Many in the independence movement are frustrated by the lack of progress since 2014, despite Brexit, Westminster scandals, and rising support for independence.
In this film, we explore the SNP’s golden years under Alex Salmond, what changed after the 2014 referendum, the IndyRef2 strategy, the Supreme Court block, internal divisions in the movement, and why trust in politicians has become a key issue for pro-independence voters.
If you’re asking where did it all go wrong for Scottish independence, this breakdown takes you through the key moments and turning points.
0:00 Intro Independence stalled 0:44 SNP golden years (2007-2014) 1:38 2014 referendum fallout 2:21 Frustration with SNP strategy 3:17 IndyRef2 and Section 30 block 4:22 Alex Salmond and SNP rise 6:41 2011 majority and referendum 7:41 Media, fear and Better Together 11:46 Brexit - the turning point 13:15 IndyRef2 timeline and delays 15:13 Supreme Court and legal route 16:05 Gender reform priorities debate 16:55 Salmond allegations and fallout 19:07 Alba and list vote split 21:14 Operation Branchform impact 22:10 Did Sturgeon betray the cause? 23:16 What happens next for independence? 26:19 Outro
Where did it all go wrong?
It's a question many in the Scottish independence movement
have been asking for some time now.
The SNP was riding the crest of a wave from 2007 to 2014,
winning a majority of seats in 2011
in a system designed by the UK state
to prevent independence parties from ever
gaining a majority in the new devolved parliament.
But the result in 2011 forced then Prime Minister David
Cameron to agree to an independence referendum,
raising excitement and genuine optimism among those
who felt Scotland should be a normal, independent country
of a better future away from the suffocating and largely
failing union.
The majority won under the late Alex Salmond's leadership
in 2011 was a testament to a highly successful devolved
government in Scotland, which appeared
to run like a well-oiled machine,
seamless between all departments and delivering
on so many of its manifesto commitments,
from freezing council tax, abolishing bridge tolls,
scrapping prescription charges, to restoring
free university education, building the Queen's Ferry
crossing on time and under budget,
a huge contrast to Westminster's HS2 and the London Crossrail
project, increasing renewable energy capacity
and putting an extra 1,000 police officers on Scotland's
streets, leading to the lowest levels of recorded crime
in 30 years, all while London was slashing police numbers
in England, and all this achieved with both hands tied
behind their backs by the stifling Westminster system.
Salmond and his deputy Nicola Sturgeon
appeared to be at one.
She was Salmond's closest and most trusted ally.
So when Salmond stood down after the 2014 referendum defeat
and his deputy took over the reins,
many felt confident that the SNP's track record
of delivering for the Scottish people
and pressing home the independence cause would continue.
So what did go wrong?
Join us as we delve deeper into why the push
towards independence has stalled for the past decade,
despite Brexit and the endless round
of Westminster scandals, corruption, and sleaze.
Before we take a closer look at why the push
to Scottish independence has seemingly stalled,
please like, comment, and subscribe to our channel.
And let us know where in Scotland or the world
you're watching from in the comments below.
Many in today's independence movement believe
the SNP has given up on independence
to become a British devolutionist party instead.
They believe that unlike the golden years
between 2011 and 2014, the SNP, like most parties,
has been hijacked by career politicians,
riding the Westminster gravy train,
and way too cosy with their feet
under the Westminster table.
There's no doubt the independence movement
in Scotland has become fractured
compared to the years leading up
to the 2014 independence referendum,
when a non-party campaign group, Yes Scotland,
succeeded in shifting support for independence
from 27% to a minimum of 45%.
And whilst support for independence
is now almost certainly significantly over 50%,
there's little excitement in the air,
unlike the hope and optimism which characterise
the movement in the run-up to 2014.
Many in the movement are sceptical
about John Swinney's SNP majority, both votes plan,
where if the SNP win a majority
against the predictions of all polling,
he will be able to demand another section 30 order
from the English prime minister of the day,
whoever that may be, despite the fact
that a succession of prime ministers,
both Labour and Tory, have continued
to rule it out under any circumstances.
This frustration, which began under Nicola Sturgeon's
near decade in office as first minister
and continued under her successors,
Humza Yousaf and then John Swinney,
has only grown since with new parties,
most notably ALIPA and most recently Liberate Scotland,
promising independence, nothing else,
being set up to fill the perceived void left by the SNP.
The problem for pro-independence voters boils down to trust.
Very few people trust politicians
regardless of who they are.
Does John Swinney just want another five cushy years
leading the devolved administration?
Or does he know something we don't
with regard to what many in the movement believe
is a flawed policy?
I guess we won't know until after the May election.
Of the new parties set up to fill the void,
publicly at least, is ALIPA,
founded by retired television producer Laurie Flynn,
which was led by Alex Salmond.
Regardless of what some may have thought of him
and he has had his detractors,
most people certainly within
the Scottish independence movement
regard Alex Salmond as the man who came closest
to freeing Scotland from the Anglo-British Union.
Indeed, this charismatic figure,
a true giant in Scottish politics,
transformed the SNP from a political sideshow
to a major force, not just in Scotland,
but across the UK,
where Scotland was finally being noticed for a change.
Little wonder then that the UK state saw him
as a genuine threat to its survival
and would later go on to do what it does best,
destroy the reputations of its most dangerous adversaries
with the help of its compliant media.
Having successfully defeated Margaret Ewing
in the SNP leadership contest of 1990,
Salmond went on to lead the party
through the first elections
to the devolved Scottish Parliament nine years later,
where the SNP emerged as the largest opposition party
to the Labour administration.
In 2000, however, following some internal criticism
and fallouts with party members,
Salmond was replaced by John Swinney
while he went on to become the party's Westminster leader.
Swinney was seen as a safe pair of hands,
but he was never going to set the heather on fire.
Four years later, Swinney stood down
following the party's poor performance
in the 2004 European election,
which followed an equally poor performance
in the Scottish parliamentary election a year before.
Despite having the overwhelming support
of party delegates in 2003,
the SNP began privately briefing against Swinney
following the European election results a year later.
Rosanna Cunningham was the first to launch her bid
for the leadership, followed by Nicola Sturgeon
and then Mike Russell.
Speculation abounded as to whether Alec Neill,
who ran in the 2000 leadership contest against Swinney,
would run and whether Salmond would also run.
After initially declining to stand,
Salmond launched his bid
and Sturgeon withdrew her candidacy to support him
while she stood for deputy leader on a joint ticket.
From there on in, it seemed as if the SNP were unassailable
and they emerged as the largest party at Holyrood
following the 2007 Scottish election.
Salmond headed up the first SNP minority government
with Sturgeon as his deputy
and between 2007 and 2012,
she served as health secretary
overseeing the scrapping of NHS prescription charges.
Having gained the trust of the Scottish people,
the SNP went on to win a landslide majority in 2011,
which forced then Prime Minister David Cameron
into agreeing to an independence referendum.
It had always been argued by unionists
that Scotland was in a voluntary union
so the English state, posing as the UK,
could hardly deny a vote
given that Salmond's party
had achieved the seemingly impossible
by winning a majority in a voting system
deliberately designed to prevent independence parties
like the SNP from doing so.
A genuine wave of hope and optimism
that Scotland might actually be able to look forward
to a far brighter future than that on offer
from a highly centralised Anglo-British state
swept across Scotland
whilst the UK mainstream media
did everything it could to dampen support
with scare stories and omission,
a powerful propaganda tool in itself.
They wanted to make it seem
that a country running its own affairs
and its own interests
was somehow an unusual proposition
and that Scotland, despite six decades of oil and gas
flowing from its waters,
was far too poor and insignificant
to be able to go it alone
without the broader shoulders
of the mighty Anglo-British state to prop it up.
As a collective mouthpiece for the UK state,
they went into overdrive
to talk Scotland down at every opportunity
and mislead Scots into believing
that it was only because of the largesse of England
that Scotland had any chance of surviving
whilst many billions of pounds in oil revenues
flowed from Scotland into the English UK Treasury
to be invested in London or simply squandered.
According to the UK government,
Scotland's oil has provided 400 billion in tax revenues
since the 70s,
although it must be remembered
that under England's control,
Scotland's oil was sold off
at three times less than independent Norway achieved
from its smaller oil sector.
That has allowed Norway,
a country with the same sized population as Scotland,
to go on to become the fourth richest country in the world
with a sovereign wealth fund of nearly $2 trillion
while Scotland, as part of the UK,
has no sovereign wealth fund at all,
not a single penny.
The fact that broadcasting and media was not devolved
should have set alarm bells ringing for Salmond,
who should have anticipated
that the entitled and corrupt UK state
would stop at nothing
to thwart Scotland's right to self-governance.
They gave way more coverage
to the unionist Better Together campaign
and hardly ever challenged anything
Better Together or the stream of unionist politicians
who were barely off our screens claimed,
no matter how untrue or wild those claims were,
and always portrayed the Yes campaign negatively,
challenging everything pro-independence politicians
said in minute detail
on the comparatively few occasions
they were invited on screen.
But despite this, polling at one point in the campaign
showed Yes in the lead
and the Anglo-British establishment went into panic mode,
even enlisting Queen Elizabeth
to make a speech in support of the union
despite the monarch being supposedly politically neutral.
The unionist side also scared pensioners
with claims that no one in an independent Scotland
would get their state pension if they voted Yes,
and the media gave zero coverage to a statement
from the Department of Work and Pensions
rubbishing the claims, confirming that they were untrue.
And Salmond made what was seen as a fatal mistake
during a television debate with Edinburgh South MP
and Better Together chairman Alistair Darling
when he maintained,
against the advice of his closest advisers,
that Scotland would continue to use
the English pound sterling as its currency,
allowing England to say
that it would block Scotland from doing so,
even though it couldn't,
as the pound is an internationally traded currency.
That, coupled with the breaking of Perder rules
when Westminster unionist politicians had the so-called vow,
a list of everything the union promised to do
if Scots voted No,
published on the front page of the Daily Record
two days before the vote,
left the Yes campaign hold below the waterline.
In the event, the Yes campaign had swung support
for independence in Scotland,
from 27% to a solid 45%,
changing Scotland forever
and making the prospect of independence
far more likely than it was before.
Salmond resigned on September 19th,
the day after the vote,
and Nicholas Sturgeon became first minister,
picking up a wave of support
from bitterly disappointed independence supporters,
which saw the SNP's membership surge
from just 20,000 to more than 120,000.
Whilst unionists often cited the 2014 referendum
as a once-in-a-generation event,
Sturgeon argued that the independence movement
must continue as long as support exists
and circumstances change.
And Scotland did not have to wait long
for circumstances to change.
Britain's warp media had UKIP leader Nigel Farage
appearing almost daily on TV screens
following the 2014 vote,
leading to England narrowly voting
to leave the EU in 2016
and dragging Scotland out against its will,
showing clearly that Scotland has absolutely no voice
in this supposed union of equals.
Sturgeon argued that this constituted
a significant and material change in circumstances,
especially as unionists had told Scots
during the independence campaign
that the only way to remain in the EU
was to vote to remain in the UK.
Based on her comments,
many in the independence movement
believed that she had a secret plan
ready and waiting to capitalise on the Brexit vote
and that a second referendum would be forthcoming.
Hopes were raised when,
against a background of Brexit uncertainty,
she declared that Scotland's interests
cannot be properly or fully protected
within a UK context
and independence must remain a viable option.
She then published a draft bill
for a second independence referendum,
much to the dismay of unionist politicians
who refused to accept
that being dragged out of the European Union
against the will of the majority of Scots
was a material change in circumstances.
However, London insisted that,
despite previously acknowledging
the sovereignty of the Scottish people,
the devolved parliament,
a branch of Westminster,
doesn't have the authority
to hold a legally binding referendum,
not even a consultative one.
As far as the English UK government were concerned,
the issue of Scottish independence
had already been addressed
and then-PM Theresa May
had her hands full dealing with the fallout
from Brexit with UKIP
and right-wing Tories pressing for a hard Brexit
in withdrawal negotiations with Brussels.
It was at this point
that Sturgeon appeared to start rowing back
from her earlier statements
when she told the SNP conference
that Indyref 2 would only happen
if there was strong and consistent evidence
that people had changed their minds
and that independence had become the choice
of a clear majority.
This, on the face of it, appeared sensible,
but many expected that the SNP
would then immediately address
the issue of campaigning
to persuade the population as a whole
that independence represented
the best future for Scotland,
something which was notably absent.
Nevertheless, she did announce
the Scottish government's intention
to hold a second referendum on independence
between the autumn of 2018
and spring of 2019
and said she would seek a Section 30 order
from the UK,
allowing a legal referendum to take place,
despite the Brexit-preoccupied UK government
ruling this out.
That would be the gold standard, Sturgeon said.
Following the SNP's election-winning streak
in 2016, albeit with the loss of some seats,
Sturgeon pushed the limits of devolution
with the EU Continuity Bill
in an attempt to ensure Scots' law alignment
with EU law post-Brexit.
This was challenged by the UK government
in the so-called UK Supreme Court,
set up by Tony Blair in 2009,
despite the fact that Scotland and England
have entirely separate legal systems.
Being effectively an English court,
it was hardly surprising that it ruled
in favour of the English UK government.
Sturgeon remained adamant
that the Scottish government
had a mandate for holding a second referendum
on the basis that the SNP won
the 2016 Scottish Parliament election
and that Brexit represented
a material change of circumstances.
But then-Prime Minister Boris Johnson
made clear that his government
would not grant a Section 30 order
to furnish the Scottish Parliament
with the power to hold it.
So, perhaps surprisingly given the previous ruling,
she referred the question of the legality
of the draft referendum bill
to the so-called UK Supreme Court
under paragraph 34 of Schedule 6
of the Scotland Act 1998.
Again, to many in the independence movement,
it was hardly surprising that this English court
rejected it, causing increasing frustration
at what many regarded as half-hearted attempts
to deliver Scottish independence,
even though she described the ruling
as a democratic outrage,
confirming that the notion of the UK
as a voluntary partnership of nations,
if it ever was a reality,
is no longer a reality.
She insisted alternative means were necessary
to ensure Scottish democracy was not denied,
and Scotland's voice was heard on independence,
proposing that the next UK general election
in 2019 should be a de facto referendum
on Scottish independence.
At around the same time, Sturgeon pledged
to review and reform gender recognition laws
to align with international best practice.
From 2017 onwards, the Scottish government
began formal public consultations
on reforming the Gender Recognition Act
to introduce a self-declaration system,
leading some in the movement
to question her priorities
and the lack of any real campaigning
by the SNP in the previous three years
to persuade Scots that independence
was the only way for Scotland
to protect its own interests
in a union where only England has a voice.
She was clearly becoming distracted
by gender reform.
Unbeknown to the wider public,
in January 2018, the Scottish government
received formal complaints
of sexual misconduct made against Sturgeon's
former friend and mentor, Alex Salmond,
allegations dating back to 2013
while he was First Minister.
These became public on August 24th, 2018,
when the Pro-Union Daily Record
exclusively reported that Salmond
had been reported to the police
over claims he sexually assaulted
two Bute House staff members
during his time as First Minister.
Salmond resigned from the SNP.
On January 24th, 2019,
Police Scotland charged Salmond
with 14 offences against 10 women,
including two counts of attempted rape,
nine of sexual assault,
two of indecent assault,
and one of breach of the peace
in what some in the movement
regarded as a stitch-up by the British state
as punishment for Salmond
daring to challenge it
and almost succeeding in ending the union.
Suspicions that the whole scandal
had been engineered by MI5
to bring down Salmond,
widely seen as the biggest threat to the union,
were confirmed in the eyes of many
in the independence movement
when a jury cleared Salmond
of all the sexual assault charges
laid against him,
allegations which he had told the court
were deliberate fabrications
for a political purpose.
However, his former protégé
did not come out unscathed
from her handling of the internal investigation,
which preceded the court case.
Whilst an independent report found Sturgeon
did not breach the ministerial code,
a separate inquiry by MSPs
questioned some of her evidence
and described the Scottish government's
The Scottish government eventually admitted
it had acted unlawfully
and had to pay Salmond
more than half a million pounds
in legal fees.
Ironically, Sturgeon had once said of Salmond
when questioned over what were regarded
as sexist remarks he had made to Anna Soubry
in the Commons
following his return to Westminster in 2015,
There's no man I know who is less sexist.
By 2020, however,
Covid had arrived
and despite some misgivings
over her commitment to independence,
and her mishandling of the Salmond inquiry,
Sturgeon's daily Covid briefings
compared to Boris Johnson's
chaotic handling of the pandemic in England,
not to mention his rule-breaking parties
at Number 10
and the non-stop PPE scandals,
led people throughout Britain
to praise her handling of Covid in Scotland.
But it was after forming a coalition
with the Scottish Greens in August 2021
that Sturgeon accelerated her plans
on the Gender Recognition Reform Bill
to the increasing frustration
of many in the independence movement
who wanted independence
to be far higher up on her list of priorities.
In the meantime,
Salmond went on to lead the Allopaw Party
in February of that year
in what he described as his bid
to build a super-majority for independence.
However, the SNP continued to encourage supporters
to give both the first and second-list seat votes
to the SNP,
widely seen as allowing unionists into the Parliament
through the back door
on second votes for seats they hadn't actually won.
Salmond argued that voting SNP 1 and Allopaw
on the second vote
would boost the number of pro-independence MSPs,
creating a super-majority.
But Sturgeon refused to work with Allopaw,
which some regarded as dividing the movement,
which, before 2014, had been united
under the non-party political banner
of the Yes campaign.
Nevertheless, the SNP won its fourth consecutive term
in devolved government with 64 seats,
a net increase of one from the 2016 election.
Bolstered by the result,
Sturgeon heavily championed the passing
of the contentious Gender Recognition Reform Scotland Bill,
which aimed to make it easier for people
to change their legal gender
whilst many felt independence should be the priority.
Polling also suggested that public opinion
on gender reform in Scotland
was deeply divided with 51% of people opposed
and only 26% supporting the move,
with 23% having no view either way.
Opposition centred on concerns
about the removal of medical certification
and the potential impact on women's rights
and single-sex spaces.
Nevertheless, gender reform, not independence,
appeared to drive Sturgeon's administration
much to the frustration of many in the movement
who had concerns over aspects of the policy
and who believed that it was long overdue
that the SNP should prioritise independence.
However, allegations that funds specifically raised
by the SNP for independence campaigning
had been spent on other activities
led to Police Scotland launching an investigation,
Operation Branchform, in 2021,
which precipitated the resignation of Nicola Sturgeon
as SNP leader and first minister in March 2023,
although she claimed her leaving office
was to do with burnout.
She was drained by the unrelenting
and unforgiving pressures of modern politics, she said.
Like the Alex Salmond case a few years earlier,
media coverage of Operation Branchform
and perceived delays in bringing the case to a conclusion
led both the SNP's supporters and its opponents
to claim that the investigation had been politicised
by the Anglo-British state
to undermine the SNP's electoral chances
as much as possible.
Why, for example, would police need to put up
a large forensic tent,
usually only used in murder investigations,
on the lawn of the former first minister's home,
if not to create a photo opportunity
for unionist media to gleefully exploit?
So, did Nicola Sturgeon betray the independence movement?
She certainly made some bad choices,
referring the bid to allow a second referendum
to an English court rather than Scotland's highest court,
the Court of Session in Edinburgh, for example.
And her almost complete obsession with gender reform
certainly did her no favours either,
with just 0.44% of the population in Scotland
identifying as trans.
She also failed to capitalise on Brexit.
But such is the continuing chaos in London politics
with a daily crisis confronting the most unpopular
of unpopular governments in London,
the SNP look on course to win May's Scottish election,
the fifth in a row.
Regardless of the damage the UK clearly continues to do
to Scotland, however,
Swinney's insistence that an SNP majority
will lead to any UK government
is very unlikely,
given how close they came to losing in 2014.
And with polls suggesting the SNP
are unlikely to win a majority of seats,
Swinney will have the perfect excuse to claim
that he doesn't have a mandate
to call on the UK government to agree to one.
It seems the Scottish independence cause
has been boxed into a corner for now.
But as former Prime Minister Harold Wilson once said,
The growth of reform and the potential for Labour
to lose Wales to plied Cymru for the first time ever
could see the union collapse all on its own
in something akin to Scotland's Berlin Wall moment.
So, did Nicola Sturgeon betray the independence cause?
Was she being blackmailed by the British state
to hollow out the SNP?
Probably not.
In life, everyone makes mistakes,
even political giants like Alex Salmond.
But one thing is for certain.
Voting SNP 1 and 2 is an appallingly bad idea,
unless you live in an area
that is likely to return a Tory candidate
with a landslide majority
and where reform is unlikely to split the unionist vote.
Otherwise, voting SNP 1 and another independence party,
which has the greatest chance of success on the list vote,
is a far better way to go
if you want Scotland to be a normal country,
able to be governed in Scotland's best interests.
At present, the Greens look set to do best
and polls suggesting they will win nine seats
on the list vote bar one, Edinburgh Central.
Because the reality is
that few other smaller independence parties
that have been created to make independence the priority
realistically have little chance
of breaking through to electoral success
without huge financial backing
and access to Anglo-British mainstream media,
which they won't get.
It's not ideal, but it is reality.
However, whichever independence party
has the best chance of success on the second list vote
is the one to vote for.
Hopefully, they will secure enough MSPs
to ensure that a minority SNP government
doesn't stray off course
and makes independence their driving priority again.
Of course, where politicians are concerned,
there are still no guarantees they will deliver.
But at least making clear that you want independence
is way better than voting for a pro-union party
in any circumstances.
After all, the principle that Scotland's place
in the union is voluntary
has been explicitly and repeatedly affirmed
by successive UK prime ministers
who have stated in the UK parliament
that Scotland is an equal partner
in a voluntary union of nations
and then gone on to block Scotland's right
to decide its own future.
These are not offhand remarks by British politicians.
They are foundational statements
of the UK's constitutional arrangements.
The critical question, therefore,
is not if the union is voluntary,
but how that stated position is to be made real.
A promise without a process is merely poetry.
A right that cannot be exercised is not a right at all.
It is a fiction.