What makes a messiah and does Jesus meet the criteria? Join Shabbos Kestenbaum and Christian theologian and apologist Sean McDowell as they examine together one of the most consequential theological questions in history.
📣 NEW SHOW 📣 We’re excited to launch our newest show with Shabbos Kestenbaum: Theological — exploring the biggest questions about faith, morality, and meaning across religious traditions.
00:49 Introducing Sean McDowell 01:37 A Legacy of Apologetics 02:37 Wrestling with Doubt and Faith 03:48 What Does “Messiah” Mean? 06:27 Why Aren’t There More Sources About Jesus? 10:17 Did Jesus Claim to Be the Messiah? 14:10 Christianity and Its Jewish Roots 16:37 What Must the Messiah Accomplish? 22:37 Miracles and the Resurrection 28:08 Salvation: Faith or Actions? 36:50 Can Anyone Be Forgiven? 41:27 When Is the Messiah Coming?
My understanding is Jesus, in his life, he was not claiming to be a Messiah.
He was not trying to start a new religion.
I don't think Jesus saw himself as starting a new religion.
Christians have not done a good job respecting and talking about our Jewish roots.
What does the Messiah actually mean?
What is the expectation that he is meant to be fulfilling?
Are we going to trust a source written 500 years later,
or four Gospels written within the lifetime of that person?
He goes, I am Lord of the Sabbath.
Which, if he's not, is total heresy to say that.
But if he is actually God, then he has the authority to do this.
So we're joined by professor and theologian, Sean McDowell.
Sean, thank you so much for joining us.
Shabbos, this is a joy and an honor.
So Sean, you're a theologian, you're a professor, you're a podcaster.
Tell us a little bit about yourself.
First off, I'm a husband and I'm a dad.
I have three kids, live in Southern Orange County,
teach at a wonderful school called Talbot School of Theology, a part of Biola University.
Really, above all, I'm a communicator.
I really believe Christianity is true.
I want to defend it and I want to proclaim it to people.
But like with you on this show, I want to do it civilly and respectfully and kindly.
Some of this comes from my own father, who was an apologist.
If you actually go back about four decades, my dad was the Charlie Kirk of his generation.
Now, he wasn't political at all, but Charlie Kirk spoke at 120 universities.
My dad spoke at 1,200 universities.
He would get 10, 12, 15, 20,000 students out.
They would pack stadiums going back to like 70s and 80s into the early 90s.
He had over 250 debates with debated Muslim, debated atheist, skeptics, all sorts of people.
That's the roots that I grew up in.
This revolutionary, like my dad and Dennis Prager go back years.
They've done stuff together, interestingly enough.
When I was, I think, 19 or 20 years old, this is like mid-90s to date myself,
and I got on this new technology called the internet.
I'm fishing around and I found some of the atheist secular web.
At that time, I was dedicated in part to taking my dad's books chapter by chapter,
scientists, historians, lawyers, trying to debunk them.
I had never heard such thoughtful challenges to my faith.
For the first time in my life, I was like, oh man, I could be wrong.
I went to my dad.
We're in Breckenridge, Colorado.
I was like, dad, I just don't know that I'm convinced Christianity is true.
This great world-changing leader.
He didn't freak out.
He looked at me Shabbos and he goes, son, I think that's great.
I was like, did you hear anything that I just said?
He goes, you can't live on my convictions.
You've got to follow what you think is true.
He goes, only give up Christianity if you're convinced that something else is true
and I love you no matter what.
That's the kind of background I've been raised in.
Not afraid to engage other ideas.
A willingness to follow truth no matter what it costs
and that's how I try to live my life today.
That's beautiful.
Thank you for that.
I want to frame the conversation as follows.
I am not Christian.
Spoiler.
I don't know if it was the kippah or the fact that my name is Shabbos Kestenbaum.
That gave it away.
But as an outside observer to Christianity,
I've always viewed Christianity as having two foundational truth claims.
The first is Jesus Christ as the son of God
and the second claim which I want to focus on first is Jesus as the Messiah.
My understanding of the Greco-Roman time period is
no other faith other than Judaism were making messianic claims.
The Messiah was not a central figure in any major religion.
So when I'm told by Christians, by friends of mine that Jesus is the Messiah,
well, my first question is, well, what does the Messiah actually mean?
What does he do?
Before we talk about who it can be,
I was wondering if you can shed some light the Christian conception of a Messiah.
What can we expect from a messianic figure?
I'll take your word for it because it matches my experience that there's not
messianic expectation outside of Judaism.
That's why I think when Jesus comes on the scene,
he's consistently appealing not to like these pagan stories.
He's not appealing to these Greco-Roman myths,
but specifically appealing to some of the Jewish scriptures as a part of his identity.
So the messianic expectation, I don't know that I can answer that in the abstract apart from
Jesus and how he saw himself as the Messiah.
And I guess I think of Luke chapter 4.
So Jesus has been, he's been baptized.
He's gone through the temptation with Satan in the wilderness for 40 days.
And then he's at home in Nazareth, goes in the synagogue,
stands up and they hand him a scroll of Isaiah.
And he starts to read Isaiah 61.
And he says to the effect of, I don't remember the exact words,
but the poor had the good news preached to him,
the blind see, the captives are released,
that he's this anticipated figure who would come and bring redemption,
bring salvation, bring healing for the people, bring peace for the people.
Jesus saw himself as that figure.
So I, I take issue in the Orthodox community where I was born and raised,
whereby we are fearful of having these types of conversations
because a pretty relevant, strong history of first forced conversions or persecution.
But at the same time, I'm confident enough in my own Judaism,
whereby I was sort of joking with you earlier,
but if you can make it like a convincing argument about Jesus,
like I'm happy to be swayed one way or the other,
but there are certain stumbling blocks I have before me.
And one of them though, is within antiquity,
you don't see non-Christian sources at the time of Jesus
who are actually talking about Jesus.
So if I wanted to believe that he was this, this miracle doer,
that he was a messianic figure, that he was creating a new,
I wouldn't say religion, but a new branch of conceiving your relationship to God.
How come more people weren't talking about him?
I think, and correct me if I'm wrong,
it was Paul in about 50 CE who was the first one to really discuss Jesus.
And they didn't have much of a relationship.
I don't think Paul actually knew who Jesus was.
How come more people at the time aren't discussing
this very legendary son of God figure?
Totally fair question.
First thing I would say is thank you for being willing to have this conversation.
I think Christians and Jews, I think you can go both ways sometimes,
that there's a fear of the conversation for a range of reasons.
And you're absolutely right.
I had a chance to interview someone who, one of my favorite thinkers,
Os Guinness, and he was like,
Christian mistreatment of Jews throughout history
is one of the greatest stains like in history and certainly on the church.
And I know that's often lurking behind this.
So having these kinds of conversations and you pushing back is like, great.
I think that's a step forward that's really positive.
So I would say a few things.
I would say even if there were no extra biblical sources about Jesus,
I would still believe the sources that we have.
Why?
Because I think the sources are early.
I think they have the earmarks of reliability and are trustworthy
and paint a story about Jesus that matches up with the history of that time.
Now we could go into some of that in depth if you want to,
but I cited Luke earlier, Luke chapter four.
Luke, who's a medical doctor, who's obviously trained, he's smart,
he's systematic, careful in how he writes that gospel.
He starts by saying,
many have undertaken to drop an account of the things that are amongst us.
He goes, but I have carefully investigated everything from the beginning
to ensure the certainty of the things to you.
He's writing to a Theophilus,
so you can have confidence in this kind of report.
I didn't do that word for word, but you get the gist of it.
That's an ancient way in a biography of saying,
I'm writing history as best as I can.
And then when we look through the gospel of Luke,
it's remarkable how many things historically match up.
Now with that said, in some ways,
it's interesting to ask how much historical writing should we expect
of somebody like Jesus who is ministering in Galilee.
It's a corner of the Roman empire.
I've been reading Luke over and over again.
I've been reading John and he's kind of downplaying who he is
so he can reveal himself at the right time.
Why would we have writings about him during that time?
Of course, we have Josephus referencing twice in the mid nineties.
There's other sources outside of the Bible that are Christian sources,
like Clement of Rome, the end of the first century,
you get into Ignatius early second century.
Then you have other Roman sources like Cassius in the second century.
So there are historical writings
that match up significantly on the life of Jesus.
But I think we have to ask how much should we expect
given who Jesus claimed to be.
The paucity of sources during that time,
and probably seven to 10% of people were even littered anyways,
a lot was passed on orally.
So bottom line, I guess to answer your question,
I think we have a sufficient amount about Jesus outside of the Bible,
a good amount for who he was.
But even if we had none,
I think the gospels and the letters of Paul are reliable sources about his life.
So let me push back because you mentioned who Jesus claimed to be.
And I think that's sort of the central question here.
My understanding is Jesus in his life,
he was not claiming to be a Messiah.
He was not trying to start a new religion.
These things sort of came after the crucifixion.
Would that be an accurate assessment of who Jesus was and his mission in life?
So two things.
And sorry, and this is operating under the assumption,
which I agree with, that Jesus actually existed as an historical person.
Sure, which you agree with, right?
Just, okay, good.
All right, we don't have to start there.
Fair enough.
I'm not ready to concede the point that he was the Messiah,
but I am ready to say he was an actual person who lived and died
and was operating during the temple period.
Absolutely.
And I'm not avoiding the question,
and you base that on the gospel accounts and the extra biblical ones?
Like what convinces you?
No, I don't base that off the gospel.
Interestingly enough, I actually base it on the Talmud.
Okay.
The Talmud was referencing Jesus.
Yep.
They, the editors of the Talmud, which was really finished in 500 CE,
they were not afraid of Christianity at the time
because it wasn't really existing as a religious movement.
And only once Christianity became a religious movement,
there was much to fear.
And so later editions of the Talmud kind of censored
their more explicit references to Jesus.
But the way I understand Jesus existed is because, well,
our rabbinic tradition actually speaks about him in passing
and in short clips, but they do acknowledge that
there was this person who was saying these things.
Totally fair.
So that makes sense that you're Jewish,
have those commitments, talks about Jesus centuries later.
I think I would say if somebody didn't start with your commitments and mine
and said like, what can we know about Jesus?
Are we going to trust a source written 500 years later
or four gospels, historical bios written within the lifetime of that person?
Historically, some without bias would clearly start with letters of Paul,
the gospels, et cetera.
And again, we can come back to that,
but I don't think Jesus saw himself as starting a new religion.
Now, if I was presumably, if I was Jewish,
I would feel like Christians are starting a new religion.
So I get that.
Like, that makes sense.
But Jesus, like in Luke 24 is like,
don't you know that the old Testament or the scriptures speak of me?
In John, he's like over and over again.
He's like, Isaiah spoke of me.
Moses spoke of me.
The father spoke of me.
So Christians have not done a good job in the past and in the present,
really respecting and talking about our Jewish roots.
I think sometimes Christians have gone out of the way to separate themselves from it,
which I think is profoundly unfortunate for a lot of reasons and just theologically bad.
But I don't think Jesus saw himself starting a new religion.
That's why in Luke four, he's like, this is fulfilled.
Now, as far as the Messiah in John chapter four,
when Jesus is talking with the woman at the well,
he distinctly says he is the Messiah in John chapter four.
So this is on his lips, not just somebody about him.
Now, of course, we got to ask the question, can we trust the gospel of John?
And that's a question we could go down that trail if we want to.
But we have multiple sources early on the different gospels,
writings of Paul referring to his identity in that fashion that I think are pretty early.
So if Jesus came back, which actually is something you very much hope happens,
but if he were to come back today and he were to see the Catholic church,
he were to see Lutherans or Protestants,
would he actually be caught off guard as to what are you guys doing?
Because to your point, if he didn't see himself as starting a new religion,
I mean, by our 21st century goggles, Christianity very much is
its own unique religion, very much different from Judaism.
And presumably Jesus saw himself first and foremost as a Jew.
So what would his reaction be to the advent of contemporary Christianity?
So first off, I would say amen to Jesus seeing himself as a Jew.
This is important and worth saying is that when people say, well,
Christians are anti-Semitic, I go, maybe some have been.
We talked about that.
And that's not because of what scriptures teach.
That violates what the scriptures teach.
So Jesus was Jewish.
John the Baptist is Jewish.
The 12 disciples were Jewish.
Jesus's message was first to the Jew and then to the Gentile.
People miss this.
Even like the Gospel of John, it's really interesting how
the religious leaders of that time are clearly the foe.
Like we get that.
But I think it's said pretty clearly, like this generation,
this is not castigating all Jews.
It was those religious leaders at that time.
And one way I think we know this is because there are other Jews that are cast positively,
even like the Gospel of John, even like small things.
When in John chapter 11, with the raising of Lazarus,
some of the Jews were there comforting them.
Well, why would they, why do they even need to make this up
and put it in the story if they're the foes?
I think there's a lot of hints like that to make that point.
So what would Jesus say if he came back?
Part of me, I'm hesitant to say, Shabbos, here's exactly what Jesus would say.
Like, there's a reluctance in me to say that.
But when it comes to different denominations,
and where exactly do we draw that line of a denomination?
Again, it's a question we could have.
But I think there's space in the Bible for different church structure,
for emphasizing different things.
Like some churches will emphasize the sovereignty of God.
Some will emphasize the Holy Spirit.
Some have different structures and way of doing evangelism.
I don't see those things as being bad.
I see those things as being good.
Because there's diversity and unity within the body of Christ.
Even though somewhere we have to draw that line as a whole,
I don't know that that's necessarily a bad thing to me.
And he would be shocked that you have different denominations of people
practicing their faith in a different fashion.
So even within the different denominations and the different components
whereby Christians look at Jesus for his piety,
they look at Jesus for his, I don't know, saving of mankind.
There is a cross agreement that Jesus is the Messiah,
which goes back to our first question.
That's right.
What does that mean?
Like Judaism, we will say Messiah has to do specific things.
There's like criteria for how you know someone is a Messiah.
And it's not really about the person.
It's more about the things by which they are,
the things they are accomplishing as the Messiah.
So what is Jesus's role as a Messiah?
What is the expectation that he is meant to be fulfilling or has already fulfilled?
There's an expectation, I think we both agree on,
that somebody would come and save the people,
forgiveness of sins and redemption.
Like we see quoting in Isaiah,
there would be signs around this person.
And there's some passages in Isaiah, I think it's Isaiah chapter 9,
if I'm not mistaken, that refers to certain miracles.
There's kind of hints at that.
And that he would save the people.
Now, one of the areas where I suspect we would differ over,
what does it mean to bring peace?
What does it mean to save the people?
And there were expectations of a military type Messiah.
And the gospels talk about this, like they're not hiding away from it.
So you see James and John and they're like,
can we reign on your right?
And can we reign on your left?
And in part, what Jesus is doing is he's saying,
okay, you understand certain things about the Messiah,
but you don't understand the full picture of who the Messiah would be
and what he would do until he really dies and resurrects.
And then their eyes are open to it.
You mentioned Isaiah.
Isaiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, they talk about,
there are specific things that the Messiah must accomplish.
So the ingathering of the exiles, bringing the Jews back to Israel,
there must be knowledge throughout the world of God's existence.
There would be peace in our time.
You would rebuild the final third temple.
And I'm reading those scriptures and I'm saying,
okay, well, just from an objective perspective,
even if I was a Christian,
there's no way that someone can make a credible argument
that Jesus, for example, built the third temple
or that Jesus brought back the Jews into Israel.
So if I wanted to believe in Jesus,
it seems like that is an almost immovable objection.
I think we need to take these one by one and look at them.
So, and here's how Christians would make sense of this.
There's a lot of debate from what I understand within rabbinic circles
about how to, what the Messiah would do,
when he would accomplish it, what it would look like,
how we would know.
There's not a uniform perspective that just existed all the way through
that Jesus didn't match up with.
And there's volumes that go into some of these in detail.
And so I would argue it's not quite as clear cut,
like there's one perspective you're laying out here.
On top of that, I would say, okay, so take the one on peace.
Yeah, there's not physical peace in the land,
but Jesus brought peace.
He brought peace with God and our relationship with him.
He brought redemption.
And it's the first fruits, the sign of the peace that yet would come.
Can I just interject?
I'm sorry, when you say he brought redemption, what does that mean?
It's spiritual peace with God, that Jesus is the God-man,
pays for our sins.
You could say, lives the life that human beings can't live,
fulfills all the 10 commandments,
dies for us, pays that debt to God.
So redemption is available for all.
Now, all won't take it, right?
We're not in the heavenly state yet
when we're with people who really embrace that.
But Jesus has brought peace with God available and accessible
and inviting everybody into that.
Now, whether or not an individual is redeemed
is up to how they respond to the grace that God has offered.
So it talks about peace for all in the Old Testament.
In part, Jesus going, yeah, I'm fulfilling that.
But in a way you don't understand.
So he's not contradicting it.
He's fulfilling it and opening up their eyes in a different way.
Now, in part, so let me frame it this way.
I think the gospels are very aware that Jesus is doing something
that the religious leaders of his day are calling him on.
So like when he's walking through, I think it's in Luke chapter 6,
he's walking through in the Sabbath and they're eating on the Sabbath.
And they're like, this violates the Sabbath.
What are you doing?
And Jesus is like, well, he gave an exception of David
during the time of the high priest of Abiathar that eat the bread.
And he's kind of saying from the lesser David, he goes,
I am Lord of the Sabbath, which if he's not, is total heresy to say that.
He's completely violating exactly what he should be doing.
But if he is actually God and he is greater than David,
then he has the authority to do this.
So in one way, he's aligning himself with the Jewish scriptures and expectations.
He's also saying, yeah, I was the one who was in the burning bush.
I was the one who created, I made the Sabbath and have the authority to do this.
So really the question is, does Jesus have that authority?
Can he say that the Old Testament scriptures spoke to him?
And that's a question like, did he do the miracles?
Did he actually claim to be God?
Did he rise on the third day?
That it seems to me would address the question of authority or not.
That's how I and many Christians look at it.
Right. I mean, my immediate response would be we have in the rabbinic tradition,
sage after sage saying that you can conceivably have
individuals who can do wonders and make miracles.
And that would in no way suggest that they are divine or that they are a Messiah.
But in the Old Testament, I mean, you have non-Jews
who are doing miracles.
In fact, the first two of the 10 plagues, the Egyptians say, no biggie, we could do that too.
OK, you turn the water into blood.
We could do that.
You can create frogs out of the water.
We can do that.
So the idea that someone can perform miracles.
OK, we're not really convinced by that.
So even if I were to concede the point that Jesus was a miracle doer,
it still wouldn't in any way move me one way or the other in accepting Jesus as a redeemer.
But because you give such insight...
Yeah, sorry, go ahead.
Can I comment on that?
Yes.
So this is a really interesting passage in the Exodus 7 to 14 passage
where they're doing miracles and the magicians are able to do the first few.
But they come up to a point where they can't do additional miracles.
And what do they say?
That's the finger of God.
So there seems to be a recognition that even non-Jews
can maybe do some supernatural things, right?
It's in Deuteronomy.
If somebody even does a miracle and tells you to follow a different God, don't do it.
So you and I agree that there are supernatural phenomena that exist
and can do supernatural things, but there's a limit to their power.
So it's one thing to do the kind of miracles that are in the Exodus.
It's another thing, as St. Eugene said,
the sign I'll give you is the sign of Jonah.
Three days and three nights in the belly of the whale.
And I will conquer death.
That to me is a qualitatively different miracle
that seems for me to pause and go, okay, wait a minute.
Every other prophet is still in the grave.
Every other religious leader is still in the grave.
This guy claimed to be the Jewish Messiah.
He claimed to be God.
And he rose on the third day, arguably the greatest miracle one can conceive of.
To me, I'm like, I think I'm going with that guy.
Well, I mean, to play devil's advocate, as is the theme of this conversation.
I mean, you do have Elijah who was able to resurrect.
But I hear the point that there are qualitative differences between certain miracles.
That's not a resurrection, right?
Those people were going to die again.
We see that with Elijah, with Elisha in the New Testament.
Resurrection, 1 Corinthians 15.
And this is a difference, like you and I both believe in a resurrection.
I presume you believe it's at the end times,
like in Daniel 12 too, there's a resurrection.
Correct.
And Christians are like, oh, it happened in the middle of time,
which is in line with the resurrection and a sign of God's power.
But like, wait a minute, was this supposed to happen in the middle of history?
Jesus had his resurrected, eternal, perfect body.
Everybody else raised, died again.
So there's still something qualitative I would push back on a little bit.
No, I would agree.
Maimonides writes the 13 principles of faith.
One of them being we believe in the resurrection of the dead.
In fact, he takes it so far to suggest that if you don't believe
in the resurrection of the dead, you're a heretic.
In the Shemona Esrei, which is the, let's say,
emotional and spiritual climax of our thrice daily prayer,
we refer to God as the resurrector of the dead.
So I agree.
Both Christianity and Judaism would say there's a qualitative difference
between resurrection and turning water into blood, for example.
But I want to go back to a previous point.
And because your answers are so insightful and so interesting,
I'm going on a tangent, so I blame you for this.
But we were talking about earlier that the risk of me as a Jew being wrong
are so much greater than the risk of you as a Christian being wrong.
Because if I am wrong as a Jew and I don't accept Jesus
or I don't accept Muhammad as a prophet,
then I'm destined to eternal damnation.
You know, I'm in for a really rude awakening.
Whereas if I am the Jew am right, you, Sean McDowell, as a Christian,
you're kind of fine.
Jews, we don't proselytize.
We don't try to convert.
We really don't focus on expanding.
Which, by the way, it's interesting how Jews,
we obviously predate Christianity,
yet there's more than a billion Christians and there's only 15 million Jews.
Mormonism only started in the 1830s and 40s
and there are already more Mormons than there are Jews.
How is it that a people that have been around longer than Islam,
longer than Christianity, longer than Mormonism,
we're only like 15 million?
But I digress.
But you're the only people group that goes back so long
and still has an identity.
Canaanites, Moabites, Mesopotamians all fade
because of the identity of who you are,
the scriptures that God has given you.
Yeah.
That's unique.
A lot of people miss that, but keep going.
Now you're batting for my team.
Maybe I'm converting you.
Well, I consider you a part of my team.
Oh, that's true.
That's true.
In that sense.
Right, that's a good point.
So in terms of redemption,
if I were to just genuinely believe that Jesus is my Lord and Savior
and I don't really change my actions,
but I really do believe that he's the Messiah
and he's the Resurrector and all that.
Am I saved?
Do I go to heaven?
Is that all that is required?
And I think, by the way, that's a misconception within Judaism.
If I'm wrong, I think our attitude is that within Christianity,
so long as you accept Jesus, you might be a sinner,
you might be a bad person,
but it's less about the action and more about the belief.
Whereas I would say Judaism is probably the opposite.
Totally fair.
By the way, if Muslims are right, you and I are both going to hell.
Right, right.
I mean, that's a fact.
If 1.5 billion or whatever the number is, 1.8 billion Muslims,
I don't know the latest count.
If they're correct, we are both spending eternity in hell.
And the Quranic depiction of hell, I think, is worse than the biblical one.
So it's not just Christians, and I know you weren't saying this,
who proselytize and say that they're right.
And by the way, I don't fault Muslims for that.
If they're right, I would believe it.
I'm just not convinced that they're right.
So we've got to clarify what we mean by accept.
There's a deeper Hebrew understanding,
and you would probably know this a lot better than I would,
and kind of an analytical modern understanding,
in the sense that we think believe is I just assent to something.
I believe that George Washington was the first president of the United States.
I believe that.
Sure.
Is that what Jesus meant and Paul meant by belief?
I would say that's not what's meant by belief.
Belief is more a sense of trust.
It entails a sense of my life.
I believe in you and I follow you.
Now, the key is you're not saved by works.
I mean, Paul is super clear about this.
I think Jesus in John 6, he's like, what work must you do?
Believe.
Paul's like, it is not by works of righteousness by which we are saved,
but by his grace, by his mercy.
So Christian understanding is we can't earn our salvation.
There's nothing I can do to merit eternal life.
Jesus on the cross, the God man paid the debt that I owe to God.
All I can do is accept by grace through faith what he's done for me.
Now, the reality is when and if I really understand who God is and what he's done for me,
I can't live the same Shabbos.
I can't live the same.
I'm just telling you from my life when I understand the depth of
sinfulness of my own life and how much I failed and I've fallen short.
And I understand what Jesus does for me.
I'm not perfect, but it changes you from the inside out.
And so if somebody says, oh yeah, I believe, but their life is not different at all.
I would say, I'm not really sure you actually believe and you get it.
The life change is not what makes you save.
You might say it's the fruit, so to speak.
So I think it's in John 14, 15 through 17.
Jesus is like, if you love me, you will obey.
If you love me, you'll obey.
So I love Jesus.
He's changed my life.
So I'm drawn to live differently because of that.
That's the fruit that's made known to the world.
Like in 1 Samuel 16, it's like, you know, when they're trying to get the next king,
it's like man judges the outward appearance, but God judges the heart.
So the changed life is the fruit of the heart of grace,
where somebody has accepted what Jesus has done for them.
So I look at, I can't say all because people who are genuinely saved
can do some pretty terrible things and repent of it.
But I look at at least a ton of the way Jews have been mistreated.
And I'm like, what are you doing?
That is not the kind of fruit
of really knowing Jesus and being saved by him.
Now, I don't know their heart.
I can't make that assessment.
But to me, I'm like, that is not consistent with somebody who says they're saved.
And so to answer your question, I would just make a distinction.
Christianity is not like you just check off the box.
No, I believe I trust in Jesus.
I receive by grace through faith.
And that makes you a new creation.
That's what leads to life change.
So that's a beautiful answer.
I mean it.
That's a very beautiful answer.
I believe you.
That belief influences behavior.
And that when someone is so overcome by their spiritual awakening,
then there's no other choice but to change who you are as a person.
I think that's a great answer.
But what if someone doesn't change their behavior?
What if they just have the belief?
We're talking about these things as we can just kind of siphon them off together.
I don't know what it means to say, I trust you, Jesus.
And my life doesn't change as a result of that trust.
That doesn't make sense to me.
That doesn't fit.
So we're logically parsing things.
And in some ways, Christians are kind of responsible for this.
We're like, just get your fire insurance and then live like everybody else.
So some of your question probably stems from things Christians have said
and the way we've acted and not lived differently.
But biblically, it follows that if I really believe, it's going to result in a life change.
And so if there's never life change, it's like timeout, you didn't believe.
From a human perspective, God is the one who knows somebody's heart.
Now, so maybe I'm overthinking this.
Maybe somebody really believes and we don't see life change for five years
and they die in a terrible car accident, but they believed.
And we just didn't have time to see that fruit develop in their life.
Okay, maybe.
That's why with a lot of people, I'm like,
you've got to give them time to see life change and the spirit work in their heart.
And so someone lives 40 years and there's never life change.
I'm like, I don't know what that means to say you trusted Jesus.
And there's nothing different in your life.
So I studied in an all-male yeshiva in the old city of Jerusalem.
So I lived two minutes away from the Al-Aqsa Mosque,
the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the Dome of the Rock.
Yeah, it was very, when you sinned, you felt extra bad about it.
And I had a rabbi, Rabbi Sklar, if he's watching, which I'm sure he isn't.
But he often had this line that really stuck with me.
When I would say, why do you have so many
religiously observant Jews or Jews who definitely look the part and they're sinning?
And I don't just mean they forgot to say a blessing on food
or they forgot to put on their phylacteries.
But you have Jews who unfortunately are pedophiles.
You have Jews who unfortunately commit tax fraud in the same way in any faith.
There are Christians who commit tax fraud and Christians who are pedophiles.
And he would often say, Judaism as a religion is perfect.
And I don't find flaw in the religion.
Jews, and you can substitute Christian or Muslim or atheist, really people are imperfect.
So I do actually think it makes sense that someone can
internally or spiritually trust Jesus as their Lord and Savior.
But then in practice, by virtue of simply being a human being,
does things that are very much not in compliance with Jesus's law.
And so the question that I'm getting at is trust alone.
Is that enough?
And I do think there are people who very much do trust
and very much do think of themselves as in compliance with biblical law.
But at the same time, you and I as objective observers would say,
well, how can you really be a good person if you've also committed murder
and tax fraud and child rape, God forbid?
So I think there's a difference between somebody who trusts God
and does things that are not in line with God's commands.
I think that's the way you framed it.
Yeah.
All of us do that.
Myself, I'm going to go on a limb and say that you do that.
Everybody watching this.
And there's degrees of things.
It's like, well, it's one thing to, I don't know,
cut to someone because I'm angry and to be a pedophile, right?
Like there's degrees, where do you draw that line?
Some are clearly far more evil than other things.
But there's a difference.
So there's a difference in saying you do things not in line with God's commands
and you say you trust and you don't see any change in your life whatsoever.
So I'll tell you, and maybe I'll get in trouble for saying this.
I have people, all the things that you mentioned,
who I've known, who have done those kinds of things.
And I believe that God can forgive us for any sins that we've done.
But when that person, even a pedophile, gets caught,
is that person really going to cry out to God for forgiveness?
Own what they did is wrong.
Do whatever they can to, you know, make,
you know, it's as evil thing as you can basically do.
If that person believed, we're going to see that fruit work out at some point in their life.
And maybe we differ over this.
I don't know how Judaism would say to someone who's a pedophile and came back,
can they be forgiven?
On Christianity, we would say you actually can be forgiven.
And that's possible.
And I've seen people, I mean stories.
I think about Lee Strobel's book, The Case for Grace.
He saw one of the guys who worked in, I think it was in Cambodia,
and responsible for like mass murder.
And in prison was just convicted of the depth of his sin.
And like cried out to God for forgiveness.
And then did everything that he could do after that to make right.
And even some family members of people he had been responsible for,
like were able to reconcile with him.
To me, that's a beautiful thing.
If somebody really on their deathbed had an awareness of the depth of their sin
and cried out to God for forgiveness, could that person be saved?
And the answer I'd say is yes.
And I think about my own, and we have to talk about the reasons why
and means of salvation within Christianity.
But if I thought about my own kids, and I had a kid go down a road
and just do the most horrible things possible.
I'm a dad, I have three kids.
And they just rebelled and caused havoc and did evil.
And on their deathbed, they looked at me and they said,
not just, hey, I believe in Jesus, the way it's depicted in Family Guy.
And mocked and said, Dad, I am so sorry.
I wish I could rewind the clock and take back the horrible things that I did.
I was absolutely wrong in that.
Please tell everybody that I did this to, that I'm sorry.
And I wish I could take it back.
Will you forgive me?
Any minute, I would say yes to my son.
No question about it.
That's similar to what God has done for us through the person of Jesus Christ.
So I think that person can get forgiveness.
Now, how likely is it going to be that that person is going to do that?
I don't know.
I mean, I've heard stories of things like that that happen at times.
And for anybody watching, I'm like, don't bank on having that last moment.
Get right with Jesus now.
I'm a Christian, of course, I'm going to say that.
But I think that's the amazing grace that God actually has for us.
I mean, you tell me, I'm really just curious.
If a person was at that point and they were a Jew, it would be like, too bad.
You're out of luck.
Well, the Jewish concept of heaven and hell is markedly different than the Christian concept
of heaven and hell.
And one of the reasons we don't proselytize is because we actually think you could be
a very good person and an upstanding citizen of your society so long as you keep the seven
Noahide laws.
And the seven Noahide laws, most people keep by virtue of just being alive.
So I know we didn't get into this, we won't have time.
But partly what Christians do is we look at the words that Jesus spoke, the things that
he did, the authority that he had as signs that he's God in human flesh.
So that would be one example like, wait a minute, who can forgive sins but God alone?
And Jesus is like, well, yeah, I have the authority to forgive sins because I'm God,
which is made clear later on.
I want to wrap up this discussion by circling back to the opening question, which is to
say this.
In Judaism, one of the things we say at the end of our morning prayer is the line from
Maimonides of the afa pishi isma mea im kol zeh hakelo b'chol yom she'ava, which is
even though the Messiah may delay, we nevertheless have full and complete faith that he can come
at any moment, at any day.
He can quite literally appear.
It is also true that there are ways we can hasten his arrival by doing good deeds, by
observing the Sabbath, by connecting with our religious identity.
So ultimately, we don't know when he's coming.
We try to think that as Jews, if we observe more of the commandments, we can expedite
his arrival.
But ultimately, only God knows.
And in fact, the rabbis point to Jacob on his deathbed.
He was about to reveal, say the rabbis, to his 12 sons when the Messiah was to arrive
and God immediately cut his life.
But I want to ask sort of the obvious question, which I'm sure many of the listeners are
asking.
When's he coming?
When's the Messiah coming?
Great question.
Let me go back and then I will not answer that question.
Okay.
Now you're sounding like a rabbi from the Talmud.
I'll tell you why.
So just to understand, every morning you have a prayer from Maimonides.
From Maimonides, yes.
About the coming of the Messiah, like daily.
Yeah, it's fundamental to our belief.
Separate conversation.
I have so many questions.
I want to ask you about that.
That'll have to be part two.
I'll come on your show and we'll do a part two.
So thank you.
You said it live.
You just, you owned it.
Okay, let's do it.
That's fun.
I'm going to take you up on that.
Okay, so part of the Christian view rooted in the Old Testament is that the day of the
Lord is at hand.
It could be tomorrow or it could be 800 years later.
We see this with some of the prophets, like the day of the Lord is at hand.
It's like, wait a minute.
Then judgment came a long time later.
So there's this tension that Christians have that I think is rooted in our Jewish roots
that Jesus could come back this afternoon or he could tarry 2000 years.
So anyone who tells you they know the date Jesus is coming back is a heretic.
In fact, just last week when we're recording this, I don't know when this goes live,
but there was all this talk online.
Hundreds of thousands of views of people giving specific dates when Jesus was coming back.
Rapture dates.
He's going to come back and do the rapture.
And the problem is theologically, Jesus is like, no one knows the day and the time that
I'm returning.
He says that clearly.
And there's a lot of people who then start selling their stuff.
They believe that this is what Christianity says.
And then when it doesn't happen, they're financially stuck and they reject Christianity,
even though it's a straw man.
The more important question for me is not when is he coming back, but why do I have
confidence that Jesus is coming back?
And my answer is because I think Jesus very clearly claimed not only to be the Messiah,
but he claimed to be God in human flesh.
I think, Shabbos, we have good evidence that he walked on the water and we have good evidence
that he healed the blind.
I think we have really good evidence, I'd love to talk about sometime, that he lived,
that he died, he was buried, and he rose on the third day.
And so in Revelation at the very end, it's like, I am coming soon.
Amen.
Jesus has conquered sin, the kind of redemption, even though we won't see it.
So let me end by saying this, maybe this will be helpful.
When we talk about sin as Christians, there's salvation in the past from our sin.
There's salvation in the present being sanctified, being made like Christ.
Then there's salvation, glorification in the future when Jesus comes back
and ushers in the kind of messianic era that you're talking about.
Why do I believe he's coming a second time?
Because the first time he came, who he claimed to be, the miracles he did,
rose on the third day.
I don't know when, but that gives me a lot of confidence that Jesus is coming back
and I should live my life in light of that promise.
Just like you every day, read the prayer or statement about Maimonides
and try to live your life in light of that.
Wow.
That's a great answer.
And it's funny because in Orthodox culture, the way a rabbi ends his sermon,
even when it's not referencing Messiah at all, is he will say,
and the Messiah should come.
Amen.
The congregation says, Amen.
And now, you know, the sermon's over.
Every time?
Almost every time.
At least most of the rabbis I know, that's how they'll end their sermon.
I think that's a good way of ending our show, that the Messiah should come.
We may have differences of opinions, but I think we both agree
that these conversations are vital between Christians and Jews.
Not only do we have nothing to fear from the other,
but I think we actually have a lot to gain.
I certainly gain a lot from you and my Christian friends,
and hopefully the feeling is reciprocal.
But I really appreciate you coming on.
Thank you for a spirited and fun and enjoyable and educational,
conversation.
I really mean it.
Keep it up.
Appreciate it.