BaBattleship; The Blockbuster Attempt That Sunk Itself

Battleship
6 followers
11 Video Views·Feb 11, 2026
I'm Jason. Jason what? Holt. Jason Holt. Don't you have... Holt doesn't sound Jewish.
Well my dad's Jewish. My dad is too. You don't have to join the Israeli army? You do. Well
when are you going to join? In the 2000s Hasbro decided to take their wide range of IPs and adapt
them for the big screen. Their first attempt with Transformers was a massive success and spawned a
franchise that would crash and burn horrendously killing millions of people. Their second was G.I.
Joe Rise of Cobra which sure was a movie. After two absolute hits Hasbro was sitting around and
thought you know what kids find really cool? Battleship. We really gotta milk that current
hot trend of Battleship. Then another executive said that's a great idea and you know what I
think when I imagine a Battleship adaptation? Aliens. Aliens. Both of these executives were
charged by the Geneva convention the following year but it was too late. Battleship the movie
was greenlit and debuted in theaters in 2012. The end result was a film that combined every overused
trope and director style at the time. A trend I've noticed with a few of my videos is that I
tend to give a piece of media that isn't perfect you know some benefit of the doubt. Battleship
is fascinating to me in just how irredeemable it kind of is. Mountain right now. Wait what's going
on why? The island's under attack. Attacked by who? I don't know people using the word alien.
Aliens? It can't be that bad right? First if you like this movie that's completely fine uh just
probably genuinely re-watch it before giving me anything in the comments. Second if you say it
has fun moments yeah you're right it's just this scene and that's it. So let's briefly and I mean
briefly talk about what happens in the other 90% of this film. If you attack Iran now they're gonna
fight you back right? There's gonna be blood. Would you rather take that now or let them get a
nuclear bomb? It's the most serious issue facing our planet today. More so than the movie Battleship
which I'm very excited to have directed and I love Rihanna she's a great actress.
The Battleship movie begins with an absolute trip through time and space. Scientists talk about
shooting a laser into space to talk to aliens. Hard cut to two guys hanging out in a bar.
One guy called Hopper is a bit of a loser. If he looks familiar it's because Hopper is played by
the guy that was John Carter once and never in anything else. His brother is a captain of a navy
ship and he wants Hopper to pick his life up. A new direction a game change you're joining me in
Hopper responds to this by hitting on a girl breaking into a convenience store for her
and getting tased by the cops. Turns out that girl Hopper tried to get with was the
admiral's daughter and he probably embarrassed his brother in the navy's eyes.
So what's the solution to all of this? Have Hopper join the navy of course. An undisclosed
amount of years have passed and Hopper has gone from literal deadweight to a weapon officer on a
naval destroyer. Oh and he's also dating the admiral's daughter. Anyway the Japanese navy's
in town and both countries are having war games. It's meant to be a time of friendly cooperation
and learning experience for everyone involved. Hopper though really hates that one Japanese
captain and they get into a fistfight. Everyone gives him the typical speech that he's got talent
but he's just lazy. You're a very smart individual with very weak character leadership and decision
making skills. You're a loose cannon meow meow fuzzy face. You've seen this before. Well I wonder
if there will be some extraordinary situation from which he can prove his worth. Oh wow an
extraordinary situation from which he can prove his worth. You see this whole time aliens have
been following the signal established earlier and head directly to beat up this one nerd.
Fracturing one ship and sending it spiraling directly into Hong Kong.
Hopper boops the giant ship and accidentally sets off a Simpsons movie style dome
that encompasses all of Hawaii. Coincidentally sealing off the islands from the entire
U.S. Navy. You know except for our main characters of course because movie has to happen. All
communication is dead. Radar doesn't work. The only way any ship can operate is by firing and
viewing manually. It turns out the aliens only react when weapons are aimed at them or they only
attack weapons and not humans. The movie kind of flip-flops on which it's supposed to be but
getting back to the story the aliens blow up two allied ships including Hopper's brother
leaving him the reluctant hero. But like super reluctant. Like he's actually incredibly useless.
So many other characters actually do a lot more in the plot than Hopper. His rival Japanese friend
figures out how to use the bullies in the ocean to create the actual battleship game and take out
three ships. His girlfriend does more. The aliens are defeated and blown up. Their shield goes down
and they face the full force of a trillion dollar military budget. The end. Okay let's talk about
the problems. I find this movie fascinating because the only way I can truly describe it
is if you took elements of Battle Los Angeles and Transformers and brutally mashed them together.
Because I don't know if you could tell but the visual aesthetic and directing style of this movie
is just Michael Bay light. And that faux Bay-ness trickles down to the very core of this film. And
they don't just copy Michael Bay but other directors of the time too. Like say just throw
some J.J. Abrams in there as well. This is what's popular right? It's like the worst elements of
this period in time were chucked into a blender and this was the concoction. So the best way to
show this is through visual presentation. 1. Lens flares. So many lens flares. In fact half of the
time what even is happening? Is this just to cover up for the shoddy CGI? 2. Emulating Michael Bay.
Bay's style only worked for like three movies. Nobody should ever try to reproduce it. 3. The
absolute over-reliance on CGI. A video essayist talking about how bad CGI is? What will they
think of next? 4. Whatever the hell this shot is. What is this? I've literally never seen a
blockbuster ever do this. Yeah so those are the visual issues. There's a lot more but I'm trying
to condense this. The overall aesthetic of Battleship 2012 is that of a mobile game ad.
Like this kind of looks cool but you know the real visuals of the game are not gonna look like
this. I don't know should I talk about the story or characters? No no I guess I should. It's just
draining looking at this for too long. You know how about we take a break and we'll all come back
nice and refreshed. Have you been in the Israeli army? No. What? How'd you get out of that? Are you
a draft dodger? How old are you? 25. You gotta join the army ************. So I actually remember
this. Around the 2010s it was often peddled in pop science fiction blogs that when aliens ever meet
humanity it would be like Columbus meeting the natives. As in you know not good. And you just
know that the screenwriter that wrote this saw that line and thought man it sure would be deep
to include this. If there is intelligent life out there and they come here it's gonna be like
Columbus and the Indians. Even though this is the one alien invasion story where that line is not
applicable at all. Independence Day? Sure. War of the Worlds? Also sure. But the aliens in Battleship
are the nicest invaders ever. As you see they actively go out of their way to make sure that
the main characters are never harmed whatsoever. Nobody in the main cast actually dies except for
you know. They only attack when human guns are literally pointed right at them. And they don't
even go after actual humans. They just go after weapons. I got a bad feeling about this. What kind of bad feeling?
Like we're gonna need a new planet. Kind of bad feeling. Okay. What are you talking about? They could
have just killed you all right then and there and instead decided to leave. I've seen people
interpret the aliens not being overly violent in this movie as them actually being good.
That this entire movie was simply started over a miscommunication. And my response to that is no.
They're just ridden badly. The movie seems to switch on a whim when the aliens will and won't
use violence. And they have no qualms just killing side characters.
Say even if the aliens were secretly good and this was a misunderstanding. Then why even bring
up the Columbus allegory in the first place? If there is intelligent life out there and they come
here it's gonna be like Columbus and the Indians. Only where the Indians. What are you trying to say
Are you saying the Spanish only attacked the natives through misunderstanding? You know in
some ways let's compare this to Battle Los Angeles. Those aliens were designed to be fought by a
specific branch of the U.S. military with small squad-based raiders that were perfect for Marines
to deal with. The aliens in Battleship aren't simply designed to be fought by the U.S. Navy.
They were designed to be fought in an adaptation of a board game. Every aspect of the way these
aliens acted and were designed was for them to be easily destroyed by warships blindly firing
like in the game. Their ships despite coming from space don't fly. They hop on the water like
dolphins. They don't use lasers or any sci-fi weaponry that can't be deflected by a modern
warship. They lob big shells which can be easily dodged by a ship from World War II. Which brings
up the biggest question. Why aliens in the first place? Well it's simple really. Marketability.
This movie was an attempt to please as much of the general audience as possible. World War II
that's too historical. Ships fighting in the modern day well that'd be too political. So the
best next thing was chosen. An enemy that would cause no controversy whatsoever. Aliens. But even
though some believe the aliens were good we know the main reason why some of you may like this film
to this very day.
