, I believe there was 18 states
that had issues with issuing those CDLs.
Most predominantly was reissuing those licenses
when there were expiration dates from a couple of years.
I think there was an example of four years
this person's license was expired,
but they were able to continue to drive.
So obviously it's been in the news.
It's very controversial.
The audit for California found,
California has 62,000 non-domiciled CDL holders
of which 20,000 were going to be revoked.
They were gonna have those licenses revoked.
And so the feds gave the state of California
up until around January 5th to revoke those licenses.
And the state of California, I believe is January 5th,
they issued a notice saying they were gonna extend
60 days for those folks
because they were working with the feds
on trying to come up with some solutions.
So in response to that,
the feds said, okay, well,
since you're not following this
in your corrective action plan,
which we outlined what you needed to do
to follow what we're seeking you to do,
they decided to withhold $148 million
of federal highway funds from the state of California,
which I believe equates to 4% of all the federal funds
that the state receives.
But for highway funds,
these funds go towards roads, bridges,
safety of having folks operate on the roads
in the state of California.
So between those two,
you're almost $200 million being withheld
for those two items.
Was there a reason that the state didn't comply?
The audit that they went through,
the feds found some issues of not being in compliance
or following the rules.
And so this administration is showing
that they are gonna show
or they're gonna require states to follow these rules.
And so we're seeing that time and time again
with a lot of these requirements
that they're having states to follow.
So what the audit found was just a lot of gaps
in their state licensing program
on issuing of the non-domiciled CDLs.
You mentioned there's 700,000 drivers right now.
Do they all have work right now
based on what you guys are seeing?
With the freight market the way it is,
it doesn't mean that these drivers are driving all the time.
It just shows a lot of them have the ability to drive.
And they have licenses that they've been issued
to be able to be a commercial truck driver.
So as far as like the numbers of those
that are not driving or trucks are parked,
I don't have that information.
There was an electric mandate, but then that got revoked.
Last year, it was moving towards it being pulled
or it wasn't gonna go anywhere,
but we're talking about the Advanced Clean Fleet Regulation
which mandated trucks migrating from diesel
to electric trucks over a certain period of time.
We filed litigation, but I think the state and the agency,
I don't think they had Trump winning the presidency
on their bingo card.
So I think a lot of folks thought
that this rule was going to go into play.
Once the administration change occurred,
CARB withdrew the proposal from a waiver proposal
because when you have to get granted
by the Environmental Protection Agency, Federal EPA,
a waiver to move forward on something like this,
they knew that the new administration wasn't gonna pull it.
So they withdrew the waiver to allow them
to enforce the Advanced Clean Fleet Regulation.
So we were in court, other groups litigated it as well.
And so we were able to work out a settlement with CARB
where later on this year,
they're gonna officially strike that
from the code of regulation.
So the ACF will be gone.
And I honestly don't think you're gonna see another rule
or regulation similar to that.
That rule was just ripe with just many issues.
You had lack of infrastructure, cost of these vehicles,
weight concerns.
These trucks, I think in time,
you will see a larger penetration of these vehicles
into the market.
But under a regulation like that,
it just was doomed for failure.
But since that time, it's the state of California.
They would like to see the trucking industry
go into a zero emission type.
And we're actively engaged on discussions
on what they're looking at.
It's probably too soon to tell,
but they are having workshops.
They are involving the industry and stakeholders
on providing input on what the next proposal
could look like.
I think timing wise,
you probably won't see much as far as a framework
for a couple of years, maybe next year.
But I think timing wise,
it's gonna align with when,
if there is a change in the federal administration,
if it's a democratically led presidency,
that's when you're probably gonna see a timing
for the next rule as far as the transitioning of a fleet
from diesel to electric.
Also pay close attention to indirect source rules.
And so indirect source rules are basically a rule
we'll use, for example,
South Coast Air Quality Management District
and their warehouse rule for indirect source rules.
It's a rule placed on facilities that intake trucks
for delivering goods into their warehouse.
And so their rule applies to warehouses
over 100,000 square feet.
And so what's been talked about is you're seeing other
states looking at indirect source rules
to bring down emissions,
but also the California legislature,
they just introduced a statewide proposal.
I think it's AB 1777 that would allow CARB
to promulgate a statewide indirect source rule.
So pay close attention to that.
We're obviously engaged on that,
but that would allow other regional entities to adopt
or implement something similar to what South Coast is doing.
There's a lot-
So essentially, they would monitor the emissions
at the warehouse.
Correct, and so if your facility does not meet
certain emission requirements,
you're gonna have to do things, invest in it,
invest in your facility to be able to bring
those emissions levels down.
And one of the ways that you can do that is
you can go to your trucking companies
that service your facility and say,
you need to bring your emissions levels down.
You need to change your fleet.
So you're gonna have to operate zero emission trucks
or we're not gonna let you service the facilities.
The facility, they have to make investments like solar,
make those types of investments
to bring emissions levels down.
How would something like that impact you guys?
Oh, if you aren't able to service your customers,
unless you have electric vehicles,
you have to make that decision.
Am I gonna invest in these types of equipment?
I have to be able to service my customers.
I have to stay in business.
So if you're seeing more and more of those types of rules,
it could be problematic.
But it also, what happens is it just drives the costs up
for everybody else.
So my members or our members are just moving the freight.
It's the customer's freight.
And so what the customer will do is,
well, okay, the trucking company,
they're saddled with these regulations
that they have to invest all this money
in upgrading their equipment.
They're not gonna absorb that.
They're gonna have to pass it on to their customer
who then is going to pass those charges or fees,
raise the prices to you and I, the consumer.
And so it's the downstream impact
that people don't really understand
is when you put these rules and regulations
on these businesses,
and in particular in our industry,
we're just transporting the freight.
Rates have been depressed for years.
I mean, during COVID, you saw a very large increase
for rates because people, the demand was there.
People needed their stuff to get moved.
But it's always, it's historically lower rates.
And so these folks, if they're having to invest more
into really expensive trucks or technology,
they can't absorb that.
So they're gonna pass it to the customer.
Exactly.
And what about the roads?
The quality of the roads in California are questionable.
And I've driven in different counties
and I've seen some of the best areas,
best cities of California.
Unfortunately, the roads are not in a good shape.
What are your thoughts on that?
The transportation funding bucket
to pay for road improvement, bridges, capacity improvements,
that funding bucket is shrinking.
And the reason it's shrinking
is you're seeing cars getting way better gas mileage
than they did historically.
So their pay into the pot is less.
You're also seeing-
For the gas tax.
Collected.
Yeah, and so the way it works is when you go
to fill up your gas tank at the local gas station,
you put the pump in there, that's your payment.
Every time you fill up, that money is going
towards the tax and everything is going
towards road improvements.
It goes into the transportation funding pot.
And that's like kind of strict, right?
It's going to that.
Yeah, so it's basically, that's how you pay your share
of operating your car to pay for the roads
when you fill up the gas tax and the sales of the gas,
that goes towards transportation funding.
So you're seeing cars with better gas mileage
and you're also seeing a larger penetration
of electric vehicles into the marketplace.
And the electric vehicles, up until a few years ago,
they paid nothing, but now they're paying $100
and I think it's adjusted for inflation costs every year,
but it's a road improvement fee of $100.
And the average person that's driving is paying $300
for their gas vehicle.
Is that per year?
Yeah, so that's, you know, each person that drives,
that's what the data shows.
And so that funding bucket is shrinking.
And so the state, a few years ago,
they wanted to see if there's other options
that they could look into to substitute
the current mechanism of how roads are paid for
with something else.
And so what's been talked about for years
is a per mile fee, vehicle miles traveled,
road user charge, those are the Ackermans
or RUC road user charge, and then also VMT.
And it's not received very well,
but the state is looking into that as a option
other than the current mechanism
of how you pay for roads.
And so-
There was a bill to study that, right?
And a lot of people are angry about it.
Yeah, and I'll walk you through a little bit of,
you know, before that.
So in 2014, recognizing that something has to be looked into
and, you know, we have to start planning for this.
And so they created a technical advisory committee,
road user charge technical advisory committee.
I'm one of the representatives on it under the,
I represent the road user portion of folks,
myself and AAA.
And so you have really great experts.
They did a really good job on putting together
a good advisory committee.
And so you have privacy experts,
you have academia folks,
you have transportation funding experts,
you have rural communities represented,
you have agricultural,
all sorts of different entities are represented
because we wanna make sure that we're getting input
from multiple stakeholders.
And so since 2015, we've been meeting, you know,
probably four or five times a year
and looking at identifying issues
of a road user charge type program.
There has been some pilot programs that have occurred.
There is one that is going on also.
Originally and ideally what was talked about
is finding a way to substitute the current gas tax
and swap that with a road user charge,
make it revenue neutral.
And so what you're seeing a lot out there
is I think a lot of people are confusing that
and saying, oh no, it's gonna be both.
The intended purpose of it was to find a substitute,
just a straight swap of those two
and come up with a revenue neutral number for that.
So that's what's, you know, what's being looked at.
Unfortunately, you're also seeing
a lot of other special interest groups
that are getting involved in the process.
And I like to call it the old Christmas tree analogy
with people putting on their ornaments on their tree
and they overload their tree with too many ornaments.
Well, what happens with the tree?
It falls over, right?
When you start putting,
you start decorating a road user charge tree
with multiple ornaments,
stuff that are things that need to get looked at,
but do they need to get looked at
through the transportation funding lens?
The public does not view favorably
to swap over to a road user charge for a myriad of factors.
You have privacy concerns, evasion of paying,
administrative costs, what's that gonna look like,
which obviously if administrative costs are expensive
or, you know, higher, who's gonna be paying for that?
It's gonna be increased, what you're paying into the pot.
So it's all these things that are getting looked at
and need to get looked at.
Now, for our industry,
it's different than just you driving your personal car.
You're talking about fleets,
you're talking about out-of-state fleets.
What about the out-of-state competition?
Are they gonna be subject to this?
So there's all these things that we are looking at
to see if this is a viable program.
Is it, does it have issues?
Absolutely, but those are the things
that need to get looked at and flushed out
before you make that transition.
And we're looking at, you know, a few years down the road
if that even does happen.
When I talk with my members and from the industry,
we understand that something has to get looked at.
Could this be a viable option?
I don't know, but we are definitely gonna be involved
in the process and have a seat at the table
throughout the discussions.
We pay over 4 billion annually.
That's our chip into the transportation funding pot.
So we're paying, you know, the average truck
through licensing, registration, taxes and fees
the average truck is over $12,000.
That you see rolling down that truck is,
yeah, that truck is contributing $12,000 in taxes and fees
just to operate that one truck.
But as a whole, the trucking industry
is contributing over 4 billion
or almost $4 billion annually towards roads.
Are you using as much?
With the trucking industry,
you're not seeing like the leaps
that the passenger cars have seen
as far as like miles per gallon increase.
As a matter of fact, some of our members say
that they get worse fuel economy from the trucks
from years ago of the trucks that they utilize.
So you're not seeing that huge gain
with the trucking industry as far as mileage improvements.
But what they're looking at obviously
over the past many years is electric vehicles for trucks,
you know, trucks, you know, ZEVs for the trucking industry.
And that could be the way it goes in a few years,
but it has to be done right.
Let the market dictate itself.
And I do think you'll see more and more
of those on the road down in the next few years.
In California, we have our own rules
and it's different from the rest of the country.
In terms of out of state trucking companies,
are they doing business with us
and are they coming into California?
Because some people had said they didn't want to come here.
Yeah, you're seeing that.
But what I always say is
there's such a huge customer base in this state.
You can't ignore the business opportunity that it presents.
Does it have its challenges?
Absolutely.
But there still is a lot of trucking companies
that are operating in and out of California
just because of the business that it does provide.
But it does dare businesses to be successful.
And it's like competing in an Olympic event
where if you're able to navigate
through all these rules and regulations,
you can get that medal at the end and be successful.
But getting through it is always the problem.
The federal government just changed some ruling EPA did.
Is that going to impact
the out of state trucking companies coming into California
or are they still regulated by the California?
You're talking about the Clean Truck Check Program.
So we'll call it the CTC.
That is the nation's first
and I believe the only smog check program
for trucks, commercial trucks.
Recently, the federal government, the EPA,
basically ruled that that program cannot be used
for emissions reductions
under the state's state implementation plan.
So previously they were able to utilize the reductions
from that program to count towards the SIP.
And so what they basically said is
you cannot use that for your reductions.
California, which sees it as a viable program
in their efforts on reducing emissions,
they're continuing to utilize that program
on in-state fleets
and they also are going to be continuing to use it
on out of state fleets,
meaning that trucks that come in from out of state.
The feds say that, you know,
they've been talking about that
being a interstate commerce clause violation.
So we'll see how that plays out.
CARB is pretty adamant that they do have the authority
that they can still enforce it on out of state fleets.
We're in constant contact with CARB about this.
We're in constant contact with EPA about it.
We're in constant contact with our members.
So we'll just have to wait and see how that plays out.
In terms of the trucking space,
so you said certain areas are doing well
and certain areas are not doing well.
What can the state do for you guys?
There's a lot of factors that have to occur
with the volatility of these trade policies
are either working out or not working out on the tariffs.
There's a lot of uncertainty there.
I think long-term, you know,
you see a lot of benefit long-term from those possibly,
but for us, the trucking industry,
it leads to a lot of uncertainty.
And so, you know, their customers are, you know,
maybe pausing on making decisions
that they historically used to just make all the time.
And so it's impacting our folks.
What I've noticed over the years
is when certain segments are struggling,
this industry is very resilient.
And I really appreciate representing
trucking company owners
is that these are multi-generational trucking companies.
You know, third, you know,
second or third generation family-run trucking companies,
job providers do a lot for communities,
like in donations, they're always helpful,
always willing to help out folks.
They're also very resilient.
And so an example I like to use is one of our members,
he was in a different segment of the industry.
That segment of the industry was really slowing down.
So he pivoted to entertainment,
so sporting events, concerts,
and his company's thriving
and they've been doing really well.
And you see a lot of those examples,
but it's just, it's a struggle
for a lot of these trucking companies.
To answer your question on what they can do
to make things easier is the lack of uncertainty
during the whole advanced clean fleet regulation
that was moving forward up until they withdrew the waiver.
You had a lot of companies
that just made this huge investment
because they thought that that's the way
this was gonna go.
And unfortunately, you know, they made the investment
and they got these big payments
and it's impacting their ability to, you know,
in some cases, stay in business.
So, you know, from the state's perspective,
if you're gonna come up with these types of programs
that are mandating you to transition
to zero emission vehicles,
there has to be a funding source to help offset those costs
because those costs for those vehicles
is extremely expensive.
And in some cases, they're usually three, four times more
than what they're driving right now.
What's the impact of the trucking industry
in California in general?
Why should average people care about?
Well, it's the old saying,
if you got it, a truck brought it.
So this is the kind of stuff I really like to talk about.
Trucks service 80% of California communities.
So most communities in the state,
they receive their products and goods from a truck.
And so it's a job provider type of industry.
I believe it's one in every 21 Californians
is involved in some mode of, you know,
supporting the transportation industry,
whether that's warehouse worker, truck driver,
it's just a huge footprint.
But I think what this industry really showed
was during COVID and how around the clock
drivers were working to make sure
that folks were receiving the necessary goods and services
that they needed during that time.
And unfortunately, when you see a truck down the road,
it's someone that's like, oh, that polluting,
you know, heavy truck,
look at the damage it's doing to the roads.
Well, since the on-road truck and bus rule regulation
from, you know, the first in the port,
the port rule from a year before that,
two years before that,
the trucking industry has cleaned up
the environment significantly.
And they've invested billions of dollars
in clean burning, clean diesel burning motors and engines.
And so they've invested in it.
So we've done our fair share and then, you know,
and more of cleaning up the environment.
And there's constantly improvements in the technology.
We understand that,
but you look at the results from the emissions reductions
from the trucking industry,
since those two rules came into place,
you also look at what the industry pays to go towards roads.
When people say, oh, they beat up these roads.
As I mentioned earlier, they pay almost $4 billion.
And that goes towards road improvement.
And we represent a fraction of the motoring public.
So they are making the investment in, you know,
improving the roads.
A lot of these companies, you know,
people talk about accidents involving trucks.
Accidents happen, unfortunately,
but the trucking industry, they're, you know,
regulated for many safety regulations
to make sure that their trucks are operating safe.
They have to do inspection checks on the vehicles
and all that.
They're subject to,
so California truckers are the only state
that has essentially the trucking industry
is regulated by two safety programs.
So the California Highway Patrol
has its basic inspection of terminal program.
And then the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration,
USDOT has the federal inspection programs.
So California truckers,
they're subject to two safety programs.
Eric Sauer with California Trucking Association.
It was great to have you on.
Hopefully you guys will do better soon.
Yeah, thank you.
Thanks for having me on.
Appreciate it.
Tell us what you think about this discussion with Eric.
Do you agree with Eric's points?
And what are your thoughts on tax per mile concept?
You can always email us at ciamacacaliforniansider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Ciamak Khorrami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.
