Winslow Homer A Legacy in Watercolor

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
9 Video Views·Feb 11, 2026
Join artist James Prosek and conservator Judith Walsh as they explore Winslow Homer's watercolor technique in the MFA's Morse Study Room and his studio in Prout's Neck, Maine. Additionally, Prosek gives a glimpse at what inspires him as he creates his own watercolors at home in Connecticut.
Featuring:
Judith C. Walsh
Conservator and Professor Emerita, SUNY Buffalo State College University
James Prosek
Artist, Writer, Naturalist
This is my favorite one. Of all Winslow Homer's work, or his watercolors, or? They're all my
favorite, but this is one of the ones I really, really like, because it's so perfect in so many
ways, and I wonder how an artist would look at it. You know, like this brush stroke, where he
just puts it down, it's so sure, puts it down, lifts the brush up, then comes back and blots.
Did he remove that? Yeah, that part's blotted, so the boat comes down, and that's just astonishing
to me. It's telling that we both chose, of all the 49 works, or however many are at the MFA,
I would say this one is probably my favorite. I mean, not just because I love trout fishing,
but I actually, I not only think that Homer's the greatest watercolor painter of all time,
you know, better than Turner, whoever, but I think that this is one of the greatest watercolors. I
these works for me are not just like, there's something beyond painting here, it's like
they're spiritual for me. When I look at this, I just am delighted by it. I can imagine being on
the river, I can imagine these trouts suddenly jump up, and you see how delighted Homer was
to see this, you know, like, wow, this is really great, and come home and paint it this way.
I mean, the lilies, like, when you see the lily pads turned over, that usually means there's a
breeze, you know, I can feel them flapping, and I can see the, like, the stems of the lily pads are
undulating into the waves. But, you know, these pictures are his late work. This is when he was
at the height of his powers, and he was, what, 65 years old? He'd been painting since he was
in his 30s, and he just broke open with this new style of painting, and I think he understood
intuitively, or without thinking, what each of the pigments could do. He'd been using this paper
for 35 years, he knew what the paper could do, and he knew how to draw, and he had all those
skills, and suddenly they just came together in this sort of flow, where everything is working,
and I don't even have to think about it. These Adirondack works are a big part of why I think
I wanted to be an artist, or push my technique. This is a great one, because the water, this kind
of green water, you really have to get the light behind it, and to see through it. The water has
to be pretty warm. In Maine, the water gets so cold that there's not very much oxygen in it,
so as it warms up in the summertime, you get more of that green color, and it's really beautiful.
Look, here's another long blue stroke. Like in your blue boat? Yeah, like in the blue boat. Is that
Prussian blue, you think? Yep. The brook trout in particular has features that make it really nice
to paint. It's like a painting itself. I mean, that white rim along the edges of the fins,
and then there's a black line next to it. I mean, that's really there in these fish, as you know,
and the blue halos again with the red centers, and then the yellow dots. It really looks like
it's shimmering. Homer did things with watercolor that nobody else has ever done, and I just have
been captivated by his work since I was a kid, so he probably painted 15 pictures that brook trout
appear in. That's a guess. I imagine, because I can feel it in Homer's work, that the trout wasn't
separate from the landscape. It's just like it's all melting together, and you can feel the
atmosphere. You can feel the air and the cool dark woods in the background, and the brook trout also
have these really cool markings that probably evolved to help them be camouflaged in the river,
so they're these, they call them vermiculations, and the colors on a brook trout are not like,
you wouldn't think they would work together. They're just so crazy. There's olive and
and red bellies, and it's just, they're just crazy, but it's totally harmonious somehow.
I feel like Homer was about as good of an observer of nature as you could get, because he was a
painter and a fisherman. The world is being reflected in the water, but also abstracted,
because the wind and the currents are altering the reflection in interesting ways.
It didn't all just come to him all of a sudden. He worked very hard and diligently on his technique,
particularly with watercolors, because he had to look at other people's work,
just like I've looked at Homer my whole life. He went to England to look at Turner,
and Turner was considered at the time to be the preeminent watercolor painter. I've always wanted
to go to Prout's Neck and see the inside and the outside of Homer's studio. I've found when I
get deeply into someone's work, it's always illuminating to see the actual place where they
worked. This is incredible. Wow. Beautiful. Nice space, huh? Yeah. Good light. Incredible.
The house is this way. Whoa, look at his fishnets. Yeah. His fish? And his skin, and his
brook trout. Good thing he painted, because he wasn't a great taxidermist. That's a big brook
trout. Whoa. This was a sign he put outside his studio, because people kept bothering him,
and so this he thought would keep all the young ladies away. You think that's a deterrent?
He was trying to keep young ladies away? Yeah, he was, because they kept bothering him.
Beautiful. So here's all the pictures of him. Here's a picture of him fishing.
On the rocks. And there's he catching fish with his brother. That's Charlie. And here's Dad.
Oh, wow. And his dog. Jack Russell? Yep, and his dog, Sam. But this porch is fabulous.
Isn't this amazing? Do you think he painted outside a lot on the rocks? I think he painted
some down there, but I suppose he put things in his studio to fix them. Artists do that,
don't they, James? Yeah, I do. It's hard to stop working on things. So the family has been
taking care of Homer's legacy for four or five generations. And it's wonderful that they did
this, and now we have this as a public space. No, it gives you a pretty major insight into the
person. So here we go, James. Into the rocks. Through the gate. Nice. I can start to smell
the sea. Yep. Wow. Beautiful.
