Ancient Symbols Spark Claims of Global Prehistoric Society

Ancient Civilizations
15 followers
#ancienthistory #kevinosullivan #history
Kevin O'Sullivan discusses the theory of an ancient civilization that supposedly existed before the pyramids and was wiped out by a catastrophic event. Historian Ashley Hern explains that this idea, known as hyper diffusionism, suggests that similarities among ancient cultures indicate a single source of inspiration.
Hern argues that there's no independent evidence for this dating, which relies on speculative alignments with star positions. He notes that during the Ice Age, humans were in small hunter-gatherer groups, lacking the infrastructure for a civilization.
Let's talk about ancient civilizations and the intriguing suggestion that before even the
pyramids, dating back 40,000 years, the world was kind of ruled by an advanced civilization that
was somehow wiped out by some kind of cataclysm, some kind of dreadful global meteorological event
or earthquake or whatever. It crops up a lot, this theory. Let's talk to our favourite historian,
Ashley Hearn. Hi Ashley, how are you doing? Hi Kevin, good to speak to you. Good to talk to you.
I know you're going to knock this down, but let's have a chat about it, shall we? This story has
cropped up in a couple of the papers this week. Mysterious carved symbols found across the world
could point to a lost human civilization dating back 40,000 years. There are claims that there
are these symbols, similar symbols, all over the world which have uncovered, I don't even know what
this means but I'm going to read it out, have uncovered paradigm-shifting evidence of a lost
civilization that could radically rewrite human history. Now you'll have heard this before,
it's not the first time I've heard that before even the pyramids, before human history began to
be recorded, there was, according to these theories to some historians, an ancient civilization that
ruled the world as it were. They were very advanced technologically, they knew about
geometry, they knew about astrology and that somehow or other this civilization
was wiped out by a catastrophic global event, some kind of cataclysm.
You've heard these theories, what are they based on and what do you think?
Well I mean these ideas have been around for quite a long time, at least a century,
it's called hyperdiffusionism and it's the theory... I knew that of course,
hyperdiffusionism, what is it? Hyperdiffusionism, or the similarities you can spot amongst different
human groups through history, rather than being the idea that they all adopted these ideas
separately, they all got them from one single inspiration and so they used to be the idea that
Egyptians travelled across the Atlantic and brought ideas to say Central America,
Mesoamerica, there's this pyramid of Mesoamerica, you've got pyramids in Egypt,
so did they get that idea from Egypt essentially? So that was one of the older arguments and this
one is the idea that Egypt itself got its ideas of building pyramids from this ancient civilization.
So the chap whose work is sort of in all of these headlines is a man called Matthew McQuire,
he's a sort of independent archaeologist, he's written several books arguing for this sort of
ancient civilization and in a way sort of all our minds, all our ideas about the divine etc have
all come from this civilization 40,000 years ago. The evidence essentially is partly because
he claims to have found a site in eastern Turkey where he believes that the sort of signs
originated. Now you could say well there's some sort of merit that these symbols pop up everywhere,
surely that must mean something. The central problem is that these pyramids are quite common
because if you're going to build a structure, one of the ways you keep it up is you sort of
have a flat bottom and a thin top, there's no sort of, you didn't need to invent that idea and spread
it around. Humans probably came up with that idea independently. The central sort of dating
thesis, this 40,000 years, this comes from his argument that the sort of sphinx, we're back to
our dear old friend the sphinx, and other structures are aligned with how the stars would have looked
at different points in the past. This is something called precession, so as the earth spins around
over time, its axis moves because it's sort of affected by gravity from the sun and the moon.
So as time goes on, the stars look different. And so if you argue that the civilization of
particular buildings have been set up according to a particular sort of stellar star alignment,
and you can say well actually that star alignment would only match at a particular period in time.
So he argued that essentially you've got two time frames, you've got one about 12,000 years ago
and you've got one about 40,000 years ago. So essentially if you have a civilization which
then inspires all of these common practices, you then find a date range when that could work.
So that's where the dating comes from. And again to be representative of the order of the white
wet blanket as I usually am, there's no independent evidence to support this dating. And again it's
built up on a series of speculative leaps. Let me just put this into context. This guy Lacroix
claims to have found symbols that seem to indicate a common culture in, as you say, Turkey,
Egypt of course, Cambodia, Peru, Bolivia, in other words all across the world. He says
that this civilization of which he talks were proficient in cosmic cycles, they
anticipated global disasters, they concealed a sophisticated code within geometry, symbolism
and monument design across the globe to preserve their knowledge ahead of catastrophic events.
If the story is true, their ability to anticipate global disasters did not preclude them falling
victim to one. So do you see what I mean? Lacroix's story is that at a certain point
there was some kind of global catastrophe, meteorological earthquakes, seismic whatever,
that wiped this ancient civilization out. The central problem with all of these theories is
that at the time they're talking about during the ice age there's no evidence of any sort of
advanced civilization at all. Humans, all the evidence, all the archaeological evidence,
of which there is quite a lot, suggests that humans are working in small hunter-gatherer groups.
Now these hunter-gatherer groups could be quite sophisticated. Their brains are essentially the
same as ours. As we know humans are pretty ingenious creatures who can come up with
solutions to all sorts of problems. But for a civilization you need things like the development
of domesticated agriculture. And there's no evidence that domestication of food occurs anywhere
in the last 10, it's probably 11,000 years. But the best evidence suggests it's about 9,000 BC
in modern day eastern Turkey, northern Syria. That's where domestication first takes place.
Now there's lots of really interesting things happening when humans start to domesticate.
There's sites like Obekli Tepe, which a lot of people use as sort of this prototype. That's a
really interesting site. These hunter-gatherers are creating these big monumental structures.
But further south there's also agriculturalists who are starting, who are also building sort of
structures. Would this be like 40,000 years ago? No, this is 10,000, 11,000 years ago.
So what would you say, 40,000 years? So 10,000 years ago hunter-gatherers were beginning to
create interesting structures and therefore kind of form a civilization. 40,000 years ago,
what state was humanity in, in your opinion? Well, operating in small groups in a very
difficult sort of environment where you don't have the last glacial period, but you've got a
series of sort of cold snaps where you have glaciers moving down and then other periods
of relative sort of stability. They're quite short. It's pretty erratic. And all the evidence
is that humans are having to adapt to very sort of difficult circumstances. I mean,
there are examples or evidence for global catastrophes. There's volcanic explosions.
There's one about 70,000 years ago. But you can trace humans and human groups moving around.
And of course, you remember 40,000 years ago, there's not just us. There are other human
species around still at that moment. Yeah, and there would have been the Neanderthals and all
that. Neanderthals, you've got Homo floresiensis, this remarkable little hobbit people who lived
in modern day Indonesia. So there's lots of interesting things going on. But it's very small
scale. It's looking at small groups. And you simply can't, there's so many sort of pre sort
of requirements that you need to build a civilization. It's a massive population,
you need food, you need trade, you need all of these sort of qualities. And there's simply no
evidence of that happening. So your contention or your knowledgeable contention would be 40,000
years ago, the idea that some very advanced civilization prospering on the planet is far
fetched. But you know, I'm always going to ask you that. Is it at least outside chance possible?
I mean, anything is possible. The evidence at the moment doesn't support it. And again,
this is an interesting creative theory. The key point is his site that he believes is the source
for all of these sort of civilization, which he believes begins in eastern Turkey. Again,
he's got no independent dating. Most archaeologists who work in that area believe that this sort of
city is from what's called the Eritrean period, the Iron Age. So we're talking in the last 4,000
years or 3,000 years. Okay. All right. So listen, fascinating stuff. And I'll tell you what,
I'm going to get you back on now because you've intrigued me. I've got to talk to you about the
Hobbit people of Indonesia. So stand by for a phone call from my top team and we'll get you on,
Ashley.
