Trapped in a Coma for 20 Years: The Sarah Scantlin Miracle
Feb 19, 2026
In 1984, 18-year-old Sarah Scantlin was left in a coma-like state after a hit-and-run. For two decades she lay seemingly unresponsive—until, in 2005, she spoke: “Hi, Mom.” This film traces Sarah’s extraordinary re-emergence, from that first phone call to the painstaking rehab that followed. Through her family’s home videos, best friend Lori’s memories, and clinicians explaining minimally conscious states and neuroplasticity, we explore the science and the mystery behind a recovery doctors said was impossible. A tender, hopeful portrait of love, grit, and the long road back.
Good evening. For 2,000 years, the miracle stories have been part of Christian tradition.
The curing of the sick, the raising of the dead, the feeding of the 5,000.
But do miracles still happen today? Every year, millions of devout Christians make their way to
shrines such as Lourdes, hoping for a miraculous cure. Tonight, we look at two case studies of
what believers claim are modern-day miracles. In our second story, the evidence was so convincing
that even the Vatican was compelled to take note. But first, the story of a woman who thought she
was dying of an incurable disease. Now she's well. But was it a miracle?
Now, we have a grand day for traveling, Marion. Ladies and gentlemen.
Sunday, the 3rd of September, 1989. Marion Carroll begins the journey which will change her life.
Diagnosed as severely ill with multiple sclerosis, she was taken from her home in Athlone,
County Westmeath, on a pilgrimage to a small village in the west of Ireland.
I've never prayed for a cure in my life, but I did trust the Lord. Whether I lived or I died,
he knew what was best for me. But the story began 20 years ago, when Marion,
with a young family to look after, experienced the first signs of a mystery illness.
I woke up one morning, and my leg felt numb, and there was a pain in, you know,
She was sent to a psychiatrist, because her doctors in Athlone
could find no physical explanation for her problems.
I asked him, is it my nerves? I said, my husband's in the army, and he's away a lot,
and I have to be a mother and father, and I'd like to be able to pull myself together.
And he said, no, if all my patients come in like you, I'd be out of a job.
But in 1978, a specialist raised the specter of a terminal illness.
Mr. Kearney says, your wife has got multiple sclerosis. No, he said, your wife's got MS.
And I said, sorry, doctor, I don't know what MS is. And he says, multiple sclerosis. And I said,
I still don't know, because I've never heard that word before.
The disease leads to progressive deterioration, and there is no known cure.
Marion began to suffer from kidney infections, blackouts, and the loss of power in her limbs.
She became almost completely dependent.
I had a special chair that Marion had to be washed every morning. And I used to put her into
the chair, and bring her down to the bathroom, and shower, and put her back in the bed again.
I was just like a baby in a pram. I had to be washed, fed, changed, moved.
As they approached the Shrine of Nock in County Mayo, Marion was at an all-time low.
Her husband told me that Marion didn't want to go, that she was after getting one of these kidney
infections. You know, I felt myself, well, she can't have a whole lot of time left. I wondered
to myself, was it going to be a waste of time bringing her at all, even? But we carried on.
The Shrine of Our Lady in Nock draws over a million pilgrims every year.
They come to visit the place where the Virgin Mary is believed to have appeared to 15 villagers
in 1879. Marion was brought here to the reception ward for invalid pilgrims.
Sadie Feeley, one of the handmaids who nursed the sick of Nock, took charge of her.
She had no sight, very poor sighted, very poor speech. She had no use in one hand,
and very little use in the other. Marion was really dying.
Now, I mean, I'm not saying anything extreme now when I say that. Marion was critically ill.
The sick are brought into the basilica to be anointed,
and it was here that Marion was taken on the afternoon of the 3rd of September, 1989.
Put me in the centre, right under the statue of Our Lady of Nock,
and I said to her, you're a mother too, you know how I feel. I knew I was going to die,
and I had been praying, asking Jesus and Mary to let me live long enough
to see Cora and Anthony out of their teenage years.
Marion felt restless throughout the service, but it was at Communion
that her remarkable experiences began. Body of Christ.
After I received Holy Communion, I got a very bad pain in both my heels,
which was very unusual. And I realised something, that I received Holy Communion normal,
which I hadn't been able to do in a long, long time.
Also that pain that came in my heels, that pain went,
and when that pain went, every pain in my body went with it.
It was during the blessing of the sick at Benediction
that Marion experienced her most intense feelings.
And when he came in front of the stretcher, and he held it up and he blessed me,
it was at that time I got this beautiful feeling, a magnificent feeling,
and like a whispery breeze telling me that if the stretcher was open,
that I could get up and walk.
Marion was returned to the ward,
where a doctor's wife was one of two witnesses to the miracle she claims.
Do you think I was crazy if I said I thought I could walk?
Not at all, Marion. It's been a long day.
You must be tired out now. You'll be away home soon.
No, no, I really think I can, whichever under the straps.
I can't do that, Marion. I'd have to get a nurse.
Shall I fetch Maureen?
Yeah, yeah, do.
All right.
I said I would ask Nurse Maureen, which we did,
and it was Maureen who came over and opened her straps.
Now, Marion, can I help you?
Maureen, I want to get up. I think I can walk.
Now, Marion, you know you can't.
I have the strangest feeling something happened in there.
Please undo the straps.
All right, Marion.
I thought maybe she'd been a long time lying on the stretcher
and that the straps were tight.
So I said I'd undo the straps for her,
and then she wanted me to take the blankets off.
Take it easy, Marion.
Take it easy. Be careful.
She tried to move her legs off the stretcher.
Easy, Marion. Be careful.
We gave her, I suppose, a little help.
Good girl.
Easy, easy, easy.
Leave me now. I can do it myself.
Now, leave me, leave me, leave me, leave me.
We were trying to help her, and she kept doing this.
Go away and don't touch me.
I can do it myself.
She had a catheter and urine bag,
and they were dragging on the floor,
and I really didn't know what to do with her.
When I stood up and knocked, just right in front of me,
I seen my own heart, and it was so full of joy and peace.
It was like looking directly into the sun.
The Carroll family immediately contacted their parish priest
with news of the cure.
When I got the phone message, I just took it for granted
that Marion was either dead or dying.
Marion's cure and miracle was just as spectacular
and sensational as any of the great gospel miracles.
Six years on, Marion Carroll has not had an ache or a pain,
but was her recovery a miracle?
Such claims are dealt with first by the Knock Medical Bureau.
Marion arrived very disabled and went home properly cured,
as testified by her own personal physician the following day.
For someone to make such a dramatic and instant cure
immediately raises a medical interest
as to exactly what was going on here.
It's Dr. Marley's job to establish
whether Marion's recovery can be explained medically.
It has been the experience,
sometimes looking at cases of people who've been cured,
we find that they have not been suffering
from what they thought they were.
Perhaps there is no more difficult disease
to get a variant of opinion among the medical profession,
particularly in the early stages, than multiple sclerosis.
Thy will be done, Amen.
Marion's medical records show that there were doubts
about the diagnosis in Marion's case.
In 1981, one specialist noted mild multiple sclerosis
with functional overlay,
suggesting that Marion was exaggerating her symptoms.
But the records also document her deterioration in walk
and muscular power and many other signs of the disease.
Like a two-year-old.
Marion's recovery has puzzled many doctors,
including her own GP, Dr. Patrick O'Mara.
It was an incredible sight.
I can't explain it.
I don't think anybody can at this stage.
It was something that I certainly have never seen before
and I'm unlikely to see again.
The doctors involved in Marion's case
will attend a medical commission at the shrine next year.
If they cannot explain her recovery,
it'll be left to the church to decide
what happened at Nock that day.
Sometimes we actually need to feel, touch and see God's love
because we're so human.
That's why I'm sitting here now with you talking.
It's not my gift, it's a gift to the people.
Why he chose me, I don't know.
Skeptics might say that Marion's recovery
is no more than a remission, a common feature of MS.
But doctors in her case point out
that remissions are normally not as complete
and rarely last as long.
The jury is still out in Marion's case.
This is a book of saints, but it's already out of date.
A new saint may be proclaimed at any time.
Candidates for sainthood have to be officially investigated
and approved by Rome.
A would-be saint has to have proof of one or two miracles
attributed to their power of intercession.
No miracles, no sainthood.
Tonight, our second story takes us to Philadelphia,
to a family that prayed for just such a miracle and got one.
You ready to go for a bike ride?
Want to see the ducks down at the river back there?
Good.
35-year-old Robert Gutterman
lives with his family in Philadelphia.
Flowers there on the tree.
He believes he owes his life to a miracle.
20 years ago, he was rushed to St. Christopher's Hospital
in severe pain.
What began as a simple earache
had turned into a brush with death.
This young man had what we call an acute mastoid infection.
When the doctor examined his ear on the operating room table,
he found that part of the bone that separates the ear
to the brain had already been destroyed,
exposing the covering of the brain,
which is called the dura mater.
Now, if the infection had progressed just a little bit more,
the boy would have ended up with either a meningitis
or a brain abscess and death.
After the operation, the doctors told Robert's mother
they believed they had saved her son's life,
but his hearing would be permanently damaged.
Mrs. Gutterman, a devout Catholic,
prayed for his recovery.
Ear surgeon Dr. Miles Tertz
had been forced to abandon the operation
and was expecting further problems.
There was so much disease,
I made the judgment, the decision,
that the best I could do
would be to clean it out as much as possible
and stay away from all those things
that could give him a serious, significant,
or conceivably life-threatening complications
from the procedure.
But there was a remarkable development
on the very evening of the operation.
Who's calling me?
Somebody's calling my name.
No, Bobby, it's just a noise outside.
I heard somebody calling me.
It's not you, Bobby.
It's just somebody else in the corridor.
Now go back to sleep.
Go back to sleep now.
Mrs. Gutterman was convinced that against all the odds,
her son's hearing was perfect.
Nurse?
Well, I remember the next morning
when the doctor came in,
my mother had told him that I can hear.
And I remember him looking and saying,
we already told you that there's too much damage there
and that he'd never be able to hear out of that ear.
But Mrs. Gutterman's certainty
that a miracle had happened to her son
persuaded Dr. Turt to carry out an immediate test.
The results showed a return to normal hearing.
I have no explanation.
If you ask me, what did I do to get that outcome?
I will tell you I didn't do anything to get that outcome.
Thank you, doctor.
So extraordinary was Robert Gutterman's recovery
that the Archdiocese of Philadelphia
set up a series of special tribunal hearings
to examine the case in detail.
The Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, amen.
We ask you for the strength and wisdom
we need to carry out our task today.
Pray this through Jesus Christ.
Acting on rules set down by Rome
for the investigation of miracle claims,
the tribunal set about interviewing key witnesses.
Do you swear to tell the whole truth
and nothing but the truth
to all the questions placed before you?
I do, Father.
What is your name?
Beatrice Marie Gutterman.
And what is your relationship with Robert?
I am his mother.
Dr. Turt set out the clinical picture to the tribunal.
Well, the mastoidectomy showed an ear
which was filled with granulation
and a middle ear which was also filled with granulation
and none of the ossicles could be identified
because of the disease.
The ossicles are small bones in the middle ear
crucial for hearing.
They seemed to have grown back.
The doctor was absolutely amazed.
When he examined him, he said,
I don't believe it.
He is actually reconstructing anatomy.
I asked what that meant.
And he said that the flesh was fusing together
to repair the hole in the drum.
He asked what we did that his other patients don't do.
Both Robert and I said, we pray.
Having exhausted all the medical possibilities,
the tribunal required evidence
that prayer had been instrumental in the cure.
Mrs. Gutterman told the tribunal
how she had turned to the Sisters
of the Blessed Sacrament Order near her home.
Sister, may I please speak with you?
She knew us because her son had been an altar boy here.
And so she came to us to ask the Lord
to help him bear the pain.
That was the first thing.
Then she asked if he could only be well.
The nuns prayed to the founder of their order,
Mother Catherine Drexel, who died in 1955.
She was an heiress who gave away a fortune to the poor.
The sisters believe strongly in her power
to bring about healings.
I can't explain the hearing.
The only way I can explain it is that the hearing was lost
and now it's there.
Whatever he was doing in that middle ear,
I would love to take a look at that middle ear now.
The tribunal agreed that Robert should be asked
to submit to another examination of his ear,
which would show once and for all
if the damage really had repaired itself.
It was now 13 years since the original operation.
A new test on Robert's ear was conducted
with the latest technology.
The examination was carried out
by one of America's foremost ear specialists,
Professor Louis Larre.
Against all expectations,
there were no signs of the earlier damage.
This is the eardrum here.
This is the malleus here,
which is the first ossicle or bone.
And when we examined Robert Guthrie,
we could see this tympanic membrane or the eardrum,
which appeared normal.
We could also see the malleus.
And so just from physical exam externally,
it looked quite normal.
What's the explanation from no ossicles in 74
to normal ossicles in 87?
I keep repeating,
I don't make the judgment what's a miracle and what's not,
but it's certainly not explainable by my medical career.
We, as non-clergy, do not have the right
to deal in miracles.
But to the best of our knowledge,
we felt it was something that we could not explain.
The Archdiocese of Philadelphia
had shown there was a miracle case to answer.
Now it was the turn of Rome to provide the final say.
The Vatican's archives contain the records
of miracle investigations going back to the 16th century.
The evidence in the Gutterman case
was painstakingly re-examined
by Rome's own medical and theological experts.
The process is rigorous
and many cases fail at this final stage.
Quite an amount of study
by highly qualified experts is necessary.
That is the most important requirement
because we do believe in miracles,
but we are not eager to presume a miracle.
It has to be proved and proved up to the hill.
If there's any lingering doubt,
we will just cast it out.
The next stage was for Robert's case
to be heard by the cardinals of the Congregation
for the Causes of Saints
in the Vatican's Apostolic Palace.
We were allowed a brief glimpse
of their secret deliberations.
It was this committee
that passed Robert's case unanimously in 1987.
After all the preparations,
it goes to the Holy Father
and he signs a decree.
He is ultimately in all these matters
the final judge.
When he puts his signature under it,
the thing is official
and only then it's official.
Robert's cure was declared miraculous by the Pope.
The decree put Catherine Drexel
on the road to sainthood.
She was beatified in a ceremony in Rome in 1988,
attended by the Gutterman family.
Well, the guys at work were kind of shocked
when I ended up on the six o'clock news.
They looked at you and they sort of said,
well, gee, Bob, you're the regular guy.
You know, you go out and you have a couple of beers
with the boys and how could this be?
You know, and again, it gets very kind of difficult
because God doesn't just show up to the holy people
or to, you know, the worst of people.
God loves us all equally.
The blessed Catherine Drexel
needs one more miracle attributed to her
and then she'll become Saint Catherine.
And Robert Gutterman, well,
he remains one of those rare hospital patients
who can honestly say he's had a miraculous recovery.
Good night.

