Watch What Will Happen After El-rufai Taped NSA Rubadu's Phone Line, E-Transmission Implementation

Voice Tv Nigeria
11 followers
1 Video View·Feb 17, 2026
Observe the significant developments that will unfold following the incident where El-Rufai allegedly intercepted the phone communications of the National Security Adviser, Rubadu, particularly in relation to the implementation of electronic transmission of results. This situation promises to unveil a series of consequential reactions and ramifications not only within the political landscape but also regarding the broader implications for national security protocols and electoral integrity in the country. The intersection of surveillance, governance, and technology could lead to heated discussions and debates surrounding the ethical dimensions of such actions.
AI Generated·May contain errors
The revelation by Marlon Nasir El-Rufai, former governor of Kaduna State,
that he tapped the phone of Nigeria's NSA, Ntohowi Badu,
before his arrest, has reopened uncomfortable questions
about power, privilege, and Nigeria's security architecture.
Tonight, we won't be unpacking, rather than chasing gossip,
we'll be interrogating power. And to do this with us
is our socio-political commentator, Douglas Glass.
It's a pleasure to have you here, Martin. Thank you.
Let's start simple. Is this revelation shocking because it's illegal
or because it was admitted? I think that it's shocking, really,
and mind-boggling on more than two levels.
So, the fact that somebody can actually admit to hacking
or tapping the conversations of any other person,
of any other Nigerian, without a legitimate warrant of a court,
for instance, itself is very shocking to admit that,
not only because it is illegal to do that,
but it also speaks of impunity, of a disdain for the rule of law
and for due process. Now, what makes it doubly shocking
is that this is not an admission by any ordinary person,
a criminal, a thug on the street, a gang boss on the street.
This is an admission by a politician who was played at the highest level
and who is still playing at a very high level.
A former governor who is also a former minister
of the Federal Republic of Nigeria and chief security officer of a state
admits this openly, but it's not just saying that,
look, I have the capacity to and I did hack the conversations
of my opponents, my other political opponents,
but actually of the national security advisor of the country.
The national security advisor, that's the office that coordinates
the security architecture on behalf of the president in the country.
And so to have the guts to actually not just undertake the action itself of hacking,
but to actually then publicly admit it and in a boastful
and nonchalant manner speaks volumes to the way and manner in which politicians
think that the Nigerian state is their estate, their personal estate,
and that they can do whatever they like with it.
So are we saying the problem in Nigeria isn't just the abuse of power,
but the audacity to confess it?
Absolutely.
And you see, there is a link between the two.
Now, if you are used to serially abusing power,
for example, let's use crime now as an analogy,
since we are talking security, it's also about crime.
So let's use crime.
When you have cases about, when they say that somebody,
for example, is a serial rapist,
somebody is a serial killer,
somebody is a serial trafficker, drug trafficker, and the rest of that.
And then eventually the person is caught and you build a case for the person.
You see that what has happened over time is that the person has abused,
has violated over time.
But because when they do that, they get away with it.
It builds this confidence to say that one is untouchable.
And so exactly this is what is happening in this scenario, in this case now.
So this is revealing of a personality type that believes that they are untouchable,
that they cannot do wrong,
that the violation of the law is what other people do, not themselves.
And that what they do, regardless of what the law says, is correct and is right.
When people have been accustomed to doing that,
then they can have the audacity to actually publicly admit it.
And this calls into, it begs the question, really,
if somebody can admit to that, it begs the question,
what else the person has been doing?
If a governor of a national Euro 5 statute could allegedly tap the phone
of a man heading the sensitive anti-corruption apparatus of Nigeria,
should Nigerians feel protected and exposed?
So now that's a big challenge.
Protected?
I think most Nigerians will actually say they already feel that their protection is shaky,
even as it is at the moment.
And you see, the funny thing about some of the way these things happen,
and that's because you have asked this question,
it's important to actually dwell on the point I want to make now,
is that when people, and particularly politicians,
political office holders and politicians, politically exposed persons,
when they act in manners that actually undermine institutions, societal institutions,
the most important thing to do is to recognize that
as a grievous incident and to treat it as such.
But unfortunately, when that happens,
it's always taken within the context of the political sentiments around and the rest of that.
And so people don't look at damage that is done to the institutions,
they just look at the individuals at play.
So you find online, you find some persons really don't feel that this is a big deal.
Some persons are actually cheering this on and thinking that,
oh yes, it means that we can checkmate this government, you know, and so on and so forth.
But that's the danger that happens when we equate,
when we substitute our institutions for individuals and our political opponents.
So because what this simply means, and I want to throw this open to people,
what this simply means, this is not just about the National Security Advisor right now
and the security architecture of the country.
What this means is that people who have the capacity, the wherewithal,
the audacity to do it and the audacity to be able to bold about it,
it means they can also actually act financial systems.
It means that they can act, you know,
or any other platform, digital platform and so on and so forth.
So it means that they have the capacity and the ability to do that if they want to do it.
And for individuals and not the state to have that ability
and to have that power is very dangerous for the country.
So it's something that has to be checked.
Yes, based on what you just said about hacking a certain instrument of governance,
electronic transmission has been the conversation now,
and particularly where Malam Nasser Roufai is leaning towards people from that camp
have actually pronounced the flu protests that they want e-transmission.
With this NSA hacking and the e-transmission protests,
is it normal to say, I'm not sounding like a conspiracy theorist,
that the opposition has the ability to actually manipulate what they're asking for?
So before I expand ----, I would first of all just say that I will not say the opposition.
I will say that what is clear is that certain individuals have that capacity to do this.
And people forget one thing.
In the 2023 elections, the former Minister of Communications,
who was former Nixda Boss, I've forgotten his name, Professor Patame, yes.
You know, at that time when the election results were out,
when all of those things were happening, and when the court cases were out,
you know, the Communications Minister Nixda actually released a report
about that election, about the election,
and that some of the glitches faced by the IRF border was because of hacking.
That in fact, on the day of the presidential election,
that more than one million acts were made on IRF.
People forget these kinds of things.
So it was easy to just dismiss that and say,
oh, these are people who wanted to rig the election,
so they are talking, they are saying this and that.
But is it possible for that to happen?
It is possible for it to happen.
And do you have the capability and the capacity to be able to then
prevent that from happening?
That stands to reason.
And then, so let's now talk about electronic transmission,
because it's important to actually talk about electronic transmission.
The conversation around electronic transmission is being deliberately confused,
just like the conversation around tax,
and probably by both sides, you know, being deliberately confused.
I use the word deliberate confusion, because to be clear about one thing,
what does electronic transmission mean?
Electronic transmission is not the same thing as electronic voting.
Electronic transmission does not mean electronic voting,
but the Supreme Court has made that very clear.
There's a distinction between to vote electronically
and to transmit results electronically.
Now, to have real-time transmission of results,
real-time, in real-time, requires you to have real-time e-voting.
So as you are voting, the platform is tabulating it,
and so you can be saying it's changing.
That's real-time.
Real-time e-transmission is not possible.
More like on the screen.
Yes, it's not.
It's not possible without real-time e-voting.
That has to happen for that.
So it means that your, what was that?
The bivars, the bivars, right?
That as you are voting, it is electronically recording it
and transmitting it, and tabulating it, and transmitting it.
That's what, and it means that it's an electronic something
that you are voting electronically.
That's not what we are doing.
So if you are not doing e-voting,
there is no way you can have real-time,
which is happening at the same moment.
The only thing you can have is,
the next closest thing to real-time is to have that
once it is collated.
In the form EC.
In the form EC and in those collation centers once it's,
so for example, at the polling unit press,
once it is collated,
and then you go to the collation center,
it is collated and your feed data,
that's when it can then be transmitted electronically.
That's electronic transmission now to IRA,
which is the viewing board.
And then, you know,
and the viewing board does not change automatically
after you have transmitted it.
You still have to do the calculation.
The collation.
There's still an algorithm there
that does the collation at the backend
that does all of that.
So that's what it means.
And so people should start confusing Nigerians
and putting expectations on realistic expectations.
And I've asked this question several elsewhere in the world.
Give me an example of a country in the world
where the election is done mainly by
electronic voting,
where they have electronic voting,
where people still don't have to go and queue and do this.
Because electronic voting,
you don't really have to.
You may not have to go.
You can do it from your hub and the rest of that.
Yeah.
So give me an example of any country in the world,
including the so-called advanced countries
where there is no paperwork,
where you don't have to keep paper documentation
in order to back up what is on the electronic.
So if something should happen to the server,
how do you resolve that crisis?
Because the people who are saying,
don't choose form E, C,
don't choose all these forms,
just transmit.
If something should happen,
maybe a glitch happens.
Maybe the glitch is even now a glitch
that is electronic.
It's not malicious.
Even that alone, what happens?
How do you get the backup?
So what do you use?
Actually, it seems to me like people are simply
just trying to prepare the ground for anarchy.
Because then if something then happens,
you have that kind of situation and then you cannot...
Even Kenya where people make reference to
in terms of a real-time transmission.
And what happens?
The real-time transmission that happens in Kenya
is a kind of real-time transmission
that is envisaged by our new law,
by the law in 2023 and the new law now,
that after you are collated, you transmit.
Which was why it was possible
when that election result was contested,
it was possible for the opposition led by Rahila,
to gather the papers and then go to court.
Otherwise they would have had to go to court
to ask for warrant, to look at the server and all of that,
which really is neither here nor there.
So people should be very clear about that.
But I haven't answered that question and clarified this.
So the question now is this,
if we already have people with the capacity
to ask to act some of the most secure lines in the country,
because there shouldn't be any more secure line
than that of the security advisor.
Probably only that of the presidency should be more secure.
Now, if you have people who have the capacity to add that
and can audaciously and openly boast about it,
what do we say about hacking IREC?
Because people can hack IREC and actually post wrong figures
to confuse the situation.
And people think that when you have a problem,
the solution to it is to throw technology at the problem.
No, technology is as good and as useful
as the people who use it.
Technology is there to help you,
to make this easier for you.
If you are the one using the technology
and you want to use it wrongly, you use it wrongly.
So the fact that that, because technology is very neutral,
in this case, it is neither good nor bad.
But it can be put to good use, it can be put to bad use.
People forget that Donald Trump
is still disputing the 2020 elections,
even though there have been two elections after that.
He's still disputing the 2020 elections.
And if those paper trails were not there,
those camps were not there,
he would have been able to really discredit
the elections as they are.
But on each occasion, there were more than 147 lawsuits
challenging different results in different places.
All of which were dismissed by the courts.
And so when people talk about the courts
also dismissing cases here, and this is electorate,
and they say that it's the judges that are determining,
I mean, it's like people have a selective amnesia
that they're not really looking at the facts of the case.
It's like the Supreme Court said
during all of those rulings,
they were ruling on the point of law.
So if you claim, for instance,
that you won this election
and that your votes were taken from you
and awarded to the, it's your duty to prove it.
It's not the duty of the Supreme Court
or the defendants to prove that.
It's your duty to prove it.
If you claim that you won the election
and your votes were taken,
and meanwhile you had, what is it called?
What do they call it?
The agents, you have polling agents
in only 40,000 out of 230,000 polling units.
How can you then prove that such an election
was rigged?
On what basis?
On what basis do you prove that?
And that of the 40,000 agents that you said,
you brought 16.
You brought 16 to court as witnesses, okay?
You brought 16 to court as witnesses.
All of these 16, none of them testified about,
none of them testified about
their own specific polling unit.
They testified about polling units elsewhere,
which under the law is ASA.
So the point I'm making is that,
look, if you don't allow for this backup documentation
to happen and the rest of that,
then how do you resolve a crisis that emerges?
How can any court be able to then rule,
make any legitimate ruling on that?
Except, of course, what people are calling for
is that they want to instigate a constitutional crisis.
So if politicians of this magnitude,
because during Buhari Attiku's court cases,
there was a conversation around Sava.
Now, again, before the election again coming up in 2027,
there's a problem of hacking
the security architecture's phone online.
What exactly separates Nigeria
from surveillance state-run by private interests?
If a politician of high repute,
such as these two examples,
can actually penetrate intelligence channels
or state security channels,
such as this,
and someone like El Rufai,
what he has just done,
shouldn't he be prosecuted,
really, by our laws?
Let me respond to the last question first.
Let's be very clear about this.
If an ordinary person goes on TV,
just say an ordinary person,
or just an activist who is not a politician,
goes on national TV to say
that they hacked the line of the commissioner of police,
not the NSA,
of the commissioner of police,
and that they heard JB was doing this,
and that they have proof,
where do you think that person would be right now?
The person would have been picked up.
There will be issues around investigations,
prosecution around it now.
And it would have been legitimate to go through,
it would have been due process to go through that.
The only thing that is keeping El Rufai out now
is because he's a politician,
and he's a politically exposed person.
That's the only thing.
And that he plays a big role in the opposition.
And so the idea that you don't want to fall into the narrative
of surprising or witch-hunting the opposition
just when elections are around the corner.
So it's really like holding the country hostage and ransomed.
Shouldn't the law supersede the narrative of witch-hunting?
Absolutely, it should.
But then, I mean, politicians,
we're always very careful about narratives.
So that's the point that I'm making,
because that's why I made the decision that I said that,
if this was an ordinary person that has done this,
the person would be in detention right now.
And we would probably have been even brought to court
for the first appearance in court in front of it.
But people of this level who abuse their leverage,
who abuse their exposure, who abuse their authority,
are the ones who are actually undermining the state,
the institutions of the state.
And that's what I've said elsewhere,
particularly when we talk in civil society
and even with the media,
when we talk about Nigeria's election and the rest of that.
And I said, look, the biggest risk to Nigeria's elections
is not the electoral act.
It's not the electoral law.
It's not the constitution.
It's not the electoral management body.
The biggest risk to Nigeria's democracy
is the Nigerian politician.
Because if we get the Nigerian politician right,
then nobody will be deliberately undermining.
And politicians in Nigeria actually vote resources
deliberately to undermine the political processes.
So when people do this,
you can see that they are actually the danger.
It's not the process itself that is a danger and a threat.
It's these people who are actually the danger.
And until Nigerians realize this
and begin to hold our politicians accountable,
begin to separate between the politician and the institution
so that we safeguard our institutions
and deal with the individuals and the politicians,
we are going to continue to be in problem as we are today.
Should anybody who admits to this kind of thing,
should that person not be prosecuted?
Of course, the person should be prosecuted.
The only reason why this person is not being prosecuted today
is the reasons that I've given you.
And again, let us also be clear about one thing.
The reason why people like this also do what they are doing,
and I think we've had this conversation before,
but maybe we can put a bit more light on it,
is that one of the reasons why the Nigerian state,
why governance is dysfunctional in Nigeria,
appears to be very dysfunctional
in spite of good intents of some individuals.
And so why sometimes it seems like no matter what you do,
nothing is working and nothing is changing.
It goes back to this politically exposed persons.
We have a ruling political class in Nigeria
that one, does not agree amongst itself,
so it does not have a minimum consensus.
So there's no national consensus
that they are all committed to and loyal to.
They are not loyal to Nigeria,
they are loyal to themselves
and their different segments.
So Nigeria, and so when you have a majority
of political actors this way,
it's not as if there are no nationalists Nigerians
but we have the majority,
you have the playground, which is like this.
Now what they also do is that every political actor,
make somebody, give somebody,
even if it is a politically appointed position,
not even that you have one,
every politically exposed person
who is a political office holder,
you know what they try to do?
They try to convert that aspect of the state
that they control,
they try to convert it into an instrument
for their personal service,
not the service of Nigerians.
And so you have a state that is therefore very,
that has been,
if the Nigerian state was just captured
by the ruling class,
a ruling class that has a national consensus,
it would have even been better.
But you have a Nigerian state
that has been captured by different segments
of the Nigerian ruling class.
And so each segment controls different,
each faction of the ruling class
controls different segments of the state.
And so the state cannot act as a state.
So you look at security, you look at this.
If people are doing this,
by what stretch of the imagination
can the state and the security architecture
actually act in a uniform manner?
With this scary picture,
how then can we have a conversation
around democracy and rule of law
when certain individuals
admit to weaponizing state machinery?
For me, you know,
the biggest problem would be with abuse of office
is the audacity and the impunity.
But impunity grows from where?
Impunity grows from lack of response.
If people can do things and get away with it,
then of course you are laying the foundation for impunity.
You are laying the foundation for abuse.
But if every action has a consequence,
so if it's a positive action,
that's a positive consequence.
If it's a negative action, that's a negative.
If every action, every choice that we make,
if it has consequences,
and if some people are not excluded
from those consequences,
then we'll be able to get it right.
And it seems to me like
the way the Nigerian state has not been paralyzed,
it takes all of us as Nigerians and citizens
to start becoming more institution-focused
than individual-focused
and to start protecting Nigeria
rather than protecting whichever politician
we think we are loyal to.
If an institution has been compromised,
can we deal with the compromise of that institution?
Without irrespective of the sentiments that we may have.
And so that for me is the biggest thing.
But this also requires leadership.
So citizens are not just going to wake up and do it.
It also requires leadership for that to happen.
Where's that leadership going to come from?
Some people have to really take the bulls by the horns.
At the core of events like this,
controversies such as this,
is money.
The conversation about money springs up again.
Does this episode,
just like the Sava conversation,
the last election,
last two elections,
does this episode reinforce the belief that
wealth in Nigeria doesn't just buy comfort,
that it buys institutions?
I think it's the other way around.
I think politicians,
Nigeria's ruling elite are interested
in taking over institutions
because it enables them to accumulate
and protect wealth,
egotism wealth.
So the institutions,
that's why they weaponize
and instrumentalize the institutions
for their own personal gain
because that's how they make,
that's how they make ends meet.
That's how they make their wealth.
So if you acquire wealth illegally,
then you also need to be able to protect it.
So you need the institution
not only to acquire the wealth illegally,
you also need the institution
in order to be able to protect that illegality,
which is why you find
the politically exposed in Nigeria,
they are never outside the corridors of power.
Once they're outside the corridors of power,
you can actually see a visible decline
in their status, in their wealth,
because that's the only thing that they do.
So, and I guess for me,
that part of what this,
I think this is a challenge
for two groups or three groups,
really, of citizens.
I think that active citizens
in civil society, in the media,
need to band together
and become more politically active.
I think that business people,
particularly those who have,
of course, they may have benefited
from patronage from politics,
but actually business people and investors,
I think it's high time
they also become very interested in politics
so that they can sanitize politics
so that even their own wealth
that they are actually making
in more legitimate ways
can actually be safeguarded
because otherwise,
these people who are making illegal wealth
would simply crash everything for them.
And then the third level of people
that I think also needs to be able
to do this after citizens
and after the business people.
I think that it is also high time
that workers, organized workers,
should become, first, workers as workers
should become conscious
of their role as citizens,
of the fact that everything
that pertains to their working conditions
is actually determined
in the political arena, governance,
and so to become politically conscious
in their own interest.
Because right now,
it's not as if workers
are not politically active,
but they are active
in the interest of other people,
not in their own interest
because if they were organized politically,
be organized in their own interest,
then even when they are supporting people,
they will be bargaining.
They would have a platform.
So when I say bargaining,
they're not bargaining for position.
Oh, you give me this and that.
They're bargaining in terms of policies.
They're bargaining in terms of
what we want.
Direct impact.
We want on our lives
if we give you our support.
We need to get to that point.
And for me, that's actually the way
to save Nigeria's democracy right now.
Politics, national security,
where do we draw the line?
The two are really very...
So ordinarily when you say,
when you look at national security
as citizens' security,
then it should trump politics.
But when people see,
than those who see national security
as their own security,
then they merge the two.
They merge politics and national security.
Because national security is really not...
It's not the security of the state.
It's not the security of the regime.
It's not the security of the wealthy.
It's the security of the nation.
So if we can see national security
in that context,
as the security of the people
and the rest of that,
then politics should not be played
in a manner that undermines
that national security.
But if we see national security
as our security,
then of course,
as our individual security,
because we have leverage,
because we have status,
then of course our politics
will be played in a manner
that we subordinate
that national security
to the interest of politics.
How has this level 5 saga impacted
on our image when it comes
to security conversations
in the global space?
I'm sure that people are going to be...
People would ask questions.
I mean, because let's be honest.
So it's not as if these kind of things
don't happen in other places.
Okay?
That politicians don't try to...
They do.
The difference is the extent
to which you can actually do it
and be audacious about it
and be boastful about it
and then get away with it.
That's the difference.
Because otherwise,
in every polity,
people want to abuse power,
except you don't just put guardrails,
but also vigilance to ensure that...
I mean, in the U.S. today,
we can see with all degree of certainty
that the current president of the U.S.
is abusing his powers in the U.S.
and the executive decisions
that he is taking,
almost sometimes,
is up in the role of Congress
and also is up in the role of the courts
and the rest of that,
as well as what is that.
But you can see the pushback.
The institutional pushbacks,
that's because they will not allow it to happen,
you know, and they are fighting it
and they will stop it.
So that's the difference.
And so in our case,
in this kind of situation,
the danger inherent in what has just happened
is not that it is not happening
and being covered,
but that it has happened this brazenly
and it is allowed to go.
The danger is that you are setting a precedent
because other people can also do it.
And then when they do it
and you go after them,
they will say,
but everybody did it the last time.
This other person did it the last time.
Why didn't you go after this person?
Because you remember,
look at our anti-corruption war.
If you go after somebody,
says it is witch hunting,
that you didn't go after this other person.
So when are we going to start
and where are we going to start from?
Because that fight has to start from somewhere.
And a friend of mine would say this.
He said that when they say,
when they talk about the witch hunting,
witch hunting,
he said, yes,
he said let every regime be a witch or a witch hunter.
If every regime actually haunts witches,
what it means is that progressively
there will be less witches to haunt.
So if every regime decides
to go after people who are corrupt,
they may be in your position,
but they are also not going to be in power forever.
So when the other people also come,
then we also go after them.
That if we do that and we do it consistently,
then we get rid of,
we'll be able to get rid of it.
And that's the point that is not,
that's what is not happening now.
That for me is the danger that this potence,
that may have,
but in fact for me,
two clear dangers that this potence.
One is that you are laying a precedent.
If you do not address what has happened,
this breach,
this security breach that has happened,
you do not address it,
you are creating a precedent.
You are saying that,
that yes, we may,
although we may know that all of you
are doing these things hush hush,
but it is not okay to even be brazen about it.
Okay, that's the first thing.
The second danger is the danger
about the ability of individuals,
including foreign interests,
to be able to then subvert
our different architectures
and our different infrastructure.
Is it going to be the next time?
Is it going to be the transport infrastructure?
Is it going to be the banking infrastructure?
Is it going to be the stock exchange?
You know, and so on and so forth.
And what is the capacity of these elements?
What is the residual capacity of these elements
to actually cause damage?
We don't know now,
which is why beyond every vice case,
there is a need for actually
a very broad-based investigation
and interrogation of all of these processes.
This is the time that we should press a reset
and say, how secure are our infrastructures really?
Now, there was a coup that was foiled
and now the NSA's office is tapped.
What is the danger really
for a country trying to get itself
toward development
and matching the advanced countries?
Because if you are this fragile,
we're still fighting insurgents.
Bandits are there every day.
And now with this new business,
because like you rightly said,
the danger is being a precedent
and opening a new market.
What is the danger for Nigeria, for the people?
And why play in opposition?
Where do we draw the line?
I think that that's for me,
is why I say that we should hold
our political class responsible collectively.
Because look, everywhere in the world,
no matter how politicians fight,
they have basic minimums
that they will not tolerate,
which is why you can see people,
they will say, oh, people from across the aisle
or across party lines,
bipartisan position on an issue.
They will say, oh, no, no, no, no,
that has crossed the line
because there are some minimums
that they have said that, look, no, no.
If we go below this,
we're actually undermining all of ourselves.
And that's the danger in Nigeria
because you also mentioned fragility.
The fragility of the Nigerian state,
it's not because the Nigerian state
is actually not strong
or does not have the capability
to deal with the issues
that it's being contended with.
Yes, that state has been hollowed out over time.
This business of the state has no business
with business and so on and so forth.
All of these things has hollowed out the state,
but it still remains a very huge bureaucracy
and a very powerful state.
The challenge, the fragility of the Nigerian state
results from this fractionalization
of the Nigerian state.
The fact that different components
of the ruling class
have cut out different components of that state
and use it for their own.
That's what makes the Nigerian state very fragile.
Otherwise, it's very huge and immense machinery
that can actually be put to use.
People talk and talk about,
for example, when we talk about insecurity,
for instance,
and people talk about policing
and they say,
we have only 330,000 police.
Let's be clear in our minds, really.
If we had 330,000 police personnel,
if they were like,
we have 30, how many states?
If you have 36 states,
let's assume that you just have 10,000 personnel
in each state.
They are trained, they are well equipped.
We do a lot, we do a lot.
So it's not the numbers,
but it's because the ability to function cohesively
as a unit is being daily
and constantly undermined
by people who have access,
people who have power.
That is why it's police
that will come and resolve a land dispute.
It's police that will come and resolve problems
in the compound and the rest of that.
There are things that you don't need to,
but because people can weaponize the state
and that's why it's actually...
So what I'm saying in essence is that
it is the degree to which the state is weaponized
that is responsible for the fragility of the Nigeria state.
And that's what we really need to deal with.
That's why we are facing all of these challenges
that we are facing.
That's why the state cannot act.
That's why they talk about the lack of coordination.
You can't act together
because people have different instructions
from different components of the state.
Now, and that's dangerous.
Very dangerous.
But when people who are actually
not holding any institutional position
also begin to have those kind of,
begin to retain and use those kind of powers,
then it means we have really gotten into a situation
where if we are not careful,
we will not be able to get ourselves out of it
because that would be like just creating multiple states
states within the state.
Sir, your last words now will be advice to me.
You know what has been said,
it can be taken away and they are like evidence and reference.
What would you say if you were to see a fight now?
What would you say to the NSA now?
And what would you say to the Nigerian public?
I would say to the,
I would say to the politicians in general
and then opposition politicians in particular
that, yeah, it's important that we should,
that it's important to play politics.
But it's also important to be sensible
and be strategic about how we play politics.
So IDEC has announced the date
for the presidential and electoral elections now.
February and March, it's just a year, okay?
This is the time to start addressing
real issues on the ground.
This is time to start focusing on real problems.
So if you are opposed, for example, to the tax reform,
this is time to announce very clearly
what is it that you are opposed to
and what would be your alternative if you are in power.
If you are opposed to,
you are talking about the electoral act
and constitutional reform now.
If you were to be elected into power today in 2027,
what would be your constitutional reform agenda?
What would be your electoral reform agenda?
This is the time to have that conversation
because the period of electionary campaigns
is the only period when citizens
are enabled to participate massively en masse
in policy debates.
But that's what has been consistently denied citizens
in Nigeria because rather than have those,
look at the 2023 election.
The question was about the Muslim-Muslim divide
and the not-South divide and the rest of that.
Kristen, I'm not about-
Away from those issues.
Not about, it's away from those issues.
So we should, so that would be my advice
to politicians in general.
To everybody, I would say that people should be very careful
that those who live in glass houses should not cross roads
because the extent to which they have accumulated
power and authority in this edifice called Nigeria
is also the extent to which they are also vulnerable.
Because if this country collapses,
there is more at stake for them
than there is for ordinary citizens.
Who, in any case, have learned to survive.
So my advice to such people will also be
that they should act less with impunity
and act more with political sensibility.
Now, what would be my advice to Nuh Ubadu
and the security architecture?
Without prejudice to the fact that whether they should go
after the individual directly or not,
I think it's a wake up call.
This is the time for that security architecture
to actually undertake a very comprehensive
and thorough audit, forensic audit
of the security architecture in terms of access,
in terms of vulnerabilities,
in terms of who authorized or unauthorized,
and then put more checks in place for that.
That should lead to investigations and prosecutions
because part of the challenge in this country
is that people get away with what is wrong.
So for me, this would be my advice.
And then to Nigerian citizens,
I think that for the Nigerian electorate
and the Nigerian citizens,
we need to start asking real questions.
Yes, politics cannot be separated from sentiments
because what is political is also sentimental.
But it's not everything that is sentimental
that is also wishful.
You can be very sentimental about facts.
You can be very sentimental about the truth.
So it's for Nigerian citizens to open their eyes,
shine their eyes, ask the proper questions.
Because without our intervention,
we are not going to help these politicians.
And if we don't help these politicians,
we are not going to help our country
because ultimately we are the ones
who will bear the burden of whatever happens.
The decision.
Exactly.
So we need to be more up.
Young persons, for example, in Nigeria,
where is the...
And since answers, for instance,
in 2020, five years, six years,
for that to emerge,
where is the non-partisan,
but political youth agenda in Nigeria
that you can say,
this is a youth political and economic agenda
that is minimum,
that all young Nigerians align with
and that they mobilize all.
So that regardless of what political party you are in,
it becomes the basis for you to engage in that party.
If that party is not going to give this to young persons
or it's not going to build in Nigeria
that will enable young persons to thrive
on the basis of some of the demands that you have made,
you have no business in that party.
So it should be something that is clear
that a minimum, a basic minimum youth manifesto,
what is it that young Nigerians...
What is the vision?
What is the vision of Nigeria's young persons about Nigeria?
The country that they want to live in,
the country they want to lead,
the country that they want to grow in,
grow their businesses in,
the country that they want to...
They start their families in.
What's the ambition of that country?
That's all about the likes of your vegan movement.
Particularly them,
because it's not enough to have a movement,
to have a business.
What is the agenda?
What is it that people can relate with?
And so the first thing is,
and it takes discipline, that is it.
You know, it takes discipline,
it takes discipline,
organizing, coordination, have you?
To be able to have a consensus amongst different youths
and say, okay, this is what we all...
Regardless of where we are,
and then you have this,
then it now takes even more discipline
to be able to now convince other people
who are not young people,
political parties,
to say, okay, to negotiate, you know?
And then say, okay, this is our charter,
this is our demand,
this is what we need to do.
So for me, that's really what is necessary,
what is important now.
So in Nigeria today,
there are three movements
and three political agendas,
three political charters that we require.
On the basis of which you should have movements,
you need a youth charter of demand,
and then you need a youth movement
that is political but non-partisan
so that their members can belong
to different political parties
and push that youth agenda wherever they are.
We need a women's charter,
a women's manifesto as well,
because when we talk about gender,
things that we talk about,
all these things that we're talking about,
where is the women's political movement
that is pushing this
so that they are talking with the same voice
in the different political parties?
I expect to see a situation
where women will speak with one voice on certain issues,
regardless of their political affiliations.
There should be such minimum agenda.
And we used to have this under the military.
I mean, I grew up with a Nigerian youth movement
that has a youth agenda.
I grew up in a Nigeria
where there was a women's charter.
We had women in Nigeria
that had a political charter
in the anti-military, pro-democracy movement.
And then the last one,
which is actually the more important one,
is you also need a workers' charter of demand,
a workers' political and economic charter of demand
that will be championed by workers.
And when I say workers,
workers and the organization,
so when I say the organization,
it's not just trade unions
because those are not the only places
where workers are organized.
Workers are also organized in cooperatives
or whatever in their communities.
So workers' organizations,
we need to have like a minimum charter
and say, look, as Nigerian workers
or as people who are aspiring to be workers
or as people who have young ones
that are going to be workers.
You know, what is it?
What is our vision?
And then begin to engage
with the political parties with this,
regardless of which political parties
we then individualize.
Because we can agree, for example,
that we should have,
we should not, that unemployment
should be less than 5% in the country, okay?
But I can have a program
that wants to address that
as a socialist or a social democrat.
And you can have a program
that wants to address that
as a market-oriented person.
So we should be able to belong
on the basis of our ideological something
to those two subjects,
but agree that we want to reduce unemployment,
that that's our basic minimum,
that unemployment should not be,
and that poverty, for example,
should not be, poverty rate
should not be higher than this in the country.
We should be able to agree on certain minimums
and then, of course,
find our different pathways
to then make sure that we can achieve that.
This conversation isn't about personalities.
It's about whether Nigeria is governed by law
or by memories of who once held power.
Thank you, Mr. Jaye, for your time.
I will be calling on you again
on further conversations.
Thank you so much for having me.
