How Close Are We to Creating Life in the Lab

Science and life
122 followers
Do we have a sufficiently good definition of life for us to then know the moment you may have created it?
Yeah, so there's many definitions of life out there, right?
And there's not really consensus on one, but I would say in my field, bottom-up synthetic biology,
what we really use as a working definition, and you'll be happy to hear this, Neil,
is a self-sustaining chemical system capable of Darwinian evolution.
And that definition was put forward by NASA, and we extended it.
We don't just want a system capable of Darwinian evolution,
we actually want a system capable of open-ended evolution.
So it can essentially increase itself in complexity, it can evolve to perform any desired task in the end.
So that's what we are after.
So what's the difference between Darwinian evolution and open evolution?
So Darwinian evolution can be, there can be open-endedness in Darwinian evolution.
So what we are really after is a system where the evolutionary landscape is large enough
so that at any given time the number of genotypes only exploit a sufficiently small space on that evolutionary landscape, so to say.
So there is really a lot of space to introduce serendipity, to introduce changes,
to introduce, well, also some kind of emigrant properties that are inherent to living systems.
So Darwinian would presume that the change is favored only for the survival of the organism,
and you're suggesting there might be forces operating that just simply change the organism,
without reference to its survival.
Is that a fair way to think about open-ended evolution?
Yeah, well, yeah, to essentially go for systems that increase in complexity and do interesting things.
So that's what we are after.
So if an organism never dies, or lives sufficiently long, then it can't undergo Darwinian evolution.
So on the population level, I think introducing death into living systems is absolutely crucial,
because otherwise you just have exponential growth and the resources will be exploited.
I've never heard anybody say that before.
We have to make sure you die in order for us to evolve you.
That makes perfect sense. Yeah, again, that's sort of a little mind-blowing, but yeah, of course.
I'm not saying it doesn't make sense, I'm just saying I've never heard anybody admit that.
Yeah.
So you're the first biologist I've heard be honest about the fact that Darwinian evolution requires that everybody dies.
Yeah, so, I mean, on the population level at least, when we think about synthetic cells,
we really think about very, very minimal and living entities that are much simpler
than the simplest cell that we currently know on Earth, so much simpler.
We are really talking something where essentially we want to get to the point where chemical evolution becomes biological evolution.
That's where we want to get.
And in that context, I'm saying that if we manage to construct a system which is capable of self-replication,
then eventually resources will be exploited, especially if you have, of course, limited resources.
And in this stage, this is where we have a situation where survival of the fittest is what's driving evolution essentially.
We have a situation on our hands.
So this conversion from complex chemistry to simple biology, that harkens back to the Miller-Urey experiment.
Very famous experiment. When was that, in the 1960s was it?
Perhaps early 70s. Could you remind us about the Miller-Urey experiment and what that did in your field back then?
Yeah, so I think it was earlier even than that. It was around 1950, 1952 or so.
Oh, the 50s, okay.
Yeah, so it was the first time that essentially Miller was performing chemical reactions
in a way that is kind of similar to early Earth, to the environment on early Earth.
So he was trying to recreate the atmosphere that was present on early Earth.
And then he could see that very simple building blocks of life, such as some amino acids, which build proteins, so to say,
were present in that solution after he provided the system with energy.
So that kind of showed that organic synthesis is possible under prebiotic conditions essentially.
And that's far away from a biological system, so we're talking really individual amino acids,
but it shows that prebiotic conditions can give rise to organic molecules like amino acids that build proteins today.
So in the Miller-Urey experiment, they knew to start with organic molecules, right?
They knew to start with that, and they went to then see what the organic molecules might do for themselves
when left unmonitored and left alone, but they had to give it an energy source, right?
And if memory serves, that energy source was a little spark, very Frankenstein-like.
Simulating lightning, so to say, on early Earth, yeah.
You want a big light switch or something?
Yeah, I want a massive lever that someone... Do you have a henchman? I'm hoping you have a henchman.
I'm afraid not. But what I find interesting about this experiment is that, you know,
even before that, about 100 years earlier, there was the common belief among chemists at the time
was that organic molecules are molecules which can only be synthesized by living things, right?
That organic synthesis in the laboratory is essentially impossible.
And then chemists at the time, like 1800-something, managed to actually make the first organic molecule synthetically in the lab,
and that was actually urea.
And that proved that we as human beings can synthesize organic molecules
which are otherwise made by living things from scratch, right?
And I see synthetic biology or the bottom-up creation of synthetic life a little bit at a similar point right now,
where, you know, kind of a proof of principle is needed to show that we cannot only make organic molecules,
like the ones that were made in the Miller-Urey experiment,
but that we can also actually achieve a transition from matter to life in a laboratory setting.
How does your work follow this? And what's different about your approach?
So, essentially, we start at a much, much later point.
So, we start with biomolecules, and we ask ourselves the question whether it's possible to actually assemble molecules
in such a way that we can create a system that's capable of undergoing,
create a self-sustaining chemical system that's capable of evolution.
So, that's our starting point and end goal.
And what we do in order to get there is we are making lipid vesicles, so kind of the envelope of a cell,
and we are building, constructing our own molecular machinery, and we do so with RNA, RNA nanotechnology.
And that may be a little bit reminiscent of the RNA world hypothesis and the origins of life.
www.microsoft.com
