Advanced Science at Karahan Tepe - Solstice Alignments That Should Not Exist! - Megalithomania

Artifact Archives
9 followers
6 Video Views·Feb 12, 2026
Hey, megalithomaniacs.
I'm gonna read this out to you.
This is the latest article.
You can download it on Academia or Scribd
at the links below.
They're freely available.
And here is an outline of what we've been doing
over the last few months,
trying to get this chapter in a forthcoming book
together for you.
And we present it here for the first time.
The title of the article is called
Reconstructing Karahan Tepe's 11,400-Year-Old
Winter Solstice Alignment by Hugh Newman and J.J. Ainsworth.
A remarkable winter solstice sunrise phenomenon
at the pre-pottery Neolithic site of Karahan Tepe
was discovered by myself, Hugh Newman,
and J.J. Ainsworth in December, 2021.
Known as the sister site to Gobekli Tepe
and part of the Taztepela or Stone Hills Project,
it is located in the Tek Tek Mountains,
some 20 miles southeast of Shanlurfa.
Karahan Tepe was first discovered in 1997 by Bahatin Selig,
with excavation beginning in 2019.
Hunter-gatherers constructed large stone circular structures,
sunken bedrock pits,
and hundreds of T-shaped pillars and intricate statues.
This unique winter solstice discovery
is the oldest known solstice alignment on the planet,
being 7,000 years older
than the summer solstice at Stonehenge.
However, it has recently been claimed
that the ancient builders had little interest in astronomy
and that a roof may have blocked any such alignment.
The authors stand by their findings
as new 3D reconstructions and astronomical data
reveal how well it worked in ancient times,
even with a hypothetical roof.
On December the 20th, 2021, 7.37 a.m.,
we witnessed the sun rising over the rocky hills
in the southeastern sky from Karahan Tepe.
10 minutes later, an upright blade of light
appeared on one side of the oversized stone head
protruding from the western wall of structure AB,
which is a sunken pit with 11 upright pillars,
also known as the Pillars Shrine.
The sun's rays were clearly coming
through a bedrock porthole to the southeast,
which leads into structure AD, a 75-foot-wide enclosure.
The slim shard of light slowly moved across the face,
widening and descending to the area of the mouth and neck
over a period of 45 minutes.
This was clearly a deliberate alignment
built into the structure to record this phenomenon.
On a subsequent visit in December, 2022,
this time with author Andrew Collins
and some Turkish colleagues,
the site was investigated on three consecutive mornings
to record the phenomenon in more detail,
which included taking accurate orientations of the sunrise
and using time-lapse photography
to capture the process in detail.
In our previous series of articles
and in the appendix of Andrew Collins' new book
called Karahan Tepe,
we presented our analysis of the findings,
which utilized the astronomy software called Stellarium,
backdating the alignment to the time of Karahan Tepe.
We chose the date of 9,000 BC
as the site was in use from 9,400 BC to 8,200 BC,
and we felt this was a good choice to focus our research on.
Yet still, even a few hundred years before or after this
would not affect the results.
We concluded that at this time,
the phenomenon would not only
have still functioned effectively,
but would have illuminated the stone head more completely
due to the slightly different position of sunrise in 9,000 BC
due to the obliquity of the ecliptic.
On the winter solstice in 9,000 BC,
the sunrise would have been at 757 AM.
10 minutes later at 807 AM,
the sun will reach the correct altitude
when it will start illuminating the stone head.
This will continue as it does in the current era
for about 45 minutes.
This takes into account refraction
for a temperature of 15 degrees Celsius.
To summarize, the sun would appear just over one degree
to the right or south on the horizon
compared to where the sun is located today.
This is due to the change in the ecliptic.
The sun on the winter solstice
reaches its most southerly sunrise position on the horizon
and appears to rise in approximately the same position
for several days.
Solstice literally means standstill of the sun.
It is on the 24th or 25th of December
that the sun starts slowly rising
in a more northerly position
away from the extreme winter solstice position.
When this starts happening,
the phenomenon stops working in structure AB
and will only happen again one year later.
Due to this being a directly observable phenomenon,
which can be witnessed by anyone choosing to do so
over a few mornings during the period
of the winter solstice, it is uncontentious.
This is not a hypothesis, not a theory or an idea.
This is an astronomical fact that happens every year
and is built into the site in bedrock.
No T-shaped pillars or movable monoliths are involved.
The plausibility of this phenomenon
is its simplicity and permanence.
Dr. Neshmi Karar, the head archeologist at Karahan Tepe,
wrote a paper detailing the extremely careful burying
of structure AB and the porthole,
while much of the rest of the site
was partly destroyed before being buried.
This heavily suggests this was the most important area
to be preserved.
Karar also noted that the stone head's eyes
look to the entrance, meaning towards the porthole stone,
as though the eyes were carved
to show it looking through the hole
towards the winter solstice sunrise.
Independently of our discovery,
Dr. Martin Sweatman of Edinburgh University
worked on a paper looking at potential lunisolar calendars
at Karahan Tepe and Gobekli Tepe.
We mentioned his hypothesis in our previous articles.
Since then, in July 2024, his paper was peer-reviewed
and published in Time and Mind Journal.
The reason we are bringing this back into the spotlight
is because his paper received worldwide acclaim
and may prove to correlate with our discovery
by giving his lunisolar calendar a start date,
i.e. the winter solstice.
The 11 pillars in structure AB he proposed
represent the 11 lunar months and 11 epigominal days,
or intercalary months,
which are used to complete a solar year.
The freestanding 11th pillar
could represent the summer solstice,
which Sweatman believes was a unique epigominal day
at Gobekli Tepe.
However, it could also easily represent the winter solstice.
The stone head may represent the 11th lunar month,
the final month.
We also believe it represents the new year being announced
by the representation of the open mouth
and the eyes looking towards the porthole
in line with the winter solstice sunrise.
The winter solstice sunrise alignment
is highly likely to have been
the observable annual time marker
that restarted this calendar every year.
The author spoke directly to Sweatman in May, 2024
at the Megalithomania Conference in Glastonbury
about our discovery,
and how it may fit in with his hypothesis.
But he believed it may not work
because structure AD probably had a roof, he said.
This was not the first time
this roof hypothesis had come up.
So we examined the idea carefully with a civil engineer
who had investigated both sites and a 3D graphic artist
to reconstruct Karahentepe with a roof
to see if it would affect the illumination
of the stone head on the winter solstice.
In our previous articles,
we looked at other ancient structures around the world,
including Newgrange in Ireland and Gavranese in Brittany,
all which have winter solstice sunrise alignments
marked with thin blades of light,
being directed into the interior of these megalithic sites.
Many of these had permanent stone roofs,
but did the Tazteplah sites of Turkey
have such coverings over the main enclosures?
In a recent article
called Debunking Claims About Gobekli Tepe,
Nesmi Korayil stated,
the structures at Gobekli Tepe are not observatories.
We found wooden traces
that suggest the site structures were roofed,
and no astronomical evidence has been found
to support the observatory theory.
Korayil avoided talking about Karahentepe,
but he certainly knows about the winter solstice alignment.
He continued, we believe that 12,000 years ago,
standing stones were used as supports,
covered with materials like wood and branches.
We cannot say they did not observe the sky.
However, there is no archeological evidence of this.
These wooden traces he talks of
are in fact remnants of burnt charcoal
and two negatives where wooden poles may have once existed.
These were found in the fill in enclosure D
at Gobekli Tepe in the slope slide
that Dr. Lee Clare discovered,
and therefore from some of the later smaller buildings
up on the hill above the main enclosures.
These were known to have had small-scale roofs.
Also, the negatives are less than two meters in length,
so they match the dimension of the later buildings,
not enclosure D.
We should also ask why haven't dozens of other negatives
been recorded in the archeological layers?
Also, no wood and no negatives
have been found at Karahentepe.
If a permanent roof was required,
we should ask why did they not build one
into the original design of the sites?
At Mnajdra and other sites in Malta,
the Neolithic people built stone roofs
over the top of temples
and still accurately recorded the solstices,
equinoxes, moon cycles, and certain stars on the horizon.
The porthole stones and entranceways
were their windows into the heavens.
The same can be said of Newgrange,
stony Littleton Longbarrow,
Gavranese, and even Stonehenge,
as remarkably, there is a roof hypothesis
associated with Britain's national temple,
but this is not taken too seriously.
Likewise, should we take the roof hypothesis seriously
at Karahentepe and Gobekli Tepe?
In the 2011 article, So Fair a House,
archeologist E.B. Banning
suggests the main enclosures of Gobekli Tepe
were elaborate houses with roofs
which he based upon carpentry logistics.
His text has been much criticized,
and French archeology professor Remy Haddad
weighed in on the debate,
who said, the exact form of the roofs
has so far been reconstructed
only on the basis of a classical carpentry design,
where beams connect the peripheral
and central pillars in a radial pattern.
Given the difference in size
between the two points of support,
however, this solution seems implausible.
Having had the chance to look closely
at the interior of Gobekli Tepe in 2013 to 2015,
when low walkways existed between the main enclosures,
it was clearly evident that the heights and angles
of all the T-pillars were, well, different,
and the bases of the central T-pillars
were tapered inwards
and were balancing in their sockets precariously.
This strongly suggests that these could not have been used
as supports for a heavy roof.
Haddad continued by saying,
the stability of the whole structure is dubious
because of the irregular disposition of pillars
and the difference in level
between the periphery and the center.
This problem was also commented on
by civil engineer Daniel Matthys, P.E.
In a private email, he said,
given the relative sophistication
of the stonework at Gobekli Tepe,
I'm skeptical that the T-pillars,
with tapered undersized base dimensions
and heavy oversized horizontal pieces at the top,
would be purposed as roof supports.
The heavy mass high above the small unstable base
is exactly the opposite of what is needed for stability.
Turkey is in a very active earthquake zone
when lateral stability is important.
Dan had visited the sites in 2024
before he made these conclusions.
However, we are open to the idea of this type of discussion
as non-permanent roofs may well have been used
or even lighter configurations
that do not destabilize the central T-pillars.
We wondered if these and other solutions
could incorporate both roofs
and astronomical alignments together.
Matt Sibson, who runs the Ancient Architect YouTube channel,
worked with graphic 3D artist Kevin Esslinger
to create a hypothetical roof over structure AD
at Karahan Tepe.
Sibson, along with Martin Swetman,
believed a roof would block the view of the sunrise
on the winter solstice.
Esslinger went ahead and reconstructed a roof
with our assistance, and what he quickly realized was,
based upon studying Native American roofs
that had similar structural designs,
is that there were likely to be openings
between the outer T-pillars to create windows
to allow light in.
He then placed the sky from 9,000 BC
using stellarium with precise data from myself and JJ,
and after creating the roof
and all the wooden beams in 3D,
concluded that the winter solstice sunrise alignment
works with a roof with a perfect gap
between two pillars that are in the outer circle
and also the two central T-pillars
that would allow the light through.
Esslinger originally set out
to disprove the winter solstice alignment,
but was surprised by his own findings.
Even after this analysis,
which was tested by various
slightly different configurations
and placements of the wooden beams and the covering,
it still worked, even with a complete thatch covering
based upon traditional Pawnee Native American techniques.
After some discussion with them both,
we received a private email from Matt Sibson
in which he stated,
Kevin Esslinger sent me some screenshots
of his most recent solstice alignments.
With your adjustments, with the carihan face and wow,
and the wooden posts added to the structure
don't obstruct it.
So it means there could be a compromise.
The roof of the enclosure
could be more like a football stadium
with the perimeter benches covered,
but the middle section open to the elements.
This would allow for your solstice alignment
and will give a structural explanation for the pillars.
Matt's response was both surprising and revelatory.
A hypothetical solution had been revealed
that went along with traditional Pawnee techniques
of construction and integrated
the winter solstice alignment.
Now this may be so,
but we must remember that still no wood
has been found at Carihan Tepe or wooden beam negatives.
And the structural integrity of the T pillars
is still in question according to Daniel Mathis
and Remy Haddad.
However, it does prove that the winter solstice alignment
is valid with or without a roof.
Experimenting and reconstructing a possible roof
has become a fascinating project in its own right.
But it is now clear that investigating solar,
lunar and star alignments
should be just as important to explore
as the two can now apparently easily co-exist.
Esslinger then stated,
architecturally, there are intriguing parallels
between the Pawnee and the builders of Carihan Tepe
and Gobekli Tepe.
The Pawnee constructed dome-shaped earthen homes
with central holes in the roof,
which served dual purposes,
structural ventilation and astronomical observation.
These holes allowed light beams to enter the interior,
marking specific points throughout the year,
such as the winter solstice.
Esslinger concluded by saying,
I believe that the play of light
on the face found at Carihan Tepe
was absolutely used to indicate the winter solstice
to the community who were living there.
So perhaps it is now time for the academic establishment
to look to the skies once more,
just like our ancestors did,
as it is now beyond doubt that astronomy play a part
in the mindset of the Tazteplah people
whether roofs cover the sites or not.
We feel that the winter solstice discovery
could integrate something important culturally
for the current population of the region.
Wouldn't it also be good for tourism
and attract more people to the area
if they could see this remarkable phenomenon
in person every year?
As with Newgrange, they could limit numbers
to view it over several days
and make it a special occasion,
or they could open it up freely to the public,
just like at Stonehenge.
Another concern is the plan in 2025
for a new roof to be built to protect the site.
Now this could block the phenomenon for good,
so we urge the archeologists at the site
to allow archeoastronomers to make relevant calculations
before this happens.
And we request that the winter solstice sunrise
should still be able to be viewed
with a notable gap in the new covering
so that future generations can continue to witness it
and even celebrate it
just like the people of Karahantepe once did.
