Superbowl LX went to the Seahawks, but the halftime show went to Puerto Rico with musician Bad Bunny, who performed almost entirely in Spanish (except, of course, when he took a dig at America's right to call itself America). The production targeted normie TV viewers with a joyous, positive aura--all while subtly communicating a leftist message of globalization. Was this a stroke of genius, or is Bad Bunny already cringe? Meanwhile, California continues to spiral, expropriating its top earners mob-boss style through aggressive taxes and de facto wealth confiscation. Will the Right rally around its own positive message, and go toe-to-toe with the Left? Plus: Show changes and a new, premium offering to come Thursday! #claremontinstitute#superbowlhalftimeshow#badbunny#trump#superbowlmoments#globalization
------
Chapters 00:00 Roundtable Updates 03:05 Superbowl Halftime Show 20:48 California’s Tax Regime 33:16 The Left’s Positivity Facade 38:58 Closing Remarks
Hello and welcome once again to the new, updated, and improved Roundtable, your weekly podcast from
the publishers and editors of The American Mind. I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor
of the Claremont Review of Books and Editor Especial de la Mente Americana. I am joined
this week by publisher and President Ryan Williams and by our occasional welcome guest
Matt Peterson. So we previewed a little bit last week that we are going to be switching things up
here at The American Mind just a bit. The major kind of headline of this is that we want to bring
you more Roundtable. MOAR! The people crave MOAR! And in addition to that, a lot of podcasts that
are similar to ours have been adding like paid tier for paid subscribers. So we decided we're
going to be doing the same thing. This is part of a package called Claremont Digital Plus.
You can get it by going over to our substack and we'll drop the link in the description of this
episode. But just go on substack and look for the Claremont Institute where you can pay a really,
I must say, quite modest fee, 40 bucks a year, which is less than a lot of substacks. And you
get a bunch of extra content, not just for The American Mind and our podcast, but also for the
other podcasts that we do, The Close Read, the Claremont Review of Books. And on top of that,
you get some extra articles from the editors of CRB and a variety of other goodies. So this is
kind of an all-inclusive suite of offerings. And the part of it that comes from the Roundtable
is going to be an extra episode every week. So if you want to support us and you want to help
keep the show, keep our lights on, keep us in ring lights and microphones, you can subscribe
to do that. If you don't and you've just been a loyal listener all this time for free and you
want to keep reloading, you are more than welcome to do that. We cherish all of our listeners and
we're going to keep doing these free episodes every week. We are going to try out a slightly
different format for them, which is to say we're going to open up with a little bit more of a
freewheeling kind of conversation about the news of the week in general, rather than slicing and
dicing into three specific topics. We always joke that the best part of the show is before we turn
the mics on when we're kind of just hitting each other and talking about what's going on. And so
we want to actually try to just turn the mics on for that part of it rather than doing quite such
a formal structure. And then we will deep dive into a particular topic every week. So you'll
notice that this is a slightly shorter episode for the week in three, and then there's extra
content for the paid subscribers. But hopefully we will also be letting you free subscribers in on
a little bit more of the fun stuff. So with that having been said, I think this is a perfect
opportunity to kick this off because I know that the guys are chomping at the bit to get on my case
over my execrable, vile opinions. Ray Bad Bunny, I was going to try to say his actual name, but I
don't know. I'm realizing I don't I don't know it. Do you guys watch the Super Bowl?
Although in the halftime show, it was kind of a dud of a game. I did watch the whole thing. Yeah.
Wow. Okay. What do you think of the actual play? Well, it was, it was a bit boring,
three quarters or so. Because you had at a certain point, Amelia and I were wondering,
is this game going to end 12-0 Seattle with just field goals? That's what it was trending towards.
I would have been close to that, but for some desperate play from the young quarterback of
the Patriots who ended up turning the ball over and making it a little more exciting. I mean,
it's just good football. It shows that Seattle kind of hit its stride at the perfect time this
season. No touchdowns would have been a first time in Super Bowl history. Correct. That is right.
The football was fine. I mean, Seattle had an impressive defensive performance.
My joke lately has just been, I don't have much love for either the Seahawks or the Patriots,
like most of the rest of America, maybe especially the Patriots outside of Massachusetts.
I was quoting Kissinger about the Iran-Iraq war and hoping that they could both lose.
I know. It was really hard to get excited about either of these teams. Obviously,
long-time listeners to the show know that I root for the Tennessee Titans as a form of self-harm
because I feel that I require penance for my sins. I've been long out of the game.
You have here the king of self-harm in football with us, Matt Peterson.
Oh, good point.
Bill's fan.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. All right.
I'm sorry. It's not self-harm. That is the path of virtue.
That's fidelity, which always comes with grief.
Suffering can be offered up in an efficacious way.
That's redemptive.
The game was pretty bad. I think it was pretty bad. You were saying the field goals.
Some gal tweeted, so which is your favorite field goal so far?
I watched both halftime shows. I flipped back and forth between them.
Some men just want to watch their Twitter feed burn, and I am one of them. I was watching most
of the Bad Bunny one. We should set this up a little bit. This guy has bad politics. I think
it's fair to say. He's a huge Puerto Rican pop star. He sings mostly in Spanish. He did the
entire show in Spanish. He has been making all manner of anti-ICE and anti-Trump, and I wouldn't
even say anti-America, having borders kind of statements in the press. This is another political
choice by the NFL. One of the things they do that I think is really clever is they pick
people whose persona is inherently political, and then they tell them to tone down the politics
clearly or to make the politics covert. My case for the Bad Bunny, you'll notice, by the way,
if you go on the offending Twitter thread that I wrote about this, that I never said I liked
the show. In fact, personally, I can't watch, listen to more than 15 seconds of Bad Bunny
without getting a toothache. Those first 15 seconds are always kind of catchy, and then
it gets to be a bit like, listen to a jackhammer. I had to hand it to him. I thought it was kind of
a work of lefty genius. Think about this guy going up at a moment when Trump is suffering
in the polls over ICE and Minneapolis and all this stuff we've been talking about on the show.
This guy's objective is to make open borders and the globalization of America, especially
all of the Americas in one. He's there to make that look cool. Specifically, his task is to
associate radical leftism with vigorous normalcy, again, because the right has completely owned
heterosexuality and vitality and joy. This is something that they tried to kind of claw back
with Kamala to zero effect with deep kind of astroturfing. This, on the other hand, I thought
was a very carefully produced for TV display of all the joys on our side. They had an actual
straight marriage at the center of the whole thing. It just makes us look like we're taking
our ball and going home when we do this peripheral sideshow with Kid Rock. I mean,
am I wrong about this? It seems like a bad look for us. First off on the visuals, I agree with
you. I thought it was going to be a dumber FU to America. It's just what you'd expect, given what
they've done in the past. They didn't do that. I think you're right. It was surprisingly tame.
He wasn't wearing a dress and doing his gender fluid stuff. Besides some old school crotch
grabbing and sexual lyrics, you couldn't actually translate. You didn't actually know if you didn't
know Spanish. Otherwise, more people would have been appalled. People were mad about the Spanish,
but less able to be mad. Right. It was nothing like that warms the heart of a boomer or someone
who's very empathetic about immigration than hearing the Spanish language like,
oh, look at their culture. Yes, exactly. Hilariously racist in their way. It's so cute.
You're right. I think it was. Also, it was positive. That's the big thing to me.
It was bright colors. It was positive. He said, God bless America. Of course, meaning all the
Americas, but he said, God bless it. There was an actual wedding, so it was very upbeat and
positive. It was actually a brilliant piece of propaganda. Still, ultimately, a large FU to
over half the country. Then on the other side, TPUSA, God bless them. I think they proved the
concept. This is near and dear. Matthew Marston and myself have been talking about this for 10
years, doing this, an alternative halftime show and alternative Oscars. TPUSA, God bless them,
did it. I think they proved the concept, given that they had enough people that certainly for
streams on the internet, that's a significant amount of people. Not going to be the same as
a Super Bowl watchable ride, but they did it. That's good. I don't want to rip on them for
doing it. I think it's good. On the other hand, it was just a concert. It was a country music
concert, basically. There were some poignant moments, but I don't think it ultimately was
the replacement for a Super Bowl halftime show. Wait a minute. I thought this was going to be
Matt and Ryan getting up on Spencer Day. Is this actually Matt and Spencer getting up on Ryan Day?
Let's go. Maybe. I'm not ripping on what they did. I think it should be very different.
If you mean, it sounds like what you're saying is what I do believe that that was effective
propaganda, even though it was an F you to half of America. Yeah, they're still better at it than we
are. That was the main point. I said it because it's just Twitter. I said it in a maximally
aggressive way, and I pissed a bunch of people off, which I like, fine. Basically, what I'm
saying is the left still has much better and more sophisticated instincts when they execute on this
stuff than we do, even though we're right and they're wrong. No, right? Yeah. No, I think that's
right. You guys promised you were going to attack me. We had a group chat where you said that you
were going to come for me. Well, look, I thought about it more and slept on it, and I think you're
mostly right. I think Trump's denunciation of it missed the mark. I think it would have been
better if he just stayed aloof and kind of dismissed it instead of getting indignant about
you can't understand a word he's saying, which I agree with. That's one of my main complaints.
It was a celebration and spectacle of the new multicultural America. In that sense,
it made perfect sense. The NFL is also trying to expand its international footprint. I think
at least competing with their let's get somewhat political guys, but get them to tone it down,
was also their desire to grab new audiences, including in Latin America.
I think it was effective for the NFL for that reason. I'm sort of disappointed in all the
critics and the cheerleaders on the right. Trump didn't really do it that elegantly. He just seemed
kind of ranty about it. Then all the usual suspects who were praising it were all the
lame GOP consultants and a few political figures from the last 20 years or so.
You did get a lot of like, this is exquisite, which is also not the move, right?
It was the most made-for-TV one that we've ever seen, though.
100%. That was very interesting.
Somebody had the camera angle from field level, and they're like,
this is what it looked like on the field. It's just a bunch of people, trees, and glimpses of
people inside the set. They all saw it on the Jumbotron.
Those little Dr. Seuss-ian frond people that were prancing around.
All the Lord of the Rings jokes about the trees to all the Shakespeare references about the trees.
We're all too much in agreement, so I'm going to throw one. I think that we are speaking at
an elite level, in a way, about this. Production-wise, just let me say,
the tight shot the entire time. You could see that the Snoop Dogg one,
they kind of wanted to do that, where they had all these sets that you'd come in on tighter.
Remember when my wife was complaining, can't we just go back to something we all grew with,
like Snoop Dogg? Unoffensive, uncontroversial,
all-American hero. 30-year-old rap that everyone likes.
Those sets, you could tell they wanted to come in tight on, but this was just like,
they wanted to do the vibe of that one long commercial following them around, which was great
for TV. I will say this, though. I asked my son, because a lot of the kids at his
fancy school aren't as political as I would expect them to be at all.
They were just kind of hanging out, and I don't think they had any idea about
Bad Bunny and the controversy. I'm like, so what do you guys think of this halftime?
He was just like, oh, it's just lame. Everyone just said it was stupid. Why?
He said this without any, none of these words are trigger words for them. He's like, well,
first off, no one knows who Bad Bunny is, so you can't sing along,
except for a few people who might know Spanish. You can't understand what he's saying.
He's like, I'm taking Spanish. You can't understand what he's saying.
It was kind of random and dumb. I don't teach you those words in
Spanish class. Senorita Consuela is not going to be like, you know.
At the end, he was like, oh, yeah. Also, it wasn't American. The Super Bowl should be American.
I don't think that was based on reading any commentary. I think it was just kind of like,
why are we doing this international stuff? It was just a fact. That was weird.
I don't think for the Normie, it really hit. Now, of course, he is my son.
Well, exactly. How Normie can Matthew Peterson's son ever really be? Sorry if you're listening.
Did you guys notice the, well, go ahead, but we should talk about the memes,
the effectiveness of this and activating our old friends who are libs, right?
Yes. Well, it's also an initiative made for TV. It's really made for
clips on social media and for me, which is important. But to just respond to your son's
point about the Super Bowl should be American, like that's obviously true, right? We should say,
or I should maybe say, because I've been giving people shtick about this, that the people who say
that it's an affront to the country to have this anti-American kind of like globalists singing in
Spanish at the halftime show are completely correct. Just on principle, that is obviously
true. In actual fact, London has fallen long ago, right? That ship has sailed and the towers of
sour among the wise has abandoned reason for madness. We are way, way past that point.
But it is the case that when you zoom out and you think like this ridiculous and this guy,
I mean, the God bless America thing, which this is, I think the biggest stroke of genius and maybe
gets at the point I'm trying to make is that, right, it was brilliant. It was the most brilliant
part of the performance and also the most evil part of the performance because he goes, God bless
America. The only thing he says in English and all these boogers, like you say, Matt, who are
watching, their culture is so nice. Their culture is all American and they do each other's nails
and they have family and they sleep on chairs at weddings, all these people that are watching.
And look, he really is an assimilationist. He believes in the melting pot. He says,
God bless America. And then he says, Ecuador and Colombia and Canada and all these other countries,
basically implying that America as the United States has no right to exist.
This one portion of a giant continuum. And so on the one hand, that is proof that all the critics
are correct. On the other hand, it's also proof that I'm correct. It was done in a way that was
so artful as to both dog whistle to the haters of America and come across as a stop to the boomers.
But the other thing that you raised, which is I think maybe more on the nose is, is Bad Bunny
already print? Like he is a big pop star, but I think he kind of had his moment maybe. And that's
just, I guess, for the kids to deter, but maybe that, yeah, that's. And to be fair, I mean,
Super Bowl, I mean, it certainly has London rockers on it, but they don't talk about countries.
They're just saying rock and roll back in the day. And then also,
I mean, it usually is pretty washed up people anyway. But I don't know, Ryan,
I think Trump's comments would have fit if he had given the real finger outright instead of this
move that was ingenious in its way. But the ranting about it in the way he did, it's like,
well, that's not what people actually saw. And I don't know about you guys, but everyone seems to
have the same experience I've had where what's going on right now is, is an activation of like
a BLM beyond BLM levels of all these people who are, you know, white squishes kind of, you know,
we're going to be able to go back and forth on MAGA. And they're just, they're up in arms. I've
seen it in many different groups where they are absolutely, you know, everyone's a fascist,
who's MAGA, Nuremberg trials are going to happen. And these are like normal people,
they're not Antifa members or whatever. And this just activated them to the heavens.
And, you know, I think having an alternative is a good idea. I think they've proved the concept
TPOSA and kudos to them for that. But, you know, of course, you know, Kid Rock is someone
who's trotted out every time you need someone who's right wing at a concert. And he did some,
you know, he did some great stuff. I don't think it was without his moments.
You know, you could complain about, but it was like, it was not, it was not a sufficient response
to the level of deal that they had culturally. And so everyone just doubled down. And, you know,
I don't know. The Super Bowl halftime show, though, to me, it's always been kind of a trap
because of the dynamics that you mentioned. It's always like they're trying to beat Red America.
And the sad thing is when you saw Roger Goodell hug him afterwards, if you saw that video after
he got done and came inside, it was just like, man, these people, this is a bad, a bad scene.
It was a celebration and spectacle, a sectarian, a demographically sectarian appeal to
a certain portion of the country and then dressed in the garb, as you say, Spencer,
somewhat subversively of, no, no borders, no human is illegal. Can't we all just be one happy
beige brown family across the Americas? So it's, it was deeply un-American in that sense,
but pretty subtle. It's, it's skin suitery at its finest, no doubt. And this is their
most effective skin suit that they have seized as the Super Bowl because it's the fricking Super
Bowl, right? Like, I mean, I want to return to Matt's point a little bit and actually,
and maybe this can get us into talking about, we should talk about California as well,
which is the radicalization of the, of the normie left.
Part of me just feels like I'm learning that the average American voter operates
in a state of directionless, directionless, global hysteria. Like the sort of default is
there is a terrible atrocity going on and it's our job to take to the streets to prevent it.
And really it's just a question of effective demagoguery, which direction that hysteria
gets pointed. Like, is it, is it, you know, they're, they're transing the kids or is it
ISIS fascist? I mean, we would like to think that one of those points of view is correct while the
other one is false. And that's what makes the difference. Increasingly I wonder if it's simply
like a competing shadow plays because now we've got, it does seem like they're doing BLM again
with this stuff in, in Minneapolis and like a lot of the normies who were maybe winnable for Trump
or are starting to, I don't know, go in for this thing that like, you know, deportation is,
is equal or, or the way that they're doing deportation is equal. And meanwhile,
Ryan sent us this thread about how California is like actually expropriating its citizens at this,
at this point. This is the, we've talked a little bit, I think about the wealth pack,
but this is a guy called Sightsbringer, the prophet. Here is the bare truth. California
is entering the seizure phase of the wealth cycle. The productive core has thinned. The
debt load is locked. The spending base cannot shrink without simple fracture. The only lever
left is the static pool of accumulated capital that remains geographically or legally tethered.
That tether becomes the target. The, the comment on this from Balaji, another Twitter account that
we, or a person with a Twitter account that we often follow is that like all of these CEOs have
departed from California. And, you know, mostly just following the three of us, I think we're,
we're just the trendsetters in this, in this respect. But like, I mean, you do get the
impression that I guess my, the theme of this question that I have for you guys is like,
is the left gathering its forces? Like is, is Mordor on the march again? I should,
I should stop referring to Lord of the Rings because it's so corny, but like,
is the, is there a darkness gathering in the West with all of this stuff?
Well, California continues its decline. And this seems, I'm not quite sure what the thought,
well, I am sure what the thought process is. It's, it's classic liberal entitlement.
They think California is so magnificent that they can pursue wealth, billionaire taxes. And then
as the post points out, millionaires are coming next. They, they had some motions towards it in
2020 to start taxing the millionaires. So they're, they're chasing the dragon in California
tax revenue wise. And I guess they assumed that only, only so many people would actually get up
and leave. I mean, California has been notorious for years if you move out of it. I have not
experienced this yet, inshallah, may I not, but they, they will hound you out of the state and
try to assert that you're actually still living there and still owe them taxes for years after
you've left. And I know one prominent millionaire who had this, I mean, sent a millionaire who had
this experience of, you know, a year or two, maybe he was like five years out of California
and they sent him a tax bill. And he asked his accountant, you know, what can I do about this?
Let's sue them. And the accountant and the lawyer said, well, there's good news and bad news. The
good news is they only looked back five years. The bad news is if you challenge this, you're
going to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars and you probably wind up losing. So you should
just pay it. And he ended up paying, it was, you know, $1.4 million in back taxes. And I think that,
that was his tribute cost to be finally done with California. So that will continue. And it's,
it's a demonstration of California's desperation and their incipient authoritarianism that they
conduct themselves this way. So the question would be, what does this doom loop look like with
revenue and spending and all the rest of California? As we've argued and Matt has argued
longer than me, he used to be in the thick of investigating this sort of stuff. California
has been functionally insolvent for at least a decade. The question is, when does the toll
finally chime for California's disaster? And maybe it'll be sooner than they, than they had
hoped. So in that sense, this seems short-sighted and if it's utterly predictable at the same time.
Yeah, we should, we should note our friend and colleague, Michael Anton loves to say this to
people as well, that they're just going to take your stuff. They're just going to take your stuff
and people would say, oh, well, you know, I can stay here and weather it through.
And the problem is, you know, they don't stop, right? There's no limit to progressivism here
and they'll just keep going. And so if you don't leave, eventually they will come for you. They'll
come for, take your stuff. They won't let your kids into college, et cetera, et cetera. So,
I mean, this is, it's interesting how this is playing out with the tech overlords, right? I
mean, you got Cernovich out there just angering everyone in tech by being his grumpy self and
telling them all, like, I don't feel sorry for you. You all caused this and F you. I don't think
that's the right approach. I think there were people who were kind of, they had day jobs and
they were slow to wake up to this, but he does have a point. And I think many people in tech
realize that. I mean, David Sachs, for instance, took a similar approach. He didn't say F you to
everyone in tech like Cerno, which is ridiculous. You need them in the coalition. They're a very
important part of it and they're doing great stuff, the right kind of tech people. But Sachs
said the same thing, like you guys caused this and now you're going to leave. And it was absolutely
predictable. They were not going to stop. They were going to come after just expropriating wealth
and that's what they're doing. And I know that a lot of people who are friends there after the
election, they felt a little better about life, which is understandable. And now everyone's sort
of realizing the election alone doesn't solve a thing. It doesn't solve what needs to be done
in the administration. It doesn't tamp down on the other side at all unless we take these actions.
The administration is doing some of that, but California is just going to get worse and that's
the way it is. And they'll continue to persecute people. They'll continue to come after wealth.
There's no conception of... I really loved it when they put out the billionaire tax,
which is absolutely ridiculous in so many ways and unjust. And they put this out,
billionaires tax, we're going to tax them. And you got these responses from some of these business
guys and they were the most naive, boy scoutish thing I've ever seen in my life. They're like,
well, but let me explain how this works. This doesn't make any sense because
someone will have, they don't even have any money, but they have
the ownership in this company and this will increase innovation. You're sitting there like,
oh, you sweet summer child. Let me point to the chart. I have charts, please.
If you could explain the economics of this to these people, they do not care at all.
And my point would be to look at CalPERS. There's a guy on the board of CalPERS, which has,
I don't know, like half a trillion dollars that they invest for the state. And on the board,
the big board, one of the guys, his resume is 30 years a mob boss for the AFL-CIO in LA.
What do you think he learned about managing $500 billion in that job? Absolutely nothing about
finance by friends, but he doesn't need to know anything about finance. He needs to know friends
and enemies and he knows that very well. And that's, welcome to the Thunderdome.
Yeah. Okay. So this is getting at what I was trying to gesture at with my in-depth
Lord of the Rings references. It turns out I'm better at Dune than I am at Lord of the Rings.
But what I was trying to get at is Matt, what I think you are trying to get at too, which is,
okay, look, won like a big election in a big way. And it was an actual victory. Nobody can
accuse anybody on this podcast of not having duly celebrated. We took several victories. We did not
go immediately into Doomer's bill right after the big Trump landslide, but it's been more than a
year now. And we always knew that the left was going to shake itself off and regroup. And when
they do, there was all this talk, all this Ezra Klein level nonsense about, yeah, we're going to
really moderate. We're going to go back to kind of sound economic policy and we're going to have
abundance. Yeah, bro. It's going to be great. The blue dog Democrats are back, baby. Get after
it, son. And you heard it here first. It is impossible for them to, it is structurally
impossible for them to do that. It is just baked into the actual makeup of the Democrat party.
There are path dependencies like a mile deep here. Besides which every major player involved
has already committed himself to woke maximalism on camera at some point during the fervor of 2020.
And it's really, really hard to walk that back without implicitly condemning yourself for being
the evil anti-whatever racist that you accuse everyone else of being. And so instead what
they're going to do is they're going to bad bonaficate the Democrat party.
And they're going to go whole hog on this, but put a vigorous, fun, dancing face in front of it.
And they're going to get better at doing that than they were on short notice with Kabbalah.
And meanwhile, they're literally going to take your stuff. As you say, Matt,
and as Anton is always stressing, it does not matter. He does not care that this is
perhaps unconstitutional, that this will ultimately drive the state into the ground,
that it will immiserate innumerable people, that you can't just tax wealth into existence.
None of the things that you could explain with charts and careful white papers and
delicate sort of subtle arguments, none of that is going to matter. Even like,
God bless him, Thomas Sowell is not going to explain to these people in plain terms
why they are wrong because they want to be wrong from our perspective. The thing that they are
doing is the point. And so, yeah, you've got this going on in California. I heard,
I don't know if this is true, but because the Super Bowl itself took place in San Francisco,
I heard that the players, having spent more than eight days in California,
lost money from the Super Bowl because they overstayed the amount of time that they have
to be there to get. Then you get a chunk of your income taken out proportional to California's
income tax, and it wiped out the bonus that they were getting paid to play in the Super Bowl.
Our listeners are going to have to fact check me on this because I was just at
lunch with some Google bros, and they were telling me all about how insane this was.
And in fact, all of that is by design. That's the program. So it does seem as if Trump is a
little bit or Trump world is needing to find its footing a little bit more. And maybe it'll just,
I hate to say this, maybe it'll just be a shellacking in the midterm that brings people
back around to getting serious or something. I don't know. Well, two things quick. I'm curious
what you guys think about that last larger point. But yeah, it strikes me, the analogy is it's like
you're running a 7-Eleven and a bunch of thugs come in with guns and they're going to rob the
7-Eleven and take your money. And you're like, guys, guys, wait a minute. This doesn't even
make sense. If you just worked here at the 7-Eleven, you would make more money over time
and it doesn't matter because they're like, I want money for cracking out. I mean, they don't
care at all. That's not the point. And that's kind of the dynamic you see over and over again,
playing out. But this point about the left putting on the face, the face or the facade,
like in the Super Bowl is positive. What they did is they had a positive vision. So if someone
was like, oh, it was pro-family and it was this and that. So they presented a positive and a happy
vision, which was, I think, the smart part about it. It was like, you know, bright, boisterous.
And, you know, the game is like, we are the side of, you know, love, we're good, love, not hate,
and all these Orwellian slogans. So I do think that there is a problem on the right of what are
we fighting for, where, you know, there needs to be a positive vision that comes across the
vibe. That is a good one. That's a winner, you know, and talking about things in positive terms
and then remaining very strong on, you know, deportation and everything else,
but painting this more positive vision. And I think that that's waned a little bit, you know,
over the last few months as, you know, because we did, at least the administration seemed to want
to go, we got to go head toe to toe with the left, but you got to do both things. You got to project
the positive vision you're fighting for. And that I think is, you know, needs to return. I believe
it will before the midterms, but I don't know, it might be too late for the midterms. But there's
still three years, there's an eternity left. There should be no blackmailing.
Yes. No, no, no. Right. But what's that thing about if you're having fun, you're winning?
Well, it's interesting. I mean, there's a certain part of me that thinks if
Gavin Newsom were truly ambitious, he would have spent his last term moving heaven and earth,
leaving aside whether he could actually do it for coalitional reasons in California and
ideological reasons mixed in. But trying to bring California slightly back to what it was
in its heyday, that is the late 80s and 90s, which is a middle-class paradise, to the extent that he
could transform his party sufficiently to be the avatar for that sort of prosperous California,
and to truly be the abundance Democrat. That's the pathway to real supermajority status.
However, it seems that a good portion of the left, Newsom included, and, you know, Whitmer's
similarly positioned, she's been very quiet about all this ICE stuff, pretty much silent about it
because she's trying to toe the middle road. But I think they assume that, like in 2016 in Hillary,
they're on the cusp of permanent rule or something close to it because of the demographic
transformation of the country and the voting habits of said demographic. So I think they
think they can ride this out, and eventually they're going to have their way even in California
because they're going to have their way nationally. That seems to be the calculus.
And the great test of American self-government will be whether they're right about that
and who stands in their way. Trump has made two valiant efforts to stand in their way,
or we're coming up on a midterm that may put the final nail in that coffin.
Not to bring us back to Doomerism, but this seems to be the plan.
Yeah, I think there's now more of a vibe. You can see what the fight is going to look like now,
I think, a little bit more, which is not the same thing as Doomerism. It just means that,
you know, Matt was kind of saying, you know, in an election, whoever is having fun is probably
winning. And that seems like something we've got to work to get back just on a vibes level,
not to resurrect that tired, tired idea. But we should not close out this altogether without,
before producer Ryan shows up with a giant like foam hand telling me that I have to be dragged
off the stage. He might actually come into my studio with a candy cane and yank me off the
podcast. But we shouldn't close without giving a shout out to our boy, Jeremy Carl,
Senior Fellow of the Claremont Institute, decorated scholar, I think it's fair to say,
and a friend of all of ours, who has been nominated by Donald Trump for a major position
at the State Department, and is now up, obviously, for Senate confirmation. And through the fire of
none other than one Chuck Schumer, I was saying before we started recording, like, I'm not
convinced that one is always over the target when one is taking flack. But when one is taking
flack from Chuck Schumer, that's a bullseye, baby. So we should just say, Jeremy made a beautiful
response in the replies to Schumer's accusation that he's a racist and a white supremacist.
Not only, Carl not only forthrightly denies that, but demonstrates why Schumer is a toad,
and is clearly speaking out of both sides of his mouth. As I look at it right now, Jeremy's reply
has 1.5 thousand likes, and Chuck Schumer's has 1.3 thousand. So that is officially a ratio.
But you can do your part to make it a mega ratio, to make it a nuclear ratio, by checking him out
around Jeremy Carl, and that we should all hope it gets confirmed with all due expediency.
And I'll clarify for our State Department nerds, this is an important position for those that know
it. Just go do a little research about what it oversees, but we want to get it right. He's up
for Assistant Secretary of State for International Organizations, which is at one of the, at a nexus
of what has for a long time been the American left's exportation of its pathologies abroad
at various NGO level, et cetera. So kind of USAID territory in many ways.
Trey Lockerbies Yeah, and who better than Mr.
Carl for that post. All right, this is it. I can feel the candy cane is actually coming off screen.
You can't quite see it yet, but Ryan is about to, Producer Ryan is about to pile drive me
onto the floor if I don't wrap this podcast up. This was a lot of fun. Welcome to the new and
improved Roundtable, and this doesn't have to be the end for you folks, because there is more
at Claremont Digital when you sign up to become a paid subscriber and support us.
We will always be coming to you weekly with one free episode, of course, and we're very grateful
for all of our listeners. But if you want more, Ryan and I are going to do a little deep dive
into AI sentience, which is a buzzy topic that's been getting particular attention lately, an
article in Nature claiming that the bots are already alive. So we're going to pick that apart
a little bit over on the paid episode. And if you want to hear that, go check out the link in
the description of this episode of this podcast episode. But with that, thank you very much for
listening to the Roundtable. If you want to know more besides the paid episode about all of our
stuff, you can go to our websites at AmericanMind.org, ClaremontReviewBooks.com, and our
DC-based Center for the American Life at DC.Claremont.org. You can donate to support the
show and the Institute at Claremont.org slash donate. And thank you very much for listening.
Don't forget to rate, review, share, subscribe, let people know about the show. Thanks to our
producer, Ryan, who's coming in now actually with just a giant burlap sack to carry me away in.
It's a pleasure as always. He's dressed like a tree. It's really...
President Burley game, when Burnham Wood comes to the stage. Let me say quick before he comes,
I mean, the great thing about the Super Bowl was the Patriots lost. As Bill's fan, that was
gratifying for them to be exposed on national TV as the Bakers that they are. And White Hill at
the very end here for me, even though there was a 13% decrease in the overall audience for the
Super Bowl on Sunday, which is understandable given the teams that were playing. But for the
Super Bowl performance, there was a 39% decrease in the audience compared to Kendrick Lamar last
year. Dang. All right. I'm wrong about everything. This was a disaster for the
left and bad money sucks. See you all next week.